Where were Jez and Gerry standing when they did their talking? Ideas solutions

[Alice Purjorick]

I think I did that a while back on another thread. The Ace he could never play without incriminating himself.

I think the answer is a lot simpler than that.

If I trip over a brick it's cos I am a clumsy plonker not looking where I am going.
If a Prince trips over a brick it's an assasination attempt cos someone put the brick there with malice aforethought...................err no.
It's because the Prince was also a clumsy plonker not looking where he was going.

[Robittybob1]

Yes. IMO that is when the abduction occurred.

Give me your best reasons for that then please?

[misty]

I think the answer is a lot simpler than that.

If I trip over a brick it's cos I am a clumsy plonker not looking where I am going.
If a Prince trips over a brick it's an assasination attempt cos someone put the brick there with malice aforethought...................err no.
It's because the Prince was also a clumsy plonker not looking where he was going.

The Prince tripped himself up when he mouthed off to a journalist. It was all going so swimmingly.....then the PJ were left with the impossible task of eliminating Smithman. IMO.

[misty]

Give me your best reasons for that then please?

1. Tannerman.
2. 2 door moves before 9,30pm
3. Room light enough for MO to see twin(s) breathing in cots at 9.30pm.

[Alice Purjorick]

The Prince tripped himself up when he mouthed off to a journalist. It was all going so swimmingly.....then the PJ were left with the impossible task of eliminating Smithman. IMO.

Then that nice DCI Redwood said words to the effect "we need to identify this man" [who probably is Peter Brady].
Were this lot an orchestra one would be forgiven for believing they did not know their Brass from their Oboe.

[misty]

Then that nice DCI Redwood said words to the effect "we need to identify this man" [who probably is Peter Brady].
Were this lot an orchestra one would be forgiven for believing they did not know their Brass from their Oboe.

Therein lies the difficulty if Smithman is Peter Brady, which is why, I believe, the investigation is so complex.
In the absence of definitive proof that A N Other was responsible for Madeleine's disappearance, Smithman remains both a defence tool for anyone who may be charged & also potentially leaves an abductor still at large.
If Smithman can be identified as an innocent person carrying his child, that clears Gerry of any suspicion with regards to Martin Smith's identification.

[Miss Taken Identity]

....Or an accomplice's accomplice.

Bet you hadn't thought of that.

Maybe there was an entire fleet of child abductors, & watchers, with walkies talkies & getaway vehicles.

Yes!  someone also mentioned a boat... now this is beginning to ring true Sadies abduction theory maybe by Mossad was behind it because Sadie mentioned about the Jewish name connection.... ahh it's all coming together now!

[Robittybob1]

Yes!  someone also mentioned a boat... now this is beginning to ring true Sadies abduction theory maybe by Mossad was behind it because Sadie mentioned about the Jewish name connection.... ahh it's all coming together now!

What about the Palestinians going for Jez' daughter, because he was the head of the Jewish Youth Movement and because of a mistaken Identity they get the wrong girl.

[sadie]

If Sadie thinks the video has been altered, then she should be able to link to the original video and demonstrate the changes.

If you bothered to read my earlier post you would see that the original has been wiped as far as I can see.   I commented about the two videos a few months ago and gave their addies.  Bet they have been wiped.

At the time I noticed a diffference in length of each of them, but I didn't have the time and energy to analyse them in detail.   Am wishing I had now thio.

[sadie]

Videos can be deleted by the channel owner.  If I knew how I'd like to save entire videos as I think they will disappear altogether over the years. What will be available to discuss in 10 years from now?

I am not a techie, but I think that you can save them on a USB stick. 

Please delete if I am incorrect.

[Alice Purjorick]

Therein lies the difficulty if Smithman is Peter Brady, which is why, I believe, the investigation is so complex.
In the absence of definitive proof that A N Other was responsible for Madeleine's disappearance, Smithman remains both a defence tool for anyone who may be charged & also potentially leaves an abductor still at large.
If Smithman can be identified as an innocent person carrying his child, that clears Gerry of any suspicion with regards to Martin Smith's identification.

If wishes were 'orses beggars would ride......................
If a sewing machine 'ad bigger wheels it might be a car.
Meantime no one knows just who Smithman is/was nor what he was at and in my opinion he occupies a space in two police forces files labelled "Don't know....yet. Pending. More evidence needed".

[misty]

If wishes were 'orses beggars would ride......................
If a sewing machine 'ad bigger wheels it might be a car.
Meantime no one knows just who Smithman is/was nor what he was at and in my opinion he occupies a space in two police forces files labelled "Don't know....yet. Pending. More evidence needed".

I would hope any pending files contained specific phone records from the relevant period.

[sadie]

It is not that we are saying Sadie is lying about this but it is a matter of remembering an entire video.  I don't know if I ever saw  the original video.  I know how we can solve this; if there was a video that has gone missing has someone put a link to over the years, if so we will find a broken link. I'll search "cutting edge"

I have searched using various combinations of the words Cutting Edge, Madeleine, Reconstruction, Channel 4 etc but was unable to find anything.  If you can that would be great.

I actually posted both videos, on here a few months ago and mentioned various things about them.  Haven't the energy to check, but my guess is that they will have been whooshed

[Robittybob1]

I am not a techie, but I think that you can save them on a USB stick. 

Please delete if I am incorrect.

Does anyone save entire videos?

[Robittybob1]

I have searched using various combinations of the words Cutting Edge, Madeleine, Reconstruction, Channel 4 etc but was unable to find anything.  If you can that would be great.

I actually posted both videos, on here a few months ago and mentioned various things about them.  Haven't the energy to check, but my guess is that they will have been whooshed

Was this one https://youtu.be/na4aBr5PTYY?list=PLUi_lxCT70vDvcNK7Cq-EyaUgSizyfPJt