McCanns' Embedded Confessions - Statement Analysis ( Richard D Hall release)

[Alfie]

But the ones doing the investigation are also following what is being said right here.

[Alfie]

Releasing "official" translations could help them demonstrate their innocence and refocus energy in pursuing other avenues.

This assumes significant errors one way.

Help them demonstrate their innocence to who?  You?

[Alfie]

It makes the damage to the search argument slightly ludicrous when they couldn't even assist the search by demonstrating innocence.

WTF?

[ShiningInLuz]

you're sounding more and more like a McCann basher with every post.

I don't have any problem bashing the McCanns if they deserve bashing.

Make your mind up.  Is it about the McCanns?  Or is it about Madeleine?

[Brietta]

The alternative is that confusion is good.

I prefer clarity.

For the benefit of Madeleine.

To clarify yet again the saying ... "confusion is good" which is oft times attributed to Madeleine's father but more properly may be attributed to "The Slave"

Snip
"Confusion is good"
It is falsely but nevertheless frequently claimed by anti-McCann posters that Gerry McCann used the phrase "confusion is good" in the above interview.   It is possible that this false claim has its roots in a comment which was posted under the video on the STV website:-
 
Quote by "The Slave" on 9th February 2010
"Confusion is good ? For you maybe, Gerry."
 
However, this expression was not at any time used by Gerry McCann in the interview.
http://madeleinemythsexposed.pbworks.com/w/page/39078182/Rebuttal%20of%20%22Fact%22%2039

[misty]

I don't have any problem bashing the McCanns if they deserve bashing.

Make your mind up.  Is it about the McCanns?  Or is it about Madeleine?

Police forces are trying to find Madeleine for the McCann family, not a bunch of strangers passing the time on the internet.

[Alfie]

I don't have any problem bashing the McCanns if they deserve bashing.

Make your mind up.  Is it about the McCanns?  Or is it about Madeleine?

I don't understand your question, nor do I understand why you think it is right to bash the McCanns for not releasing their translated files onto the world wide web.  It's a preposterous criticism frankly.  It seems there is nothing this couple can do right in the eyes of people like yourself.

[Alfie]

To clarify yet again the saying ... "confusion is good" which is oft times attributed to Madeleine's father but more properly may be attributed to "The Slave"

Snip
"Confusion is good"
It is falsely but nevertheless frequently claimed by anti-McCann posters that Gerry McCann used the phrase "confusion is good" in the above interview.   It is possible that this false claim has its roots in a comment which was posted under the video on the STV website:-
 
Quote by "The Slave" on 9th February 2010
"Confusion is good ? For you maybe, Gerry."
 
However, this expression was not at any time used by Gerry McCann in the interview.
http://madeleinemythsexposed.pbworks.com/w/page/39078182/Rebuttal%20of%20%22Fact%22%2039

It seems SIL is using this phrase to cast a slur on the McCanns intentions re: the translated files, I'd say that was tantamount to libel personally but no doubt it will be allowed to stand.

[Alfie]

Police forces are trying to find Madeleine for the McCann family, not a bunch of strangers passing the time on the internet.

The arrogance of some of the "internet sleuths" one encounters on the web is truly breath-taking.  It's as if they believe the McCanns owe it to them to keep them fully informed and up to date at all times to help them crack the case.  What delusions of grandeur!

[ShiningInLuz]

I don't understand your question, nor do I understand why you think it is right to bash the McCanns for not releasing their translated files onto the world wide web.  It's a preposterous criticism frankly.  It seems there is nothing this couple can do right in the eyes of people like yourself.

If you cannot tell the simple difference between whether the issue is the McCanns or whether it is Madeleine then frankly you have lost the plot, IMO.

[Alfie]

If you cannot tell the simple difference between whether the issue is the McCanns or whether it is Madeleine then frankly you have lost the plot, IMO.

Thanks for your kind words.  Personally I think it is you who have lost the plot as you are completely unable to tell us how it would help Madeleine to have the McCanns' translation of the files put on the world wide web. 

[ShiningInLuz]

Thanks for your kind words.  Personally I think it is you who have lost the plot as you are completely unable to tell us how it would help Madeleine to have the McCanns' translation of the files put on the world wide web.

There would be truth and clarity.  How hard is that to understand?

Or we can have confusion.  Is confusion good?

Which do you prefer?

[Alfie]

There would be truth and clarity.  How hard is that to understand?

Or we can have confusion.  Is confusion good?

Which do you prefer?

More rudeness from you.  What is hard to understand is why you feel so entitled, and so hard done by and so very disgruntled by the McCanns' "failure" to provide you with all the information that you require.  What made you so important?

[ferryman]

There would be truth and clarity.  How hard is that to understand?

Or we can have confusion.  Is confusion good?

Which do you prefer?

There would be a more reliable version of events.

Also heaps of people with loaded and twisted agendas to mangle and misrepresent even that record.

The official record is (rightly) available to those with a track-record of interpreting evidence to reach right conclusions in examining that record. 

[misty]

There would be truth and clarity.  How hard is that to understand?

Or we can have confusion.  Is confusion good?

Which do you prefer?

Seriously, what would you intend to do should such information be released into the public domain - seek out the trafficking gangs on the Algarve?