If Brueckner is Never Charged.

[Wonderfulspam]

So are you conceding that there was a paedophile and rapist in the neighbourhood when Madeleine went missing?

So what if there was?

There were probably Bakers & Fishermen nearby too, that doesn't mean Maddie had cake or tuna.

[Mr Gray]

Intelligence and inferences are two different things. In my opinion the German police have, at the moment, intelligence from which they  appear to have drawn inferences. They claim to have concrete evidence that Madeleine McCann is dead, but they admit they don't have the evidence needed to charge Brueckner with killing her.

Harrison said no inferences from these particular alerts...he said this after the searches
The Germans we are told have evidence ...not intelligence...concrete evidence..

They are clearly making one thing clear and that is in their view Maddie's cadaver was not in the apartment long enough to produce cadaver odour. You really should accept this

[G-Unit]

Harrison said no inferences from these particular alerts...he said this after the searches
The Germans we are told have evidence ...not intelligence...concrete evidence..

They are clearly making one thing clear and that is in their view Maddie's cadaver was not in the apartment long enough to produce cadaver odour. You really should accept this

Concrete evidence that the child is dead. No forensic evidence though.

[Mr Gray]

Concrete evidence that the child is dead. No forensic evidence though.

There was no concrete or forensic evidence Susan Pillay died..but a murder conviction

[G-Unit]

There was no concrete or forensic evidence Susan Pillay died..but a murder conviction

You seem to be relying on the 'concrete evidence' quote, but leaving out what it was relating to. I was just reminding you it is related to the child's death, not to Brueckner's guilt.

[sadie]

There was no concrete or forensic evidence Susan Pillay died..but a murder conviction

I don't like it.

Maybe SY have confirmed a belief that Bruckner was the abductor, but I can't recall it.  They claim to have concrete evidence, then fail in their searches.  That makes me uncomfortable. 

And SY just don't seem to me to have backed the German suspicions in any way.  Why not ?


But perhaps I have missed something?   I think that SY still believe Madeleine is likely alive. 

Please convince me otherwise.

[Mr Gray]

You seem to be relying on the 'concrete evidence' quote, but leaving out what it was relating to. I was just reminding you it is related to the child's death, not to Brueckner's guilt.

You are wrong again...HCW said they have concrete evidence that Maddie is dead and that CB killed her.
I'm amazed how out of touch with the facts some are

[Mr Gray]

I don't like it.

Maybe SY have confirmed a belief that Bruckner was the abductor, but I can't recall it.  They claim to have concrete evidence, then fail in their searches.  That makes me uncomfortable. 

And SY just don't seem to me to have backed the German suspicions in any way.  Why not ?


But perhaps I have missed something?   I think that SY still believe Madeleine is likely alive. 

Please convince me otherwise.

It's the Germans who have the concrete evidence and I don't see that their searches have failed. I believe SY back the Germans but like the McCanns will not accept death without proof. The Germans as yet haven't shared their concrete evidence.

I think both SY and the McCanns realise Maddie is probably dead

[Robittybob1]

You are wrong again...HCW said they have concrete evidence that Maddie is dead and that CB killed her.
I'm amazed how out of touch with the facts some are

Are you sure about that?  Specically, "and that CB killed her".

[Mr Gray]

Are you sure about that?  Specically, "and that CB killed her".

I'm almost certain ..yes..as I recall it was in the Australian documentary with HCW being interviewed by a blonde reporter..Myster hopefully has the link

[sadie]

Intelligence and inferences are two different things. In my opinion the German police have, at the moment, intelligence from which they  appear to have drawn inferences. They claim to have concrete evidence that Madeleine McCann is dead, but they admit they don't have the evidence needed to charge Brueckner with killing her.

From what we read the German police don't seem to have any concrete evidence.   But, maybe they are not prepared to share … as is, it appears, the case with SY.

If the German police have any factual substantial evidence, then why don't they go ahead and prosecute?



But please, please, don't allow them to mess up SY's findings and make a British prosecution unviable.

[Mr Gray]

From what we read the German police don't seem to have any concrete evidence.   But, maybe they are not prepared to share … as is, it appears, the case with SY.

If the German police have any factual substantial evidence, then why don't they go ahead and prosecute?



But please, please, don't allow them to mess up SY's findings and make a British prosecution unviable.

HCW has said clearly he has concrete evidence...I'm going to look for the cite

[Robittybob1]

I'm almost certain ..yes..as I recall it was in the Australian documentary with HCW being interviewed by a blonde reporter..Myster hopefully has the link

That is the "60 Minutes" documentary.  OK   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IXsXXxRek2Q

HCW: CB is Suspect "maybe" killing MM.   Not definite.  Repeat offender.  He lived there.  "Brutal rape" 2 years before. Videoed rape??
"Feeling a sense of power"
https://youtu.be/IXsXXxRek2Q?t=526  "strong evidence that the suspect killed her.."

[Mr Gray]

That is the "60 Minutes" documentary.  OK   https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IXsXXxRek2Q

Thanks Rob I had just found it...listen from 8.55..... I'm right

[Mr Gray]

You seem to be relying on the 'concrete evidence' quote, but leaving out what it was relating to. I was just reminding you it is related to the child's death, not to Brueckner's guilt.

I've just listened to it again...you are wrong. From HCW himself..in english...strong evidence that maddie is dead and that our suspect killed her..

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IXsXXxRek2Q&feature=youtu.be     at 8.55