Why don't people believe the Mccanns story of Abduction ?

[G-Unit]

So if you came home and found an empty space where your TV was when you went out  - and the police couldn't find any forensic evidence of a break in - would you expect them to insist that no burglary ever took place?

Common sense please.

 
Wouldn't that depend upon the way you left the house? Locked or unlocked? Burglary of a locked house surely requires some evidence of forced entry?

[Mr Gray]

 
Wouldn't that depend upon the way you left the house? Locked or unlocked? Burglary of a locked house surely requires some evidence of forced entry?

Locks can be picked

[Miss Taken Identity]

 
Wouldn't that depend upon the way you left the house? Locked or unlocked? Burglary of a locked house surely requires some evidence of forced entry?

Indeed, but if you planned the 'burglary yourself' to make a fraudulent claim, then you would open a window  and claim this as entry /exit?
...But then a really smart insuance detective would wonder why there is no marks on the white wall or foot prints on the ground or scrape marks on the window. See always someone wanting to put their boot in a bloody good well thought out story. Mind you if the insurance guy was a blinded idiot he would buy that story...

...but then again after further questioning, it was mentioned that a door was left unlocked then the claim would be made null and void- own fault kind of thing.


The devil is in the detail.

[Mr Gray]

Indeed, but if you planned the 'burglary yourself' to make a fraudulent claim, then you would open a window  and claim this as entry /exit?
...But then a really smart insuance detective would wonder why there is no marks on the white wall or foot prints on the ground or scrape marks on the window. See always someone wanting to put their boot in a bloody good well thought out story. Mind you if the insurance guy was a blinded idiot he would buy that story...

...but then again after further questioning, it was mentioned that a door was left unlocked then the claim would be made null and void- own fault kind of thing.


The devil is in the detail.

but as we know the mccanns are not suspects then we know SY believe the parents

[Miss Taken Identity]

but as we know the mccanns are not suspects then we know SY believe the parents

But do we know IF they 'believe' the parents version of an abduction . i.e. from a jemmied window? Hmmmm I would guess no.  Believing something does not make it true. But you know that anyway.

[Mr Gray]

But do we know IF they 'believe' the parents version of an abduction . i.e. from a jemmied window? Hmmmm I would guess no.  Believing something does not make it true. But you know that anyway.

I think we can say that with the McCanns eliminated that maddie was abducted but the details are not clear

[jassi]

You can say what you like - its a free forum.

[Mr Gray]

You can say what you like - its a free forum.

No I cannot

[Alfred R Jones]

It's a fact, that's all. From a unanimous time of 10pm one person is now moving it later, others are moving it earlier. Various explanations can be assumed, from a deliberate intention to just not remembering. I don't know why it happened, but it did.

And yet somehow Op Grange have managed to piece together a workable timeline which reveals that there was a windowof opportunity for a stranger abductor to strike,  How very galling for you!

[jassi]

Doesn't seem to have led anywhere, though. Perhaps its not quite right.

[Alice Purjorick]

Doesn't seem to have led anywhere, though. Perhaps its not quite right.

I think Andy did say "could have" and not "did".

[Alfred R Jones]

Doesn't seem to have led anywhere, though. Perhaps its not quite right.

What do you care anyway?

[jassi]

Oh I'm as eager to see a solution as the next person.

[G-Unit]

And yet somehow Op Grange have managed to piece together a workable timeline which reveals that there was a windowof opportunity for a stranger abductor to strike,  How very galling for you!

Why would that be galling for me? It's really quite simple. I can find a window of opportunity in the group's timeline too. That means nothing if it's wrong though.

[Jean-Pierre]

 
Wouldn't that depend upon the way you left the house? Locked or unlocked? Burglary of a locked house surely requires some evidence of forced entry?

I trust you are not suggesting that in order for a burglary to occur, the premises must be locked?