If the PJ were suspicious of the Tapas 9 stories right from the start, any attempt at a reconstruction would be noted by the press as an indication that the Tapas 9 were under suspicion, and that could be counter productive to the investigation of the Tapas 9. All IMO.
I had read something to that effect, but I wouldn't be able to find a cite to an article, nor would the article necessarily be true.
My understanding of a UK-style Crimewatch reconstruction is to jog people's memories to get people to phone in with potentially relevant new information.
In some other countries, it's not intended for that purpose, but is more of a forensic-style operation, to see if what x, y or y stated is impossible. I don't have a problem with that approach, per se, if the purpose is to eliminate suspects.
However, where that can go wrong is if, e.g., the police were to script that you held a gun in a certain position (to take it out of context), and then filmed the sequence, showinng that as it was possible, you were therefore guilty.
With hindsight, I very much doubt that Rebelo would have scripted them all and chosen the best sequence of possibilites, but how on earth were the T9 to know that... particularly with the Cipriano case in mind (presuming that they'd at least read the pro-PJ tabloids and had got hold of the actual files on the case)?
In those circumstances, I'd have been very suspicious as well as to the real purpose.