Do the sceptics simply misunderstand the evidence

[barrier]

Do they have means of persuasion?  I can't see any pressure coming on anyone to confess at the moment.

The only pressure will be a conscience.

[barrier]

What "corroborating evidence"?

Ask Grime he was the one asking for it.

That was a copy and paste from the report.  "It is my view that it is possible that the EVRD is alerting to cadaver scent contamination. No evidential or intelligence reliability can be made from this alert unless it can be confirmed with corroborating evidence. "  http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_GRIMES.htm

[Carana]

The only pressure will be a conscience.

Quite possibly, or simply stumbling on something that might otherwise have been ignored, thrown in a bin without a reminder; or someone, e.g., Smithman, or a friend or family member, suddenly realising that Smithman might have been the person in question (whether as an innocent dad, brother, uncle, or as someone whose behaviour now appears odd in retrospect due to other situations)...

[Robittybob1]

What "corroborating evidence"?

Short of a confession. even if they found Madeleine's body somewhere there is no linkage between the apartment and where it could be found.
If they found a blue bag with bones inside of it, then that could be significant if it matched the one in the photo.

[jassi]

Short of a confession. even if they found Madeleine's body somewhere there is no linkage between the apartment and where it could be found.
If they found a blue bag with bones inside of it, then that could be significant if it matched the one in the photo.

Or contained identifying traces of the perpetrator.

[Carana]

Short of a confession. even if they found Madeleine's body somewhere there is no linkage between the apartment and where it could be found.
If they found a blue bag with bones inside of it, then that could be significant if it matched the one in the photo.

- Not necessarily, but possibly. Do you remember the Ozzy case of the girl in a suitcase?

- What "blue" bag in "the" photo?

[Robittybob1]

- Not necessarily, but possibly. Do you remember the Ozzy case of the girl in a suitcase?

- What "blue" bag in "the" photo?

The one in the wardrobe.  I think the cadaver was in the apartment all the time. That is why there were questions about this directed at Kate.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/48_Questions_07_09_07.htm
02 --- If she looked inside the cupboard of the couple's bedroom, she said No in response.
03 --- Shown two photographs of the cupboard of her bedroom, and asked for a description of the contents, she did not respond.
--- The viewing ended and after signs of cadaver odour in her bedroom next to the cupboard and behind the sofa against the window of the living room, she said that she can not explain anything more than that already mentioned.

Interesting that she admitted to not looking in the wardrobe!

[jassi]

The one in the wardrobe.  I think the cadaver was in the apartment all the time. That is why there were questions about this directed at Kate.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/48_Questions_07_09_07.htm
02 --- If she looked inside the cupboard of the couple's bedroom, she said No in response.
03 --- Shown two photographs of the cupboard of her bedroom, and asked for a description of the contents, she did not respond.
--- The viewing ended and after signs of cadaver odour in her bedroom next to the cupboard and behind the sofa against the window of the living room, she said that she can not explain anything more than that already mentioned.

    Welcome to the dark side of the fence.

[Carana]

The one in the wardrobe.  I think the cadaver was in the apartment all the time. That is why there were questions about this directed at Kate.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/48_Questions_07_09_07.htm
02 --- If she looked inside the cupboard of the couple's bedroom, she said No in response.
03 --- Shown two photographs of the cupboard of her bedroom, and asked for a description of the contents, she did not respond.
--- The viewing ended and after signs of cadaver odour in her bedroom next to the cupboard and behind the sofa against the window of the living room, she said that she can not explain anything more than that already mentioned.

Interesting that she admitted to not looking in the wardrobe!

That's line 11, which says "... disse não responder."

[Miss Taken Identity]

The one in the wardrobe.  I think the cadaver was in the apartment all the time. That is why there were questions about this directed at Kate.
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/48_Questions_07_09_07.htm
02 --- If she looked inside the cupboard of the couple's bedroom, she said No in response.
03 --- Shown two photographs of the cupboard of her bedroom, and asked for a description of the contents, she did not respond.
--- The viewing ended and after signs of cadaver odour in her bedroom next to the cupboard and behind the sofa against the window of the living room, she said that she can not explain anything more than that already mentioned.

Interesting that she admitted to not looking in the wardrobe!

Yes interesting indeed. Once Kate KNEW instantly that her daughter was abducted she searched the apartment- not looking in the wardrope?- she left the other children and ran to tell the others.
 of course we are told by the supporters  that it was not at the moment Kate knew her daughter had been abducted but when she was told about JT's sighting.. all very confusing ...key stone cops drama.

ok- to summarise Kate did not search the apartment. Yes she did, well....

[Carana]

Yes interesting indeed. Once Kate KNEW instantly that her daughter was abducted she searched the apartment- not looking in the wardrope?- she left the other children and ran to tell the others.
 of course we are told by the supporters  that it was not at the moment Kate knew her daughter had been abducted but when she was told about JT's sighting.. all very confusing ...key stone cops drama.

ok- to summarise Kate did not search the apartment. Yes she did, well....

Except if you check the original, she didn't say that she hadn't checked...

[Miss Taken Identity]

Except if you check the original, she didn't say that she hadn't checked...

Yes. Smoke and mirrors.

[Robittybob1]

That's line 11, which says "... disse não responder."

Are you suggesting it is a translation error?

[Robittybob1]

Except if you check the original, she didn't say that she hadn't checked...

Well what did she say in the original?

[Carana]

Well what did she say in the original?

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=9213.msg453209#msg453209