Richard Hall's film 'When Madeleine Died?' uploaded to YouTube 19th Feb

[xtina]

Have you checked the other graphs yet?

no they mean nothing to me ....you have proved nothing either...........

k mcc said herself it was cold in her book.she wished she had put a cardigan on maddie .....

now that photo did not look like cardigan weather....

 photo's in the play area ...when they was supposed to be took on the Wednesday ...are maddie and twins wearing same clothes as when they arrived ....

was it ...probably not took the same day as they arrived

was maddie there after the sunday .....why is there such a problem with the photo's....unless there is ulterior motive

[Carana]

no they mean nothing to me ....you have proved nothing either...........

k mcc said herself it was cold in her book.she wished she had put a cardigan on maddie .....

now that photo did not look like cardigan weather....

 photo's in the play area ...when they was supposed to be took on the Wednesday ...are maddie and twins wearing same clothes as when they arrived ....

was it ...probably not took the same day as they arrived

was maddie there after the sunday .....why is there such a problem with the photo's....unless there is ulterior motive

What problem with which photo?

[blonk]

First things first.

Have you noticed that there is a problem with where the children were collected from in the afternoon?

Have you noticed a problem with the weather charts?

OK, then, first things first.

FIRST: "Have you noticed that there is a problem with where the children were collected from in the afternoon?"

ANSWER: Yes, I have, actually. Elizabeth Williamson (crèche nanny) is clear; the children were collected from their respective creches, not when they were allegedly all together at any 'high tea':

STATEMENT OF ELIZABETH WILLIAMSON:

She says that the twins were generally left at the creche at 09.00 and that the parents dropped them off before leaving Madeleine in her classroom. Then between 12.00 and 12.30 the parents would pick up the twins until 15.00. Between 17.00 and 17.30 the parents would collect the twins from the creche.

The problem is simply this. There is seriously conflicting evidence about whether there really was any 'high tea' that day (Thursday) on the Tapas bar - or any other day. As I said up the thread, everyone who examines this conflicting evidence has to decide how to resolve this conflict of evidence.

==========

Now second things second: "Have you noticed a problem with the weather charts?"

ANSWER: Again, yes I have. The 'problem' is that the weather on the Thursday that week does not match the weather on the Last Photo.

Frankly I find the efforts by some on this thread to try to change what the weather actually WAS on that Thursday lunchtime quite laughable.

The Last Photo is clear:

* Sunny
* Warm
* Gerry in sunglasses (the ones bought on Tuesday???)
* Perspiration on Gerry's forehead
* Gerry in T-shirt
* Gerry in shorts
* Madeleine bare-armed
* Amelie bare-armed
* Madeleine with sun hat
* Amelie with sun hat
* Gerry's feet dipped in cold water pool.

The midday temperature on Sunday lunchtime was 21oC (70oF).

On Thursday lunchtime it was a mere 17oC (63oF).

If there is any further attempt by anyone on this thread to say it was warm and sunny on the Thursday when it wasn't, then let Dr Kate McCann speak for herself ("madeleine", hardback ed., page 63, QUOTE:

"The weather was a little on the cool side and I remember thinking I should have brought a cardigan for her..."        

[xtina]

OK, then, first things first.

FIRST: "Have you noticed that there is a problem with where the children were collected from in the afternoon?"

ANSWER: Yes, I have, actually. Elizabeth Williamson (crèche nanny) is clear; the children were collected from their respective creches, not when they were allegedly all together at any 'high tea':

STATEMENT OF ELIZABETH WILLIAMSON:

She says that the twins were generally left at the creche at 09.00 and that the parents dropped them off before leaving Madeleine in her classroom. Then between 12.00 and 12.30 the parents would pick up the twins until 15.00. Between 17.00 and 17.30 the parents would collect the twins from the creche.

The problem is simply this. There is seriously conflicting evidence about whether there really was any 'high tea' that day (Thursday) on the Tapas bar - or any other day. As I said up the thread, everyone who examines this conflicting evidence has to decide how to resolve this conflict of evidence.

==========

Now second things second: "Have you noticed a problem with the weather charts?"

ANSWER: Again, yes I have. The 'problem' is that the weather on the Thursday that week does not match the weather on the Last Photo.

Frankly I find the efforts by some on this thread to try to change what the weather actually WAS on that Thursday lunchtime quite laughable.

The Last Photo is clear:

* Sunny
* Warm
* Gerry in sunglasses (the ones bought on Tuesday???)
* Perspiration on Gerry's forehead
* Gerry in T-shirt
* Gerry in shorts
* Madeleine bare-armed
* Amelie bare-armed
* Madeleine with sun hat
* Amelie with sun hat
* Gerry's feet dipped in cold water pool.

The midday temperature on Sunday lunchtime was 21oC (70oF).

On Thursday lunchtime it was a mere 17oC (63oF).

If there is any further attempt by anyone on this thread to say it was warm and sunny on the Thursday when it wasn't, then let Dr Kate McCann speak for herself ("madeleine", hardback ed., page 63, QUOTE:

"The weather was a little on the cool side and I remember thinking I should have brought a cardigan for her..."        

very well explained blonk....thank you 

[Mr Gray]

very well explained blonk....thank you 

anyone who believes halls rubbish needs their head examined...imo

[xtina]

What problem with which photo?

fgs there were only 4/5.....the ones in the play area three of the 4/5...was said to be took on the Wednesday ......yet they have the same cloths on as when they arrived .....

the video on the bus ...were g mcc said he wasn't there to enjoy himself...shows what they were wearing

so it is possible the play park ones ....is just after they arrived...not took on the Wednesday as the mccs said

[Carana]

OK, then, first things first.

FIRST: "Have you noticed that there is a problem with where the children were collected from in the afternoon?"

ANSWER: Yes, I have, actually. Elizabeth Williamson (crèche nanny) is clear; the children were collected from their respective creches, not when they were allegedly all together at any 'high tea':

STATEMENT OF ELIZABETH WILLIAMSON:

She says that the twins were generally left at the creche at 09.00 and that the parents dropped them off before leaving Madeleine in her classroom. Then between 12.00 and 12.30 the parents would pick up the twins until 15.00. Between 17.00 and 17.30 the parents would collect the twins from the creche.

The problem is simply this. There is seriously conflicting evidence about whether there really was any 'high tea' that day (Thursday) on the Tapas bar - or any other day. As I said up the thread, everyone who examines this conflicting evidence has to decide how to resolve this conflict of evidence.

==========

Now second things second: "Have you noticed a problem with the weather charts?"

ANSWER: Again, yes I have. The 'problem' is that the weather on the Thursday that week does not match the weather on the Last Photo.

Frankly I find the efforts by some on this thread to try to change what the weather actually WAS on that Thursday lunchtime quite laughable.

The Last Photo is clear:

* Sunny
* Warm
* Gerry in sunglasses (the ones bought on Tuesday???)
* Perspiration on Gerry's forehead
* Gerry in T-shirt
* Gerry in shorts
* Madeleine bare-armed
* Amelie bare-armed
* Madeleine with sun hat
* Amelie with sun hat
* Gerry's feet dipped in cold water pool.

The midday temperature on Sunday lunchtime was 21oC (70oF).

On Thursday lunchtime it was a mere 17oC (63oF).

If there is any further attempt by anyone on this thread to say it was warm and sunny on the Thursday when it wasn't, then let Dr Kate McCann speak for herself ("madeleine", hardback ed., page 63, QUOTE:

"The weather was a little on the cool side and I remember thinking I should have brought a cardigan for her..."        

I was asking Xtina... and you are presumably not her. But anyway.

Second point first:
BlonK: "The 'problem' is that the weather on the Thursday that week does not match the weather on the Last Photo."

Which location was used for weather data?

[Carana]

OK, then, first things first.

FIRST: "Have you noticed that there is a problem with where the children were collected from in the afternoon?"

ANSWER: Yes, I have, actually. Elizabeth Williamson (crèche nanny) is clear; the children were collected from their respective creches, not when they were allegedly all together at any 'high tea':

STATEMENT OF ELIZABETH WILLIAMSON:

She says that the twins were generally left at the creche at 09.00 and that the parents dropped them off before leaving Madeleine in her classroom. Then between 12.00 and 12.30 the parents would pick up the twins until 15.00. Between 17.00 and 17.30 the parents would collect the twins from the creche.

The problem is simply this. There is seriously conflicting evidence about whether there really was any 'high tea' that day (Thursday) on the Tapas bar - or any other day. As I said up the thread, everyone who examines this conflicting evidence has to decide how to resolve this conflict of evidence.

==========

Now second things second: "Have you noticed a problem with the weather charts?"

ANSWER: Again, yes I have. The 'problem' is that the weather on the Thursday that week does not match the weather on the Last Photo.

Frankly I find the efforts by some on this thread to try to change what the weather actually WAS on that Thursday lunchtime quite laughable.

The Last Photo is clear:

* Sunny
* Warm
* Gerry in sunglasses (the ones bought on Tuesday???)
* Perspiration on Gerry's forehead
* Gerry in T-shirt
* Gerry in shorts
* Madeleine bare-armed
* Amelie bare-armed
* Madeleine with sun hat
* Amelie with sun hat
* Gerry's feet dipped in cold water pool.

The midday temperature on Sunday lunchtime was 21oC (70oF).

On Thursday lunchtime it was a mere 17oC (63oF).

If there is any further attempt by anyone on this thread to say it was warm and sunny on the Thursday when it wasn't, then let Dr Kate McCann speak for herself ("madeleine", hardback ed., page 63, QUOTE:

"The weather was a little on the cool side and I remember thinking I should have brought a cardigan for her..."        

[xtina]

I was asking Xtina... and you are presumably not her. But anyway.

Second point first:
BlonK: "The 'problem' is that the weather on the Thursday that week does not match the weather on the Last Photo."

Which location was used for weather data?

I was asking Xtina... and you are presumably not her. But anyway.



now what is that suppose to mean ......starting another set of conspiracy's ...on your own again

[Carana]

I was asking Xtina... and you are presumably not her. But anyway.



now what is that suppose to mean ......starting another set of conspiracy's ...on your own again

Not at all. I asked you a question and Blonk has answered in your place. And you are presumably not the same person.

If you can't answer my questions, than I have no objection to Blonk doing so on your behalf as long as it's clear.

[xtina]

Not at all. I asked you a question and Blonk has answered in your place. And you are presumably not the same person.

If you can't answer my questions, than I have no objection to Blonk doing so on your behalf as long as it's clear.

well i answered your question .....and its an open thread ...for anyone to comment ...so what is strange about that ....and Blonk did explain it perfectly

my answer was

fgs there were only 4/5.....the ones in the play area three of the 4/5...was said to be took on the Wednesday ......yet they have the same cloths on as when they arrived .....

the video on the bus ...were g mcc said he wasn't there to enjoy himself...shows what they were wearing

so it is possible the play park ones ....is just after they arrived...not took on the Wednesday as the mccs said

[Carana]

well i answered your question .....and its an open thread ...for anyone to comment ...so what is strange about that ....and Blonk did explain it perfectly

my answer was

fgs there were only 4/5.....the ones in the play area three of the 4/5...was said to be took on the Wednesday ......yet they have the same cloths on as when they arrived .....

the video on the bus ...were g mcc said he wasn't there to enjoy himself...shows what they were wearing

so it is possible the play park ones ....is just after they arrived...not took on the Wednesday as the mccs said

That still doesn't answer my question about the weather.

Perhaps either you or Blonk could clarify where the Algarve weather data came from?

[pathfinder73]

OK, then, first things first.

FIRST: "Have you noticed that there is a problem with where the children were collected from in the afternoon?"

ANSWER: Yes, I have, actually. Elizabeth Williamson (crèche nanny) is clear; the children were collected from their respective creches, not when they were allegedly all together at any 'high tea':

STATEMENT OF ELIZABETH WILLIAMSON:

She says that the twins were generally left at the creche at 09.00 and that the parents dropped them off before leaving Madeleine in her classroom. Then between 12.00 and 12.30 the parents would pick up the twins until 15.00. Between 17.00 and 17.30 the parents would collect the twins from the creche.

The problem is simply this. There is seriously conflicting evidence about whether there really was any 'high tea' that day (Thursday) on the Tapas bar - or any other day. As I said up the thread, everyone who examines this conflicting evidence has to decide how to resolve this conflict of evidence.

==========

Now second things second: "Have you noticed a problem with the weather charts?"

ANSWER: Again, yes I have. The 'problem' is that the weather on the Thursday that week does not match the weather on the Last Photo.

Frankly I find the efforts by some on this thread to try to change what the weather actually WAS on that Thursday lunchtime quite laughable.

The Last Photo is clear:

* Sunny
* Warm
* Gerry in sunglasses (the ones bought on Tuesday???)
* Perspiration on Gerry's forehead
* Gerry in T-shirt
* Gerry in shorts
* Madeleine bare-armed
* Amelie bare-armed
* Madeleine with sun hat
* Amelie with sun hat
* Gerry's feet dipped in cold water pool.

The midday temperature on Sunday lunchtime was 21oC (70oF).

On Thursday lunchtime it was a mere 17oC (63oF).

If there is any further attempt by anyone on this thread to say it was warm and sunny on the Thursday when it wasn't, then let Dr Kate McCann speak for herself ("madeleine", hardback ed., page 63, QUOTE:

"The weather was a little on the cool side and I remember thinking I should have brought a cardigan for her..."        

The twins were next to the tapas area when Gerry collected them. That documentary claimed Madeleine was above reception which is totally wrong. Your theories are invalid if you don't even know where the child was when seen by Tapas staff at high tea  I've provided statements proving Thursday afternoon was sunny - Russ and Matt sailing. Fiona's statement. The men are in t-shirts and shorts at the Paraiso restaurant cctv images Thursday 3 May.

[xtina]

What problem with which photo?

this is what you asked .....

your chart means nothing ...proves nothing either .....

[pathfinder73]

this is what you asked .....

your chart means nothing ...proves nothing either .....

That CCTV image does on Thursday 3 May wearing t-shirts, shorts and shades.