Was Gonçalo Amaral fair game given the content of his book?

[jassi]

OMG.

A Freudian Slip, or what.   

I did wonder

[Eleanor]

According to Montclair, Amaral is fair game......So......

I think he has grossly abused his position in the investigation, and stated that his theory is fact when he has No Evidence. 
His criminal record and abuse of his brother, and others, is a matter of record. 

And his own child care leaves a lot to be desired. (Allegedly - SH)

Apart from that, he obviously does not have the ability to apply reason to anything.

So according to the rights invested in me by The Portuguese Constitution, I shall continue to express what I think.
He is fair game.

[Mr Gray]

According to Montclair, Amaral is fair game......So......

I think he has grossly abused his position in the investigation, and stated that his theory is fact when he has No Evidence. 
His criminal record and abuse of his brother, and others, is a matter of record.  And his own child care leaves a lot to be desired.
Apart from that, he obviously does not have the ability to apply reason to anything.

So according to the rights invested in me by The Portuguese Constitution, I shall continue to express what I think.
He is fair game.

So according to the rights invested in me by The Portuguese Constitution, I shall continue to express what I think.
He is fair game....seconded

[stephen25000]

According to Montclair, Amaral is fair game......So......

I think he has grossly abused his position in the investigation, and stated that his theory is fact when he has No Evidence. 
His criminal record and abuse of his brother, and others, is a matter of record.  And his own child care leaves a lot to be desired.
Apart from that, he obviously does not have the ability to apply reason to anything.

So according to the rights invested in me by The Portuguese Constitution, I shall continue to express what I think.
He is fair game.

Of course you do, you're a Mitchell.

 

[Eleanor]

Of course you do, you're a Mitchell.

 

Too true.  Never underestimate a Mitchell.

[stephen25000]

Too true.  Never underestimate a Mitchell.

I never do.

[Eleanor]

I never do.

Very wise.  For once.

[stephen25000]

Very wise.  For once.

I knew you wouldn't get my point.   

[Eleanor]

I knew you wouldn't get my point.   

Of course you did.  You simply do not understand superior intelligence.  It's in the genes.

[Carana]

The appeals court in October 2010 determined that the book was not libellous and that GA's opinion was based on the facts of the case, which were already in the public domain.

The McCanns are taking everybody and his brother to court for the simple reason that they do not want anyone to see the other side of the coin and to have access to the facts. It is nothing but a PR campaign so that no one will know anything other than what the parents say.

Here in Portugal, the law is transparent and everyone has access to court decisions and they even have the right to disagree with verdicts and to discuss them openly. Even if the judge were to decide that GA committed libel (IMO, unlikely) I still would have the right to say I don't agree with her decision and to discuss it.

To take a small example. He heard about / saw police video of certain booklets in the villa and his insinuation was that their presence was highly unusual and therefore suspicious.

The fact is: yes, they were found in the villa.

What is NOT fact is that there was anything suspicious about them, which is what he had made them appear to the average reader.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=3259.0

[stephen25000]

Of course you did.  You simply do not understand superior intelligence.  It's in the genes.

Not in the case of the Mitchell's.

A classic sign of a limited gene base.

Very limited.

[jassi]

Not in the case of the Mitchell's.

A classic sign of a limited gene base.

Very limited.

Are they amongst the group that are 40% neanderthal ?

[stephen25000]

Are they amongst the group that are 40% neanderthal ?

Look out for the brow ridges.

[Estuarine]

Seeing as we are having a knock about again. I had to Google Mitchell; is it the North American B25 Mitchell bomber or the Mitchell fishing reel made by Carpano and Pons? Please advise

[Eleanor]

Not in the case of the Mitchell's.

A classic sign of a limited gene base.

Very limited.

It must really piss you off that Clarence Mitchell is doing so well.  What a shame.  Never mind.

How well I am doing is none of your business.  But there is nothing vicious or accusatory in my soul.