Richard Hall's film 'When Madeleine Died?' uploaded to YouTube 19th Feb

[xtina]

I really don't understand.

not like you

are you board ...or having a Senior moment...

[blonk]

Upon questioning, she states that the last time she saw Madeleine was at approximately 16.30 on 3rd May 2007 when she was having dinner with the other children in their part of the restaurant, as she did each day of that week.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARIA_JOSE.htm

Are you saying that the high tea cook is lying or mistaken about catering to the crèche children that week?

WHICH crèche children?

The ones who were in the crèche at the Tapas restaurant?

Or the ones from the Mini-Club and all the other crèches as well?

You see how this is not as straightforward as it might seem

[Carana]

WHICH crèche children?

The ones who were in the crèche at the Tapas restaurant?

Or the ones from the Mini-Club and all the other crèches as well?

You see how this is not as straightforward as it might seem

No idea. You were the one who disputed any crèche high tea at all.

Blonk:

Quote: "It is disputed whether there was such a 'high tea' arrangement that week, and there is as you know evidence that contradicts it."
Unquote

[G-Unit]

Well it looks to me as if the twins were in the crèche and Madeleine was playing football with Mrs. Boyd's son until she too was taken to the crèche,  Gerry coming over when finishing his tennis session.

Looks as though it wasn't raining either.


Correction to the above,  apparently the twins were taken to the crèche at 14.40 so the twins were there when Madeleine played football with Mrs. Boyd's son,  makes no difference,  there was still time for Madeleine to have been playing with Mrs. Boyd's son before she went to the crèche and that it was not raining.

No-one has said when the courts dried but Dianne Webster mentions 'waiting' for them to dry. As play was resumed at 2.30pm perhaps that was when they were deemed dry enough. Matthew mentions going for a run with Kate at 'lunchtime' but couldn't be more specific as to time. Rachael wasn't well that day so did the run take place before the children were collected from creche? Kate says it did, then she and Gerry collected the children. Kate signed the twins out at 12.25 and Cat nanny signed Madeleine's sheet at 12.30. Kate says they were at the play area for an hour before taking the children back to their clubs.

There was an hour at the play area but two questions are still on the table. Was it dry enough for Gerry to play tennis with someone and why didn't the Boyds mention the twins?

[Carana]

not like you

are you board ...or having a Senior moment...

As far as I know, i'm not "board", nor am I having "confusement" issues.

[Alice Purjorick]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5jrnfKe7rqU

[Carana]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5jrnfKe7rqU

Lol. How about a song:  "Step out"? (Nothing to do with you, btw).

[Lace]

No-one has said when the courts dried but Dianne Webster mentions 'waiting' for them to dry. As play was resumed at 2.30pm perhaps that was when they were deemed dry enough. Matthew mentions going for a run with Kate at 'lunchtime' but couldn't be more specific as to time. Rachael wasn't well that day so did the run take place before the children were collected from creche? Kate says it did, then she and Gerry collected the children. Kate signed the twins out at 12.25 and Cat nanny signed Madeleine's sheet at 12.30. Kate says they were at the play area for an hour before taking the children back to their clubs.

There was an hour at the play area but two questions are still on the table. Was it dry enough for Gerry to play tennis with someone and why didn't the Boyds mention the twins?

What about if Kate and Gerry took the children to the play area at half past one,  Madeleine played football with Mrs Boyd's son,   Gerry took the twins to the slide etc.    Then at half past two,  Kate takes the children to the crèche.   Kate comes back Gerry finishes tennis,  Mrs. Boyd see's Gerry put his arm around Kate.

I would think the rain would have stopped otherwise I can't see them being in the play area for an hour in the rain.

[Carana]

Snip... again.
 It is disputed whether there was such a 'high tea' arrangement that week, and there is as you know evidence that contradicts it.

         

Are you saying that Team Amaral never even checked on the high tea service that week?

Not quite sure what to make of that. GASP...

[Alfred R Jones]

Are you saying that Team Amaral never even checked on the high tea service that week?

Not quite sure what to make of that. GASP...

GASP?  Doesn't that stand for Goncalo Amaral Seeks Pounds/Pennies?

[Carana]

GASP?  Doesn't that stand for Goncalo Amaral Seeks Pounds/Pennies?

Is Blonk seriously intimating that Team Amaral never even checked whether there was ever high tea that week? GAD...

[ShiningInLuz]

I think this may relate more to The Last Photo than Mr Hall's video, but what the heck.

The Last Photo was being discussed in terms of the bougainvillea behind Gerry/Amelie/Madeleine, so I went out to check, at the end of Feb 2016, on that bougainvillea.  And it was starting to bloom.

On my guest tour today, we wandered down the small alleyway to the south of blocks 4 and 5.  From that position, one can see the tree where Madeleine was photographed in front of more bougainvillea.  Today, that bougainvillea is also starting to bloom.

Roughly speaking, the only thing you can tell from the bougainvillea in the photos is that the photos were taken a little later than late Feb or early March.  Beyond that, the bougainvillea seems to offer very little that can be used to date the photos.

To be clear, I cannot remember Mr Hall's video referring to the state of the bougainvillea.

[pathfinder73]

WHICH crèche children?

The ones who were in the crèche at the Tapas restaurant?

Or the ones from the Mini-Club and all the other crèches as well?

You see how this is not as straightforward as it might seem

All the children ate together at the tapas with their parents.

16H45 at which time the twins went to the meal area. At 17h00, as usual, MADELEINE arrived accompanied by the teachers and the other children. After her arrival, MADELEINE ate, [the meal] having ended at 17H30. GM 10 May

"I think that was around, it was quite early, half four I think, five o'clock, erm, that was another sort of meeting point of the day really, where the creche would organise the tea and that was sort of outside the Tapas area, erm, and generally all of us would meet for that, all the kids had tea together." FP

[xtina]

What about if Kate and Gerry took the children to the play area at half past one,  Madeleine played football with Mrs Boyd's son,   Gerry took the twins to the slide etc.    Then at half past two,  Kate takes the children to the crèche.   Kate comes back Gerry finishes tennis,  Mrs. Boyd see's Gerry put his arm around Kate.

I would think the rain would have stopped otherwise I can't see them being in the play area for an hour in the rain.

I would think the rain would have stopped otherwise I can't see them being in the play area for an hour in the rain.



no they were sat round the pool in the blazing sun,,,,having the so called last picture taken

maddie/Amelia,,so the twins  mccs all together

as already been said...no mention of twins,,,someone else said twins ..stand out


Mrs. Boyd see's Gerry put his arm around Kate.

oh pleeeeeeeeeez.......its not proof .....its not a statement......its a magazine story ....10 a penny

it doesn't make sense either why they did it ...unless it was for money

http://www.sellusyourstory.com/sell-my-story/sell-my-story-to-a-magazine/?gclid=CLe27fCStMsCFTMo0wodNmYF8A

[Brietta]

I would think the rain would have stopped otherwise I can't see them being in the play area for an hour in the rain.



no they were sat round the pool in the blazing sun,,,,having the so called last picture taken

maddie/Amelia,,so the twins  mccs all together

as already been said...no mention of twins,,,someone else said twins ..stand out


Mrs. Boyd see's Gerry put his arm around Kate.

oh pleeeeeeeeeez.......its not proof .....its not a statement......its a magazine story ....10 a penny

it doesn't make sense either why they did it ...unless it was for money

http://www.sellusyourstory.com/sell-my-story/sell-my-story-to-a-magazine/?gclid=CLe27fCStMsCFTMo0wodNmYF8A

I think the problem you may have with what the Boyd's story has to tell us is that it flies in the face of the unlearned and badly researched conclusions detailed in Hall's apparently very boring You Tube effort at film making.
Which for some reason which makes no sense at all to me ... you have chosen to associate yourself with.

If perchance they did sell their story ... at least they did no harm.

Which is not something which can be said of others who have built careers and reputations on the complete and absolute shambles of the investigation into the case of a missing child.

GET PAID FOR YOUR STORY – NO MATTER HOW BIG OR SMALL
 
http://www.sellusyourstory.com/sell-my-story/sell-my-story-to-a-magazine/?gclid=CLe27fCStMsCFTMo0wodNmYF8A


**Snip
Amaral was booted off the investigation after just five months in charge. But his book, The Truth About The Lie, became a bestseller in Portugal even though the country’s top lawman insists there’s no evidence to back up his accusations.

A legal source close to the ­McCanns believes ­Amaral could have made as much as ­£1million in total.

“Amaral made an astonishing amount of money from his ­campaign to discredit the ­McCanns,” said the source.

“I don’t know how he sleeps at night, knowing he’s cashing in on the tragic story of a three-year-old girl’s disappearance.”
http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/goncalo-amaral-made-a-fortune-spouting-681722