The McCanns will have been interviewed by Operation Grange.

[Robittybob1]

sy have interviewed the mccanns do you agree

Could they have said "no comment" on 48 times 2 occasions?

[sadie]

It might help to compare two things; the dog alerts and Jane Tanner's sighting. In both cases evidence of what happened exists; the reports and statements in the files.

Contained within that evidence are clues suggesting what may have happened to Madeleine. The fact that the dogs alerted suggested that Madeleine may have died in the apartment. The fact that Jane saw a man carrying a child suggested that Madeleine was perhaps being abducted by that man.

OG think they found the man seen by Jane, so she probably didn't see Madeleine being abducted. Her clue can probably be disregarded.

Nothing has been found to confirm or dismiss the suggestion of death, so the dog alerts remain clues.

I read that the other way round to you.

If NOTHING has been found, then they are NOT clues.

NO clues ... NOTHING.

[Alfie]

It might help to compare two things; the dog alerts and Jane Tanner's sighting. In both cases evidence of what happened exists; the reports and statements in the files.

Contained within that evidence are clues suggesting what may have happened to Madeleine. The fact that the dogs alerted suggested that Madeleine may have died in the apartment. The fact that Jane saw a man carrying a child suggested that Madeleine was perhaps being abducted by that man.

OG think they found the man seen by Jane, so she probably didn't see Madeleine being abducted. Her clue can probably be disregarded.

Nothing has been found to confirm or dismiss the suggestion of death, so the dog alerts remain clues.

clues that tell us what exactly?

[Robittybob1]

I read that the other way round to you.

If NOTHING has been found, then they are NOT clues.

NO clues ... NOTHING.

If the dogs alert to the past presence of a cadaver and no cadaver is found there might be a clue there Sadie that someone has shifted the cadaver.  That is the clue it gave me.

[Brietta]

If the dogs alert to the past presence of a cadaver and no cadaver is found there might be a clue there Sadie that someone has shifted the cadaver.  That is the clue it gave me.

The clue it is giving me is that we are way off topic yet again.  We are spoilt for choice as far as dog threads go and the clue to what we should be discussing is in the thread title.
Let's stick to that please.

[Robittybob1]

The clue it is giving me is that we are way off topic yet again.  We are spoilt for choice as far as dog threads go and the clue to what we should be discussing is in the thread title.
Let's stick to that please.

I did make a comment on the topic earlier but got no responses "Could they have said "no comment" on 48 times 2 occasions?" 
I find it hard to discuss a topic such as this because we have no way of knowing  the answer, short of asking the McCanns.  Who seem to be rather hard to contact yet they say they get lots of letter so there must be a method of sending them mail.

[Miss Taken Identity]

clues that tell us what exactly?

The important clue was: Jane Tanners sighting which was assertained my many that she was witnessing an abduction- no Tannerman = no clue= no abduction.