Wandering Off Topic

[G-Unit]

It certainly appears this one did. Perhaps teh dogs really are intelligent and overheard the anthropologist using words such as human remains. Im not suggesting the dog lied because we all know dogs dont lie

Only in as much as he 'appears' to have alerted to clothing, shovels and spirit levels. 

[Venturi Swirl]

Pointing out that a cadaver dog is highly unlikely to alert to the scent of coconut isn't the same as insisting that dog alerts are always correct.

It's clear to me from your posts that in your opinion every alert Eddie ever made that wasn't corroborated by Keela was to cadaver odour, now tell me I am mistaken. 

[G-Unit]

It's clear to me that this discussion is never going to reach a conclusion. On the one hand are those who believe it's a fact that Eddie the VRD alerted to the scent of a coconut. On the other are those who believe that it can't be accepted as a fact for various reasons. I think it's time to stop now as opinions won't be changed on either side.

[Mr Gray]

Only in as much as he 'appears' to have alerted to clothing, shovels and spirit levels. 

To me its all conkers as opposed to coconuts. If there had been a cadaver in 5a...and it was hsndled by others.. Then that scent would have contaminated the whole apartment... Door handle.. Chairs... Everything that was touched... So I dont believe there was ever a cadaver in 5a. Just ss I dont believe amarals claims that eddie helped find a body under a slab of concrete in Jersey... All conkers

[Brietta]

It's clear to me that this discussion is never going to reach a conclusion. On the one hand are those who believe it's a fact that Eddie the VRD alerted to the scent of a coconut. On the other are those who believe that it can't be accepted as a fact for various reasons. I think it's time to stop now as opinions won't be changed on either side.

The discussion has reached a conclusion following the official inquiry carried out by the States of Jersey.
https://www.gov.je/Government/Pages/StatesReports.aspx?ReportID=421 
The fact it is unacceptable to you does not negate either the report or its conclusions.

[Venturi Swirl]

It's clear to me that this discussion is never going to reach a conclusion. On the one hand are those who believe it's a fact that Eddie the VRD alerted to the scent of a coconut. On the other are those who believe that it can't be accepted as a fact for various reasons. I think it's time to stop now as opinions won't be changed on either side.

Who has said he alerted to the scent of a coconut specifically?  Maybe he just alerted to nothing much in particular because he was bored and wanted to give internet bores something to ponder for years and years and years after the event.

[Venturi Swirl]

It's clear to me that this discussion is never going to reach a conclusion. On the one hand are those who believe it's a fact that Eddie the VRD alerted to the scent of a coconut. On the other are those who believe that it can't be accepted as a fact for various reasons. I think it's time to stop now as opinions won't be changed on either side.

Alternatively - on the one hand there are those who believe it's a fact that Eddie the VRD alerted to the scent of a cadaver.  On the other are those who believe that it can't be accepted as a fact for various reasons. 

[barrier]

Institutional corruption, institutionally racist , the Mighty MET.


Daniel Morgan: Met Police accused of 'institutional corruption' over 1987 unsolved axe murder of private detective

https://news.sky.com/story/daniel-morgan-met-police-accused-of-institutional-corruption-in-1987-unsolved-axe-murder-of-private-detective-12332406
Dick apologise which will make it better for the Morgan family.

Dame Cressida Dick said it is a "matter of great regret that no one has been brought to justice and that our mistakes have compounded the pain suffered by Daniel's family".

https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknews/met-police-chief-apologises-for-failings-in-murdered-private-detective-investigation/ar-AAL4mBn

Can she stay ?


Met chief censured for hampering corruption inquiry into investigation of 1987 death of private detective


https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/jun/15/daniel-morgan-met-chief-censured-for-hampering-corruption-inquiry

[Brietta]

Institutional corruption, institutionally racist , the Mighty MET.


Daniel Morgan: Met Police accused of 'institutional corruption' over 1987 unsolved axe murder of private detective

https://news.sky.com/story/daniel-morgan-met-police-accused-of-institutional-corruption-in-1987-unsolved-axe-murder-of-private-detective-12332406
Dick apologise which will make it better for the Morgan family.

Dame Cressida Dick said it is a "matter of great regret that no one has been brought to justice and that our mistakes have compounded the pain suffered by Daniel's family".

https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknews/met-police-chief-apologises-for-failings-in-murdered-private-detective-investigation/ar-AAL4mBn

Can she stay ?


Met chief censured for hampering corruption inquiry into investigation of 1987 death of private detective


https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/jun/15/daniel-morgan-met-chief-censured-for-hampering-corruption-inquiry

Actually - it would be well worth opening a special thread for corruption of all British police forces and the MET - there certainly seems to be enough interest and activity to keep it going for as long as it takes 😁

[barrier]

Actually - it would be well worth opening a special thread for corruption of all British police forces and the MET - there certainly seems to be enough interest and activity to keep it going for as long as it takes 😁

 Without fear or favour, you gonna guarantee it ?

[G-Unit]

Institutional corruption, institutionally racist , the Mighty MET.


Daniel Morgan: Met Police accused of 'institutional corruption' over 1987 unsolved axe murder of private detective

https://news.sky.com/story/daniel-morgan-met-police-accused-of-institutional-corruption-in-1987-unsolved-axe-murder-of-private-detective-12332406
Dick apologise which will make it better for the Morgan family.

Dame Cressida Dick said it is a "matter of great regret that no one has been brought to justice and that our mistakes have compounded the pain suffered by Daniel's family".

https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknews/met-police-chief-apologises-for-failings-in-murdered-private-detective-investigation/ar-AAL4mBn

Can she stay ?


Met chief censured for hampering corruption inquiry into investigation of 1987 death of private detective


https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2021/jun/15/daniel-morgan-met-chief-censured-for-hampering-corruption-inquiry

All organisations tend to take steps to protect their reputations, but when the organisation is a police force reputation protection must never be allowed to appear to be a cover up. It's a difficult path to tread.

[Brietta]

Without fear or favour, you gonna guarantee it ?

What on earth are you on about ~ set up a thread or don't ~ it's all one to me 😁

[Mr Gray]

It's clear to me that this discussion is never going to reach a conclusion. On the one hand are those who believe it's a fact that Eddie the VRD alerted to the scent of a coconut. On the other are those who believe that it can't be accepted as a fact for various reasons. I think it's time to stop now as opinions won't be changed on either side.

So what did Eddie alert to.. His supporters seem to want to claim now that the soil was contaminated with cadaver odour. So where did the contamination come from... Had a body been buried then removed as there were no remains found.... Or was it just a false alert, far more likely imo

[Venturi Swirl]

So what did Eddie alert to.. His supporters seem to want to claim now that the soil was contaminated with cadaver odour. So where did the contamination come from... Had a body been buried then removed as there were no remains found.... Or was it just a false alert, far more likely imo

I predict you won’t get a straight answer to this question, it’s already been asked several times before.  Eddie simply can’t be wrong, end of debate.

[Mr Gray]

I predict you won’t get a straight answer to this question, it’s already been asked several times before.  Eddie simply can’t be wrong, end of debate.

I think its Eddie cant be proved to be wrong.. I think hes wrong  quite a lot