Did Eddie and Keela work as a team prior to the Madeleine McCann case?

[stephen25000]

the dog's alerts are not supported by any real scientific evidence...so everything is pure speculation...from what I have raed I cannot see how remnant scent could survive in the flower bed for 3 months

Can you cite the evidence for that and any contradictory information.

[Mr Gray]

Can you cite the evidence for that and any contradictory information.

evidence for what...I've just stated that everything is speculation

[stephen25000]

evidence for what...I've just stated that everything is speculation

Read my last post, in connection to one of yours, as regards 'flower beds'.

[Mr Gray]

Read my last post, in connection to one of yours, as regards 'flower beds'.

I cant see the scent lasting 3 months outside in a flower bed...do you have any evidence to contradict this...no

[stephen25000]

I cant see the scent lasting 3 months outside in a flower bed...do you have any evidence to contradict this...no

Your opinion has no value.

Now can you back it up with actual unadulterated facts ?

[pegasus]

I cant see the scent lasting 3 months outside in a flower bed...do you have any evidence to contradict this...no

That's a good point. If there was simply a few scent molecules on the surface of a few leaves, you may reasonably argue those molecules would after almost 3 months have been washed away by rain.
Moving briefly to one of SY's hypotheses (burglary gone wrong) is it possible one of that hypothetical burglary gone wrong gang quickly hid some small secondary bit of evidence in soil in flowerbed and it was still there almost 3 months later? Seems unlikely but just trying to find a plausible way to solve the problem you mentioned.

[ferryman]

Your opinion has no value.

Now can you back it up with actual unadulterated facts ?

Alerts inadmissible in court have no value or relevance

[stephen25000]

Alerts inadmissible in court have no value or relevance

Not quite as simple as that.

...and of course your posts merely reflect how important it is to you and the mccanns to denigrate the dogs indications.

[ferryman]

Not quite as simple as that.

...and of course your posts merely reflect how important it is to you and the mccanns to denigrate the dogs indications.

Every bit as simple as that.

And I have never posted a single word against the dogs.

[faithlilly]

That's a good point. If there was simply a few scent molecules on the surface of a few leaves, you may reasonably argue those molecules would after almost 3 months have been washed away by rain.
Moving briefly to one of SY's hypotheses (burglary gone wrong) is it possible one of that hypothetical burglary gone wrong gang quickly hid some small secondary bit of evidence in soil in flowerbed and it was still there almost 3 months later? Seems unlikely but just trying to find a plausible way to solve the problem you mentioned.

Or a body lay at the bottom of the foliage for somewhere over 40 minutes causing the area to be contaminated by cadaver scent ?

[stephen25000]

Every bit as simple as that.

And I have never posted a single word against the dogs.

NO, it isn't as simple as that.

Your attacks and libelous posts on Grime reflect the truth.

Just because some have been deleted, does not mean they have disappeared.

[ferryman]

NO, it isn't as simple as that.

Your attacks and libelous posts on Grimes reflect the truth.

Just because some have been deleted, does not mean they have disappeared.

Who is Grimes?

[Alice Purjorick]

No Alice,  have you?

I was going by what experts have said using their experience.    Though stating four hours for that particular expert was wrong he said 12 to 24 hours.

No. I merely posted a link to part of a research project a decade before the disappearance of MM.
You very learnedly said "that sounds about right" or something similar as though you were an authority on the topic.

[stephen25000]

Who is Grimes?

No need for that.

You know whom I meant.

[Mr Gray]

Your opinion has no value.

Now can you back it up with actual unadulterated facts ?

GROUNDHOG DAY...no ones opinion on here has any value.....purely from basic chemistry I cannot see any molecules being present after 3 months