Was Gonçalo Amaral fair game given the content of his book?

[pegasus]

Those who attack Amaral and Paiva seem to cautiously avoid attacking other people part of the joint investigation
The UK's top search expert from NPIA,
the UK's top phone forensics expert,
the UK's expert crime analysts from DCIU.

[sadie]

Of greatest significance about the adultery was its aftermath, the abusive phone calls and the golden bullet death threat.

Nice.

And Amaral is defending his honour?

Am I right in thinking there was also a veiled  treat to their child?  Please correct me if I am wrong.


Nice man Amaral.  NOT

[Eleanor]

What do you mean? Are you proposing the azuremare theory (which bizarrely claimed that Amaral and Cristavao did it)?

Certainly not.  Amaral said it, not me.  But he certainly seems to have thought that it was possible to steal a child and blame the parents.
He really should have been a bit more careful.  It's all out there now.

[Cariad]

Am I right in thinking there was also a veiled  treat to their child?  Please correct me if I am wrong.


Nice man Amaral.  NOT

Amaral said, during that infamous telephone call, that he could make their daughter disappear and see to it that they got the blame.
Very worrying in the light of Madeleine's disappearance.

And he threatened to shoot the husband of his mistress.  I have no idea if he meant it, but I would have been scared witless if it had been me.

Can you please provide cites as per forum rules.

[pegasus]

Just a reminder that the attacks on Mr Amaral began while he was working on the case.
There is no other case in the world where the investigator has been attacked so vehemently.
My friend in Chicago thinks there is something very odd behind these orchestrated attacks.

[Carana]

Just a reminder that the attacks on Mr Amaral began while he was working on the case.
There is no other case in the world where the investigator has been attacked so vehemently.
My friend in Chicago thinks there is something very odd behind these orchestrated attacks.

As does my friend in Kyrgyzstan...

[Cariad]

You mean you haven't seen or heard the tape of The Phone Call?  Go Google it.  It is all over Google courtesy of Bots.

Please don't tell me that you don't know what a Bot is, or that you can't use Google.

On the other hand you can always report me to Admin and get my posts removed.  But that won't make the tape go away.

No, I haven't ever heard of the tape, yes I can use Google, but I think you'll find that the onus of proof is on you.

I have better things to do with my time than check all you spurious remarks.

Thanks in advance! 

[Eleanor]

Just a reminder that the attacks on Mr Amaral began while he was working on the case.
There is no other case in the world where the investigator has been attacked so vehemently.
My friend in Chicago thinks there is something very odd behind these orchestrated attacks.

I think that the there was something very odd about the orchestrated attacks against The McCanns, never mind my friend in Chicago.

[pegasus]

Noting a differencebetween the two books.
One mentions being questioned about the black bag sighting, but Mr Amaral's appears to not mention it.
(unless it's the pink blocks sighting?)

[Estuarine]

Me being an unworldly character and all will someone clue me in; is "NOT" an acronym similar to "FIAT".

[sadie]

What do you mean? Are you proposing the azuremare theory (which bizarrely claimed that Amaral and Cristavao did it)?

In answer to Cariad:  Well it might have been wiped now.  So much evidence is vanishing.  But it has been seen by enough people in the case to believe it.

ETA I see that Eleanor thinks it is still available

To peagsus:

1.  We are only repeating what Amaral said.

Do you think what he said was acceptable ?

.... or was it, maybe,  something very worrying  from a man who ermmm, "solves" missing child cases to say?  Cases which look like abductions but the parents always get the blame, with no proof whatsoever



Do you think that what he said was acceptable Pegasus?



2. As far as I am awate there is nothing orchestrated about our responses on here.  If there is, then I am not part of it and in seven years almost, I have never come across any orchestration.  Another Myth from the peeps against the Mccanns ?

[pegasus]

As does my friend in Kyrgyzstan...

BTW the food is superb, (back in spring 2009 it was anyway)
Back to the current attacks on Mr Amaral: The irony is that the many Brit experts worked with Amaral in the original investigation, I doubt that the attacks on the competency of that original investigation will impress those peeps in the Met, DCIU, LP, NPIA etc

[Carana]

Noting a differencebetween the two books.
One mentions being questioned about the black bag sighting, but Mr Amaral's appears to not mention it.
(unless it's the pink blocks sighting?)

Interesting. Could you cite the differences?

[Carana]

BTW the food is superb, (back in spring 2009 it was anyway)
Back to the current attacks on Mr Amaral: The irony is that the many Brit experts worked with Amaral in the original investigation, I doubt that the attacks on the competency of that original investigation will impress those peeps in the Met, DCIU, LP, NPIA etc

I doubt anything posted on forums or in the tabloids will influence the teams in charge of the investigation. At least, I hope not.

[Anna]

Noting a differencebetween the two books.
One mentions being questioned about the black bag sighting, but Mr Amaral's appears to not mention it.
(unless it's the pink blocks sighting?)

I assume this is the black bag sighting

Processos Vol II Page 316

External Inquiry

Date: 2007/05/07
Place: Lagos/Ponta da Piedade
Officer responsible for inquiry: Carlos Pimenta, Inspector and Pedro Vilhena

Description and Result of Inquiry
Yesterday afternoon, a German citizen, E***** V****, contacted the Lagos Maritime Police to say that during a boat outing in the zone in front of Farol da Ponta da Piedade, in Lagos, he saw a dark coloured bag amongst the cliffs, the bag was of some volume, contents unknown .
Given that this individual was not available for the rest of the day, it was not possible for the Maritime Police to locate this object and the inquiry was programmed for today, in the morning.
Embarking from " Lagos", at around 09h00, leaving from the quay of the marina (Lagos), the undersigned in the company of Assistant Specialist Pedro Vilhena, Commander Marques Pereira as well as two officers from the Maritime Police, following the indications of E**** V***, who accompanied us, we left for the ocean to the exact place where the bag in question could be observed. The bag was found lying on a part of the cliffs with difficult access, about 15 metres above the water line. Upon considering the place where the article was found, we had other PJ
officers go to the same place via land. These officers managed to reach the bag in question and proceed to recover it.
Photographic reports follow the statements with land-earth perspective.
Attached to the statements is the RDE elaborated by the "team" which collected the article in question.
Comments and or the proposition by the officer who executed the inquiry: Signature of the officer

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post2793.html#p2793