Author Topic: Smithman E-fits - How come there were two rather than just the one?  (Read 16294 times)

0 Members and 1 Guest are viewing this topic.

Offline Robittybob1

Funny thing with this Podesta Brother conspiracy theory it finally gives an explanation of how one person "Smithman" gives two distinct clear but different E-fits.  But then what does that say for the testimony of the Smith family?  What did they actually see?  Did they actually see two people rather than just one?  One carrying the child at any one time but as each saw it separately they had changed carrier between observations.  Was "Smithman" actually two people working together?

Can we finally say where the E-fits were produced and who produced them?
The Crimewatch program introduced the E-fits to the public https://youtu.be/OZ8jmdWlB8Y?t=1379
"Crimewatch UK - October 2013 Madeleine Mccann Special"
« Last Edit: December 10, 2016, 07:28:16 AM by Robittybob1 »
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline Brietta

Re: Smithman E-fits - How come there were two rather than just the one?
« Reply #1 on: December 10, 2016, 03:10:33 PM »
If the Smith family made a contribution which enabled the two efits to be produced it is perfectly obvious that only one person is represented.  The simple reason for that being that we know that Peter, Martin and Aoife reported seeing one individual.

It has taken time but we have seen the myths surrounding Madeleine's case being discounted one by one ... for example  - the green lichen on the window ledge.
What a pity it is that some people have learnt nothing and for reasons best known to themselves feel the need to subscribe to every mad theory dredged up as long as Madeleine McCann's name figures in it somewhere, no matter how ridiculous or implausible.

Some things just are not worthy of bothering with and in my opinion this particular fabrication is a prime example.





Claim: John and Tony Podesta personally kidnapped Madeleine McCann from her bed at a Portugal resort in 2007.

Another part of the conspiracy theory was a supposed link between the Podesta brothers and the child abduction case of Madeleine McCann on May 3, 2007. Two e-fit (electronic facial identification technique) photos released by British detectives were repeatedly used as evidence.

However, the two e-fits were based on descriptions of a single suspect by two witnesses, not two different suspects, a crucial detail that was left out.
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2013/oct/14/british-detectives-efits-madeleine-mccann-suspect

According to The Guardian, the witnesses described the man as “white, aged between 20 and 40, with short brown hair, of medium build, medium height and clean shaven.” In 2007, Tony Podesta was 64 and John Podesta was 58.

The information that the Podestas were in Portugal is solely sourced to “FBI Anon,” quoted in Victurus Libertas, a conspiracy-minded news site that suggests, among other things, that the Titanic was deliberately sunk and that the queen of England is a reptilian alien.
http://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2016/12/10/business/media/pizzagate.html?_r=0
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline Robittybob1

Re: Smithman E-fits - How come there were two rather than just the one?
« Reply #2 on: December 10, 2016, 06:02:17 PM »
Thanks Brietta only one part interests me in this thread
Quote
Another part of the conspiracy theory was a supposed link between the Podesta brothers and the child abduction case of Madeleine McCann on May 3, 2007. Two e-fit (electronic facial identification technique) photos released by British detectives were repeatedly used as evidence.

However, the two e-fits were based on descriptions of a single suspect by two witnesses, not two different suspects, a crucial detail that was left out.
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2013/oct/14/british-detectives-efits-madeleine-mccann-suspect

1. I have never been able to understand if the two witnesses were supposedly producing the same man how did the e-fits look so different? 
2. They look different to me, is that not the same for everyone else?  How can a question like what Andy Redwood asks be answered in the face of two different E-fits?
3. Were the two witnesses that produced the E-fits standing side by side?
If not there is the possibility that the person carrying the child swapped over at some stage. 
4. One child so only one person carrying a child.  Would they need to describe all the other people on the street as well?
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Smithman E-fits - How come there were two rather than just the one?
« Reply #3 on: December 10, 2016, 06:46:29 PM »
Thanks Brietta only one part interests me in this thread
1. I have never been able to understand if the two witnesses were supposedly producing the same man how did the e-fits look so different? 
2. They look different to me, is that not the same for everyone else?  How can a question like what Andy Redwood asks be answered in the face of two different E-fits?
3. Were the two witnesses that produced the E-fits standing side by side?
If not there is the possibility that the person carrying the child swapped over at some stage. 
4. One child so only one person carrying a child.  Would they need to describe all the other people on the street as well?

Mary and Martin Smith produced two e-fits.

It is a fiendishly difficult thing to describe a face, particularly of a, hitherto, complete stranger whom you have no idea, at the time, you will (later) be asked to try to memorise and reproduce. 

I don't see any problem reconciling that the individual and unique recollections of Martin and Mary are going to differ quite widely, one from the other.

I think that discrepancy precisely illustrates the limitation of e-fits, used as a method of attempting to identify people of interest in a criminal enquiry. 

Offline Brietta

Re: Smithman E-fits - How come there were two rather than just the one?
« Reply #4 on: December 10, 2016, 07:01:31 PM »
Mary and Martin Smith produced two e-fits.

It is a fiendishly difficult thing to describe a face, particularly of a, hitherto, complete stranger whom you have no idea, at the time, you will (later) be asked to try to memorise and reproduce. 

I don't see any problem reconciling that the individual and unique recollections of Martin and Mary are going to differ quite widely, one from the other.

I think that discrepancy precisely illustrates the limitation of e-fits, used as a method of attempting to identify people of interest in a criminal enquiry.

There might have been a slight chance of success had a description been taken immediately after the sighting.

That was impossible ...
  • the sighting was not reported immediately, but a fortnight later
  • in the three statements we have seen the witnesses said they would be unable to identify the man who passed them

That they were able to provide information to enable these efits to be made more than a year later seems, in my opinion, to really be the stuff of mystery.
"All I'm going to say is that we've conducted a very serious investigation and there's no indication that Madeleine McCann's parents are connected to her disappearance. On the other hand, we have a lot of evidence pointing out that Christian killed her," Wolter told the "Friday at 9"....

Offline Robittybob1

Re: Smithman E-fits - How come there were two rather than just the one?
« Reply #5 on: December 10, 2016, 07:42:01 PM »
There might have been a slight chance of success had a description been taken immediately after the sighting.

That was impossible ...
  • the sighting was not reported immediately, but a fortnight later
  • in the three statements we have seen the witnesses said they would be unable to identify the man who passed them

That they were able to provide information to enable these efits to be made more than a year later seems, in my opinion, to really be the stuff of mystery.
Not if they didn't tell us all they really knew.  Is it possible they knew or had met the Podesta brothers earlier at a pizza restaurant??  So they are not producing E-fits just from that fleeting meeting on the road but combining their image from memory of an earlier incident? (They had used the image of Gerry getting off the plane combined with what they saw in PDL)
But still had they swapped over who was carrying the child?   If the Smiths were spread out along the road with a time gap between the observations swapping over who was carrying the child can't really be ruled out can it? 
« Last Edit: December 10, 2016, 07:45:15 PM by Robittybob1 »
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: Smithman E-fits - How come there were two rather than just the one?
« Reply #6 on: December 10, 2016, 07:46:53 PM »
Mary and Martin Smith produced two e-fits.

It is a fiendishly difficult thing to describe a face, particularly of a, hitherto, complete stranger whom you have no idea, at the time, you will (later) be asked to try to memorise and reproduce. 

I don't see any problem reconciling that the individual and unique recollections of Martin and Mary are going to differ quite widely, one from the other.

I think that discrepancy precisely illustrates the limitation of e-fits, used as a method of attempting to identify people of interest in a criminal enquiry.
Cite for Mary producing one of the e-fits, or evidence thereof, if you please.

I am of the opinion Peter produced one on the e-fits, and it is not a trivial point.
What's up, old man?

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Smithman E-fits - How come there were two rather than just the one?
« Reply #7 on: December 10, 2016, 07:52:01 PM »
Cite for Mary producing one of the e-fits, or evidence thereof, if you please.

I am of the opinion Peter produced one on the e-fits, and it is not a trivial point.

http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/03/16/madeleine-mccann-latest-are-police-any-closer-to-knowing-the-tru/

Quote
Mary and Martin Smith, from Ireland, told police they saw a man carrying a child matching Madeleine’s description at around 10pm on Rua da Escola Primaria, 500 yards from the McCanns’ apartment. He was heading towards the beach, did not look like a tourist and did not seem comfortable carrying the child, they said.

Their evidence was compelling, but it was only in October 2013 that two e-fit images of the man, compiled by police from descriptions given by Mr and Mrs Smith, were released by Scotland Yard to coincide with a BBC Crimewatch reconstruction of Madeleine’s disappearance. He remains a suspect.

ETA: For a long time, I tended to a view that the second e-fit was probably produced by Aofe, simply because it always struck me that she, after her father, was the most observant witness of what the Smiths all saw.

Of course, we don't see Mary Smith's statement on-line.
« Last Edit: December 10, 2016, 08:00:21 PM by ferryman »

Offline Robittybob1

Re: Smithman E-fits - How come there were two rather than just the one?
« Reply #8 on: December 10, 2016, 08:09:22 PM »
Mary and Martin Smith produced two e-fits.

It is a fiendishly difficult thing to describe a face, particularly of a, hitherto, complete stranger whom you have no idea, at the time, you will (later) be asked to try to memorise and reproduce. 

I don't see any problem reconciling that the individual and unique recollections of Martin and Mary are going to differ quite widely, one from the other.

I think that discrepancy precisely illustrates the limitation of e-fits, used as a method of attempting to identify people of interest in a criminal enquiry.
OK we have to work out whether the E-fits were produced by two people independently.  If they are produced by the same person that doesn't make sense to me.  How far apart would Mary and Peter be from each other?  Could there be enough space and time to allow for a change over of the person carrying the child?
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

ferryman

  • Guest
Re: Smithman E-fits - How come there were two rather than just the one?
« Reply #9 on: December 10, 2016, 08:14:29 PM »
OK we have to work out whether the E-fits were produced by two people independently.  If they are produced by the same person that doesn't make sense to me.  How far apart would Mary and Peter be from each other?  Could there be enough space and time to allow for a change over of the person carrying the child?

Do you mean Mary and Peter?

Or Mary and Martin?

Offline Robittybob1

Re: Smithman E-fits - How come there were two rather than just the one?
« Reply #10 on: December 10, 2016, 08:16:08 PM »
Do you mean Mary and Peter?

Or Mary and Martin?
Martin  yes sorry.  I don't know my facts that well yet.
SIL talks of a Peter "I am of the opinion Peter produced one on the e-fits, and it is not a trivial point."

Who knows, there were a whole bunch of them, but were they spread out enough for a swap over to occur?
« Last Edit: December 10, 2016, 08:18:57 PM by Robittybob1 »
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: Smithman E-fits - How come there were two rather than just the one?
« Reply #11 on: December 10, 2016, 08:38:03 PM »
Martin  yes sorry.  I don't know my facts that well yet.
SIL talks of a Peter "I am of the opinion Peter produced one on the e-fits, and it is not a trivial point."

Who knows, there were a whole bunch of them, but were they spread out enough for a swap over to occur?
No.

Two different people each produced an e-fit of the same, single person.
What's up, old man?

Offline ShiningInLuz

Re: Smithman E-fits - How come there were two rather than just the one?
« Reply #12 on: December 10, 2016, 08:45:16 PM »
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/03/16/madeleine-mccann-latest-are-police-any-closer-to-knowing-the-tru/

ETA: For a long time, I tended to a view that the second e-fit was probably produced by Aofe, simply because it always struck me that she, after her father, was the most observant witness of what the Smiths all saw.

Of course, we don't see Mary Smith's statement on-line.
Thank you again, Ferryman.

The only issue with that standing article in the Telegraph is that it contains several errors, at least one of which was published in 2007, by the same reporter, in the Telegraph.

I am therefore wary of accepting its veracity unless there is some alternative substantiation.
What's up, old man?

Offline Robittybob1

Re: Smithman E-fits - How come there were two rather than just the one?
« Reply #13 on: December 10, 2016, 08:52:15 PM »
No.

Two different people each produced an e-fit of the same, single person.
We don't know that for all we do know is that the male was carrying a child.  How would you prove they were both seeing the same male?  It doesn't sound like it to me for the images are not alike.  Not alike IMO at least.  Do you really think they are alike?


Maybe they are "alike " because they are brothers!

I'd accept "Two different people each produced an e-fit of a person carrying a child".
« Last Edit: December 10, 2016, 08:56:48 PM by Robittybob1 »
Moderation
John has instructed all moderators to take a very strong line with posters who constantly breach the rules of this forum.  This sniping, goading, name calling and other various forms of disruption will cease.

Offline Mr Gray

Re: Smithman E-fits - How come there were two rather than just the one?
« Reply #14 on: December 10, 2016, 08:55:12 PM »
Thank you again, Ferryman.

The only issue with that standing article in the Telegraph is that it contains several errors, at least one of which was published in 2007, by the same reporter, in the Telegraph.

I am therefore wary of accepting its veracity unless there is some alternative substantiation.

how sure are you that none of your other sources do not contain errors