Richard Hall's film 'When Madeleine Died?' uploaded to YouTube 19th Feb

[stephen25000]

That is what all "conspiracy theorists" rely on.

Hall has form - 9/11, 7/7, UFOs, etc etc. 

I actually thought you were a bit more savvy than that, G-Unit.   

Watch Icke and his theory 'backed by astronomers' that the moon is an alien spaceship more than 4.5 billion years old.

That was a real hoot.

I wodered if one of the Astronomers was called Nocabollokov  *&*%£

[stephen25000]

The shelved enquiry discounted woke and wandered and in all events no trace of Madeleine has been found.

So emphatically a crime.

And the shelved enquiry established the innocence of the McCanns ....

It was a lack of evidence that led to the shelving.

Besides he was expressing an opinion and nothing more.

As to innocence......

[Mr Gray]

Not factual? I can provide cites for all of them and I can provide cites to show they were all untrue.

No-one knows whether the dog (Eddie, Keela detected only blood) detected cadaver, so no-one can prove RH is wrong.

could you provide a cite for "someone told the Lancet"....lets start there

[Mr Gray]

Not factual? I can provide cites for all of them and I can provide cites to show they were all untrue.

No-one knows whether the dog (Eddie, Keela detected only blood) detected cadaver, so no-one can prove RH is wrong.

this "no one can prove hall wrong " shows the absolute weakeness of his argument...it's a celestial teapot argument. no one can prove Maddie was not abducted by aliens from another  solar system...its  a very weak and discredited argument

[G-Unit]

That is what all "conspiracy theorists" rely on.

Hall has form - 9/11, 7/7, UFOs, etc etc. 

I actually thought you were a bit more savvy than that, G-Unit.   

I was referring to the dog alerts. No-one knows what the dog alerted to, so no-one can prove his opinion is wrong.

[Mr Gray]

I was referring to the dog alerts. No-one knows what the dog alerted to, so no-one can prove his opinion is wrong.

you are resorting to celestial teapot arguments.....that is a sign of extreme weakness in the argument..

In his introduction he does not state it as an opinion he stated it as a fact....as it is not a fact ...he is wrong

[Mr Gray]

Can we please cut the word, "Lies?"

Richard Hall could well be mistaken.

hall continually refers to statements by the Mccanns as "bare faced lies"....that's why I used the phrase...it seems its ok to insult the McCanns but not hall...

[G-Unit]

you are resorting to celestial teapot arguments.....that is a sign of extreme weakness in the argument..

In his introduction he does not state it as an opinion he stated it as a fact....as it is not a fact ...he is wrong

People refer to Madeleine's abduction as a fact....as it is not a fact....they are wrong.

[stephen25000]

People refer to Madeleine's abduction as a fact....as it is not a fact....they are wrong.

Precisely.

What is most obvious in this case, is the lack of evidence per se.

[Mr Gray]

People refer to Madeleine's abduction as a fact....as it is not a fact....they are wrong.

#I don't refer to it as a fact...and I am not aware of anyone who does..cite....

[stephen25000]

Now if you want to see some real lunacy,pun intended, watch this.

[Eleanor]

Now if you want to see some real lunacy,pun intended, watch this.

Managed two minutes.  Was that long enough?

[stephen25000]

Managed two minutes.  Was that long enough?

Yup.

So now I know that Saturn was really Earth's true Sun until a cataclysm. %&5%£ %&5%£ %&5%£

[Mr Gray]

Now if you want to see some real lunacy,pun intended, watch this.

has anyone managed to prove him wrong

[stephen25000]

has anyone managed to prove him wrong

Saturn does not have sufficient mass to reach the minimum temperature/pressures to initiate fusion reactions.