Were the McCanns innocent in the eyes of the law?

[Robittybob1]

he and davel love goading but they report us for goading 

I haven't got time for goading, but it sounds fun.

[G-Unit]

his book cannot be quoted on this forum as it is libellous
he claims he can prove maddie died in the apartment.....he has no evidence
if you think his theories would be accepted on this forum you are deluded

I've quoted from his book on the forum for the sake of accuracy. Sometimes people will accuse him of saying things he didn't say.

[Mr Gray]

I've quoted from his book on the forum for the sake of accuracy. Sometimes people will accuse him of saying things he didn't say.

He said in his documentary
Which was part of the case
Maddie died in the apartment
And I can prove it
He can't
He didn't understand the dog alerts
He didn't understand the forensic reports
And according to him neither did any other of the pj
What chance of justice for Maddie with him in charge

[stephen25000]

He said in his documentary
Which was part of the case
Maddie died in the apartment
And I can prove it
He can't
He didn't understand the dog alerts
He didn't understand the forensic reports
And according to him neither did any other of the pj
What chance of justice for Maddie with him in charge

He was case coordinator for a few months.

Doh.


As to 'justice for Maddie', I hold responsibility for what happened with her parents. No one else has been found to have been involved.

[stephen25000]

he and davel love goading but they report us for goading 

Indeed Carly, with his history on here.

[Mr Gray]

He was case coordinator for a few months.

Doh.


As to 'justice for Maddie', I hold responsibility for what happened with her parents. No one else has been found to have been involved.

If you have followed the case you might understand that he claims the whole of the pj agreed with him
He claims his theory was based on the official files
Obviously you have not been following the case

[stephen25000]

If you have followed the case you might understand that he claims the whole of the pj agreed with him
He claims his theory was based on the official files
Obviously you have not been following the case

Predictable post.


So, just remind me, when was accidental death disproved ?

[G-Unit]

I just don't like dishonesty that's all.  I'm certainly not obsessed with your thoughts, what a strange accusation!

Neither do I and I don't appreciate being accused of it either, so please desist. I'm pleased you're not obsessed with my thoughts and look forward to seeing less analysis of them in the future.

[Mr Gray]

Predictable post.


So, just remind me, when was accidental death disproved ?

The parents have been ruled out by SY

[stephen25000]

The parents have been ruled out by SY

There is no record that the parents were interviewed by SY.

The crime, if one occurred is still unknown.

You harbour this strange belief, IMO, as do others of your kind, that it is Amaral's theory that made people think Madeleine is dead.


It isn't. People came to that conclusion without him.

[G-Unit]

He said in his documentary
Which was part of the case
Maddie died in the apartment
And I can prove it
He can't
He didn't understand the dog alerts
He didn't understand the forensic reports
And according to him neither did any other of the pj
What chance of justice for Maddie with him in charge

It must be very annoying that it was ruled to be within his rights to say what he said. You and the McCanns need to accept that sometimes you will read, see or hear things you don't like.

[barrier]

The parents have been ruled out by SY

Why shouldn't they be,by OG's remit its an abduction being looked at,why? should they be under suspicion of this?

[Mr Gray]

It must be very annoying that it was ruled to be within his rights to say what he said. You and the McCanns need to accept that sometimes you will read, see or hear things you don't like.

It's not annoying at all as it doesn't affect me in the slightest
Will it be annoying for you if SY confirm that the parents are not involved and they believe Maddie was abducted

[pathfinder73]

Why shouldn't they be,by OG's remit its an abduction being looked at,why? should they be under suspicion of this?

DCI Redwood seemed to contradict himself - maybe it's catching LOL. "Primarily what we sought to do from the beginning is try and draw everything back to zero if you like. Try and take everything back to the beginning and re-analyse and reassess everything, accepting nothing."

[G-Unit]

The parents have been ruled out by SY

Whatever you think SY have decided it isn't important because it isn't and never was their case. In the unlikely event they get enough evidence for a trial they will have to go cap in hand to the Portuguese and persuade them to proceed the matter. I suspect very strong evidence would be needed before that happened.