Richard Hall's film 'When Madeleine Died?' uploaded to YouTube 19th Feb

[xtina]

More to the point, can you prove that Kate did batter Madeleine?

We have this quaint, old Law in Britain wherein everyone is Innocent until Proven Guilty.

I am well aware of the fact that this doesn't always apply in Portugal, but that is your problem rather than mine or Kate's.

Happy Hunting with that.

[xtina]

More to the point, can you prove that Kate did batter Madeleine?

We have this quaint, old Law in Britain wherein everyone is Innocent until Proven Guilty.

I am well aware of the fact that this doesn't always apply in Portugal, but that is your problem rather than mine or Kate's.

Happy Hunting with that.

happy hunting   ....its on the previouse page ...what YOU said

Elenor quote

What do you think he was expecting?  Battered children lying about all over the place?


i just commented on what D P said.....you are the one sweetie ...who brought up the battered child bit

[Brietta]

There are too many contradictions. This was only hours before she disappeared and they both have completely different recollections. A detective would think they're probably hiding something.

Interesting.  Not nearly as interesting as the man or men seen, one actually at the garden wall, staring intently at the McCann apartment only hours before Madeleine was abducted.

Did Mr Hall explain where they fitted in the jigsaw of events?

[xtina]

Interesting.  Not nearly as interesting as the man or men seen, one actually at the garden wall, staring intently at the McCann apartment only hours before Madeleine was abducted.

Did Mr Hall explain where they fitted in the jigsaw of events?

watch it and see ....you seem fascinated... or why else keep mentioning him

[Brietta]

or maybe he was just relieved all was well ...... there wasn't the trouble he was expecting .....after all he knows the family well .....

Did Richard Hall say that in his video?

I could be wrong in thinking it wasn't actionable if he did?  One only has to traduces a person by implication for it to be libel.

Surely he wasn't that thick?

[Brietta]

And it's still unsolved so there's more to discover. There are too many contradictions about that visit for it to be the truth!

I cannot believe the faux excitement generated by a friend coming to the apartment ... while strangers outside studying it cause not a ripple of interest.

That is probably the difference between video makers, armchair detectives and the real ones of the PJ and SY.

The latter of whom don't seem to be the slightest bit titillated by Dr Payne's brief visit ... far too busy looking for the real perpetrator/s.

[Brietta]

Gerry said to Fiona at tennis so why send anyone?

"Kate was getting them bathed and ready for bed."

That opens another can of worms with other controversial statements.

You really don't get it do you?

[Brietta]

watch it and see ....you seem fascinated... or why else keep mentioning him

Possibly because this is a thread dedicated to him and his oeuvre ... incidentally started by you???

[xtina]

Did Richard Hall say that in his video?

I could be wrong in thinking it wasn't actionable if he did?  One only has to traduces a person by implication for it to be libel.

Surely he wasn't that thick?

Surely he wasn't that thick?


what are you on about here ..i think you are calling the wrong one

stop being so obsessed ..with R H .....now R H being done for libel ...you wish

its what D P said in his statement that was odd

00:39:55 Reply "But err certainly enough time just to see, you know, certainly the apartment, there was nothing that was untoward, that was you know err the children all looked extremely happy,

there was no, you know signs of any problems with err you know Kate, you know or indeed the relationship that Kate had got with any of the three children. None of the children had been told off, none of the children looked like they were you know in trouble for anything, you know they were err still all talking and playing around. Err so you know it was just a very err transient you know that I'd gone in there, but as I say it just struck me how well they all looked.'


why did he expect the children to be in trouble ....when he knows the family ...

you know ...they are the perfect family ....but none of the children had been told off ...or where in trouble ...

[Brietta]

Surely he wasn't that thick?


what are you on about here ..i think you are calling the wrong one

stop being so obsessed ..with R H .....now R H being done for libel ...you wish

its what D P said in his statement that was odd

00:39:55 Reply "But err certainly enough time just to see, you know, certainly the apartment, there was nothing that was untoward, that was you know err the children all looked extremely happy,

there was no, you know signs of any problems with err you know Kate, you know or indeed the relationship that Kate had got with any of the three children. None of the children had been told off, none of the children looked like they were you know in trouble for anything, you know they were err still all talking and playing around. Err so you know it was just a very err transient you know that I'd gone in there, but as I say it just struck me how well they all looked.'


why did he expect the children to be in trouble ....when he knows the family ...

you know ...they are the perfect family ....but none of the children had been told off ...or where in trouble ...

I find your palpable ill will to all thing McCann rather strange as I presume they don't even know you exist, care even less and have never wished you or yours any harm.

However not nearly as strange as your promotion of a series of four videos made by Richard Hall and your apparent reluctance to discuss them.

Couldn't really have been much of substance in them after all.

[jassi]

I find your palpable ill will to all thing McCann rather strange as I presume they don't even know you exist, care even less and have never wished you or yours any harm.

However not nearly as strange as your promotion of a series of four videos made by Richard Hall and your apparent reluctance to discuss them.

Couldn't really have been much of substance in them after all.

Seems to have managed to generate 24 pages of discussion whatever its substance. 

[xtina]

Seems to have managed to generate 24 pages of discussion whatever its substance.

and nearly four and a half thousand views ...in just over a week

[Eleanor]

happy hunting   ....its on the previouse page ...what YOU said

Elenor quote

What do you think he was expecting?  Battered children lying about all over the place?


i just commented on what D P said.....you are the one sweetie ...who brought up the battered child bit

You think we didn't know what you meant?

[xtina]

I find your palpable ill will to all thing McCann rather strange as I presume they don't even know you exist, care even less and have never wished you or yours any harm.

However not nearly as strange as your promotion of a series of four videos made by Richard Hall and your apparent reluctance to discuss them.

Couldn't really have been much of substance in them after all.

what do you want to discuss ...when maddie died....the 29th april ...or the 3rd may

[xtina]

You think we didn't know what you meant?

WE ....who is we...you should speak for yourself ...don't u think