Was Mr Smiths claim just pie in the sky after all?

[pegasus]

I am interested in  checking the time of the sighting primarily from the Dolphin credit card transaction and the Kelly till cash transaction/transactions.

[Mr Gray]

I thought in his original statement smith didnt see the suspects face

[Anna]

I thought in his original statement smith didnt see the suspects face

He said he was clean shaven, didn't wear glasses and had a normal complexion, but the light was poor.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post534.html#p534

[Mr Gray]

He said he was clean shaven, didn't wear glasses and had a normal complexion, but the light was poor.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post534.html#p534

could be anybody

[pegasus]

could be anybody

It was definitely a male who at that moment was wearing trousers of a colour similar to cream .
Surely that rules out every male who at that moment was wearing blue jeans.

[Carana]

It was definitely a male who at that moment was wearing trousers of a colour similar to cream .
Surely that rules out every male who at that moment was wearing blue jeans.

Interesting point...

[sadie]

It was definitely a male who at that moment was wearing trousers of a colour similar to cream .
Surely that rules out every male who at that moment was wearing blue jeans.

Could they have been white?  New white decorators overalls with a jacket over?  Would fit into SY theory by the sound of it.  Weren't they decorators?

And am I imagining it or was there a report on here very rtecently , or maybe in the files, of three road sweepers wearing white overalls / boiler suits ?

[Carana]

Could they have been white?  New white decorators overalls with a jacket over?  Would fit into SY theory by the sound of it.  Weren't they decorators?

And am I imagining it or was there a report on here very rtecently , or maybe in the files, of three road sweepers wearing white overalls / boiler suits ?

I doubt that whoever it was was wearing a boiler suit, Sadie. Even if someone had just been wearing the bottom half, covered by a jacket, well after dark, might it have attracted attention.

[sadie]

I doubt that whoever it was was wearing a boiler suit, Sadie. Even if someone had just been wearing the bottom half, covered by a jacket, well after dark, might it have attracted attention.

Yep, you are right, Carana

[Anna]

Yep, you are right, Carana

Lady in 5a from 31 march 2007 They were road sweepers wearing outfits that looked like surgical outfits , so probably green. This lady's daughter cut her chin at the crèche and she thinks it had nearly stopped bleeding when she collectedher, but took her to a doctor in PDL and had it stitched.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post2887.html#p2887

[sadie]

Lady in 5a from 31 march 2007 They were road sweepers wearing outfits that looked like surgical outfits , so probably green. This lady's daughter cut her chin at the crèche and she thinks it had nearly stopped bleeding when she collectedher, but took her to a doctor in PDL and had it stitched.

http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post2887.html#p2887

You are right too !

Thanks Anna

[Carana]

Wearing a boiler suit / painting overalls wouldn't stand out to me during the day, but I'd probably notice it late in the evening.

[sadie]

Wearing a boiler suit / painting overalls wouldn't stand out to me during the day, but I'd probably notice it late in the evening.

Assuming they wear the same type of painting gear that our guys in the UK wear, I think you are right Carana.  They are not tailored enough

[pegasus]

Interesting point...

Two T9statements state (correctly I believe) was wearing blue jeans.
Two of the Smith group statements certainly rule out blue jeans.
Logical deduction is: not same person.

[Silkywhiskers]

Two T9statements state (correctly I believe) was wearing blue jeans.
Two of the Smith group statements certainly rule out blue jeans.
Logical deduction is: not same person.

either that or, one group is not telling the truth.