Kate McCann: I believe kidnapper drugged my twins night Madeleine was taken.

[faithlilly]

When did Kate ever say she feared her children were "in danger of getting worse"?

She didn't......ah but just because it isn't written down how can we know she didn't eh eh ! 

Some people seem to believe that if it wasn't written down in a police statement or described in a book then it must not have happened.  Is that sound logic in your view?

[Alfie]

She didn't......ah but just because it isn't written down how can we know she didn't eh eh ! 

Some people seem to believe that if it wasn't written down in a police statement or described in a book then it must not have happened.  Is that sound logic in your view?

Fair enough, she may have feared her children were in danger of getting worse and she may have checked their pupils and pulse to ensure they weren"t.

[G-Unit]

When did Kate ever say she feared her children were "in danger of getting worse"?

She says she looked for signs of life several times. Why do that if she was confident they wouldn't get worse?

[slartibartfast]

She did fear it, she said so.  Are you calling her a liar?

I was just taking your posts to a logical conclusion.

[slartibartfast]

I was asking the person who wrote the post I responded to with the question.  I thought you would understand how forums work by now!

I know the difference between a forum and a personal discussion.

[G-Unit]

Fair enough, she may have feared her children were in danger of getting worse and she may have checked their pupils and pulse to ensure they weren"t.

That's speculation on your part; she and Fiona say she only checked that they were breathing.

[ferryman]

That's speculation on your part; she and Fiona say she only checked that they were breathing.

It is an assumption on your part that Kate treated her work as if a learned medical tome

[Alfie]

I was just taking your posts to a logical conclusion.

That was not the logical conclusion, unless you are claiming she lied about her concern.  Is that what you are claiming?

[Alfie]

That's speculation on your part; she and Fiona say she only checked that they were breathing.

And it's speculation on your part that she feared for her children's lives but did nothing to ensure they were not in mortal danger.

[Alfie]

We have some vociferous sceptics on this thread arguing that Kate McCann feared that her children were about to die but who did nothing to ensure they did not.  So assuming they are right what does this tell us a) Kate McCann as a mother and b) about the disappearance of Madeleine McCann?  Let's start taking this discussion forward from the rut it seems to be in currently.

[sadie]

So why in Madeleine, her police interviews and the numerous media interviews she has given since the disappearance has Kate never claimed she thought the twins may have been gassed?

Your repeated repetition of the words 'Kate' and 'gassed' is little short of propaganda (disinformation) . 

Are you trying to start, or substantiate, a myth with the intention of hurting The Mccanns again ?

[faithlilly]

Your repeated repetition of the words 'Kate' and 'gassed' is little short of propaganda (disinformation) . 

Are you trying to start or sudstantiate a myth with the intention of hurting The Mccanns again ?

I rarely answer your posts Sadie but if you look back it is Alfie who brought up the subject of Kate thinking the twins may have been gassed. I made no such claim. I'll take your apology as read.

[sadie]

I rarely answer your posts Sadie but if you look back it is Alfie who brought up the subject of Kate thinking the twins may have been gassed. I made no such claim. I'll take your apology as read.

It is you that owes an apology, to Alfie .... for twisting his words repeatedly, into something he did not say.

You also owe Kate Mccann an apology for the same thing.


Trying to develop a myth, are you ?  To help Amaral, at The Mccanns expence ?



 

[faithlilly]

It is you that owes an apology, to Alfie .... for twisting his words repeatedly, into something he did not say.

You also owe Kate Mccann an apology for the same thing.


Trying to develop a myth, are you ?  To help Amaral, at The Mccanns expence ?

This is my last reply to you Sadie so no answer needed. This is what Alfie posted :

'In my opinion (conjecture here, remember I am not the McCanns so this could be completely wrong, and don't start ascribing my thoughts to them) the McCanns may have thought that their children had been gassed as stories of holiday makers being gassed and robbed on the continent have been doing the rounds for many years.

Not sure I could twist those words.

[Brietta]

This is my last reply to you Sadie so no answer needed. This is what Alfie posted :

'In my opinion (conjecture here, remember I am not the McCanns so this could be completely wrong, and don't start ascribing my thoughts to them) the McCanns may have thought that their children had been gassed as stories of holiday makers being gassed and robbed on the continent have been doing the rounds for many years.

Please refrain from lifting selective quotations from a member's post accompanied by a failure to provide a link to the post for verification.
You may not intend to be intentionally duplicitous but in my opinion that is how your posting in such a manner is coming over.

Alfie's full quote is ...
In my opinion (conjecture here, remember I am not the McCanns so this could be completely wrong, and don't start ascribing my thoughts to them) the McCanns may have thought that their children had been gassed as stories of holiday makers being gassed and robbed on the continent have been doing the rounds for many years.  Before you all jump down my throat I know these stories are considered by many to be a load of hogwash but it still doesn't take away from the fact that such occurrences have been widely reported in the media.  So it is possible that this was a thought going through Kate's panicked mind at the time. Personally I think it's an unlikely scenario, and I also think it's unlikely the children were sedated.
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?board=18.0