UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: carlymichelle on March 23, 2019, 10:27:13 PM

Title: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: carlymichelle on March 23, 2019, 10:27:13 PM
MCCANNS' LIBEL HELL Maddie McCann’s parents Kate and Gerry owe £29k libel bill to the Portuguese cop who accused them of killing their daughter

The Sun on Sunday has seen court files showing they have had to pay him £24,000 — and now another £5,500
Exclusive
From Gerard Couzens in Lisbon
23rd March 2019, 10:00 pm
Updated: 23rd March 2019, 10:00 pm

MADELEINE McCann’s parents have been hit with £29,500 in legal fees for the Portuguese cop who accused them of killing their child.


The Sun on Sunday has seen court files showing they have had to pay him £24,000 — and now they are about to be told to cough up another £5,500.

Madeleine vanished aged three from her bed during a family holiday in Praia da Luz, Portugal, in 2007.

In a 2008 book, Amaral claimed Kate and Gerry accidentally killed her and covered it up by pretending she had been abducted.

He overturned their initial damages victory over his book The Truth Of The Lie and the decision in his favour was also upheld by another court.

The extra £5,500 is to cover further costs being run up by his lawyers defending their final appeal to the European Court of Human Rights.

And the couple, both 51, of Rothley, Leics, face having to fork out even more if they lose again.

Our reporter was given permission by staff to view the huge legal dossier kept in an office at Lisbon Civil Court.

The court papers also show Amaral, 59, who has caused the parents fresh distress in a controversial new Netflix documentary, had huge debts when he wrote his book.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 23, 2019, 10:30:36 PM
MCCANNS' LIBEL HELL Maddie McCann’s parents Kate and Gerry owe £29k libel bill to the Portuguese cop who accused them of killing their daughter

The Sun on Sunday has seen court files showing they have had to pay him £24,000 — and now another £5,500
Exclusive
From Gerard Couzens in Lisbon
23rd March 2019, 10:00 pm
Updated: 23rd March 2019, 10:00 pm

MADELEINE McCann’s parents have been hit with £29,500 in legal fees for the Portuguese cop who accused them of killing their child.


The Sun on Sunday has seen court files showing they have had to pay him £24,000 — and now they are about to be told to cough up another £5,500.

Madeleine vanished aged three from her bed during a family holiday in Praia da Luz, Portugal, in 2007.

In a 2008 book, Amaral claimed Kate and Gerry accidentally killed her and covered it up by pretending she had been abducted.

He overturned their initial damages victory over his book The Truth Of The Lie and the decision in his favour was also upheld by another court.

The extra £5,500 is to cover further costs being run up by his lawyers defending their final appeal to the European Court of Human Rights.

And the couple, both 51, of Rothley, Leics, face having to fork out even more if they lose again.

Our reporter was given permission by staff to view the huge legal dossier kept in an office at Lisbon Civil Court.

The court papers also show Amaral, 59, who has caused the parents fresh distress in a controversial new Netflix documentary, had huge debts when he wrote his book.
Only £30k?  I thought the McCanns were going to be ruined??
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Brietta on March 23, 2019, 10:45:35 PM
Only £30k?  I thought the McCanns were going to be ruined??
Two questions arise ...
Snip
The court papers also show Amaral, 59, who has caused the parents fresh distress in a controversial new Netflix documentary, had huge debts when he wrote his book.

Did he clear those debts with the proceeds from his best seller? and ... the money raised to pay his legal fees ~ which charitable enterprise for children is set to benefit?
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 24, 2019, 11:30:09 AM
MCCANNS' LIBEL HELL Maddie McCann’s parents Kate and Gerry owe £29k libel bill to the Portuguese cop who accused them of killing their daughter

The Sun on Sunday has seen court files showing they have had to pay him £24,000 — and now another £5,500
Exclusive
From Gerard Couzens in Lisbon
23rd March 2019, 10:00 pm
Updated: 23rd March 2019, 10:00 pm

MADELEINE McCann’s parents have been hit with £29,500 in legal fees for the Portuguese cop who accused them of killing their child.


The Sun on Sunday has seen court files showing they have had to pay him £24,000 — and now they are about to be told to cough up another £5,500.

Madeleine vanished aged three from her bed during a family holiday in Praia da Luz, Portugal, in 2007.

In a 2008 book, Amaral claimed Kate and Gerry accidentally killed her and covered it up by pretending she had been abducted.

He overturned their initial damages victory over his book The Truth Of The Lie and the decision in his favour was also upheld by another court.

The extra £5,500 is to cover further costs being run up by his lawyers defending their final appeal to the European Court of Human Rights.

And the couple, both 51, of Rothley, Leics, face having to fork out even more if they lose again.

Our reporter was given permission by staff to view the huge legal dossier kept in an office at Lisbon Civil Court.

The court papers also show Amaral, 59, who has caused the parents fresh distress in a controversial new Netflix documentary, had huge debts when he wrote his book.

£24.000 for Amaral or for all the defendants I wonder?

Details of the £5.500 were not found in the court documents and they are nothing to do with Anaral. He isn't involved in the ECHR business, Portugal is.

Does the ECHR order people to pay anything to anyone if it rules against them? Perhaps they will have to reimburse Portugal's costs?
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 24, 2019, 11:36:26 AM
interesting mention of court costs for amarals lawyers re the ECHR case....whats that all about. I have always said that re the ECHR case it will be necessary for potugal to show taht amarals claims are reasonable
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 24, 2019, 11:37:05 AM
Only £30k?  I thought the McCanns were going to be ruined??

The Sun is nothing but a rumour mill. They said this six months ago, so where did they get those fihures?

MADDIE HUNT CRISIS Fund to find Madeline could be wiped out if McCanns lose £750k case
https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/7281872/madeline-mcann-fund-750k-case/
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 24, 2019, 11:50:34 AM
interesting mention of court costs for amarals lawyers re the ECHR case....whats that all about. I have always said that re the ECHR case it will be necessary for potugal to show taht amarals claims are reasonable

Why would Anaral's lawyers be preparing for a case he isn't involved in?
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: barrier on March 24, 2019, 12:03:41 PM
The mail.

https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6844055/McCann-parents-owe-thousands-legal-fees-libel-case.html

Quote
"Thirteen volumes of court files charting the ongoing battle the McCanns started after Amaral published in July 2008 - just three days after they were told they were no longer suspects - detail the cash settlements they have been forced into after their initial 2015 libel win was overturned by two higher Portuguese courts.

The 2,958 pages show Madeleine's parents had to pay £5,548 in costs to Truth of the Lie publishers Guerra e Paz despite its lawyer admitting to a miscalculation of nearly £1,800 in her initial estimate.

The files also show an error by Amaral's lawyer Miguel Cruz Rodriguez almost led to the McCanns paying Amaral around £1,800 more in costs than they had to".
Also.

Quote
"an appendix to the files - kept on a shelf in a seventh-floor office at the same Lisbon Civil Court which ordered Amaral to pay the McCanns £430,000 in 2015 before its first-round libel decision was overturned on appeal - also lays bare the ex-cop's dire financial position when he penned his controversial book.

Isabel Duarte applied to have his assets seized in June 2009 after lodging a claim for £1,000,000 in damages on behalf of the McCanns and their children.

But a financial probe revealed the £60,000 2700cc Jaguar car he drove was owned by a firm he set up four months after his book about Madeleine's death was published.

It also showed an Algarve home - registered in his then-wife Sofia's name - had liens totalling nearly £400,000 after the bank moved to repossess it following missed mortgage payments and Portuguese tax chiefs tried to recover a five-figure debt".
Along with

Quote
Amaral, 59, is waiting on a soon-to-come judgement from the European Court of Human Rights over the lengthy legal battle with the McCanns sparked by his hurtful 2008 book The Truth of The Lie before deciding whether to launch a compensation claim.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 24, 2019, 02:37:44 PM
Why would Anaral's lawyers be preparing for a case he isn't involved in?

He isn't preparing a case... But central Ti the ECHR case will be the validity of amarals accusations.... Based on other cases I have looked at... The ECHR will decide if amarals claims were reasonable... I think I already know the answer
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 24, 2019, 06:29:23 PM
An interesting  point is that if the mccanns get a favourable result in the ECHR and the book is still on sale.... Could they raise a new case against amaral fir defamation
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: jassi on March 24, 2019, 07:59:29 PM
Only £30k?  I thought the McCanns were going to be ruined??

Will they be able to use the fund or have to fork out from their own pocket?
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Robittybob1 on March 24, 2019, 08:20:11 PM
Will they be able to use the fund or have to fork out from their own pocket?
I vote they use the fund.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 24, 2019, 08:20:58 PM
Will they be able to use the fund or have to fork out from their own pocket?

why are you so concerned
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 24, 2019, 08:27:41 PM
Will they be able to use the fund or have to fork out from their own pocket?
They’ll pay it themselves, at 30 quid a month for thr next 100 months.   8(>((
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Angelo222 on March 24, 2019, 08:32:02 PM
MCCANNS' LIBEL HELL Maddie McCann’s parents Kate and Gerry owe £29k libel bill to the Portuguese cop who accused them of killing their daughter

The Sun on Sunday has seen court files showing they have had to pay him £24,000 — and now another £5,500
Exclusive
From Gerard Couzens in Lisbon
23rd March 2019, 10:00 pm
Updated: 23rd March 2019, 10:00 pm

MADELEINE McCann’s parents have been hit with £29,500 in legal fees for the Portuguese cop who accused them of killing their child.


The Sun on Sunday has seen court files showing they have had to pay him £24,000 — and now they are about to be told to cough up another £5,500.

Madeleine vanished aged three from her bed during a family holiday in Praia da Luz, Portugal, in 2007.

In a 2008 book, Amaral claimed Kate and Gerry accidentally killed her and covered it up by pretending she had been abducted.

He overturned their initial damages victory over his book The Truth Of The Lie and the decision in his favour was also upheld by another court.

The extra £5,500 is to cover further costs being run up by his lawyers defending their final appeal to the European Court of Human Rights.

And the couple, both 51, of Rothley, Leics, face having to fork out even more if they lose again.

Our reporter was given permission by staff to view the huge legal dossier kept in an office at Lisbon Civil Court.

The court papers also show Amaral, 59, who has caused the parents fresh distress in a controversial new Netflix documentary, had huge debts when he wrote his book.

Once the ECHR case ends Amaral will be free to sue for damages.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 24, 2019, 08:33:44 PM
Once the ECHR case ends Amaral will be free to sue for damages.

not if he loses...as i think...based on the cases ive seen...he will...and hes free to sue for damages now...whats stopping him
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 24, 2019, 09:11:20 PM
He isn't preparing a case... But central Ti the ECHR case will be the validity of amarals accusations.... Based on other cases I have looked at... The ECHR will decide if amarals claims were reasonable... I think I already know the answer

"The extra £5,500 is to cover further costs being run up by his lawyers defending their final appeal to the European Court of Human Rights."

1. Anaral isn't preparing a defence because he isn't involved. The defendant is the state of Portugal.
2. Even if he was involved no-one can claim costs in advance of a ruling.

How much did the McCann's have to pay the other three dfendants? The journalists either forgot to look or didn't realise there were more defendants I assume.

Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 24, 2019, 09:15:00 PM
"The extra £5,500 is to cover further costs being run up by his lawyers defending their final appeal to the European Court of Human Rights."

1. Anaral isn't preparing a defence because he isn't involved. The defendant is the state of Portugal.
2. Even if he was involved no-one can claim costs in advance of a ruling.

How much did the McCann's have to pay the other three dfendants? The journalists either forgot to look or didn't realise there were more defendants I assume.

The Portuguese state will need an understanding of the basis of amarals claims... Who is in a position to supply the evidence needed
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: misty on March 24, 2019, 09:39:41 PM
Once the ECHR case ends Amaral will be free to sue for damages.

Damages for what?
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Angelo222 on March 24, 2019, 10:01:07 PM
Damages for what?

The McCanns attempted to destroy Amaral in order to protect their own tattered reputation.  Their agents involved themselves in criminal conduct in an attempt to undermine him and take him down, remember "the target has been hit" remark?  I think Amaral will have an extremely good civil case against the McC's and their crooked agents.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: misty on March 24, 2019, 10:12:02 PM
The McCanns attempted to destroy Amaral in order to protect their own tattered reputation.  Their agents involved themselves in criminal conduct in an attempt to undermine him and take him down, remember "the target has been hit" remark?  I think Amaral will have an extremely good civil case against the McC's and their crooked agents.

Isn't there a time limit on most civil claims - rather shorter than the 11 years since his "destruction"? Hasn't he also already taken action against Correia - and lost?
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 24, 2019, 10:13:25 PM
The McCanns attempted to destroy Amaral in order to protect their own tattered reputation.  Their agents involved themselves in criminal conduct in an attempt to undermine him and take him down, remember "the target has been hit" remark?  I think Amaral will have an extremely good civil case against the McC's and their crooked agents.
Cloud cuckoo land.  IMO.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 24, 2019, 11:10:35 PM
The Portuguese state will need an understanding of the basis of amarals claims... Who is in a position to supply the evidence needed

If Amaral's lawyer did work for the state of Portugal in preparation for their defence to the ECHR the state of Portugal are the ones who must pay him.

Costs are only allocated after a case ends. If the McCanns have been ordered to pay costs associated with the ECHR case then the case is over and they are having to reimburse Portugal's costs imo. 
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: misty on March 24, 2019, 11:28:43 PM
If Amaral's lawyer did work for the state of Portugal in preparation for their defence to the ECHR the state of Portugal are the ones who must pay him.

Costs are only allocated after a case ends. If the McCanns have been ordered to pay costs associated with the ECHR case then the case is over and they are having to reimburse Portugal's costs imo.

The McCanns only have to pay their own legal fees in an application to the ECHR. Even if they lose, they will not be responsible for the costs of the respondent state.
https://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/Questions_Answers_ENG.pdf  (pages 8 & 9).
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Angelo222 on March 24, 2019, 11:45:45 PM
Cloud cuckoo land.  IMO.

I'm sure you and they would wish that to be the case but it won't go away.  Patrick Kennedy admitted on the Netflix Documentary that what he and M3 engaged in was illegal.  I'm surprised they haven't already been arrested.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 24, 2019, 11:57:59 PM
I'm sure you and they would wish that to be the case but it won't go away.  Patrick Kennedy admitted on the Netflix Documentary that what he and M3 engaged in was illegal.  I'm surprised they haven't already been arrested.
Arrested by whom?
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 25, 2019, 10:02:25 AM
The McCanns only have to pay their own legal fees in an application to the ECHR. Even if they lose, they will not be responsible for the costs of the respondent state.
https://www.echr.coe.int/Documents/Questions_Answers_ENG.pdf  (pages 8 & 9).

So whatever that £5,500 was for, it was nothing to do with the ECHR.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Angelo222 on March 25, 2019, 12:19:57 PM
Arrested by whom?

By the PJ of course as it was their jurisdiction.  I wouldn't hold my breath on SY doing anything useful in that respect as it would be extremely embarrassing for them.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 25, 2019, 05:21:33 PM
So whatever that £5,500 was for, it was nothing to do with the ECHR.

The Mail Online says;

The McCanns have paid Amaral approx £24,000 .
Another bill for £5.346 is pending.
There will be a further bill for £5,148 connected to the SC hearing.
They paid Guerra e Paz £5,548 for their costs.

It seems that Duarte appealed and got some of the bills reduced. Whether they are all in remains to be seen. The other two defendants haven't been mentioned yet, nor have any expense claims, just lawyer's fees.

The Mail's account makes more sense than The Sun's imo.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6844055/McCann-parents-owe-thousands-legal-fees-libel-case.html
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: jassi on March 25, 2019, 05:26:11 PM
The Mail Online says;

The McCanns have paid Amaral approx £24,000 .
Another bill for £5.346 is pending.
There will be a further bill for £5,148 connected to the SC hearing.
They paid Guerra e Paz £5,548 for their costs.

It seems that Duarte appealed and got some of the bills reduced. Whether they are all in remains to be seen. The other two defendants haven't been mentioned yet, nor have any expense claims, just lawyer's fees.

The Mail's account makes more sense than The Sun's imo.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6844055/McCann-parents-owe-thousands-legal-fees-libel-case.html


Any mention of how much Duarte has cost them?
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 25, 2019, 05:54:14 PM

Any mention of how much Duarte has cost them?

No, but there was £50,000 mentioned in the accounts for Y/E 2017. It wasn't clear if that was all owed to Duarte, however. Sje's still racking up costs, clearly because she''s the one the court is communicating with.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 25, 2019, 05:56:36 PM
No, but there was £50,000 mentioned in the accounts for Y/E 2017. It wasn't clear if that was all owed to Duarte, however. Sje's still racking up costs, clearly because she''s the one the court is communicating with.

If they wish to use it I would say the McCanns have massive earning potential
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 25, 2019, 07:20:23 PM
If they wish to use it I would say the McCanns have massive earning potential

Only if they agreed to answer any questions put to them. No one is going to pay big bucks for anything less imo.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 25, 2019, 10:32:00 PM
Only if they agreed to answer any questions put to them. No one is going to pay big bucks for anything less imo.
You don’t think an authorised McCann documentary featuring interviews with them and all their friends and family would have any commercial appeal then?
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: ShiningInLuz on March 26, 2019, 12:14:01 AM
You don’t think an authorised McCann documentary featuring interviews with them and all their friends and family would have any commercial appeal then?

Haven't they just declined such an 'opportunity'?  No to Netflix?   &^^&*
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Robittybob1 on March 26, 2019, 01:35:04 AM
You don’t think an authorised McCann documentary featuring interviews with them and all their friends and family would have any commercial appeal then?
That would be interesting.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Brietta on March 26, 2019, 01:39:28 AM
Haven't they just declined such an 'opportunity'?  No to Netflix?   &^^&*
No ... they most certainly declined nothing of the sort.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 26, 2019, 07:18:07 AM
Haven't they just declined such an 'opportunity'?  No to Netflix?   &^^&*
That was not an authorised McCann documentary and not what I was describing.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 26, 2019, 07:51:16 AM
That was not an authorised McCann documentary and not what I was describing.
I think netfix and their non participation  will have increased their value...they dont seem to want to take advantage of it so presumably they dont need to
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 26, 2019, 08:00:36 AM
d
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 26, 2019, 08:02:17 AM
That was not an authorised McCann documentary and not what I was describing.

It certainly wasn't. That's  why it was interesting. The McCanns will offer nothing new, and therefore have nothing new to say. They can't do anything while Op Grange continues anyway.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 26, 2019, 08:02:37 AM
I think netfix and their non participation  will have increased their value...they dont seem to want to take advantage of it so presumably they dont need to
I’ve read some nutty conspiracy theories elsewhere that the McCanns were secretly behind the Netflix documentary, and actually financed it.... (&^&
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 26, 2019, 08:21:38 AM
It certainly wasn't. That's  why it was interesting. The McCanns will offer nothing new, and therefore have nothing new to say. They can't do anything while Op Grange continues anyway.
How do you know they will have nothing new to say?  We’ve hardly heard Gerry’s in depth side of the story at all.  They could go to town on how badly they were treated by Amaral and his cronies for example.  They could do a whole programme on the bizarre world of the online trolls role in this case.  I’d watch that.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 26, 2019, 08:54:31 AM
How do you know they will have nothing new to say?  We’ve hardly heard Gerry’s in depth side of the story at all.  They could go to town on how badly they were treated by Amaral and his cronies for example.  They could do a whole programme on the bizarre world of the online trolls role in this case.  I’d watch that.

That just sounds like more complaining to me.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: jassi on March 26, 2019, 08:59:43 AM
How do you know they will have nothing new to say?  We’ve hardly heard Gerry’s in depth side of the story at all.  They could go to town on how badly they were treated by Amaral and his cronies for example.  They could do a whole programme on the bizarre world of the online trolls role in this case.  I’d watch that.

Yeah, it could be like one of these foody programs 'Whining & Dining with the McCanns', held at the bottom of their garden, of course.   @)(++(*
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Eleanor on March 26, 2019, 09:09:56 AM
Yeah, it could be like one of these foody programs 'Whining & Dining with the McCanns', held at the bottom of their garden, of course.   @)(++(*

A spurious  comment if ever I saw one.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 26, 2019, 10:57:38 AM
The Mail Online says;

The McCanns have paid Amaral approx £24,000 .
Another bill for £5.346 is pending.
There will be a further bill for £5,148 connected to the SC hearing.
They paid Guerra e Paz £5,548 for their costs.

It seems that Duarte appealed and got some of the bills reduced. Whether they are all in remains to be seen. The other two defendants haven't been mentioned yet, nor have any expense claims, just lawyer's fees.

The Mail's account makes more sense than The Sun's imo.
https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-6844055/McCann-parents-owe-thousands-legal-fees-libel-case.html

So the total so far is approx £35,000 not including their own legal fees which seem to be more expensive than anyone else's. Other bills may follow but for what? Two more defendants will have to be paid and possibly sone expenses claims. Where did the rumour of the Fund being wiped out come from, I wonder?

Compensation has been mentioned but the only way they will have to pay that is in connection with the freezing injunction in my opinion. I don't know about Portugal but these injunctions often include a compensation clause in the UK. That makes sense if  an innocent person's assets are frozen for years. It woulld be unfair not to compensate them imo.

Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Eleanor on March 26, 2019, 10:59:41 AM
So the total so far is approx £35,000 not including their own legal fees which seem to be more expensive than anyone else's. Other bills may follow but for what? Two more defendants will have to be paid and possibly sone expenses claims. Where did the rumour of the Fund being wiped out come from, I wonder?

Compensation has been mentioned but the only way they will have to pay that is in connection with the freezing injunction in my opinion. I don't know about Portugal but these injunctions often include a compensation clause in the UK. That makes sense if  an innocent person's assets are frozen for years. It woulld be unfair not to compensate them imo.

Amaral still owes other people and Institutions.  Nothing to do with The McCanns.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: jassi on March 26, 2019, 11:20:17 AM
Amaral still owes other people and Institutions.  Nothing to do with The McCanns.

So not really relevant to this discussion.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 26, 2019, 11:22:17 AM
So not really relevant to this discussion.

It is if his assets, are frozen due to other debts
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Brietta on March 26, 2019, 02:23:42 PM
I think netfix and their non participation  will have increased their value...they dont seem to want to take advantage of it so presumably they dont need to

Exactly.

I think what is omitted from some people's thought process is the fact that Madeleine's parents know what is going on in the police investigation into Madeleine's disappearance ... and no doubt are privy to information that Netflix and podcasts can only dream of.

They have requested restraint from the media ...
“Please be patient and respect the work of the police as they endeavour to find the answers we so desperately need.
“In particular we request that the media consider carefully Madeleine’s safety and the integrity of the investigation in their reporting.”

  ... which I think would make it inappropriate for them to cooperate with commercial enterprises on both counts.


“We are in regular contact with [her parents] Kate and Gerry McCann and they are kept fully updated on the progress of our work. We also continue to work closely with the Portuguese police and are actively considering our next steps.”
http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/home-office-to-fund-new-met-operation-into-madeleine-mccann-disappearance-8660084.html

Detective chief inspector Andy Redwood, who is leading the Scotland Yard team, assistant commissioner Mark Rowley, and Mr and Mrs McCann met officers in Lisbon last week to be briefed on the Portuguese case.
https://www.irishtimes.com/news/world/europe/portuguese-police-reopen-madeleine-mccann-investigation-1.1571864



Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 26, 2019, 02:48:37 PM
I'll believe pigs can fly before I'll believe any police investigation, a professional one that is, would let two former suspects who have never been cleared in any case know everything that's going on.. That's not to say you might be right but it will take more than a few quotes from that little bunch to make me believe it.

I would say that as SY do not see them as suspects they will be privy to details we are not
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 26, 2019, 03:06:50 PM
It is if his assets, are frozen due to other debts

His assets were frozen by an injunction issued at the request of the McCanns, no one else.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Brietta on March 26, 2019, 03:07:36 PM
I’ve read some nutty conspiracy theories elsewhere that the McCanns were secretly behind the Netflix documentary, and actually financed it.... (&^&

Obviously Netflix must have disagreed with favourite conspiracy theories and shown them up for the trash they are 
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 26, 2019, 03:12:24 PM
His assets were frozen by an injunction issued at the request of the McCanns, no one else.

Can you provide a cite that no other person or body has a charge against his assets... Otherwise you are stating opinion... Not fact
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Brietta on March 26, 2019, 03:23:39 PM
I'll believe pigs can fly before I'll believe any police investigation, a professional one that is, would let two former suspects who have never been cleared in any case know everything that's going on.. That's not to say you might be right but it will take more than a few quotes from that little bunch to make me believe it.

Did I hit a nerve there, cheeky?
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Eleanor on March 26, 2019, 03:24:17 PM
So not really relevant to this discussion.

It is if anyone is blaming The McCanns for freezing Amaral's money.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Eleanor on March 26, 2019, 03:26:55 PM
They certainly showed Metodo 3's conspiracy theory up for what that was.
https://www.dailystar.co.uk/news/latest-news/766251/madeleine-mccann-disappearance-maddie-belgian-gang-bought-netflix-documentary

If it aint one trashy conspiracy theory, it's another.

Look no further than CMoMM for those.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Brietta on March 26, 2019, 03:46:48 PM
His assets were frozen by an injunction issued at the request of the McCanns, no one else.

You are wrong.

Amaral's property dealings ... for which his brother took successful legal action against him ... led to the dire state of his finances long before the McCanns took the fateful decision to take their children on holiday to Portugal.

The McCanns had nothing at all to do with his tax debts which saw a third of his pension going in payback.

They had absolutely nothing at all to do with the financial morass he had got himself into in the years leading up to and including the year of Madeleine's disappearance.

https://expresso.pt/arquivo/tribunal-fica-com-jaguar-de-goncalo-amaral=f544234#gs.33h0qt
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Eleanor on March 26, 2019, 03:55:30 PM
You are wrong.

Amaral's property dealings ... for which his brother took court successful action against him ... led to the dire state of his finances long before the McCanns took the fateful decision to take their children on holiday to Portugal.

The McCanns had nothing at all to do with his tax debts which saw a third of his pension going in payback.

They had absolutely nothing at all to do with the financial morass he had got himself into in the years leading up to and including the year of Madeleine's disappearance.

  • However, according to the assessment made by the court, the estate of Gonçalo Amaral does not provide sufficient guarantees for payment in case of conviction. Olhão's house - which she bought with her wife in 2002 with a loan from the BIC but is registered only in her name - was arrested in 2005 due to a debt of around 130 thousand euros.
  • A year later (2006), the National Treasury registered an attachment on the house as guarantee of payment of 16900 euros. Finally, two years ago (2007), it was BES (to which BIC belongs now) to file an executive action against the couple to collect more than 300,000 euros - a new attachment.
https://expresso.pt/arquivo/tribunal-fica-com-jaguar-de-goncalo-amaral=f544234#gs.33h0qt

Absolutely Correct.  And Amaral made no attempt to pay any of these debts during the year when he did have access to The Book Money.

And he bought The Jaguar in the name of a Company.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 26, 2019, 04:05:01 PM
Can you provide a cite that no other person or body has a charge against his assets... Otherwise you are stating opinion... Not fact

I thought charges against assets applied to company debts, not individual ones.

A second injunction [by the McCaans] succeeded in freezing Dr. Amaral's assets and income, denying him the opportunity to defend himself in court.
http://pjga.blogspot.com/2016/04/statement_26.html
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 26, 2019, 04:08:32 PM
I thought charges against assets applied to company debts, not individual ones.

A second injunction [by the McCaans] succeeded in freezing Dr. Amaral's assets and income, denying him the opportunity to defend himself in court.
http://pjga.blogspot.com/2016/04/statement_26.html

No... Charges can be made against assets for individual... Personal.. Liability... Not sure how much we can trust the pjga blogspot on this... If.. As it looks like... Others had charges on his, assets.. And still do... Then I don't see he has any claim against the mccanns
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 26, 2019, 05:59:23 PM
That just sounds like more complaining to me.
You’d watch it though.  Avidly. IMO.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 26, 2019, 06:01:48 PM
All those trashy conspiracy theories hit a nerve with me, especially the ones that concern an abduction.
I'm sticking with Portuguese theory; type of crime; unknown.
LOL.  Not much of a theory that is it?
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 26, 2019, 08:03:11 PM
No... Charges can be made against assets for individual... Personal.. Liability... Not sure how much we can trust the pjga blogspot on this... If.. As it looks like... Others had charges on his, assets.. And still do... Then I don't see he has any claim against the mccanns

I'm discussing freezing injunctions imposed by the courts to ensure funds are available for a future award by the courts. You seem to be speaking about measures taken to ensure oayment of previously existing debts. Those measures don't include freeing bank accounts afaik. 
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: The General on March 26, 2019, 08:04:44 PM
LOL.  Not much of a theory that is it?
I think you'll find there's plenty of people who believe in the abduction theory.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 26, 2019, 08:09:55 PM
I'm discussing freezing injunctions imposed by the courts to ensure funds are available for a future award by the courts. You seem to be speaking about measures taken to ensure oayment of previously existing debts. Those measures don't include freeing bank accounts afaik.

do you have any details of this injunction......or just unverified gossip from the net...
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: The General on March 26, 2019, 08:11:57 PM
do you have any details of this injunction......or just unverified gossip from the net...
You do know this is the internet you're on right now, davel?
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 26, 2019, 08:14:52 PM
You do know this is the internet you're on right now, davel?

the internet is an absolutely wonderful source of facts and knowledge...the skill is sorting the wheat from the chaff....its a skill ...many science degrees teach it.....I use these skills almost every day....Im pretty good at it...so good people who dont understand call me pedantic
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 26, 2019, 08:33:57 PM
OK, it might not be as theatrical as the whooshing curtain theory on Youtube, but the unknown crime theory is the one I'm sticking with. You just let me know when it's proved wrong.

has abduction by aliens from a galaxy far away been proved wrong...let me know when it is
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 26, 2019, 08:59:35 PM
OK, it might not be as theatrical as the whooshing curtain theory on Youtube, but the unknown crime theory is the one I'm sticking with. You just let me know when it's proved wrong.
”I don’t know what happened” is not a theory, it’s a fact.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 26, 2019, 11:04:22 PM
Gerry and Kate don't know what happened, but they've still produced an abduction theory. That's a fact too.
I'll stick with the unknown crime theory. That IS a theory that predicts the type of crime will always remain unknown. You let me know when that theory is proved wrong.
The whole idea of a theory is that you don’t have the full facts, don’t know for certain but put forward a logical plausible explanation of what happened.  There “I don’t know what happened” is not a theory.  It’s just an admission.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Brietta on March 26, 2019, 11:36:44 PM
The whole idea of a theory is that you don’t have the full facts, don’t know for certain but put forward a logical plausible explanation of what happened.  There “I don’t know what happened” is not a theory.  It’s just an admission.
I see it as an admission of failure.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on March 27, 2019, 12:01:38 AM
Of course "I don't know what happened" isn't a theory. That's cuckoo. That has nothing to do with my unknown crime theory.
I have read the files, I DO KNOW WHAT HAPPENED. The prosecutor listed the type of crime as unknown. That's a fact. Like you say it may not be the full facts but I have that fact in support of my theory. I also have the facts that the crime is being investigated and remains unsolved and based on those facts I have a theory that predicts (as all theories do) the case will be closed and the type of crime will be continue to be listed as unknown. Hence my unproven at the moment 'unknown crime theory'. It's a theory OK supported without the full facts, but with facts nevertheless.
Should any of those predictions be proven to be wrong then my theory will be dust.. I know it remains to proven. So you be sure to let me know when and if any of those predictions based on the facts I've listed prove my theory wrong.

You can take your so called "I don't know what happened" nonsense and flush it down the pan. Because I do know what happened when the prosecutor wrote his report. "Type of crime; unknown."
Then we are talking at cross purposes - you are giving a theory about the outcome of the investigation but we were discussing a theory about what happened on the night of the 3rd I thought. 
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 27, 2019, 10:33:22 AM
You are wrong.

Amaral's property dealings ... for which his brother took successful legal action against him ... led to the dire state of his finances long before the McCanns took the fateful decision to take their children on holiday to Portugal.

The McCanns had nothing at all to do with his tax debts which saw a third of his pension going in payback.

They had absolutely nothing at all to do with the financial morass he had got himself into in the years leading up to and including the year of Madeleine's disappearance.

  • However, according to the assessment made by the court, the estate of Gonçalo Amaral does not provide sufficient guarantees for payment in case of conviction. Olhão's house - which she bought with her wife in 2002 with a loan from the BIC but is registered only in her name - was arrested in 2005 due to a debt of around 130 thousand euros.
  • A year later (2006), the National Treasury registered an attachment on the house as guarantee of payment of 16900 euros. Finally, two years ago (2007), it was BES (to which BIC belongs now) to file an executive action against the couple to collect more than 300,000 euros - a new attachment.
https://expresso.pt/arquivo/tribunal-fica-com-jaguar-de-goncalo-amaral=f544234#gs.33h0qt

Amaral was indeed in debt. That's why the court granted the freezing injunction so there would be money for the McCanns if they won their case. Not that it was about money of course.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 27, 2019, 10:47:48 AM
Amaral was indeed in debt. That's why the court granted the freezing injunction so there would be money for the McCanns if they won their case. Not that it was about money of course.
Do you have a cite for this... If all his assets had charges against them.... Did he have any assets to freeze
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 27, 2019, 12:27:40 PM
Do you have a cite for this... If all his assets had charges against them.... Did he have any assets to freeze

It's not long ago that someone informed me that according to another forum Amaral's assets remained frozen, which suggests that they had indeed been frozen. In my opinion a charge on assets safeguards payment of an existing debt. A freezing order safeguards a future debt.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 27, 2019, 12:34:48 PM
It's not long ago that someone informed me that according to another forum Amaral's assets remained frozen, which suggests that they had indeed been frozen. In my opinion a charge on assets safeguards payment of an existing debt. A freezing order safeguards a future debt.

So still no cite that the mccanns froze amarals assets
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 27, 2019, 12:45:54 PM
So still no cite that the mccanns froze amarals assets

I gave a cite.
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 27, 2019, 12:56:46 PM
I gave a cite.
Amarals supporters blog is not a reliable cite... So as yet no confirmation
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 27, 2019, 01:18:16 PM
Amarals supporters blog is not a reliable cite... So as yet no confirmation

Please yourself. It's been an accepted fact for years..

Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: Mr Gray on March 27, 2019, 01:39:11 PM
Please yourself. It's been an accepted fact for years..

accepted by some based on no real evidnce...so what does taht say about those who acceot it as a fact...at least now you accept that is no real independent evidence for your claim
Title: Re: McCanns hit with Portuguese legal bill for nearly £30k for failed damages case.
Post by: G-Unit on March 27, 2019, 02:13:46 PM
accepted by some based on no real evidnce...so what does taht say about those who acceot it as a fact...at least now you accept that is no real independent evidence for your claim

We shall see.