Why Were We Lied to By the BBC ?

[Robittybob1]

There is agood article in the guardian which gives the background to the panorama programme. The initial producer lookes at all the evidence and delivered a script that was critical of the pj and the press which led people to believe the mccanns may be guilty. The BBC would not accept this and the producer resigned ...they then went on to produce a programme that was far more critical of the mccanns. So far from suppressing evidence of the smith sighting the bbc supressed evidence of the mccanns innocence....seems that im a better investigative journalist than odowd

Was there a cite?  Just the phrase "in the guardian" is hardly enough? When was this "in the guardian"?

[jassi]

The PJ knew about the sighting in May 2007. Why would they have wanted or needed a report from a team of UK PI's to tell them what was important?

New information may have led them to re-evaluate the sighting - had they been aware of it.

[Mr Gray]

That was the 2007 Panorama.

Congratulations.

so we have proof that the bbc is not supportive of the mccanns...congratulations are in order....

[faithlilly]

There is agood article in the guardian which gives the background to the panorama programme. The initial producer lookes at all the evidence and delivered a script that was critical of the pj and the press which led people to believe the mccanns may be guilty. The BBC would not accept this and the producer resigned ...they then went on to produce a programme that was far more critical of the mccanns. So far from suppressing evidence of the smith sighting the bbc supressed evidence of the mccanns innocence....seems that im a better investigative journalist than odowd

Perhaps you need to bone up on those investigative skills Davel her name is O'Doherty.

[misty]

New information may have led them to re-evaluate the sighting - had they been aware of it.

Given that the child was wearing long-sleeved pyjamas & her face was not visible for identification purposes, what new information could the PJ have obtained about a person they hadn't made a public appeal for?

[Wonderfulspam]

so we have proof that the bbc is not supportive of the mccanns...congratulations are in order....

I agree with your previous point though.

Evidence of the McCanns innocence, or rather, the proof of it, is being suppressed.

SY won't tell us what it is. It might have been useful evidence at the SC.

[Mr Gray]

I agree with your previous point though.

Evidence of the McCanns innocence, or rather, the proof of it, is being suppressed.

SY won't tell us what it is. It might have been useful evidence at the SC.

if you agree then you would see I said it was supressed by the BBC ...for those who like me understand what evidence is then it is clear the mcanns are innocent...those who belong to the ...dogs dont lie brigade ...have no understanding of what evidence is imo...and therefore have reached the wrong conclusions...i would put you in that group...in order that this post will not be removed...all in my opinion

[Wonderfulspam]

if you agree then you would see I said it was supressed by the BBC ...for those who like me understand what evidence is then it is clear the mcanns are innocent...those who belong to the ...dogs dont lie brigade ...have no understanding of what evidence is imo...and therefore have reached the wrong conclusions...i would put you in taht group...in order that this post will not be removed...all in my opinion

Yes, I saw you said BBC.

I also understand what evidence is, but I'm yet to see any that convinces me the McCanns didn't do it.

[Mr Gray]

Yes, I saw you said BBC.

I also understand what evidence is, but I'm yet to see any that convinces me the McCanns didn't do it.

then you dont understand how justice works...justice works by having evidence which shows a suspect committed a crime ...not by the suspect having to prove that they did not commit the crime..its quite a basic concept but a concept that you and other sceptics do not seem to have grasped

[Wonderfulspam]

then you dont understand how justice works...justice works by having evidence which shows a suspect committed a crime ...not by the suspect having to prove that they did not commit the crime..its quote a basic concept but a concept that you and other sceptics do not seem to have grasped

I understand how justice works.

The McCann's are presumed innocent until proven guilty.

But, that still doesn't convince me they didn't do it.

[Mr Gray]

I understand how justice works.

The McCann's are presumed innocent until proven guilty.

But, that still doesn't convince me they didn't do it.

if you understand how justice works then you will understand what you think is of no consequence

[Wonderfulspam]

if you understand how justice works then you will understand what you think is of no consequence

When I write what I'm thinking, then there are consequences, usually a warning.

Thankfully, my mind is free from legal constraints.

Right now, for example, I'm still thinking it was them.

[Mr Gray]

When I write what I'm thinking, then there are consequences, usually a warning.

Thankfully, my mind is free from legal constraints.

Right now, for example, I'm still thinking it was them.

as i said...it doesnt matter...no importance whatsoever...you dont understand the evidence...afaiac

[Miss Taken Identity]

Well, look here it mentions a COLD night and Chill  in the air.. not a warm night at all as per Gerry's claim his daughter was outside the covers when he/they left her as it was a warm night during his 'beautiful daughter moment'. oh but that's nothing Tsk.

I find it amusing that people hold the BBC in high regard, WTF. Do we not recall the protection of paedophiles and do we not recall the  Dr David Kelly hounding. Pandered to the IRA cause, support the EU (because they get money from them). sexual discrimination-recent pay imbalance- What a company- full of s...ks, talentless wonders.IMO.
I mean this is a company who gets ,money from poor people and pensioners to pay that Irish eejit dj 1million pounds to host a children in need 'charity' event- the shear audacity to demand people open their purses and wallets to help the children???? Seriously!  BBC have an agenda...look closely.

I am so not surprised but well done those who sought to put them right- to dispel a myth.

[Mr Gray]

Well, look here it mentions a COLD night and Chill  in the air.. not a warm night at all as per Gerry's claim his daughter was outside the covers when he/they left her as it was a warm night during his 'beautiful daughter moment'. oh but that's nothing Tsk.

I find it amusing that people hold the BBC in high regard, WTF. Do we not recall the protection of paedophiles and do we not recall the  Dr David Kelly hounding. Pandered to the IRA cause, support the EU (because they get money from them). sexual discrimination-recent pay imbalance- What a company- full of s...ks, talentless wonders.IMO.
I mean this is a company who gets ,money from poor people and pensioners to pay that Irish eejit dj 1million pounds to host a children in need 'charity' event- the shear audacity to demand people open their purses and wallets to help the children???? Seriously!  BBC have an agenda...look closely.

I am so not surprised but well done those who sought to put them right- to dispel a myth.

Reading your post it made me think...how much had smith had to drink that night..any ideas