According to Kate McCann the choice was accidental killng or homicide.

[ferryman]

deals arent allowed...neither is beating  suspects up but they have done that...to suggest this could not have happened because it is against the rules is ridiculous...has amaral ever denied it...has kates lawyer denied it...no

What can't happen in Portuguese law is 'plea-bargains'. 

What happened (was offered to) Kate and Gerry was nothing like a 'plea-bargain' which, in any event (even in systems where they are possible and allowed) can only happen after charges are brought.

[ferryman]

So what evidence is there of a deal ?

kate mccann and aunty phiili  ?

Aside from insulting Philomena McCann, are accusing Kate of lying?

[stephen25000]

Aside from insulting Philomena McCann, are accusing Kate of lying?

How do you know she told the truth ?

If that had gone to court, unless verified, it is HEARSAY.

and that is what it is HEARSAY.

[ferryman]

How do you know she told the truth ?

If that had gone to court, unless verified, it is HEARSAY.

and that is what it is HEARSAY.

So I suppose forum protocols allow this, do they?

[Mr Gray]

Prove that it happened in this case.

 

n#you have lost the argumemt ,,,the pj has history in a related case...fact...

[Admin]

Kate described the 'deal' put to them: Kate admits to finding and hiding "a body" and gets a couple of years, while Gerry is let off; OR the pair face murder charges.

Mark Harrison was briefed to investigate exclusively murder (despite Amaral claiming that no one talked about murder).

Kate uses the word homicide in her book as the alternative to admitting to accidental death and hiding a cadaver.

[mercury]

Harrison formed no (hard and fast) conclusions of his own.

Read the penultimate sentence of his third, and final, report.

He was handed a brief by the PJ (by Amaral's boss, whose name began with E, now dead, RIP) to investigate that Madeleine had been murdered.

He (Harrison) offered to explore other possibilities or scenarios (sic) on request.

There is no evidence he was (requested) to do so.

Did I say he had formed any conclusions? I was referring to this part of hs report

This report has highlighted the extensive and professional efforts made by the Portuguese authorities regarding the search to locate Madeleine McCann alive. It has now begun to consider further opportunities to re search locations in order to address the possibility that she has been murdered and concealed nearby. This would be a proportionate and appropriate response given the elapsed time since her disappearance and previous experience in such similar cases.

---

As for not being requested to investigate other pssiblities or scenarios, what other ones that the PJ had not already worked on?


ITs like deja vu on here day after day

[Mr Gray]

Totally irrelevant.

NOW CITE.

capitals...a sign of anger...you cannot prove it didn't happen and the fact it has not been denied is evidence it did....added to the fact that we know the pj have a history of using illegal means to get a confession

[stephen25000]

So I suppose forum protocols allow this, do they?

Cite the proof of a 'deal'.

[Mr Gray]

Cite the proof of a 'deal'.

are you saying kate is lying....

[stephen25000]

are you saying kate is lying....

Merely because someone says something, it does not make it the truth.

[Mr Gray]

Merely because someone says something, it does not make it the truth.

#kate has stated it in her book...it is either true or you accuse her of lying...dont be coy...you are insinuating she is lying

[stephen25000]

#kate has stated it in her book...it is either true or you accuse her of lying...dont be coy

So if I wrote in a book my name is is James Tiberius Kirk, that would be the truth then ?

[Mr Gray]

So if I wrote in a book my name is is James Tiberius Kirk, that would be the truth then ?

if you say what Kate said is not true then you are accusing her of lying,,,,which is libellous...if you claimed that your name was James Tiberius Kirk then that might be true...untrue...or you might be insane

[slartibartfast]

#kate has stated it in her book...it is either true or you accuse her of lying...dont be coy...you are insinuating she is lying

She probably misunderstood what she was being told.....