Author Topic: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?  (Read 8882 times)

0 Members and 7 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?
« Reply #30 on: September 10, 2015, 07:40:03 PM »
I presume you're referring to the McCanns and their friends and family as they were the ones who 'opened things up to the press'. I don't think they thought it through, it just seemed like a good idea at the time.
Yes, I was referring to the McCanns and friends.

I am not saying your assessment of what may have happened is incorrect.  I just wonder if this was another missed opportunity, or it was the best that could have been done at the time.
What's up, old man?

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?
« Reply #31 on: September 10, 2015, 08:12:31 PM »
Thanks to Brietta for attempting to render that in Engllish.

Alice, I don't believe for one moment that you didn't understand the gist of that, naughty boy.

Whether or not anyone in a position of authority actually had the faintest clue what they were doing, they had to appear as if they did to conform to the public perception of US crime TV shows that miraculously get solved in 48 minutes.

I understood it to be a definite possible maybe since 1990s rather than a tradition.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

stephen25000

  • Guest
Re: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?
« Reply #32 on: September 10, 2015, 08:13:41 PM »
Taking the Lord's name in vain tends to do that.

Is that Lord Jeffrey Archer perchance ? 8)--))

Offline G-Unit

Re: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?
« Reply #33 on: September 10, 2015, 08:29:16 PM »
Yes, I was referring to the McCanns and friends.

I am not saying your assessment of what may have happened is incorrect.  I just wonder if this was another missed opportunity, or it was the best that could have been done at the time.

Sorry, I don't understand. What opportunities were missed?

They didn't all agree at first about informing the media as far as I can see. It seems to have been Rachael Oldfield who was the main one in Portugal. She rang James Landale's wife at 0142 on 4th May. Between then and 1239 there were eight other calls between them. James Landale was a political correspondent with the BBC. Rachael also spoke with James Landale himself and 'a few times' with the BBC News 24 desk.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RACHAEL-OLDFIELD-ROGATORY.htm
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?
« Reply #34 on: September 10, 2015, 10:50:28 PM »
Sorry, I don't understand. What opportunities were missed?

They didn't all agree at first about informing the media as far as I can see. It seems to have been Rachael Oldfield who was the main one in Portugal. She rang James Landale's wife at 0142 on 4th May. Between then and 1239 there were eight other calls between them. James Landale was a political correspondent with the BBC. Rachael also spoke with James Landale himself and 'a few times' with the BBC News 24 desk.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/RACHAEL-OLDFIELD-ROGATORY.htm
I should have been clearer.  Both the McCann side and the PJ side seemed to have had more opportunity to manage the media rather than being managed by the media, even in the early days.

By 4 May 2007, it strikes me as akin to media sharks circling both the McCanns and the PJ, scenting blood in the water, with both sides fairly clueless as to what to do about it.

At that point, Madeleine's chances were fast approaching zero.
What's up, old man?

Offline G-Unit

Re: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?
« Reply #35 on: September 11, 2015, 08:27:58 AM »
I should have been clearer.  Both the McCann side and the PJ side seemed to have had more opportunity to manage the media rather than being managed by the media, even in the early days.

By 4 May 2007, it strikes me as akin to media sharks circling both the McCanns and the PJ, scenting blood in the water, with both sides fairly clueless as to what to do about it.

At that point, Madeleine's chances were fast approaching zero.

A very good assessment of the situation, Shining. The 'side' which recovered the initiative was the McCann side, with help from media experts. The PJ had never, as far as I know, faced such a media frenzy before and had no idea what to do about it.
Read and abide by the forum rules.
Result = happy posting.
Ignore and break the rules
Result = edits, deletions and unhappiness
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=2.0

Offline Carana

Re: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?
« Reply #36 on: September 11, 2015, 08:40:37 AM »
I have looked in the Penal Code but have been unable to find it - there is at least one other area when an exemption can be asked for, forget what, possibly banking??

The problem being it is not automatic, the lead investigator has to make the request. 

For the moment the best I can do at the moment is a quote from Danny Collins who states in VANISHED ...


" , but Portugal's somewhat eccentric laws of judicial secrecy meant no official information could be released to the public regarding Madeleine's disappearance, although according to a Portuguese lawyer consulted during research for this book, exception to the secrecy laws are allowed in the 'exceptional circumstances' of missing children. While that may be so, no exception was made in the case of missing Madeleine McCann."

The laws on judicial secrecy have apparently changed now (towards being the exception rather than the rule), but I haven't looked into what the new ones actually state.

If I've got the gist of this, back then, there were still provisions for certain types of information to be made public during the investigation when deemed necessary, as long as it didn't compromise the investigation, privacy rights, etc.

The way 86.9 is formulated, it sounds as if it mainly deals with calming down unfounded speculation... a shame that that provision wasn't actually used.

On the other hand, if that could be applied in the general spirit of common sense, I see no reason why a judge couldn't issue an appeal for witnesses, if the purpose was to assist the investigation.

One issue was (no doubt still is), that you can't publish someone's photo or footage of them without their consent. That might have ruled out using CCTV footage in an appeal, but I don't see how that would apply to an unidentified person in an efit or an artist's impression.

Art. 86
(Publicidade do processo e segredo de justiça)
(especially point 9)
9 - O segredo de justiça não prejudica a prestação de esclarecimentos públicos:
a) Quando necessários ao restabelecimento da verdade e sem prejuízo para a investigação, a pedido de pessoas publicamente postas em causa;
b) Excepcionalmente, nomeadamente em casos de especial repercussão pública, quando e na medida do estritamente necessário para a reposição da verdade sobre factos publicamente divulgados, para garantir a segurança de pessoas e bens e para evitar perturbação da tranquilidade pública.

and

Art. 89
(Meios de comunicação social)
1 - É permitida aos órgãos de comunicação social, dentro dos limites da lei, a narração circunstanciada do teor de actos processuais que se não encontrem cobertos por segredo de justiça ou a cujo decurso for permitida a assistência do público em geral.

http://paulosantos-adv.planetaclix.pt/CPP.htm

Offline Brietta

Re: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?
« Reply #37 on: September 11, 2015, 09:10:43 AM »
The laws on judicial secrecy have apparently changed now (towards being the exception rather than the rule), but I haven't looked into what the new ones actually state.

If I've got the gist of this, back then, there were still provisions for certain types of information to be made public during the investigation when deemed necessary, as long as it didn't compromise the investigation, privacy rights, etc.

The way 86.9 is formulated, it sounds as if it mainly deals with calming down unfounded speculation... a shame that that provision wasn't actually used.

On the other hand, if that could be applied in the general spirit of common sense, I see no reason why a judge couldn't issue an appeal for witnesses, if the purpose was to assist the investigation.

One issue was (no doubt still is), that you can't publish someone's photo or footage of them without their consent. That might have ruled out using CCTV footage in an appeal, but I don't see how that would apply to an unidentified person in an efit or an artist's impression.

Art. 86
(Publicidade do processo e segredo de justiça)
(especially point 9)
9 - O segredo de justiça não prejudica a prestação de esclarecimentos públicos:
a) Quando necessários ao restabelecimento da verdade e sem prejuízo para a investigação, a pedido de pessoas publicamente postas em causa;
b) Excepcionalmente, nomeadamente em casos de especial repercussão pública, quando e na medida do estritamente necessário para a reposição da verdade sobre factos publicamente divulgados, para garantir a segurança de pessoas e bens e para evitar perturbação da tranquilidade pública.

and

Art. 89
(Meios de comunicação social)
1 - É permitida aos órgãos de comunicação social, dentro dos limites da lei, a narração circunstanciada do teor de actos processuais que se não encontrem cobertos por segredo de justiça ou a cujo decurso for permitida a assistência do público em geral.

http://paulosantos-adv.planetaclix.pt/CPP.htm

Thanks Carana ... so as far as social media is concerned ... it is permissible to publicise information if the assistance of the public is required and this is lawful if other aspects of the secrecy law are not violated in the process ??

My reading of it is that it doesn't even require a judicial waiver ... although anyone with any sense would seek advice on the information to be disseminated.

Madeleine's disappearance could and should have been publicised by the authorities ... judicial secrecy could and should have been relaxed; leading to less criticism of the media and her distraught parents.

Thinking about the first appeal made for Madeleine's safe return leads to forming the comparison when a missing person press conference is called in Britain.
The police organise it ... they control the press and the questions asked ... they show solidarity with the missing and the relations, although they are also taking a keen interest in them;  the Drs McCann were left to face the cameras alone and that didn't need to happen.
So right from the start there was a separation and implied dichotomy which eventually snowballed out of all proportion ... and that could have been so easily avoided allowing all energies to be focused on the missing child.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline Carana

Re: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?
« Reply #38 on: September 11, 2015, 10:21:28 AM »
Thanks Carana ... so as far as social media is concerned ... it is permissible to publicise information if the assistance of the public is required and this is lawful if other aspects of the secrecy law are not violated in the process ??

My reading of it is that it doesn't even require a judicial waiver ... although anyone with any sense would seek advice on the information to be disseminated.

Madeleine's disappearance could and should have been publicised by the authorities ... judicial secrecy could and should have been relaxed; leading to less criticism of the media and her distraught parents.

Thinking about the first appeal made for Madeleine's safe return leads to forming the comparison when a missing person press conference is called in Britain.
The police organise it ... they control the press and the questions asked ... they show solidarity with the missing and the relations, although they are also taking a keen interest in them;  the Drs McCann were left to face the cameras alone and that didn't need to happen.
So right from the start there was a separation and implied dichotomy which eventually snowballed out of all proportion ... and that could have been so easily avoided allowing all energies to be focused on the missing child.

I'm not certain whether they could have done or not. The formulation of the law at the time doesn't specify that it could as it concerns statements of sanctioned statements of "clarification to the public".

A lot was delegated to the PJ, but some procedures required the permission of the prosecutor / magistrate (as happens everywhere). The prosecutor doesn't appear to have played much of an active role and I can't see anything in the files to suggest that the PJ ever submitted a request.


ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?
« Reply #39 on: September 11, 2015, 01:30:10 PM »
I'm not certain whether they could have done or not. The formulation of the law at the time doesn't specify that it could as it concerns statements of sanctioned statements of "clarification to the public".

A lot was delegated to the PJ, but some procedures required the permission of the prosecutor / magistrate (as happens everywhere). The prosecutor doesn't appear to have played much of an active role and I can't see anything in the files to suggest that the PJ ever submitted a request.

As I've tended to understand it, it's more the magistrates who played a hands-on role in the investigation, granting (or denying!) permission for implementing arguido status, bugging of phones (etc.)

Somewhere in Amaral's book there is (actually quite an informative) passage on how day-to-day management of an active investigation was conducted.

Offline Carana

Re: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?
« Reply #40 on: September 11, 2015, 05:07:52 PM »
As I've tended to understand it, it's more the magistrates who played a hands-on role in the investigation, granting (or denying!) permission for implementing arguido status, bugging of phones (etc.)

Somewhere in Amaral's book there is (actually quite an informative) passage on how day-to-day management of an active investigation was conducted.

I didn't get the impression that the magistrate was particularly hands-on. Certainly not in the sense of directing the police investigation, which is the procedure in some countries.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?
« Reply #41 on: September 11, 2015, 06:20:34 PM »
I didn't get the impression that the magistrate was particularly hands-on. Certainly not in the sense of directing the police investigation, which is the procedure in some countries.

Can't find it in the files, now, but I think the PJ applied to a magistrate for permission to bug the villa (or their telephone?) and permission was denied.

Did I dream that?

Offline mercury

Re: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?
« Reply #42 on: September 11, 2015, 11:00:17 PM »
I didn't get the impression that the magistrate was particularly hands-on. Certainly not in the sense of directing the police investigation, which is the procedure in some countries.

The PJ is called the PJ for a reason...look it up

Offline Carana

Re: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?
« Reply #43 on: September 13, 2015, 09:58:25 AM »
The PJ is called the PJ for a reason...look it up


Just for you, Mercury. ;)

Here you go. That looks incredibly like it means that the Public Ministry is supposed to lead the investigation, but can delegate much of it to the PJ, with a number of exceptions for which the PJ has to request permission (search warrants, etc).

Artigo 53.º

(Posição e atribuições do Ministério Público no processo)

1 - Compete ao Ministério Público, no processo penal, colaborar com o tribunal na descoberta da verdade e na realização do direito, obedecendo em todas as intervenções processuais a critérios de estrita objectividade.

2 - Compete em especial ao Ministério Público:

a) Receber as denúncias, as queixas e as participações e apreciar o seguimento a dar­lhes;

b) Dirigir o inquérito;


c) Deduzir acusação e sustentá­la efectivamente na instrução e no julgamento;

d) Interpor recursos, ainda que no exclusivo interesse da defesa;

e) Promover a execução das penas e das medidas de segurança.

And

 

Artigo 55.º

(Competência dos órgãos de polícia criminal)

1 - Compete aos órgãos de polícia criminal coadjuvar as autoridades judiciárias com vista à realização das finalidades do processo.


2 - Compete em especial aos órgãos de polícia criminal, mesmo por iniciativa própria, colher notícia dos crimes e impedir quanto possível as suas consequências, descobrir os seus agentes e levar a cabo os actos necessários e urgentes destinados a assegurar os meios de prova.

 

Artigo 56.º

(Orientação e dependência funcional dos órgãos de polícia criminal)

Nos limites do disposto no n.º 1 do artigo anterior, os órgãos de polícia criminal actuam, no processo, sob a direcção das autoridades judiciárias e na sua dependência funcional.



Artigo 270.º

(Actos que podem ser delegados pelo Ministério Público nos órgãos de polícia criminal)

1 - O Ministério Público pode conferir a órgãos de polícia criminal o encargo de procederem a quaisquer diligências e investigações relativas ao inquérito.


2 - Exceptuam­se do disposto no número anterior, além dos actos que são da competência exclusiva do juiz de instrução, nos termos dos artigos 268.º e 269.º, os actos seguintes:

a) Receber depoimentos ajuramentados, nos termos do artigo 138.º, n.º 3, segunda parte;

b) Ordenar a efectivação de perícia, nos termos do artigo 154.º;

c) Assistir a exame susceptível de ofender o pudor da pessoa, nos termos do artigo 172.º, n.º 2, segunda parte;

d) Ordenar ou autorizar revistas e buscas, nos termos e limites do artigo 174.º, n.ºs 3 e 4;

e) Quaisquer outros actos que a lei expressamente determinar que sejam presididos ou praticados pelo Ministério Público.

3 - O Ministério Público pode, porém, delegar em autoridades de polícia criminal a faculdade de ordenar a efectivação da perícia relativamente a determinados tipos de crime, em caso de urgência ou de perigo na demora, nomeadamente quando a perícia deva ser realizada conjuntamente com o exame de vestígios. Exceptuam-se a perícia que envolva a realização de autópsia médico-legal, bem como a prestação de esclarecimentos complementares e a realização de nova perícia nos termos do artigo 158.º.

4 - A delegação a que se refere o n.º 1 pode ser efectuada por despacho de natureza genérica que indique os tipos de crime ou os limites das penas aplicáveis aos crimes em investigação.

 

 
« Last Edit: September 13, 2015, 10:14:15 AM by Carana »

Offline Carana

Re: Could the media reporting of the Madeleine case been better handled?
« Reply #44 on: September 13, 2015, 10:17:08 AM »
Can't find it in the files, now, but I think the PJ applied to a magistrate for permission to bug the villa (or their telephone?) and permission was denied.

Did I dream that?

Yes, permission was denied for something or other. There are certain actions that require legal permission (as they do in the UK).