If Maddie may still be alive...what did the dog's alert to.

[ferryman]

I'm sorry ferryman but you cannot lay the blame for that at Grime's door.  The PJ had the responsibility of providing premises, transporting the items and laying them out.  Grime's job was to deploy the dogs, nothing else.  You will be claiming next that he should have driven the cars to the car park too.

According to Amaral, Harrison deemed it necessary that clothing be inspected a second time (in the gym).

The report Harrison wrote air-brushes out involvement of Grime and his dogs in any inspections except those he (Harrison!) recommended (the places Madeleine either had been or, conceivably, might have been).

All very strange ....

[stephen25000]

According to Amaral, Harrison deemed it necessary that clothing be inspected a second time (in the gym).

The report Harrison wrote air-brushes out involvement of Grime and his dogs in any inspections except those he (Harrison!) recommended (the places Madeleine either had been or, conceivably, might have been).

All very strange ....

Why is this all very strange to you ?

[ferryman]

Why is this all very strange to you ?

If Eddie inspected stuff in place A (without reaction) -- he did, why should it have been deemed necessary to take the same stuff to a different location and test it a second time?

[stephen25000]

If Eddie inspected stuff in place A (without reaction) -- he did, why should it have been deemed necessary to take the same stuff to a different location and test it a second time?

Can you supply actual evidence of that ?

[Lace]

According to Amaral, Harrison deemed it necessary that clothing be inspected a second time (in the gym).

The report Harrison wrote air-brushes out involvement of Grime and his dogs in any inspections except those he (Harrison!) recommended (the places Madeleine either had been or, conceivably, might have been).

All very strange ....

Didn't they say something about contamination the first time?

[Brietta]

Can you supply actual evidence of that ?

Where did the boxes with the clothes packed inside come from?   &%+((£

[stephen25000]

Where did the boxes with the clothes packed inside come from?   &%+((£

' The searches conducted in the sports hall were not searches where the dog was seeking to locate Madeleine, they were searches of the items taken from the villa '

So you and ferrymans point is ?

[Brietta]

' The searches conducted in the sports hall were not searches where the dog was seeking to locate Madeleine, they were searches of the items taken from the villa '

So you and ferrymans point is ?

What ??? 

[ferryman]

' The searches conducted in the sports hall were not searches where the dog was seeking to locate Madeleine, they were searches of the items taken from the villa '

So you and ferrymans point is ?

What's your point?

Mine is that exactly the same clothing Eddie could find no hint of a scent on when inspected in the villa, he, apparently could, when it was re-inspected (in the gym).

So what was the point (of the second inspection in the gym)?

And why the discrepancy between no reaction in the villa; yet a reaction (in the gym)?

Is it sound dog-handling practise that a dog (actually, two) should trample all over stuff they are tasked to inspect?

Why did Eddie need two stabs at (apparently) reacting to cuddle-cat (after he could find no hint of a scent on a toy he played with, picked up and tossed in the air).

Answers on a postcard ...

[stephen25000]

What's your point?

Mine is that exactly the same clothing Eddie could find no hint of a scent on when inspected in the villa, he, apparently could, when it was re-inspected (in the gym).

So what was the point (of the second inspection in the gym)?

And why the discrepancy between no reaction in the villa; yet a reaction (in the gym)?

Is it sound dog-handling practise that a dog (actually, two) should trample all over stuff they are tasked to inspect?

Why did Eddie need two stabs at (apparently) reacting to cuddle-cat (after he could find no hint of a scent on a toy he played with, picked up and tossed in the air).

Answers on a postcard ...

The only answers you want is to discredit Grime and the dogs.

Hardly surprising though.

[ferryman]

The only answers you want is to discredit Grime and the dogs.

Hardly surprising though.

I just record (accurately!) what happened.

The rest does itself.

[stephen25000]

I just record (accurately!) what happened.

The rest does itself.

Your posts are selective and contain 'extracts' to suit your agenda.

[ferryman]

Your posts are selective and contain 'extracts' to suit your agenda.

My posts are an accurate (and complete!) record of what happened.

[stephen25000]

My posts are an accurate (and complete!) record of what happened.

Your posts are your interpretation of what happened.

[pathfinder73]

"Is the match genuine of is it a chance match."

A chance match? &%+((£