Innocentman came forward in 2007!

[Sherlock Holmes]

Why don't you drop the "accuse", we're no court here !

There is a fine line between suggestion and accusation.

When one says 'J'accuse' it is a figure of speech.

[Eleanor]

You're not trying to understand what happened to Madeleine, but how the abductor managed to make her vanish.
I'm not sure that your mentor would approve that..

So I am not trying to understand because I don't agree with you?  Has it ever crossed your mind that you could be wrong?

[Redblossom]

Yes, the simplest and best way possible.

Ironic that so much time and effort has gone into discussing scenarios that are altogether much less likely - such as Smithman's evening stroll.

Or Tannermans

Or a charity collector three weeks earlier being the abductor, because he gave some old woman the creeps,or a man seen in Oct 2006 around the apartment being the abductor, or a near death 67 yr old ex convicted child abductor being the abductor, or a woman in barcelona buying a baby, that the witness took two yrs to come forward with info for, or all the long string of other pathetic and "manufactured" sightings, all so much more likely I suppose

[pathfinder73]

You're correct Davel a crime would have been committed for a cover up to happen IMO.

[AnneGuedes]

I think you over-emphasise my connection with my mentor.

Aside from some amateur attempts at violin playing I have nothing in common with the man.

Then play the violin, forget 221b, and dedicate yourself to the 3rd Partita of Johann Sebastian. That's my wish for you.

[AnneGuedes]

You're correct Davel a crime would have been committed for a cover up to happen IMO.

Not imo.

[AnneGuedes]

There is a fine line between suggestion and accusation.

When one says 'J'accuse' it is a figure of speech.

Let's say "suggest" then ! We're no Zola here !

[AnneGuedes]

Yes, the simplest and best way possible.

Ironic that so much time and effort has gone into discussing scenarios that are altogether much less likely - such as Smithman's evening stroll.

Is is ironic to discard the little blond girl Smithman was carrying so fatherly ?

[Sherlock Holmes]

Then play the violin, forget 221b, and dedicate yourself to the 3rd Partita of Johann Sebastian. That's my wish for you.

Actually just working on the Double concerto now!

[pathfinder73]

Not imo.

From the time period hypothesis I have there's adult(s) in 5A if it happened so there's more to this than a tragic accidental death. More Incriminating factors are involved if that did happen in order for anyone to go to those lengths using that hypothesis.

[AnneGuedes]

Actually just working on the Double concerto now!

Then you have a partner, that's marvellous !

[AnneGuedes]

From the time period hypothesis I have there's adult(s) in 5A if it happened so there's more to this than a tragic accidental death. More Incriminating factors are involved if that did happen in order for anyone to go to those lengths using that hypothesis.

Are you referring to the Payne questionnaires ?

[Sherlock Holmes]

Is is ironic to discard the little blond girl Smithman was carrying so fatherly ?

Considering a driver could have been miles away by the time Smithman was spotted...

[Eleanor]

Then you have a partner, that's marvellous !

Que?

[AnneGuedes]

Considering a driver could have been miles away by the time Smithman was spotted...

A ghost driver, yes certainly !