Does the Madeleine McCann case warrant a Public Inquiry?

[Brietta]

We're on the same wavelength.

My only point - regarding Jim Gamble's piece - is that the lessons regarding better practice may well be mutual.

I agree ... I think the only way such a working relationship could be maintained would be a mutual respect and I imagine one side has as much to contribute as the other.

I think, as noted in James Murray's article, everything keeps on coming back to issues which were overlooked by the initial investigation and the concentration on the assumption that there was no need to look further than Madeleine's parents and their friends.

Nothing exemplifies that more than the cursory attention given the available information on the telephone calls, with as can be seen from the files, the exception of Robert Murat and his associates and the McCanns and their friends.

Even so, I doubt if a public inquiry either here or in Portugal would cast any more light on that since the PJ and SY have already gone into the matter in fine detail.

[Miss Taken Identity]

Did I say he did it for PR reasons? It would have been difficult to say no to Brooks but I don't doubt his sincerity about what he's said he believes happened to Madeleine.

What he believes is no real good reason just because he is PM. Now let's look at this from a different angle. who are the major players here?

Murdoch- Brooks. media moguls who win elections...maybe that is the Politicians favoured interest?

Murdoch has made millions from Maddie....hmm you thinking what I am thinking? Murdoch says jump  they scream how high? well, anyway.. It is HOME OFFICE MONEY which is weird because this is a police investigation? unless there is a national security risk?..

[Brietta]

What he believes is no real good reason just because he is PM. Now let's look at this from a different angle. who are the major players here?

Murdoch- Brooks. media moguls who win elections...maybe that is the Politicians favoured interest?

Murdoch has made millions from Maddie....hmm you thinking what I am thinking? Murdoch says jump  they scream how high? well, anyway.. It is HOME OFFICE MONEY which is weird because this is a police investigation? unless there is a national security risk?..

                                        &%+((£   Who are the main players?    &%+((£

I think the most obvious one may very well be a girl called Madeleine McCann ... remember her?  She is the child you want everyone to stop looking for despite your desire for truth an justice for her.  Funny that.

[Miss Taken Identity]

                                        &%+((£   Who are the main players?    &%+((£

I think the most obvious one may very well be a girl called Madeleine McCann ... remember her?  She is the child you want everyone to stop looking for despite your desire for truth an justice for her.  Funny that.

Little Maddie in NOT a major player here. I will tell you why, you may not like the answer but hey you are a big girl let's go for it.

She had no say in her upbringing- she challenged her parents regarding their evenings leaving them alone, she must have been frightened- she was crually ignored. That whole story has been played down by you and many others. Maddie tried to protect herself and her siblings by letting her mother know they woke up crying.

[Brietta]

Little Maddie in NOT a major player here. I will tell you why, you may not like the answer but hey you are a big girl let's go for it.

She had no say in her upbringing- she challenged her parents regarding their evenings leaving them alone, she must have been frightened- she was crually ignored. That whole story has been played down by you and many others. Maddie tried to protect herself and her siblings by letting her mother know they woke up crying.

Madeleine McCann is missing ...

The police are looking for her ...

There are those who object vociferously to that ...

[Miss Taken Identity]

Madeleine McCann is missing ...

The police are looking for her ...

There are those who object vociferously to that ...

Yes indeed they are!  and I am not one of them!   So kindly refrain from implying I am part of a ha ting group who you follow around looking for negative PR.

[stephen25000]

Madeleine McCann is missing ...

The police are looking for her ...

There are those who object vociferously to that ...

She has been looked for , for 8 years, with no result.

One has to ask why people such as yourself keep wanting tax payers money spent on an investigation going nowhere.

[Brietta]

She has been looked for , for 8 years, with no result.

One has to ask why people such as yourself keep wanting tax payers money spent on an investigation going nowhere.

One has to ask why there are people who want a Public Inquiry to disrupt the very difficult work involved in the search for a little girl who went missing eight years ago.

Are you one of them?

[sadie]

One has to ask why there are people who want a Public Inquiry to disrupt the very difficult work involved in the search for a little girl who went missing eight years ago.

Are you one of them?

Some people dont want Madeleine found, Brietta.  It would expose their hitherto whiter than white orgisation.


And cause them to lose millions illicitly "earned"


Am not saying that Stephen is one of them.

[Alfred R Jones]

What about a Public Inquiry into the disappearances of Ben Needham and Claudia Lawrence while we're at it?  Or don't they deserve one?

[Miss Taken Identity]

What about a Public Inquiry into the disappearances of Ben Needham and Claudia Lawrence while we're at it?  Or don't they deserve one?

Good question. Why not post it on the relevent threads this one is about:Does the Madeleine McCann case warrant a Public Inquiry?

[stephen25000]

One has to ask why there are people who want a Public Inquiry to disrupt the very difficult work involved in the search for a little girl who went missing eight years ago.

Are you one of them?

Nothing has been found.

SY's investigation has merely wasted public money, with zero results to show for it.

[stephen25000]

Some people dont want Madeleine found, Brietta.  It would expose their hitherto whiter than white orgisation.


And cause them to lose millions illicitly "earned"


Am not saying that Stephen is one of them.

I hate to disappoint you sadie, but I only post here on my own volition, and nothing to do with mysterious organizations.

[Carana]

Back to topic:

Re: Does the Madeleine McCann case warrant a Public Inquiry?

If so why? If not, why not?

[Eleanor]

Back to topic:

Re: Does the Madeleine McCann case warrant a Public Inquiry?

If so why? If not, why not?

A Public Enquiry about what?  The disastrous Portuguese Investigation?  Not really our business.  So what else is there to enquire about.

I did get some hint that certain Folks think this would drag The McCanns into Court to answer questions.  But that won't wash because The McCanns aren't obliged to answer anything at this stage.  And almost certainly never will be.