DCI Redwood now admits Madeleine may not have left the apartment alive.

[Mr Gray]

Really wacky, given that SY have not come to any conclusion, they have not charged anyone nor brought a case to court to put before a Judge and jury.

Clearly you are not privy to al SY's thinking, are you?

you are wrong...SY have reached certain conclusions as I have posted

[Albertini]

they have reached certain conclusions...the parents are not suspects...maddie may be alive...or sadly dead...they are investigating an abduction

The only time you can claim agreement with their conclusion is when a case is brought to court and that case is based on the parents not being charged and a third party abductor.

[Albertini]

you are wrong...SY have reached certain conclusions as I have posted

No, I'm really not.

[Albertini]

Who do you think you are to tell me anything...amaral reached conclusions or is your memory so short you have forgotten

Since when have i either mentioned Amaral or claimed to be him?

What has Amaral got to do with our discussion?

[Mr Gray]

Since when have i either mentioned Amaral or claimed to be him?

What has Amaral got to do with our discussion?

because no one has ever questioned the fact that amaral reached conclusions...you are just devasated...because SY do not blame the parents and are disregarding the dogs alerts

[icabodcrane]

The McCanns have always said  that there is absolutey nothing to suggest Madeleine is dead

If that is true,  why have Scotland Yard have said Madeleine may have died in the apartment  ? 

They  (  Scotland Yard  )  must think  there  IS  something that suggests Madeleine might be dead,  mustn't they  ?  ...  I mean they wouldn't say she might have  died in the apartment if there was nothing at all to suggest she might have,  would they  ? 

I think what leads them to believe Madeleine may have died in apartment 5A is that a cadaver dog alerted there 

I think Scotland Yard are giving the dog inteligence serious consideration

[Albertini]

because no one has ever questioned the fact that amaral reached conclusions...you are just devatstaed...because SY do not blame the parents and are disregarding the dogs alerts

Amaral's conclusions were documented and presented to the world in a tangible way, first with the Arguido status imposed against the McCann's then the release of the case files.

SY have not released any of their case files nor made anyone a formal suspect.

See the difference?

ETA

Yet SY have said Madeleine could have died before she left the apartment, which does not disregard the dogs alerts, does it?

If you think about it the only way SY could disregard the alerts was to say for definite that the child DID NOT die in the apartment. Yet they have said precisely the opposite.

Funny that.

[Cariad]

they have reached certain conclusions...the parents are not suspects...maddie may be alive...or sadly dead...they are investigating an abduction

Actually, abduction doesn't follow all their thinking in this case.

[Mr Gray]

The McCanns have always said  that there is absolutey nothing to suggest Madeleine is dead

If that is true,  why have Scotland Yard have said Madeleine may have died in the apartment  ? 

They  (  Scotland Yard  )  must think  there  IS  something that suggests Madeleine might be dead,  mustn't they  ?  ...  I mean they wouldn't say she might have  died in the apartment if there was nothing at all to suggest she might have,  would they  ? 

I think what leads them to believe Madeleine may have died in apartment 5A is that a cadaver dog alerted there 

I think Scotland Yard are giving the dog inteligence serious consideration

if SY say Maddie may be alive then SY are discounting the dog's alerts...Sy say maddie may still be alive...which part of that don't you undersatnd

[Wonderfulspam]

The McCanns have always said  that there is absolutey nothing to suggest Madeleine is dead

If that is true,  why have Scotland Yard have said Madeleine may have died in the apartment  ? 

They  (  Scotland Yard  )  must think  there  IS  something that suggests Madeleine might be dead,  mustn't they  ?  ...  I mean they wouldn't say she might have  died in the apartment if there was nothing at all to suggest she might have,  would they  ? 

I think what leads them to believe Madeleine may have died in apartment 5A is that a cadaver dog alerted there 

I think Scotland Yard are giving the dog inteligence serious consideration

Why wouldn't they, what other serious lead do they have?  Gypsies, tramps and theives I suppose.

[Wonderfulspam]

if SY say Maddie may be alive then SY are discounting the dog's alerts...Sy say maddie may still be alive...which part of that don't you undersatnd

Then your suggesting the alerts are proof she died.

[Mr Gray]

Amaral's conclusions were documented and presented to the world in a tangible way, first with the Arguido status imposed against the McCann's then the release of the case files.

SY have not released any of their case files nor made anyone a formal suspect.

See the difference?

ETA

Yet SY have said Madeleine could have died before she left the apartment, which does not disregard the dogs alerts, does it?

If you think about it the only way SY could disregard the alerts was to say for definite that the child DID NOT die in the apartment. Yet they have said precisely the opposite.

Funny that.

First I see the difference... with amaral..he didn't understand either the dogs alerts or the dna evidence..SY do.


The opposite of DID NOT is DID...SY have said MAY...  Sy have not said precisely the opposite.....you are 100% wrong again

[jassi]

Why wouldn't they, what other serious lead do they have?  Gypsies, tramps and theives I suppose.

A fan of Cher by any chance?  By the way it's thieves

Well, they've done the gypsies and thieves, so its only fair that they give the tramps a go.

[Mr Gray]

What you've posted is SY views that may be subject to change. A conclusion is a very different prospect.

semantics

[jassi]

Well, they've done the gypsies and thieves, so its only fair that they give the tramps a go.

Only the ones in  Portugal?

I don't suppose tramps travel abroad very much.