UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: pathfinder73 on March 31, 2019, 11:38:49 AM
-
4 May 2007
QUALMS ABOUT INVESTIGATING THE McCANNS
Someone puts forward the hypothesis according to which Madeleine would have died in her apartment, and that a member of the group would have removed her. It’s a possibility, but nothing so far, no evidence, happens to support that theory.
The McCanns are put up with David Payne. We want to search the accommodation of the family friends to try to pick up Madeleine’s clothes, especially those she was wearing on May 3rd at 5.35pm when she returned from the day centre with her mother and the twins. Evidently, this initiative is not widely supported. The British ambassador meets with the team directing the investigation. The political and the diplomatic seem to want to prevent us from freely doing our work.
– I’m sure this check is necessary.
– The clothes? Are you mad? if I understand you properly, you want to go into the apartment to take clothes to have them analysed?
– Yes. What’s the problem? It’s a perfectly normal procedure in cases like this.
– Of course, but with this media hype…I don’t think I have ever in my life seen so many journalists….And I didn’t come down in the last shower. (TOTL by Goncalo Amaral - Criminal Investigation Coordinator)
That suggests that John Buck prevented the Portuguese police from freely doing their work on investigating the family who are usually first suspects in these cases. Your thoughts?
-
Is Amaral suggesting the street clothes worn by Madeleine on Thursday afternoon could hold clues?
Nannies.
Staff where the high tea was taken.
Staff involved in the beach event.
Other people who might have played with her that afternoon, parents other kids at the day creche. We might finally know who was in the group of 6 kids that went sailing on Thursday.
Were there 6 kids at Creche that Thursday in the morning or the afternoon?
-
John Buck - British Ambassador in Portugal in May 2006 - resigns his post on 10 September 2007 - shortly after the McCanns are made suspects
4 May 2007
QUALMS ABOUT INVESTIGATING THE McCANNS
Someone puts forward the hypothesis according to which Madeleine would have died in her apartment, and that a member of the group would have removed her. It’s a possibility, but nothing so far, no evidence, happens to support that theory.
The McCanns are put up with David Payne. We want to search the accommodation of the family friends to try to pick up Madeleine’s clothes, especially those she was wearing on May 3rd at 5.35pm when she returned from the day centre with her mother and the twins. Evidently, this initiative is not widely supported. The British ambassador meets with the team directing the investigation. The political and the diplomatic seem to want to prevent us from freely doing our work.
– I’m sure this check is necessary.
– The clothes? Are you mad? if I understand you properly, you want to go into the apartment to take clothes to have them analysed?
– Yes. What’s the problem? It’s a perfectly normal procedure in cases like this.
– Of course, but with this media hype…I don’t think I have ever in my life seen so many journalists….And I didn’t come down in the last shower. (TOTL by Goncalo Amaral - Criminal Investigation Coordinator)
That suggests that John Buck prevented the Portuguese police from freely doing their work on investigating the family who are usually first suspects in these cases. Your thoughts?
What has John Buck got to do with it?
It suggests to me that Amaral was being a bit creative with the truth as to why they weren't taken by forensics, who were, after all, there that night and the next day.
-
What has John Buck got to do with it?
It suggests to me that Amaral was being a bit creative with the truth as to why they weren't taken by forensics, who were, after all, there that night and the next day.
It certainly wasn't normal procedure for an Ambassador to be involved, especially at such an early stage. It has never been explained why he felt the need to travel from Lisbon so early on.. The child could have been found at any moment, making his journey superfluous.
-
It certainly wasn't normal procedure for an Ambassador to be involved, especially at such an early stage. It has never been explained why he felt the need to travel from Lisbon so early on.. The child could have been found at any moment, making his journey superfluous.
Perhaps he’s in on it?
-
It certainly wasn't normal procedure for an Ambassador to be involved, especially at such an early stage. It has never been explained why he felt the need to travel from Lisbon so early on.. The child could have been found at any moment, making his journey superfluous.
Do you have an opinion as to why normal procedure was not followed by the Ambassador in this instance?
-
It happened. Seems little point in speculating on the reason why - IMO
-
It happened. Seems little point in speculating on the reason why - IMO
Speculation abounds on various aspects of Madeleine's disappearance.
Why not on this aspect?
It has been raised as abnormal behaviour for an Ambassador.
Do you have an opinion why not this case an Ambassador became involved?
-
Speculation abounds on various aspects of Madeleine's disappearance.
Why not on this aspect?
It has been raised as abnormal behaviour for an Ambassador.
Do you have an opinion why not this case an Ambassador became involved?
Leonor Cipriano?
-
Speculation abounds on various aspects of Madeleine's disappearance.
Why not on this aspect?
It has been raised as abnormal behaviour for an Ambassador.
Do you have an opinion why not this case an Ambassador became involved?
None at all. but don't let me stop you from speculation ?{)(**
-
None at all. but don't let me stop you from speculation ?{)(**
I didn't realise that the Ambassador's early intervention was far from the norm.
So I've no need to speculate.
-
He interfered by stopping the police from visiting the McCanns to carry out their investigations. Buck is not a detective so he should not have obstructed their work. His behaviour was unacceptable.
-
He interfered by stopping the police from visiting the McCanns to carry out their investigations. Buck is not a detective so he should not have obstructed their work. His behaviour was unacceptable and he resigned when the McCanns were made suspects.
I wonder if he caught the same flight home @)(++(*
In Your Opinion. Unless you have a Cite. If not then I will delete your comment.
-
The cite is in my opening post lol.
Ambassador Buck was interviewed by the Leicester Mercury. Quote: "As you know, I spent quite a lot of time with the McCann family on Friday and over the weekend. "I wanted to come down today to see Kate and Gerry again and to continue to support our consular staff, who have been working on this for a number of days."
For enquiries or bookings for John Buck please call us on +44 (0)203 002 4125 or use our contact form
http://www.specialistspeakers.com/?p=6615
Alexander Wykeham Ellis was appointed as Her Majesty’s Ambassador to the Portuguese Republic on October 10, 2007, replacing John Buck.
https://www.portugalresident.com/2010/11/26/british-ambassador-to-leave-portugal/
On September 21, newly-arrived British Ambassador
Alexander Wykeham Ellis informed Ambassador Hoffman that
European concerns over Russia's aggressive energy policies
and the need for market competition were the driving forces
behind the third EU energy liberalization package. He
suggested that Russia's position with its neighbors was
guided by a self-proclaimed right to do "what it wants, when
it wants" in its own neighborhood. Regarding Robert Mugabe's
participation in the proposed EU-Africa Summit, Ellis said
the UK would not discourage other member states from
participating if PM Brown stayed away. He doubted, however,
if the Dutch, Irish, or Swedish would attend in Brown's
absence. Ellis also noted that it was the British police that
developed the current evidence against Madeleine McCann's
parents in the high-profile case that has captured
international attention. He informed the Ambassador that
former British Ambassador John Buck had accepted a
private-sector position at a UK gas company and that his
departure had nothing to do with bilateral issues. END SUMMARY
THE MADELEINE MCCANN CASE
-------------------------
5. (C) Madeleine McCann's disappearance in the south of
Portugal in May 2007 has generated international media
attention with controversy surrounding the Portuguese-led
police investigation and the actions of Madeleine's parents.
Without delving into the details of the case, Ellis admitted
that the British police had developed the current evidence
against the McCann parents, and he stressed that authorities
from both countries were working cooperatively. He commented
that the media frenzy was to be expected and was acceptable
as long as government officials keep their comments behind
closed doors.
https://wikileaks.org/plusd/cables/07LISBON2527_a.html
-
Do you have an opinion as to why normal procedure was not followed by the Ambassador in this instance?
No I don't.
-
The cite is in my opening post lol.
Ambassador Buck was interviewed by the Leicester Mercury. Quote: "As you know, I spent quite a lot of time with the McCann family on Friday and over the weekend. "I wanted to come down today to see Kate and Gerry again and to continue to support our consular staff, who have been working on this for a number of days."
For enquiries or bookings for John Buck please call us on +44 (0)203 002 4125 or use our contact form
http://www.specialistspeakers.com/?p=6615
Alexander Wykeham Ellis was appointed as Her Majesty’s Ambassador to the Portuguese Republic on October 10, 2007, replacing John Buck.
https://www.portugalresident.com/2010/11/26/british-ambassador-to-leave-portugal/
"That suggests that John Buck prevented the Portuguese police from freely doing their work on investigating the family who are usually first suspects in these cases. Your thoughts?"
This suggests, you say. So it is just your opinion.
-
Suggests is used because I wasn't present but Amaral was and being the lead detective said Buck obstructed their police work at the start to rule the parents in or out!
-
Suggests is used because I wasn't present but Amaral was and being the lead detective said Buck obstructed their police work at the start to rule the parents in or out!
This is still Your Opinion, and Amaral's Opinion as well. There is No Proof that John Buck deliberately obstructed the investigation.
-
That is obstruction - he was questioning the police work. It has nothing to do with him. Did he work for the PJ?
-
That is obstruction - he was questioning the police work. It has nothing to do with him. Did he work for the PJ?
Surely as a British child had disappeared he had a duty to ensure that the police investigation was as it should be?
Perhaps he had concerns that it was not.
-
Nonsense. Parents are always first suspects in a missing child case.
-
Nonsense. Parents are always first suspects in a missing child case.
In what way did he help them?
-
In what way did he help them?
John Buck didn't help The McCanns, beyond normal Consular help.
-
John Buck didn't help The McCanns, beyond normal Consular help.
I thought so.too.
-
Buck was the Ambassador, not a consul.
-
In response to an FOI from a meddling busy body on the subject of John Buck's involvement:
"HMG provided consular support to the McCann family as we would
for any British national in similar circumstances. The provision of consular support is assessed
on a case by case basis. The level of consular and media support the McCanns received was
judged to be appropriate given the extremely difficult circumstances the McCann family were in
and the exceptional media interest surrounding the case. We cannot go into specifics about
the assistance we provided to the McCanns as we have a duty to respect their privacy".
-
Buck was the Ambassador, not a consul.
John Buck was Leader of The Consular Staff. And he knew what had happened to John Cooke and Leonor Cipriano.
-
Nonsense. Parents are always first suspects in a missing child case.
They should have been....
"It was due to those diplomatic issues, the ambassador’s intervention and all else, who promptly wanted to push towards the abduction thesis. That limited the police action in the sense that they [McCanns] would have been treated as suspects from the start otherwise. What does that imply? That means, that they and those close to them would have been the target of direct, personal surveillance, and also of electronic surveillance. We were lead to consider other paths and only later did we return to that starting point. In some way we wanted to be considerate, we wanted to be somewhat friendly, diplomatic, when that isn’t part of a police investigation." -GA
"In the first instance, the parents should be your number one suspects,
In most cases, in the first few golden hours, as you collect evidence, you can then rule them in or out
And that was one of the huge flaws in this – people didn't focus on clearing the ground beneath their feet in those chaotic first few hours that led into the haphazard first few weeks.
Jim Gamble
Someone misinformed Clarence Mitchell....
"Before that first meeting with Gerry, I was briefed by British police working alongside the Portuguese on the case. They told me then, categorically, that they had “cleared the ground beneath their feet”.
In other words, the British authorities believed that Gerry and Kate were categorically not guilty of any involvement in Madeleine’s disappearance.
-Clarence Mitchell
-
Isn't it possible that they were cleared but afterwards became suspects with the results of the cadaver dog alerts in the McCann's apartment, hence the examination of the villa and the rental car as well.
-
Isn't it possible that they were cleared but afterwards became suspects with the results of the cadaver dog alerts in the McCann's apartment, hence the examination of the villa and the rental car as well.
Not according to both Gamble & Amaral, No.
An unlikely pair in agreement.
-
Just be very careful. Libel will be Deleted. No further warnings.
-
Not according to both Gamble & Amaral, No.
An unlikely pair in agreement.
When would Jim Gamble become involved in the case? (What is the date of the quote above?) Where as Clarence Mitchell was involved in the case even before he became supportive of the McCanns from memory.
To me Amaral is looking for excuses as to why he cleared the parents and then had to look at them again later.
When did Jim Gamble say this: ""In the first instance, the parents should be your number one suspects,
In most cases, in the first few golden hours, as you collect evidence, you can then rule them in or out
And that was one of the huge flaws in this – people didn't focus on clearing the ground beneath their feet in those chaotic first few hours that led into the haphazard first few weeks."?
-
When would Jim Gamble become involved in the case? (What is the date of the quote above?) Where as Clarence Mitchell was involved in the case even before he became supportive of the McCanns from memory.
To me Amaral is looking for excuses as to why he cleared the parents and then had to look at them again later.
When did Jim Gamble say this: ""In the first instance, the parents should be your number one suspects,
In most cases, in the first few golden hours, as you collect evidence, you can then rule them in or out
And that was one of the huge flaws in this – people didn't focus on clearing the ground beneath their feet in those chaotic first few hours that led into the haphazard first few weeks."?
Is that from the review that he carried out for the Home Office, long before OG ?
-
Isn't it possible that they were cleared but afterwards became suspects with the results of the cadaver dog alerts in the McCann's apartment, hence the examination of the villa and the rental car as well.
I think that is the most plausible explanation. Everything used to constitute them as arguidos was as a direct result of the misinterpretation of the dogs' role and the misunderstanding of the forensic results.
Until then there was absolutely no evidence which could be used against them.
Anyway ... what kind of national police force is it which allows itself to be brow beaten into kowtowing to foreigners in the conduct of a criminal case?
I very much doubt if the Portuguese come into that category.
I think protestations of political pressure and MI5 involvement are pie in the sky being pushed by a senior officer trying to deflect from his abysmal mismanagement of a case which was under international scrutiny.
-
Is that from the review that he carried out for the Home Office, long before OG ?
From the scoping report ordered by Alan Johnson I believe.
-
Surely as a British child had disappeared he had a duty to ensure that the police investigation was as it should be?
Perhaps he had concerns that it was not.
And as a non policeman/detective how would he gage this investigation, and why would he not just call the Portuguese Ambassador to find out what is going on.
These concerns would they be the parents sister mouthing off about jemmied shutters/and Maddie being abducted? AND they were left all alone to look for the little girl who was missing- the police were doing nothing...Ahem! He was surprised to see the media -
-
And as a non policeman/detective how would he gage this investigation, and why would he not just call the Portuguese Ambassador to find out what is going on.
These concerns would they be the parents sister mouthing off about jemmied shutters/and Maddie being abducted? AND they were left all alone to look for the little girl who was missing- the police were doing nothing...Ahem! He was surprised to see the media -
Would the Portuguese ambassador know anything about the case? Where would the Portuguese ambassador be based?
-
Would the Portuguese ambassador know anything about the case? Where would the Portuguese ambassador be based?
There are many of them, based in foreign countries. They have no role within Portugal.
-
There are many of them, based in foreign countries. They have no role within Portugal.
Which is why I found Rob's humour rather droll in the way in which he pointed this salient fact out. 8(0(*
-
There are many of them, based in foreign countries. They have no role within Portugal.
That is what I thought so what would be the benefit of contacting the Portuguese ambassador. He would hardly be up to date about what was happening in PdL Portugal.
-
That is what I thought so what would be the benefit of contacting the Portuguese ambassador. He would hardly be up to date about what was happening in PdL Portugal.
Just a lack of understanding regarding the role and function of an ambassador, I think.
-
Just a lack of understanding regarding the role and function of an ambassador, I think.
I thought their primary function was to hold Ferrero Rocher parties.
-
That is what I thought so what would be the benefit of contacting the Portuguese ambassador. He would hardly be up to date about what was happening in PdL Portugal.
Ambassadot to ambassador. The british would call the Portugues ambassador and ask him to contact the relevent authority to find out why NO ONE was looking for the little girl- according to the parents and family.
Ambassadors do NOT get involved with criminals abroad! they don't ,in so far as I am aware visit wrongfully arrested innocent Brits, abroad.
http://icfuae.org.uk/news/british-fco-must-do-more-help-british-nationals-detained-uae