Has Martin Smith Changed his Opinion ?

[Mr Gray]

Reread your original post to me on evidential reliability and evidence

I haven't made an original post on evidential  reliability...the thread is re smith man...

[mercury]

No, it doesn't.

Unless you think Martin Smith would have produced an efit of a man he was 60 to 80% sure was Gerry.

Which is absurd ....

shall we not do groundhog day again and again and again? It must be  weary for the soul lol

[ferryman]

shall we not do groundhog day again and again and again? It must be  weary for the soul lol

Would he?

And if so, why?

[Mr Gray]

Would he?

And if so, why?

how can you produce an e fit of a face you admit you did not see

[mercury]

I haven't made an original post on evidential  reliability...the thread is re smith man...

Are you slow or playing dumb? Your post 871 as i said about evidential reliablity, made to ME!

actually dont worry, im bored of you already

[mercury]

Would he?

And if so, why?

So you enjoy groundhog day, have fun

[ferryman]

how can you produce an e fit of a face you admit you did not see

I don't place much store on the PJ reports, not because I have disrespect for the officers who took them, but because they were taken in reported form, delivered in one language, translated into another, then re-translated back into English and in the form we (finally) read on line.

I believe 'Watcher' on Amazon has the low-down on the technology that can be used for the production of efits as detailed as those produced by the Smiths.

How good it is (at enabling eye-witnesses to produce images that lead to identification of their subjects) I have no idea.

But Watcher suggests that's what they used.

She may be right.

I've no idea.

Perhaps the efits are, ultimately, not very useful (in helping to identify anyone named).

But they are the best shots, of an honest couple, both desperate to assist efforts to identify and nail the abductors of Madeleine, the best way they can.

We should applaud their efforts (I think) .....

[Mr Gray]

Are you slow or playing dumb? Your post 871 as i said about evidential reliablity, made to ME!

actually dont worry, im bored of you already

871 doesn't mention evidential reliability.......someone is certainly dumb and slow

[mercury]

871 doesn't mention evidential reliability.......someone is certainly dumb and slow

Ah yes it mentioned "evidential evidence"

 

[Mr Gray]

Ah yes it mentioned "evidential evidence"

 

dumb and slow were the words you used

[mercury]

dumb and slow were the words you used

I asked you if you were slow or playng dumb in answer to a post whch was clear, that is not the same as calling you dumb and slow, pls dont twist, its dishonest

And evidential evidence is the oxymoron you used

[Mr Gray]

And evidential evidence is the oxymoron you used

I was quoting you from one of your now removed posts

[pathfinder73]

I don't place much store on the PJ reports, not because I have disrespect for the officers who took them, but because they were taken in reported form, delivered in one language, translated into another, then re-translated back into English and in the form we (finally) read on line.

I believe 'Watcher' on Amazon has the low-down on the technology that can be used for the production of efits as detailed as those produced by the Smiths.

How good it is (at enabling eye-witnesses to produce images that lead to identification of their subjects) I have no idea.

But Watcher suggests that's what they used.

She may be right.

I've no idea.

Perhaps the efits are, ultimately, not very useful (in helping to identify anyone named).

But they are the best shots, of an honest couple, both desperate to assist efforts to identify and nail the abductors of Madeleine, the best way they can.

We should applaud their efforts (I think) .....

The McCanns spent 100K to get the files translated. If that was paid by the fund they should be released.

"Gonçalo Amaral went on air on CMTV to say Gerry McCann had also been seen on the beach on the night Madeleine went missing - but that the witness who placed him there (a British tourist) had her testimony wiped from police records."

[mercury]

I was quoting you from one of your now removed posts

Oh really, nice try, as pathetic as your squirming and avoiding, par for the course

[ferryman]

The McCanns spent 100K to get the files translated. If that was paid by the fund they should be released.

"Gonçalo Amaral went on air on CMTV to say Gerry McCann had also been seen on the beach on the night Madeleine went missing - but that the witness who placed him there (a British tourist) had her testimony wiped from police records."

No clue what you are driving at.

.....