Alleged Miscarriages of Justice > The kidnapping and shooting/murder of Anni Dewani while on her honeymoon in South Africa. Trial of Shrien Dewani was held in Cape Town, SA.
Dewani May Take The Stand In A British Court
Carbon Copy:
--- Quote from: Myster on August 30, 2015, 06:52:10 AM ---Uh-oh!!... time to switch into PTSD and severe depression mode again. 8(8-))
--- End quote ---
I don't think symptoms of PTSD and severe depression are the type of things that you can switch on and off at will.
Carbon Copy:
--- Quote from: Eleanor on August 30, 2015, 06:58:34 AM ---Well, since it appears that he can't be forced to answer questions, and the convicted parties won't be appearing, this seems a bit pointless.
We all know that she was murdered, but I don't think it is the place of an inquest to decide if an acquitted person is actually guilty.
I do feel sorry for her family, but I don't think he was guilty, on balance of what I read about the trial.
--- End quote ---
It does seem a bit pointless since the cause of death has already been determined as being a gunshot wound through the neck and the only other persons present were Xolile Mngeni and Mziwamadoda Qwabe. Mngeni died of brain cancer and Qwabe resides in a South African jail after having perjured himself at both trials he has testified at.
I also feel sorry for the family not least because they must be receiving some pretty questionable legal advice if they're pinning their hopes on the coroner somehow ruling anything different than the SA court.
Passer-by:
--- Quote from: Carbon Copy on August 31, 2015, 08:02:22 PM ---It does seem a bit pointless since the cause of death has already been determined as being a gunshot wound through the neck and the only other persons present were Xolile Mngeni and Mziwamadoda Qwabe. Mngeni died of brain cancer and Qwabe resides in a South African jail after having perjured himself at both trials he has testified at.
I also feel sorry for the family not least because they must be receiving some pretty questionable legal advice if they're pinning their hopes on the coroner somehow ruling anything different than the SA court.
--- End quote ---
It has nothing to do with her family: it's an administrative process carried out by the British Government.
dewanifacts:
--- Quote from: Passer-by on August 30, 2015, 01:03:43 PM ---This makes it a lot harder for Dewani to refuse to give evidence, as the only eye-witness to the crime, yet also maintain his innocence.
--- End quote ---
The statement above is wrong on so many levels.
Shrien Dewani was a victim of the crime not a witness. Even if one does not accept that Shrien Dewani was a victim, it is common cause fact that he was not present when Anni died, so he cannot possibly provide any answers as to the circumstances surrounding Qwabe shooting her.
The inquest promises to be of some interest, particularly if Shrien chooses to answer questions regarding why he didn't mention the helicopter or the money in his police statement, although I fear that those topics will be well beyond the scope of a coronial inquest and that such questions probably won't even be allowed to be asked let alone answered.
I predict that all we will see is Shrien Dewani repeat what he has already told the family and explained in his plea statement with regard to why they visited Gugulethu and how he exited the vehicle. These seem to be the two issues that concern the Hindocha family. The problem for them is that Shrien's explanation is entirely plausible and not contradicted by the objective evidence so the inquest will have no option but to accept it.
mercury:
--- Quote from: dewanifacts on September 01, 2015, 06:45:23 PM ---The statement above is wrong on so many levels.
Shrien Dewani was a victim of the crime not a witness. Even if one does not accept that Shrien Dewani was a victim, it is common cause fact that he was not present when Anni died, so he cannot possibly provide any answers as to the circumstances surrounding Qwabe shooting her.
The inquest promises to be of some interest, particularly if Shrien chooses to answer questions regarding why he didn't mention the helicopter or the money in his police statement, although I fear that those topics will be well beyond the scope of a coronial inquest and that such questions probably won't even be allowed to be asked let alone answered.
I predict that all we will see is Shrien Dewani repeat what he has already told the family and explained in his plea statement with regard to why they visited Gugulethu and how he exited the vehicle. These seem to be the two issues that concern the Hindocha family. The problem for them is that Shrien's explanation is entirely plausible and not contradicted by the objective evidence so the inquest will have no option but to accept it.
--- End quote ---
SD may not have "witnessed the actual shooting" but he certainly was a witness as far as most things go...he was there at the time though not at the specific time of death...if his testimony was not important it wouldn't be asked for surely
Navigation
[0] Message Index
[#] Next page
[*] Previous page
Go to full version