CMTV Gonçalo Amaral - O Enigma - with English subtitles

[sadie]

Also by you.  Frequently.

Very frequently.  I think I lost 6 posts one day and also a warning for libel.   

I have been hard hitting and very sharp at times but I dont think that I have ever committed libel.  If you get the sharp stuff from others you give it back and boy have I been abused over the years on here


Despite never having libelled I have a long list of accusations of it and no-body ever gives a proper explanation.  John gives something of an explanation but can never point to in any way to how I have libelled per se.

Now I am being denied the right to pm John, or to pm Brietts or Eleanor at the time to discuss it.   Recently both stephen and slarti have been ruthless in cutting my posts ... I think they are trying to hassle me out, like davel, ferryman and Alfie.

[Brietta]

If Tannerman had been going from east to west, Jane would have been following him after she reached the corner of the junction.......

As it is Jane's diagram shows where Tannerman was when she initially saw him ... and where he was as she reached the top of the road to turn home.

His direction of travel has caused much speculation over the years.  His very existence has caused much speculation.

My gut reaction is that Scotland Yard are speculating no longer on either point and your speculation gave me a 'revelation moment'.

[slartibartfast]

Very frequently.  I think I lost 6 posst one day and also a warning for libel.   

I have been hard hitting and very sharp at times but I dont think that I have ever committed libel.  If you get the sharp stuff from others you give it back and
boy have I been abused over the years on here


Despite never having libelled I have a long list of accusations of it and no-body ever gives proper explanation.  John gives something of an explanation but never says that I have libelled in any way

Now I am being denied the right to pm John or to pm Brietts or Eleanor at the time to discuss it.   Recently both stephen and slarti have been ruthless in cutting my posts ... I think they are trying to hassle me out, like davel, ferryman and Alfie.

If you don't realise you are libelling, you need to look at your posts more carefully.

[sadie]

It was very quiet. None of the T5 who checked saw anyone or were seen by anyone except Wilkins even though;


The Moyes came back at 9, were on their balcony at 9.15
The executive chef drove past 5A and parked outside the Tapas 9.10
Up to seven families left the Tapas complex after their dinner.
Various parents were carrying children around.

As far as we know !   But why would anyone report seeing any of the Tapas group going to and fro.  None of them was carrying a little girl

[sadie]

She's got Gerry on the left hand pavement too; he says he was on the right hand pavement.

Amaral and Jez also got Gerry on the left hand (west) pavement.  Gerry remembered it wrongly.

[sadie]

If Tannerman had been going from east to west, Jane would have been following him after she reached the corner of the junction.......

Exactly.  They are just prevaricating, dodging the issue cos they dont like mention of an abductor  IMO

[Robittybob1]

If Tannerman had been going from east to west, Jane would have been following him after she reached the corner of the junction.......

I cannot accept Jane got her observations so wrong. 

[sadie]

If you don't realise you are libelling, you need to look at your posts more carefully.

If I have libelled rather than been hard hitting and sharp, kindly give me the evidence.  TY

[sadie]

I cannot accept Jane got her observations so wrong.

Quite.

Jane is no idiot and you and misty are right.  As misty says, had crechman been going east to west, Jane would have been following him

Then she would have seen where he went into the distance.

[misty]

As it is Jane's diagram shows where Tannerman was when she initially saw him ... and where he was as she reached the top of the road to turn home.

His direction of travel has caused much speculation over the years.  His very existence has caused much speculation.

My gut reaction is that Scotland Yard are speculating no longer on either point and your speculation gave me a 'revelation moment'.

I think the latest press releases stating SY have completed their work & are only on a watching brief is evidence that they are no longer speculating over Tannerman. It will be very interesting to see what happens next - maybe we will all have a "moment" in one form or another. 

[G-Unit]

If Tannerman had been going from east to west, Jane would have been following him after she reached the corner of the junction.......

It was my feeble attempt at a joke. Ignoring the facts and speculating is fun. Perhaps crecheman, heading for block 4, realised he'd left his kid's favourite cuddly toy at the creche so he turned back. That's when Jane saw him.

[Robittybob1]

It was my feeble attempt at a joke. Ignoring the facts and speculating is fun. Perhaps crecheman, heading for block 4, realised he'd left his kid's favourite cuddly toy at the creche so he turned back. That's when Jane saw him.

Well you could but if the child was asleep just pick it up tomorrow.

[G-Unit]

Well you could but if the child was asleep just pick it up tomorrow.

Can't. The child will cry all night if it wakes up and it's toy's not there. 

[misty]

It was my feeble attempt at a joke. Ignoring the facts and speculating is fun. Perhaps crecheman, heading for block 4, realised he'd left his kid's favourite cuddly toy at the creche so he turned back. That's when Jane saw him.

I did consider that in my theory but it made no sense for Crecheman to carry his daughter all the way back to the creche when his apartment was less than 200m away & his wife would almost certainly be there to care for their child while he nipped back to collect the toy.

[faithlilly]

I did consider that in my theory but it made no sense for Crecheman to carry his daughter all the way back to the creche when his apartment was less than 200m away & his wife would almost certainly be there to care for their child while he nipped back to collect the toy.

So are you saying that there are three men now carrying bare-footed Madeleine-loakalikes around PDL on the night of the third ?