Author Topic: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?  (Read 133073 times)

0 Members and 3 Guests are viewing this topic.

Offline Brietta

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #105 on: November 12, 2015, 12:56:36 PM »
Another way of looking at this whole mystery is to ask the question, what are the chances of two men fitting the same description clad in similar clothing carrying a barefoot young child also similarly clad, in the exact same way at exactly 9.15pm on 3rd May 2007? 

There was a similar situation in the Luke Mitchell murder of Jodi Jones case where two identically dressed youths were claimed to have occupied the same space at exactly the same time on an almost deserted road. Not likely imo.

DCI Redwood was of the opinion that Tanner did not see an abductor which if true means that Jane Tanner was mistaken about the frilly bottoms.

I spoke to a friend who was walking in the direction of his home.

A few minutes later I drove past him and wondered why he was walking in the direction he was.

A few minutes after that, I passed him as he was approaching his garden gate.

The guy I had passed after speaking to my friend was dressed in identical clothing, had the same receding hair and was wearing the same style thick rimmed glasses.  I would unhesitatingly have identified the stranger as him had I not seen him entering his property.

So it does happen ... and my recent experience proved to me that eye witness testimony can be unreliable even if one knows a person very well.

Even before misidentifying my friend, one of the things which has impressed me about Jane Tanner's sighting was the vagueness of it and her refusal to put an identity to a person whose features she had not seen.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline John

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #106 on: November 12, 2015, 12:59:17 PM »
Who said that he wore exactly the same clothes (as many tourists, I must add) or that it was at exactly 9.15?

I am not sure what times the creche operated at night, but it seems a bit early to be collecting a child, unless he was taking her there of course.

We have no statement from Crecheman .but apparently as parents of one of the 11 children in the creche that night, those parents thought that it was possibly them. That is according to the crime watch video already posted on here.

How could he remember exactly what he and the child was wearing that night?

Please correct me if I remembered anything  incorrectly.

In his Crimewatch interview Redwood refers to the pj's as being "uncannily similar".  But they weren't if Jane's description is correct.
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline John

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #107 on: November 12, 2015, 01:01:50 PM »
I spoke to a friend who was walking in the direction of his home.

A few minutes later I drove past him and wondered why he was walking in the direction he was.

A few minutes after that, I passed him as he was approaching his garden gate.

The guy I had passed after speaking to my friend was dressed in identical clothing, had the same receding hair and was wearing the same style thick rimmed glasses.  I would unhesitatingly have identified the stranger as him had I not seen him entering his property.

So it does happen ... and my recent experience proved to me that eye witness testimony can be unreliable even if one knows a person very well.

Even before misidentifying my friend, one of the things which has impressed me about Jane Tanner's sighting was the vagueness of it and her refusal to put an identity to a person whose features she had not seen.

Oh I agree, it does happen but on the night a three-year-old just happened to disappear?

With so many people wandering around the block how did any potential abductor ever have a window of opportunity? 
« Last Edit: November 12, 2015, 01:04:43 PM by John »
A malicious prosecution for a crime which never existed. An exposé of egregious malfeasance by public officials.
Indeed, the truth never changes with the passage of time.

Offline Anna

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #108 on: November 12, 2015, 01:09:01 PM »
Apart from the fact that a child disappeared that night, it makes no difference to the dressed alike tourists walking about that night, or in fact any night.
I have seen photos of some the tapas group wearing very similar outfits......That's what people wear on holiday. JT did not see a face.

ETA
Crecheman's times were approx.
There was a window at this time  9.15pm. as it was known that Gerry had just checked. It would not be known that Gerry had stopped to talk to Jez or that JT child was sick.
« Last Edit: November 12, 2015, 01:15:13 PM by Anna »
“You should not honour men more than truth.”
― Plato

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #109 on: November 12, 2015, 01:16:05 PM »
It's very simple, Mr Redwood should have explained why his crècheman was walking in the wrong direction had he been returning from the night crèche.
Why should he?  Is he obligated to explain everything he and Operation Grange do whilst the investigation is on going?

Offline pathfinder73

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #110 on: November 12, 2015, 01:21:32 PM »
I don't keep making excuses for anyone, I simply prefer reality.

Why did Redwood dig up central Luz?  The bit he dug up is an integral part of the one-way system.  Both Rua 25 de Abril and the seemingly meaningless road across the mound are essential to traffic flow.  Presumably Redwood looked at Streetview and thought they were minor.

Why did Redwood not twig that 3 nannies in the search put Godfrey Barrington Norton and his Escort van on top of the mound that night.  Well, that would be because he wouldn't understand that there are 2 places in Luz that people camp. One is on the flat and can be ruled out as the nanny said the van was on a hill.  The hill people camp on (motorhomes, not tents) is the mound that SY dug up.

So Redwood did not understand the Luz traffic system or where folks camp.  Did this make him look a tw..?  To people who understand both, the answer is a definite yes.  So here is the unapologetic but realistic answer.  Redwood did not understand Luz therefore he could not reach this conclusion.

So, is Redwood a tw.. for not getting boots on ground to actually understand Luz?  I have my own opinion on that.  Please feel free to make up your own mind.

Is Nicola Wall a tw.. for not getting boots on ground?  I have my own opinion on that.  Please feel free to make up your own mind.

Here's another thought.  The nanny in question could not identify where the hill was. So ... why not?  After all, Luz is a very compact place.  From memory she had been out here for about a month.  Surely by then she should have known where the hill was in Luz?  That would have tied up everything nicely.  But she didn't, according to her statement.  Why not?  1) She would have been on foot (no car).  She would have had little familiarity with the 1-way system and no need to drive on either 25 de Abril or the road through the mound.  2) The one and only reason I can think of why she might have gone near there is to go to a small take-away.  It is the one that says Kebab/Pizza in Streetview, though it has been through at least 2 changes since 2007.  She would not have seen the mound even if she did go there.

So the nanny had no reason to know where the hill was, and unsurprisingly, she did not know where the hill was.

Nor did the PJ.

Nor did Redwood.

So, let's turn to Amaral.  He makes Luz 'closed' early in the evening of 3 May 2007.  This is important, as if Luz was closed, then obviously Smithman could wander at will.  My own take is that around 70 commercial establishments were open in Luz AT SMITHMAN TIME i.e. 10pm.  With this info, Smithman is totally innocent, or EXTREMELY lucky, or he has a very good knowledge of Luz.

If you really believe the PJ should have mapped Luz to an extent that they knew there was a crèche before those 8 families went home to wherever, try answering the following.

1) I believe that there was at least one other organisation offering sports holidays in Luz at the time.  I have not followed up on this as I can't see the relevance.  But is the OC crèche the only one that was operating that night, or should we be considering more?

2) Smithman hardly fits with the OC crèche, so we have more to explain than the OC crèche.

3) How about a test of Luz in another factor that is important?  How many commercial establishments in Luz ran large screen TVs on 3 May?  I am sifting through this because I believe it is relevant to cracking the telephone traffic that evening.  And that info has to go to OG before it shuts down because once it does, there is no way to access the data. Should the PJ have established this, when they got the phone data?

It is 8.5 years on and there is still a lot that needs to be mapped, so lets have a splash of reality rather that simplistic PJ-bashing.  No one has covered themselves in glory on this one.

My question is still how SY got its hands on a crèche register after 6 years, when said register is not in the PJ files.  I am having trouble believing this actually happened.

Barrington Godfrey Norton  - The dogs should have examined his van and apartment 1 of Vila King Palm to completely eliminate him. Anybody discovered outdoors alone is a lead that needs completely eliminating.

When asked how he found out about the disappearance, he mentioned that at about 01.00 of 4th May when he was asleep at the usual place (camping site near the beach), he noticed flashing blue lights, immediately presuming that they came from a police car. At about 01.30 he was approached by OC staff, telling him that at about 22.00 the girl in question had disappeared from the resort.

He remembers that at about 07.30 on 4th May he was approached at the same site by GNR officers who carried out a search of his vehicle, but did not find anything unusual.

http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/BARRINGTON_NORTON.htm

Note from PJ National Directorate

On this date, I state that in the current process, that from information provided by the OC resort, it was possible to establish that, in accordance with the statements by Barrington Godfrey Norton, a Canadian couple had stayed at the resort during the period between 23-04-2007 and 06-05-2007.

With relation to their identities, they were L**** E*** V***** and S*** P*** V****.

It should be mentioned that during that period, both of them stayed in apartment 1 of Vila King Palm in P da L.

8th May 2007
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #111 on: November 12, 2015, 01:29:34 PM »
Another way of looking at this whole mystery is to ask the question, what are the chances of two men fitting the same description clad in similar clothing carrying a barefoot young child also similarly clad, in the exact same way at exactly 9.15pm on 3rd May 2007? 

There was a similar situation in the Luke Mitchell murder of Jodi Jones case where two identically dressed youths were claimed to have occupied the same space at exactly the same time on an almost deserted road. Not likely imo.

DCI Redwood was of the opinion that Tanner did not see an abductor which if true means that Jane Tanner was mistaken about the frilly bottoms.
I posted a direct quote from Jane Tanner in which she categorically does not say "frilly bottoms" with any great certainty. 

Offline pathfinder73

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #112 on: November 12, 2015, 01:34:06 PM »
I posted a direct quote from Jane Tanner in which she categorically does not say "frilly bottoms" with any great certainty.

Exactly frilly bottoms was surely planted in her head.
Smithman carrying a child in his arms checked his watch after passing the Smith family and the time was 10:03. Both are still unidentified 10 years later.

Offline Brietta

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #113 on: November 12, 2015, 01:48:15 PM »
Oh I agree, it does happen but on the night a three-year-old just happened to disappear?

With so many people wandering around the block how did any potential abductor ever have a window of opportunity?

The Smith sighting was not reported for a fortnight after the event and seems to have been given as much attention as Jane Tanner's was.  Although in my opinion Jane's sighting, paces from the McCann apartment was one which should have been given saturation response immediately the localised search did not produce a result on what might have been a wandered child.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #114 on: November 12, 2015, 01:53:01 PM »
I posted a direct quote from Jane Tanner in which she categorically does not say "frilly bottoms" with any great certainty.

"The artists impression was created by Portuguese police following interviews with Ms Tanner".
Complete with frilly bottoms (see opening post). So at some point she remembered they were frilly.
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #115 on: November 12, 2015, 01:57:49 PM »
"The artists impression was created by Portuguese police following interviews with Ms Tanner".
Complete with frilly bottoms (see opening post). So at some point she remembered they were frilly.
She said there was some design on the bottom, maybe a cuff or frills - he had to draw something!

Alfred R Jones

  • Guest
Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #116 on: November 12, 2015, 01:58:19 PM »
Exactly frilly bottoms was surely planted in her head.
By whom and to what end?

Offline Brietta

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #117 on: November 12, 2015, 02:04:33 PM »
"The artists impression was created by Portuguese police following interviews with Ms Tanner".
Complete with frilly bottoms (see opening post). So at some point she remembered they were frilly.

Nope ... I think the one to which you refer is 'eggman'.



Artist's impression of suspected abductor of Madeleine McCann, known as the Tanner image or Tanner report
Source   The source is Kate McCann, Madeleine: Our Daughter's Disappearance and the Continuing Search for Her, Transworld Publishers, 2011, between pages 352 and 353.

The copyright holder is Madeleine's Fund, which commissioned and published the image in 2008.

It was created by a forensic artist working for the Fund and is based on a description given by Jane Tanner, a friend of the McCanns, who saw a man carrying a child at 21:15 hours on the night of the disappearance.
She saw the man very close to the McCanns' apartment, 45 minutes before the alarm was raised.
The image has no commercial value and has been widely published and discussed.

The Tanner image has become an iconic representation of the investigation into her disappearance.
An innocent man stepped forward to say he was probably the man in the image, although it is not known when this happened.
Scotland Yard detectives photographed the man in the same clothes and pose as on the night of the disappearance; the clothes his daughter was wearing also matched Tanner's description of the child she had seen.

The image is therefore discussed now as a possible mistake that may have been made, which led detectives in the wrong direction for several years and gave them a false timeline.
See here for an example of the coverage about the image.
Also an article here about this image's relationship to another one of a possible suspect.
Discussion in the Wikipedia article here and here.
The lead investigator for Scotland Yard described their decision to rule the image a red herring as a "revelation moment": "DCI Redwood said it was a 'revelation moment' when police discovered that the man seen by McCanns' friend Jane Tanner at 9.15pm was almost certainly an innocent British holiday-maker collecting his two-year-old daughter from a nearby creche."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Artist%27s_impression,_Madeleine_McCann_disappearance.jpg
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #118 on: November 12, 2015, 02:08:18 PM »
She said there was some design on the bottom, maybe a cuff or frills - he had to draw something!

So your postulation is she signed off on something she knew wasn't particularly accurate but coincidentally bore a remarkable resemblance to "yer actual" ?
So really the artists impression is little more than GISS?
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey

Offline Alice Purjorick

Re: Why was Tannerman going the wrong way?
« Reply #119 on: November 12, 2015, 02:31:32 PM »
Nope ... I think the one to which you refer is 'eggman'.



Artist's impression of suspected abductor of Madeleine McCann, known as the Tanner image or Tanner report
Source   The source is Kate McCann, Madeleine: Our Daughter's Disappearance and the Continuing Search for Her, Transworld Publishers, 2011, between pages 352 and 353.

The copyright holder is Madeleine's Fund, which commissioned and published the image in 2008.

It was created by a forensic artist working for the Fund and is based on a description given by Jane Tanner, a friend of the McCanns, who saw a man carrying a child at 21:15 hours on the night of the disappearance.
She saw the man very close to the McCanns' apartment, 45 minutes before the alarm was raised.
The image has no commercial value and has been widely published and discussed.

The Tanner image has become an iconic representation of the investigation into her disappearance.
An innocent man stepped forward to say he was probably the man in the image, although it is not known when this happened.
Scotland Yard detectives photographed the man in the same clothes and pose as on the night of the disappearance; the clothes his daughter was wearing also matched Tanner's description of the child she had seen.

The image is therefore discussed now as a possible mistake that may have been made, which led detectives in the wrong direction for several years and gave them a false timeline.
See here for an example of the coverage about the image.
Also an article here about this image's relationship to another one of a possible suspect.
Discussion in the Wikipedia article here and here.
The lead investigator for Scotland Yard described their decision to rule the image a red herring as a "revelation moment": "DCI Redwood said it was a 'revelation moment' when police discovered that the man seen by McCanns' friend Jane Tanner at 9.15pm was almost certainly an innocent British holiday-maker collecting his two-year-old daughter from a nearby creche."
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Artist%27s_impression,_Madeleine_McCann_disappearance.jpg

I was only going by the comment at the top of the opening post.
I must admit I was of the opinion that the most popular one was the Melissa Little, commissioned by Brian Kennedy in 2008, version.
I wonder why the one the cops did from JT's description, early doors, wasn't used ? A bit of Gilbert and Sullivan creeping in maybe?
"Navigating the difference between weird but normal grief and truly suspicious behaviour is the key for any detective worth his salt.". ….Sarah Bailey