2 things Sadie.
1. How many young blond haired girls have a similar appearance ?
2. Do you how many people share similar genes ?
1. It depends how discernig your eye is
2. I have no idea, but all I know is that I have never seen two identical people unless twins, when they are very close.
When deciding whether a child is Madeleine, other things would have to be taken into account such as bone mass /petiteness , clarity of skin, mannerisms, energy levels, intellect, posture, length of stride, sense of humour, similarities to parents and close blood relatives .... this isn't complete; such a large group of criteria come together to make the whole.
Some people simply do not have the ability to see the likenesses which are pretty obvious to others.
Now that we know the eyes can be completely camauflaged, we must not be over-ruled by the apparant lack of Coloboma in her eye
http://www.clspectrum.com/articleviewer.aspx?articleID=104098