Author Topic: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?  (Read 27259 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline pegasus

Re: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?
« Reply #90 on: February 26, 2014, 10:16:04 PM »
IMO the author wrote the book honestly and genuinely hoping it would help to to find what happened to her child.

Redblossom

  • Guest
Re: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?
« Reply #91 on: February 27, 2014, 11:12:47 AM »
The fact that the book focuses so heavily on Kate, her feelings, thoughts, ideas, and has a prose style that is heavily inflected with emotion and subjectivity, shows that emotional reasons were very important in its creation.

Yes, it was going to make money. But if it had been written with investigative value in mind, it would have been more fact and less emotion focused. As redblossom mentions, for example, no reference to the Smith e-fit (though they were not mentioned anywhere at that point so for continuity's sake Kate would have had to omit them).

This book was not merely a money spinner, or a setting straight of records;  nor was it an homage to Madeleine whose name is mentioned far less frequently than one would expect it to be. It is an emotional mother's emotional response.

Note that she is the author - not Gerry or a joint project.

It was actually promoted as somethng that might jog someones memory...and it will be a piece of evidence as well, appended to the PJ process for future reference and use as was their documentary. Both as good as witness statements.
« Last Edit: February 27, 2014, 11:14:41 AM by Redblossom »

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?
« Reply #92 on: February 27, 2014, 02:01:16 PM »
It was actually promoted as somethng that might jog someones memory...and it will be a piece of evidence as well, appended to the PJ process for future reference and use as was their documentary. Both as good as witness statements.

It may well have been promoted as that, and useful for other things too, but that is separate from the motivation.




Offline Carew

Re: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?
« Reply #93 on: February 27, 2014, 05:39:55 PM »
Goes without saying that the financial was a big part of it - not denying that.

But the cathartic element was strong. And I agree with you, Luz. The purpose of Catharsis is emotional purge, not  exposition of facts.


The reason Dr K. McCann gave for writing the book was to give "an account of the truth".

This would imply that the exposition of facts was the principle aim.

"My reason for writing it is simple: to give an account of the truth"

Offline jassi

Re: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?
« Reply #94 on: February 27, 2014, 05:59:22 PM »

The reason Dr K. McCann gave for writing the book was to give "an account of the truth".

This would imply that the exposition of facts was the principle aim.

"My reason for writing it is simple: to give an account of the truth"

I've always been told that truth is in the eye of the beholder.
I believe everything. And l believe nothing.
I suspect everyone. And l suspect no one.
I gather the facts, examine the clues... and before   you know it, the case is solved!"

Or maybe not -

OG have been pushed out by the Germans who have reserved all the deck chairs for the foreseeable future

Silkywhiskers

  • Guest
Re: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?
« Reply #95 on: February 27, 2014, 06:16:56 PM »

The reason Dr K. McCann gave for writing the book was to give "an account of the truth".

This would imply that the exposition of facts was the principle aim.

"My reason for writing it is simple: to give an account of the truth"

"An Account of the Truth" isn't actually the same as The Truth.


Offline Carew

Re: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?
« Reply #96 on: February 27, 2014, 06:26:32 PM »
"An Account of the Truth" isn't actually the same as The Truth.

Yes, I know.........

I just gave the reason as Kate stated it......in response to another post about exposition of facts/emotional reasons.


icabodcrane

  • Guest
Re: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?
« Reply #97 on: February 27, 2014, 06:27:33 PM »
Goes without saying that the financial was a big part of it - not denying that.

But the cathartic element was strong. And I agree with you, Luz. The purpose of Catharsis is emotional purge, not  exposition of facts.

The purpose of Catharsis  ( in psychological terms )  is the purging of repressed emotions

I have read Kate's book and I do not see any such cathartic process  ...  there are no emotions expressed in it,  that I can see,  which have not been expressed previously  (  and often  ) 

What are the emotions you are refering to  ?   (  which Kate repressed  prior to writing the book  )

Silkywhiskers

  • Guest
Re: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?
« Reply #98 on: February 27, 2014, 06:33:08 PM »
The purpose of Catharsis  ( in psychological terms )  is the purging of repressed emotions

I have read Kate's book and I do not see any such cathartic process  ...  there are no emotions expressed in it,  that I can see,  which have not been expressed previously  (  and often  ) 

What are the emotions you are refering to  ?   (  which Kate repressed  prior to writing the book  )

Not only are there no emotions, there are no descriptions of Madeleine the little girl.

We get Madeleine in the Tennis Ball photo, Madeleine in her new outfit, all descriptive of PHOTOGRAPHS.

There is nothing personal, or emotional at all, when she talks of her daughter.  Madeleine has become her own image rather than a living, breathing, much loved baby.


Redblossom

  • Guest
Re: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?
« Reply #99 on: February 27, 2014, 06:35:13 PM »
The book was also to be a record of events for the three kids to read when they are older? Its in the intro somewhere. IIRC

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?
« Reply #100 on: February 28, 2014, 02:42:15 AM »
The purpose of Catharsis  ( in psychological terms )  is the purging of repressed emotions

I have read Kate's book and I do not see any such cathartic process  ...  there are no emotions expressed in it,  that I can see,  which have not been expressed previously  (  and often  ) 

What are the emotions you are refering to  ?   (  which Kate repressed  prior to writing the book  )

The term 'catharsis', as far as I remember, is Aristotelian. It is certainly a Greek word, and if not coined by Aristotle himself, was used by him to refer to purging and cleansing, often through the production of works of creativity.

Repression is a nineteenth century term and concept, and I do not believe Catharsis is necessarily the purging of repressed emotions, but merely the removal of strong and important ones.

As we have mentioned before with regard to Gerry and Kate McCann, people obviously have different ways of expressing those emotions. Kate is clearly uncomfortable displaying her feelings, and over compensates in the book by making crude references to extremely personal thoughts and ideas, out of the blue. 

There are indeed few direct references to Kate's feelings in the book, and more significantly, as Luz points out, few warm references to Madeleine. In fact there isn't that much in there about Madeleine at all.

A book entitled 'Madeleine' should really be about someone called Madeleine (forgive me my simplicity, I'm just a high school English teacher!). This book 'Madeleine', however, is really far more about Kate. That essential narcissistic element indicates that the book was really written for Kate herself - whether she puts in fluffy and emotional comments or not.

The process of writing and displaying that writing in the shop window was more important for Kate than the actual 'Madeleine' content. Quantity (of words) constituted the purge, rather than their emotional quality.

The act of catharsis lies in the process of creating. Whether the final product is what the audience was expecting is something else.




« Last Edit: February 28, 2014, 03:03:11 AM by Sherlock Holmes »

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?
« Reply #101 on: February 28, 2014, 02:50:16 AM »
I am surprised you are indulging me in my psychobabble, icabod, but I appreciate it.  ?{)(**

Offline valeria

Re: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?
« Reply #102 on: February 28, 2014, 09:03:16 AM »
catharsis in Aristotele is the effect of the tragedy on the viewr in theater. Although the importance of the term has risen over the centuries the intellectuals,the most accepted meaning of the term is atonement that comes after you pass the process of pain. The exact etymological sense of the word in greek is exemption from something harmful. Was the writting of the book a painful experience for Kate...i dont know. I havent read it. You can understand better.

Offline Sherlock Holmes

Re: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?
« Reply #103 on: February 28, 2014, 06:09:39 PM »
catharsis in Aristotele is the effect of the tragedy on the viewr in theater. Although the importance of the term has risen over the centuries the intellectuals,the most accepted meaning of the term is atonement that comes after you pass the process of pain. The exact etymological sense of the word in greek is exemption from something harmful. Was the writting of the book a painful experience for Kate...i dont know. I havent read it. You can understand better.

Thanks for the clarification, valeria. It seems we are mixing up the idea of catharsis with the more modern concept of the expulsion of repressed or other emotions.

These technicalities aside, it is well known that many people write books about major events in their lives, and that the process of writing is of assistance to them - whether the title hits the bestseller list or not.

Offline Carana

Re: Was the book Madeleine written for cathartic or financial reasons?
« Reply #104 on: February 28, 2014, 07:34:18 PM »
Thanks for the clarification, valeria. It seems we are mixing up the idea of catharsis with the more modern concept of the expulsion of repressed or other emotions.

These technicalities aside, it is well known that many people write books about major events in their lives, and that the process of writing is of assistance to them - whether the title hits the bestseller list or not.

Or composing songs, hitting punch bags or whatever else. A way of releasing pain, anger, frustration.