CMTV Gonçalo Amaral - O Enigma - with English subtitles

[stephen25000]

The information portrayed in Amaral's latest offering is not consistent with the PJ files in many respects.

As I said,we do not have access your all the case information.

Amaral was the coordinator.

He would have, at the time.

[stephen25000]

We are discussing the video and Amaral states things that are not true
Amaral does not have access to all the facts of the case
He is no longer  involved

How do you know what info he had access to.

You don't,  of course.

[Mr Gray]

We know that, according to the info provided in the public domain.

There will of course be information we don'the know.

Do you know what information Amaral had access to.

Rhetorical question, of course.

Amaral is supporting his claim by falsely distorting evidence that is in the public domain
We know what he is claiming is blatantly false
 It is easily shown to be false

You are making an assumption that there is further evidence
Pure speculation based on nothing

[Mr Gray]

What will you say if they fail to find an abductor, and as I have stated for some time,  shelve the case again ?

I will continue to say Maddie was badly let down by the original investigation

[stephen25000]

Amaral is supporting his claim by falsely distorting evidence that is in the public domain
We know what he is claiming is blatantly false
 It is easily shown to be false

You are making an assumption that there is further evidence
Pure speculation based on nothing

That is exactly what you are doing.

You simply do not know all the facts in the case.

[Erngath]

Surely SY must be aware of his theories.
Either they have dismissed them, investigated them further or ignored them.
I would never claim any police force is infallible but have difficulty believing the latter.

[stephen25000]

I will continue to say Maddie was badly let down by the original investigation

I will continue to say, she was let down by her parents.

Madeleine was searched for by many people.

Nothing was found.

[Mr Gray]

The basis of Amarals claim is the alerts by the dogs
He claims they are proof of cadaver odour
They are not even evidence

[Mr Gray]

I will continue to say, she was let down by her parents.

Madeleine was searched for by many people.

Nothing was found.

That's a reasonable opinion but she was also let down by the original investigation which clearly did not have a clue

[carlymichelle]

I will continue to say, she was let down by her parents.

Madeleine was searched for by many people.

Nothing was found.

many many many many people  around the world agree with you

[Erngath]

many many many many people  around the world agree with you

That is only your opinion.

[stephen25000]

many many many many people  around the world agree with you

Indeed Carlymichelle, that is the situation, IMHO.

[Mr Gray]

My views on this case are determined solely by my understanding of the evidence
Claiming I'm somehow emotionally involved  or part of the family is quite pathetic and shows how poor the posters judgement is

[stephen25000]

My views on this case are determined self by my understanding of the evidence
Claiming I'm somehow emote I vied or part of the family is quite pathetic and shows how poor the posters judgement is

You choose to make your comments and give opinions.

There is no given right that people will or should agree with you.

[Alice Purjorick]

My views on this case are determined solely by my understanding of the evidence
Claiming I'm somehow emotionally involved  or part of the family is quite pathetic and shows how poor the posters judgement is

I am sure they are.