Cadaver Dog Alerts, Missing Person Turns Up Alive.

[Alfred R Jones]

It doesn't mean the dog is wrong as the Mathews case proved. It doesn't mean a dead body hadn't been in there in regards to the DeJesus case. Better go to the source not from a report before claiming their dogs were wrong.

So a cadaver dog can never give a false alert then, even if it alerts and no body or trace of a body is discovered, is that your view?

[pathfinder73]

doesn't mean he's right either...could always toss a coin

Well ya clutching at straws to find cases aren't ya? There's countless cases of cadaver alerts being spot on and Grime's dogs were considered the best that's why the FBI wanted him.

[Anna]

It doesn't mean the dog is wrong as the Mathews case proved. It doesn't mean a dead body hadn't been in there in regards to the DeJesus case. Better go to the source not from a report before claiming their dogs were wrong.

Many factors such as cross contamination, can cause alerts too, but it doesn't mean there is or has been a body in the location alerted to.

[Mr Gray]

Well ya clutching at straws to find cases aren't ya? There's countless cases of cadaver alerts being spot on and Grime's dogs were considered the best that's why the FBI wanted him.

if he's that good why could grime not confirm the alerts

[Alfred R Jones]

Well ya clutching at straws to find cases aren't ya? There's countless cases of cadaver alerts being spot on and Grime's dogs were considered the best that's why the FBI wanted him.

"Cadaver dog alerts, nothing found" is a headline on a par with "small earthquake in Indonesia, no one injured", ie: not very interesting news to 99.9% of the world's population.

[pathfinder73]

if he's that good why could grime not confirm the alerts

Because if Eddie ever gave a false alert Grime is covered. But Grime knows Eddie has never given him a false alert and he would say that in a court of law if it is required.

[Alfred R Jones]

So a cadaver dog can never give a false alert then, even if it alerts and no body or trace of a body is discovered, is that your view?

bump

[Mr Gray]

Because if Eddie ever gave a false alert Grime is covered. But Grime knows Eddie has never given him a false alert and he would say that in a court of law if it is required.

Grime doesn't know that and has admitted it

[Anna]

OK Stay on the Topic please.....We are still looking for Dog alerts when a person is later found alive. thanks

[faithlilly]

OK Stay on the Topic please.....We are still looking for Dog alerts when a person is later found alive. thanks

It's interesting Anna that 137 posts in and we still haven't found any.

[Anna]

It's interesting Anna that 137 posts in and we still haven't found any.

That is true Faith, with the exception of two.
But how often do you hear of a earthquake warning, when it is proved to be wrong, before it has been broadcasted.

[slartibartfast]

That is true Faith, with the exception of two.
But how often do you hear of a earthquake warning, when it is proved to be wrong, before it has been broadcasted.

Sorry, which 2 were those?

[Mr Gray]

It's interesting Anna that 137 posts in and we still haven't found any.

wrong as usual...try reading the posts again

[Alfred R Jones]

Sorry, which 2 were those?

you people are priceless.  I suggest you read pages 1 & 2 of this thread again before commenting further

ETA: page 1 will do.

[Alfred R Jones]

PS: how many cases of cadaver dogs alerting in cases of missing people and then the missing person subsequently turning up alive do we need to find before the dog apologists will accept that it can and does happen?  3?  5?  20?