Did Eddie and Keela work as a team prior to the Madeleine McCann case?

[Alfred R Jones]

I can't speak for the masses out there in social media, or speak for anyone here either. On social media there's much exaggeration, we all know that. But on this forum weeks, even months, have gone by without people talking about dogs or alerts. Then you know who will start talking about them again, after which there's perfectly understandable motivation to defend MG's reputation from attacks.

Is there anything you think we'd be far better off discussing? 

It's good to see that you think it's "perfectly understandable"  to defend others from attacks which you feel are unwarranted, perhaps this will help you to understand (if you didn't already) why some people choose to defend the McCanns from accusations of immoral and illegal behaviour.

[stephen25000]

what part of my posts don't you understand

there is no science to back the alerts
therefore everything is personal opinion.
personal opinions are not supported by cites otherwise they would be more than opinion...

however anyone with a basic knowledge of chemistry would realise that a small residue would disappear due to wind and rain..via vapourisation and rain dilution.....there would therefore be no molecules left

Anyone with a basic knowledge of Chemistry would know there are many variables involved.

Such as Soil Chemistry (including pH), Temperature variances, Adsorption, rainfall, etc.

You have made a bland statement and that's all it is.

[Lyall]

When you preach truth to minds unreceptive to receiving truth, there's nothing else you can do.

And since just about all I assert is in the official files, why would I need (other!) references?

If you stuck to them nobody could have any issue. But you don't. You are inventing, or attempting to invent, pseudoscience.

There is no criticism at all of MG's work in the official documents released in 2008 is there. Therefore neither should you be critical.

[ferryman]

delete

[ferryman]

If you stuck to them nobody could have any issue. But you don't. You are inventing, or attempting to invent, pseudoscience.

There is no criticism at all of MG's work in the official documents released in 2008 is there. Therefore neither should you be critical.

There is.

But you have to read the files properly

[stephen25000]

We never stop underlying and emphasising how meaningless they are.

That is because (others) rattle on endlessly about "cadaver scent" here, there and everywhere.

What is meaningful is slaying the canard of cadaver scent (in respect of the first, shelved, enquiry and anything whatever to do with Madeleine's disappearance.)

Where has the presence of cadaver scent been disproved ?

[faithlilly]

There is.

But you have to read the files properly

Which you, of course, have done.

So why don't you attempt to enlighten us denser mortals ferryman ?

[Lyall]

Is there anything you think we'd be far better off discussing? 

It's good to see that you think it's "perfectly understandable"  to defend others from attacks which you feel are unwarranted, perhaps this will help you to understand (if you didn't already) why some people choose to defend the McCanns from accusations of immoral and illegal behaviour.

Of course I understand it, Alfred. You're only doing what the powerful did instinctively on Day 1 of the case.

[ferryman]

Where has the presence of cadaver scent been disproved ?

The presence of cadaver scent has to be proved

It hasn't been

[ferryman]

Which you, of course, have done.

So why don't you attempt to enlighten us denser mortals ferryman ?

I have countless times.

But some density is just too dense to penetrate.

[pegasus]

Nice find Mercury.

"Eddie would be tasked to tell us where the body had been before it was found and would indicate any clothing that would have come into contact with the body." (MG)

Eddie's alerts to clothing do not distinguish between clothing which which was being worn when it made contact, and clothing which was not being worn when it made contact.

[pegasus]

When the fibre samples and branch samples were obtained in the garden, were any soil samples obtained?

[faithlilly]

I have countless times.

But some density is just too dense to penetrate.

A but ferryman are these *real* errors or once you've simply made up for your own amusement ?

[ferryman]

A but ferryman are these *real* errors or once you've simply made up for your own amusement ?

Harrison waited until after both inspections at villa and gym to issue PJ personnel with translated NPIA instructions on how to conduct canine searches in buildings and vehicles.

That was an implicit criticism of Grime's work.

Harrison dismissed both inspections at villa and gym as pj exercises.

That was another implicit criticism of Grime's work.

That there was no gap between completion of the, apparent, reconnoitre of the gym and the start of the inspection of clothing tends to suggest that the PJ cribbed from these translated instructions Harrison gave them.

Find a single reference in Harrison's three reports to clothing ....

[faithlilly]

Harrison waited until after both inspections at villa and gym to issue PJ personnel with translated NPIA instructions on how to conduct canine searches in buildings and vehicles.

That was an implicit criticism of Grime's work.

Harrison dismissed both inspections at villa and gym as pj exercises.

That was another implicit criticism of Grime's work.

That there was no gap between completion of the, apparent, reconnoitre of the gym and the start of the inspection of clothing tends to suggest that the PJ cribbed from these translated instructions Harrison gave them.

Find a single reference in Harrison's three reports to clothing ....

Yep that's what I thought !