US child found alive 13 years after mysteriously disappearing.

[mercury]

Yes, the point of the story is to show that even after many years a child can be returned safe and well. These cases all appear to happen in the USA where disappearing is so much easier!

But there was never any question about the child being unsafe or unwell at any time...he was with his dad, who yes,  took him illegally, but thats about it

[Brietta]

But there was never any question about the child being unsafe or unwell at any time...he was with his dad, who yes,  took him illegally, but thats about it

175 Killer Dads: Fathers who ended their children's lives in situations involving child custody, visitation, and/or child support (USA)
- See more at: http://americanmotherspoliticalparty.org/ampp-article-library-family-court-custody-abuse-dv/1-research-articles-family-court-bias-custody-abuse-battered-moms/58-175-killer-dads-fathers-who-ended-their-childrens-lives-in-situations-involving-child-custody-visitation-andor-child-support-usa#sthash.63C3vBuZ.dpuf

[stephen25000]

175 Killer Dads: Fathers who ended their children's lives in situations involving child custody, visitation, and/or child support (USA)
- See more at: http://americanmotherspoliticalparty.org/ampp-article-library-family-court-custody-abuse-dv/1-research-articles-family-court-bias-custody-abuse-battered-moms/58-175-killer-dads-fathers-who-ended-their-childrens-lives-in-situations-involving-child-custody-visitation-andor-child-support-usa#sthash.63C3vBuZ.dpuf

This father isn't a killer.

So what has your post got to do with this case ?

[Brietta]

This father isn't a killer.

So what has your post got to do with this case ?

Have you been following the discussion at all?  If so you appear to have overlooked Mercury's post to which I was responding.

There were no guarantees when Julian was snatched by his father that he would indeed be OK.  There are many cases here in Britain where children have been killed or abused by fathers who have taken them.
Only his father knew he was fine over the thirteen years taken from his extended family maternal and paternal.

If you cannot see the correlation ... there isn't a thing I can do about it ... but I think your problem may be that you actually do see that it is possible that a child whose whereabouts have dropped off the radar for thirteen years can still be found.

[stephen25000]

Have you been following the discussion at all?  If so you appear to have overlooked Mercury's post to which I was responding.

There were no guarantees when Julian was snatched by his father that he would indeed be OK.  There are many cases here in Britain where children have been killed or abused by fathers who have taken them.
Only his father knew he was fine over the thirteen years taken from his extended family maternal and paternal.

If you cannot see the correlation ... there isn't a thing I can do about it ... but I think your problem may be that you actually do see that it is possible that a child whose whereabouts have dropped off the radar for thirteen years can still be found.

I do not have the time to read all posts on here, as I do have other matters to attend to.

However, the bottom line remains, no matter what spin is put on it.

There is no 'correlation' as you put it with this case and Madeleine's disappearance.

[Brietta]

I do not have the time to read all posts on here, as I do have other matters to attend to.

However, the bottom line remains, no matter what spin is put on it.

There is no 'correlation' as you put it with this case and Madeleine's disappearance.

Indeed, time is of the essence when one has a busy life to get on with.

Perhaps you should have chosen a thread you hadn't actually commented on before disingenuously denying interest.

This is a five page thread.

To date you have posted on every single one of those pages ... your very first post on page one ... denying any correlation with Madeleine's case.
Are you just posting formulaic responses without bothering to read to what?

[slartibartfast]

Have you been following the discussion at all?  If so you appear to have overlooked Mercury's post to which I was responding.

There were no guarantees when Julian was snatched by his father that he would indeed be OK.  There are many cases here in Britain where children have been killed or abused by fathers who have taken them.
Only his father knew he was fine over the thirteen years taken from his extended family maternal and paternal.

If you cannot see the correlation ... there isn't a thing I can do about it ... but I think your problem may be that you actually do see that it is possible that a child whose whereabouts have dropped off the radar for thirteen years can still be found.

Can you show us he correlation? Hard data?

[Lace]

But there was never any question about the child being unsafe or unwell at any time...he was with his dad, who yes,  took him illegally, but thats about it

The whole point of this story being linked to Madeleine is as I said in an earlier post,  this father managed to keep his son hidden for 13 years just by changing his surname.

The school only noticed he was on the Missing Children registrar when he was having difficulties  furthering his education.

Do schools check the missing children registrar?   

Madeleine could be at a school right now,  with a new name and maybe new hair colour.

[stephen25000]

Indeed, time is of the essence when one has a busy life to get on with.

Perhaps you should have chosen a thread you hadn't actually commented on before disingenuously denying interest.

This is a five page thread.

To date you have posted on every single one of those pages ... your very first post on page one ... denying any correlation with Madeleine's case.
Are you just posting formulaic responses without bothering to read to what?

The 'formulaic responses' are yours.

You or anyone else, have not established a real link between these cases.

Please also inform us, as to what bivariate data you are using here as regards correlation.

[Mr Gray]

Several posters including John recognise the connection

[stephen25000]

the link is a child who has managed to have been kept below the radar for 13 years...but you are too dim to see it

and what does it have to do with this case, when abduction has not been proved.

[ShiningInLuz]

The whole point of this story being linked to Madeleine is as I said in an earlier post,  this father managed to keep his son hidden for 13 years just by changing his surname.

The school only noticed he was on the Missing Children registrar when he was having difficulties  furthering his education.

Do schools check the missing children registrar?   

Madeleine could be at a school right now,  with a new name and maybe new hair colour.

For all we know Madeleine could be in a country where there is no missing children register, and indeed, in one where there has been little interest in the case.

[Mr Gray]

For all we know Madeleine could be in a country where there is no missing children register, and indeed, in one where there has been little interest in the case.

and as this case proves a child can be missing and reappear after 13 years so however remote their is still hope for maddie

[stephen25000]

and as this case proves a child can be missing and reappear after 13 years so however remote their is still hope for maddie

So is she with a paedophile or really nice family

[Mr Gray]

So is she with a paedophile or really nice family