Did Eddie and Keela work as a team prior to the Madeleine McCann case?

[John]

Evidence, broadly construed, is anything presented in support of an assertion. This support may be strong or weak. The strongest type of evidence is that which provides direct proof of the truth of an assertion. At the other extreme is evidence that is merely consistent with an assertion but does not rule out other, contradictory assertions, as in circumstantial evidence.

The dog alerts are thus evidence as Anna pointed out earlier but the significance of this evidence is as yet undetermined.  In relation to Madeleine the alerts might have no significance whatsoever but then again they might have every significance.  As Mr Grime pointed out, the alerts at that moment in time had no evidential reliability since they were uncorroborated by forensic results but nevertheless, they are evidence of something.

[Mr Gray]

Evidence, broadly construed, is anything presented in support of an assertion. This support may be strong or weak. The strongest type of evidence is that which provides direct proof of the truth of an assertion. At the other extreme is evidence that is merely consistent with an assertion but does not rule out other, contradictory assertions, as in circumstantial evidence.

The dog alerts are thus evidence as Anna pointed out earlier but the significance of this evidence is as yet undetermined.  In relation to Madeleine the alerts might have no significance whatsoever but then again they might have every significance.  As Mr Grime pointed out, the alerts at that moment in time had no evidential reliability since they were uncorroborated by forensic results but nevertheless, they are evidence of something.

so you claim the alerts are evidence but you don't know what they are evidence of...so what does that mean the alerts tell us...nothing....and what does that make the alerts...useless

[slartibartfast]

so you claim the alerts are evidence but you don't know what they are evidence of...so what does that mean the alerts tell us...nothing....and what does that make the alerts...useless

You really don't like the dogs do you.

[Mr Gray]

You really don't like the dogs do you.

you are wrong...I like the truth about the dogs...there is a massive amount of untruths being told about the alerts...I like to correct it

[Mr Gray]

So, once again, they tell us that the cadaver dog sent in by the UK reacted to cadaver odour

this is the sort of thing being posted on this forum..it simply isn't true...I like to correct it. I am perfectly happy with the dog's findings...they found nothing of any use..

[G-Unit]

so you claim the alerts are evidence but you don't know what they are evidence of...so what does that mean the alerts tell us...nothing....and what does that make the alerts...useless

The parents 'alerted' to an open window and open shutters. No-one else saw them. There was no evidence to support their 'alert'. Does that mean that the parent's 'alert' is useless and tells us nothing?

[Mr Gray]

The parents 'alerted' to an open window and open shutters. No-one else saw them. There was no evidence to support their 'alert'. Does that mean that the parent's 'alert' is useless and tells us nothing?

you are getting rather silly..the dogs have not made any statement as afar as I am aware

[stephen25000]

The parents 'alerted' to an open window and open shutters. No-one else saw them. There was no evidence to support their 'alert'. Does that mean that the parent's 'alert' is useless and tells us nothing?

NICE ONE.

[Anna]

The parents 'alerted' to an open window and open shutters. No-one else saw them. There was no evidence to support their 'alert'. Does that mean that the parent's 'alert' is useless and tells us nothing?

Amy Tierney was a witness to the windows, G
http://themaddiecasefiles.com/post27240.html#p27240

However Off topic

[Mr Gray]

NICE ONE.

not at all...the mccanns statements are accepted as evidence in court....they can be cross examined...dogs cannot speak

[stephen25000]

not at all...the mccanns statements are accepted as evidence in court....they can be cross examined...dogs cannot speak

...and never independently verified before 10 pm.

[Mr Gray]

the alerts tell us absolutely nothing...perhaps one of the experts on here can contradict me and tell me what information the alerts give us

[ferryman]

No, not at all, it's embarrassing that you are even trying that false logic

What false logic.?

[stephen25000]

the alerts tell us absolutely nothing...perhaps one of the experts on here can contradict me and tell me what information the alerts give us

John gave the position I believe last night.

Your numerous repeated posts on the issue won't change minds on here.

[Mr Gray]

John gave the position I believe last night.

Your numerous repeated posts on the issue won't change minds on here.

John gave his opinion ...his opinion was the alerts tell us nothing....perhaps you should read the post