Kate McCann: I believe kidnapper drugged my twins night Madeleine was taken.

[Robittybob1]

Amaral wrote a book hurling innuendo at the McCanns yet you support him
Disgraceful

He called it freedom of speech and just opinion.

[Brietta]

 
  Topic, please

[G-Unit]

Today seems to have been a day for hurling innuendo at the McCanns.

Give it a rest!

There seem to have been a lot of posts about the impossibility of the dog alerts being a) triggered by the scent of decomposition or b) being connected to the child.

As I see it it's possible for both to be true, but impossible to demonstrate that possibility because the subject seems to be taboo, even hypothetically.

Some accuse the forum of being biased, but those who complain are allowed to speculate in the most ridiculous ways about all and sundry. People are regularly accused of incompetence, lying, conflict of interest, inaccurate translating and interpreting, conspiring to cover up facts, and loads more. On the whole, no cites or evidence are provided to support these accusations but they are allowed to stand.

[ShiningInLuz]

Amaral wrote a book hurling innuendo at the McCanns yet you support him
Disgraceful

Kindly prove that I support Amaral.

[Mr Gray]

Kindly prove that I support Amaral.

I don't intend to do your donkey work
You are pro amaral and anti McCann
That is plain
What do think of his book full of innuendo

[Eleanor]

Today seems to have been a day for hurling innuendo at the McCanns.

Give it a rest!

Why now all of a sudden?

[ShiningInLuz]

I don't intend to do your donkey work
You are pro amaral and anti McCann
That is plain

It's not my donkey work.  It's yours.

You stated a positive.  Namely that I am pro-Amaral, which happens not to be true.  And that I am anti-McCann, which happens not to be true.

So it is up to you to provide evidence of who is the donkey.

[Mr Gray]

He called it freedom of speech and just opinion.

Strange how this forum supports amaral a freedom of speech but not that of posters on here

[Mr Gray]

It's not my donkey work.  It's yours.

You stated a positive.  Namely that I am pro-Amaral, which happens not to be true.  And that I am anti-McCann, which happens not to be true.

So it is up to you to provide evidence of who is the donkey.

You have repeatedly refused to back up your claims with cites telling me to do my own donkey work
It's called getting a taste of your own medicine
The fact you don't like it is your problem
So what do you think of amarals book of lies

[ShiningInLuz]

You have repeatedly refused to back up your claims with cites telling me to do my own donkey work
It's called getting a taste of your own medicine
The fact you don't like it is your problem
So what do you think of amarals book of lies

Note how you dodged there.

I stuck up a moderator's note to get the forum to stop posting libellous material about the McCanns.

You came back saying I am an Amaral supporter, and anti-McCann.  Without providing a single shred of evidence.

Do you ever do your own donkey work?

[Mr Gray]

Note how you dodged there.

I stuck up a moderator's note to get the forum to stop posting libellous material about the McCanns.

You came back saying I am an Amaral supporter, and anti-McCann.  Without providing a single shred of evidence.

Do you ever do your own donkey work?

Simply give us your opinion on amarals book
You won't be able to answer because you will prove my point
And by not answering you prove my point
Donkey work done

[Alfie]

That would depend on when she died, wouldn't it.

It would have to have been before the McCanns left the apartment in that scenario which I'm sure you'd agree makes the theory even less plausible.

[Robittybob1]

Kindly prove that I support Amaral.

Months back I was going to ask everyone to declare their positions.  Then we wouldn't have to guess it.
I am for the McCanns for I could imagine Madeleine being still alive, but I also believe in the dog alerts and I largely support Amaral.  One might think it is impossible to have all those views but it is not.

[Robittybob1]

It's not my donkey work.  It's yours.

You stated a positive.  Namely that I am pro-Amaral, which happens not to be true.  And that I am anti-McCann, which happens not to be true.

So it is up to you to provide evidence of who is the donkey.

Are you undecided neither for or against?

[Robittybob1]

It would have to have been before the McCanns left the apartment in that scenario which I'm sure you'd agree makes the theory even less plausible.

It only makes sense to think Madeleine was alive when they put her to bed, but there is an hour between that and going to the Tapas.  Could Madeleine have died from a brain bled during those events, i.e 7:30 - 8:30 or even later, but then when Gerry checks and turned the light on wouldn't he notice she wasn't breathing?  No matter how beautiful she was.