Richard Hall's film 'When Madeleine Died?' uploaded to YouTube 19th Feb

[Eleanor]

now you said that ....not me ..

he seemed rather pleased ...everything was fine ....

makes you think why g mcc asked him to go in the first place ...

What a very strange interpretation to put on an act that was designed to help Kate with three small children should she have wanted to take them out again.
I seriously wonder how the minds of some people work.

[pathfinder73]

What a very strange interpretation to put on an act that was designed to help Kate with three small children should she have wanted to take them out again.
I seriously wonder how the minds of some people work.

And it's still unsolved so there's more to discover. There are too many contradictions about that visit for it to be the truth!

[xtina]

What a very strange interpretation to put on an act that was designed to help Kate with three small children should she have wanted to take them out again.
I seriously wonder how the minds of some people work.

strange how peoples minds work ...yes....what was he going to help her with

it seems to me ..she had probably been in a mood.....he thought the children were going to be in trouble ...not to help in case she was going back out...


  00:39:55 Reply "But err certainly enough time just to see, you know, certainly the apartment, there was nothing that was untoward, that was you know err the children all looked extremely happy,

there was no, you know signs of any problems with err you know Kate, you know or indeed the relationship that Kate had got with any of the three children. None of the children had been told off, none of the children looked like they were you know in trouble for anything, you know they were err still all talking and playing around. Err so you know it was just a very err transient you know that I'd gone in there, but as I say it just struck me how well they all looked.'

[pathfinder73]

She did sleep in the spare bed and didn't go with the rest to the beach. So it's hard to believe she was in a good mood the following day with Gerry.

[Lace]

strange how peoples minds work ...yes....what was he going to help her with

it seems to me ..she had probably been in a mood.....he thought the children were going to be in trouble ...not to help in case she was going back out...


  00:39:55 Reply "But err certainly enough time just to see, you know, certainly the apartment, there was nothing that was untoward, that was you know err the children all looked extremely happy,

there was no, you know signs of any problems with err you know Kate, you know or indeed the relationship that Kate had got with any of the three children. None of the children had been told off, none of the children looked like they were you know in trouble for anything, you know they were err still all talking and playing around. Err so you know it was just a very err transient you know that I'd gone in there, but as I say it just struck me how well they all looked.'

If Gerry had thought Kate would be in a mood then he wouldn't have gone out to play tennis in the first place in my opinion,   he had helped to bath the children before he went,  so he would know what sort of mood Kate was in.

[pathfinder73]

If Gerry had thought Kate would be in a mood then he wouldn't have gone out to play tennis in the first place in my opinion,   he had helped to bath the children before he went,  so he would know what sort of mood Kate was in.

Normal bath time for the kids is 6:30 not Kate's.

Fiona talking to Gerry at tennis.

"Kate and the kids, I think, as I said earlier, weren't there and, you know, they, as Gerry said, were just absolutely knackered and Kate was getting them bathed and ready for bed."

[Eleanor]

strange how peoples minds work ...yes....what was he going to help her with

it seems to me ..she had probably been in a mood.....he thought the children were going to be in trouble ...not to help in case she was going back out...


  00:39:55 Reply "But err certainly enough time just to see, you know, certainly the apartment, there was nothing that was untoward, that was you know err the children all looked extremely happy,

there was no, you know signs of any problems with err you know Kate, you know or indeed the relationship that Kate had got with any of the three children. None of the children had been told off, none of the children looked like they were you know in trouble for anything, you know they were err still all talking and playing around. Err so you know it was just a very err transient you know that I'd gone in there, but as I say it just struck me how well they all looked.'

Gerry asked him to call in.  So do you think Gerry was worried that Kate might batter the children?

[pathfinder73]

Gerry asked him to call in.  So do you think Gerry was worried that Kate might batter the children?

Gerry said to Fiona at tennis so why send anyone?

"Kate was getting them bathed and ready for bed."

That opens another can of worms with other controversial statements.

[Eleanor]

Gerry said to Fiona at tennis so why send anyone?

"Kate was getting them bathed and ready for bed."

That opens another can of worms with other controversial statements.

Do you know, I think Gerry was just being kind, and so was David Payne, whose statement was made in hindsight.

[xtina]

Do you know, I think Gerry was just being kind, and so was David Payne, whose statement was made in hindsight.

in hindsight of what

[Eleanor]

in hindsight of what

In hindsight of the hideous rumours of Kate losing her temper and bashing Madeleine.

[xtina]

She did sleep in the spare bed and didn't go with the rest to the beach. So it's hard to believe she was in a good mood the following day with Gerry.

that's why i think the check ...was . ...to check the children were OK...by the responce of Payne ...in statement  they hadn't been told off etc etc...

[xtina]

In hindsight of the hideous rumours of Kate losing her temper and bashing Madeleine.

what rumours......................how do you know she didn't

[G-Unit]

Gerry said they played tennis until 16.30 and then stayed around until the twins went to the meal area at 16.45. Madeleine arrived at 17.00 with the teachers and the other children. The meal finished at 17.30.

He doesn't mention Kate's run to the beach which took place during that time. Cat Baker didn't see Gerry at the children's high tea. Kate signed the twins out at 17.25 and Madeleine at 17.30.

There's no independent evidence that Gerry was at high tea. There's no independent evidence that he went back to the apartment between 17.30 and 18.00.

If he didn't, that would explain why he asked David to check up on Kate.

[Eleanor]

what rumours......................how do you know she didn't

More to the point, can you prove that Kate did batter Madeleine?

We have this quaint, old Law in Britain wherein everyone is Innocent until Proven Guilty.

I am well aware of the fact that this doesn't always apply in Portugal, but that is your problem rather than mine or Kate's.

Happy Hunting with that.