UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Holly Goodhead on July 18, 2019, 09:45:58 AM

Title: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 18, 2019, 09:45:58 AM
 *%6^
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 18, 2019, 09:47:45 AM
*%6^

It depends what SY have
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 18, 2019, 09:51:54 AM
It depends what SY have

Well I sent a comprehensive email some days ago.  I hope it can assist.  We shall see.   ?>)()< 8(>((
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 18, 2019, 09:59:02 AM
Well I sent a comprehensive email some days ago.  I hope it can assist.  We shall see.   ?>)()< 8(>((

you will be surprised to know I really hope it does...but i very much doubt it
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: G-Unit on July 18, 2019, 11:16:51 AM
Well I sent a comprehensive email some days ago.  I hope it can assist.  We shall see.   ?>)()< 8(>((

What did you think you could offer that Operation Grange might have missed?
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: sadie on July 18, 2019, 01:33:01 PM
Well I sent a comprehensive email some days ago.  I hope it can assist.  We shall see.   ?>)()< 8(>((

Good luck with it.  Hope it presents the missing link in Praia de luz and it opens up new thoughts.


From my experience, they rarely come back to you, which leaves you in a bit of a vacuum.  Over about six sizeable documents (think book size rather than two sheets of paper for some of them), they came back to me only three times, although they did see me at sargeant level the last twice and phoned me once  (secure line) 



The first time to ask questions about one document, the second time, there was my one folder  on Crimewatch with exciting words being spoken at the same time.




It was a Lavender coloured folfer being carried but last time I looked that colour had changed to aquamarine on  almost every reference on the internet.   On the 'Find Madeleine' site, however, it had changed less obviously from Lavender to a sort of deep blue.
,


All my folders about Madeleine and these men/women involved in child abduction cases were in Lavender colour.


Why?  Because I believe, but don't know for sure, that that is what these child abusers are called in the US.= LAVENDERS




How very interesting to see that the colour of my folder has been changed  since Crimewatch  was shown on TV.   Why would that be do you think ?   



 $65*   *%6^
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: pathfinder73 on July 18, 2019, 01:53:12 PM
Of course because they have eliminated all the nonsense leads/theories.

"Scotland Yard have struggled in recent months to resolve a final lead but more money is required to complete the last stage of the investigation." August 22, 2017
https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/police-spent-11m-hunting-madeline-mccann-need-more-cash-pursue-final-lead-1636073
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: jassi on July 18, 2019, 02:15:38 PM
Of course because they have eliminated all the nonsense leads/theories.

"Scotland Yard have struggled in recent months to resolve a final lead but more money is required to complete the last stage of the investigation." August 22, 2017
https://www.ibtimes.co.uk/police-spent-11m-hunting-madeline-mccann-need-more-cash-pursue-final-lead-1636073

One would expect so, but they must have wasted a lot of time and effort in doing so - IMO
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 18, 2019, 03:27:49 PM
What did you think you could offer that Operation Grange might have missed?
(I noticed I used 'be' in the title instead of 'being' so I changed the title and all the posts.  All part of my OCD I guess *%6^)

I told Op Grange I have not shared other than I copied the email to 'The Find Madeleine' site and told my partner and I need to keep it this way. 

I might be barking up the wrong tree.  If I'm not I think we will all know sooner rather than later.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: slartibartfast on July 18, 2019, 05:05:00 PM
Good luck with it.  Hope it presents the missing link in Praia de luz and it opens up new thoughts.


From my experience, they rarely come back to you, which leaves you in a bit of a vacuum.  Over about six sizeable documents (think book size rather than two sheets of paper for some of them), they came back to me only three times, although they did see me at sargeant level the last twice and phoned me once  (secure line) 



The first time to ask questions about one document, the second time, there was my one folder  on Crimewatch with exciting words being spoken at the same time.




It was a Lavender coloured folfer being carried but last time I looked that colour had changed to aquamarine on  almost every reference on the internet.   On the 'Find Madeleine' site, however, it had changed less obviously from Lavender to a sort of deep blue.
,


All my folders about Madeleine and these men/women involved in child abduction cases were in Lavender colour.


Why?  Because I believe, but don't know for sure, that that is what these child abusers are called in the US.= LAVENDERS




How very interesting to see that the colour of my folder has been changed  since Crimewatch  was shown on TV.   Why would that be do you think ?   



 $65*   *%6^

How did you know it was secure?
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: G-Unit on July 18, 2019, 05:14:00 PM
(I noticed I used 'be' in the title instead of 'being' so I changed the title and all the posts.  All part of my OCD I guess *%6^)

I told Op Grange I have not shared other than I copied the email to 'The Find Madeleine' site and told my partner and I need to keep it this way. 

I might be barking up the wrong tree.  If I'm not I think we will all know sooner rather than later.

It's either you or Eddie lol.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 18, 2019, 07:35:34 PM
It's either you or Eddie lol.
Eddie has already passed away.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: barrier on July 18, 2019, 08:49:59 PM
It depends what SY have

Its what the PJ have that counts.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: sadie on July 19, 2019, 12:09:54 AM
How did you know it was secure?

I asked and the O.G. Police Officer assured me that it was secure.  They phoned me.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Billy Whizz Fan Club on July 19, 2019, 12:56:16 AM
It might become a little closer to being solved if the PJ or SY take up the offer of new DNA analysis.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 19, 2019, 08:41:55 AM
It's either you or Eddie lol.

 @)(++(*
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: slartibartfast on July 19, 2019, 10:59:52 AM
I asked and the O.G. Police Officer assured me that it was secure.  They phoned me.

You asked a policeman who rang you whether the line was secure?
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: barrier on July 19, 2019, 12:14:58 PM
*%6^


The sands of time are running,Portuguese statute of limitations is on a countdown.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=7626.0


1. The criminal proceedings extinguishes through the effect of prescription as soon as from the
exertion of the crime has elapsed the following terms:
a) 15 years, concerning crime punishable with prison penalty for a maximum limit superior to 10
years.
b) 10 years, when it concerns crimes punishable with prison penalties with a maximum term equal
or superior to 5 years, but not exceeding 10 years.
c) 5 years, when it concerns crimes punishable with prison penalties with a maximum term equal or
superior to one year, but inferior to 5 years.
2. For the purpose prescribed in the previous number, to determine the maximum term applicable
to each crime, the elements concerning the type of crime are taken into consideration, but not the
aggravating or attenuating circumstances.
3. When the law alternatively establishes for any crime the penalty of prison or fine, only the first is
taken into consideration for the purpose of this article.
Article 119
The beginning of term
1. The term of prescription of the criminal proceedings runs from the day when the act has been
consummated.
2. The term of prescription only occurs:
a) In permanent crimes, from the day the consummation ceases;
b) In continued crimes and habitual crimes, from the day when the last act was practised;
c) In crimes that has not been consummated, from the day of the last act of execution.
3. As concerns this article, in case of complicity the fact of the author is always taken into account.
4. When the verification of the result not comprehended in the type of crime is relevant, the term of
prescription only runs from the day that result is verified.

Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 19, 2019, 12:38:18 PM

The sands of time are running,Portuguese statute of limitations is on a countdown.

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=7626.0


1. The criminal proceedings extinguishes through the effect of prescription as soon as from the
exertion of the crime has elapsed the following terms:
a) 15 years, concerning crime punishable with prison penalty for a maximum limit superior to 10
years.
b) 10 years, when it concerns crimes punishable with prison penalties with a maximum term equal
or superior to 5 years, but not exceeding 10 years.
c) 5 years, when it concerns crimes punishable with prison penalties with a maximum term equal or
superior to one year, but inferior to 5 years.
2. For the purpose prescribed in the previous number, to determine the maximum term applicable
to each crime, the elements concerning the type of crime are taken into consideration, but not the
aggravating or attenuating circumstances.
3. When the law alternatively establishes for any crime the penalty of prison or fine, only the first is
taken into consideration for the purpose of this article.
Article 119
The beginning of term
1. The term of prescription of the criminal proceedings runs from the day when the act has been
consummated.
2. The term of prescription only occurs:
a) In permanent crimes, from the day the consummation ceases;
b) In continued crimes and habitual crimes, from the day when the last act was practised;
c) In crimes that has not been consummated, from the day of the last act of execution.
3. As concerns this article, in case of complicity the fact of the author is always taken into account.
4. When the verification of the result not comprehended in the type of crime is relevant, the term of
prescription only runs from the day that result is verified.

Does that mean there is a statute of limitation for murder too?
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 19, 2019, 12:39:59 PM
Does that mean there is a statute of limitation for murder too?

4. When the verification of the result not comprehended in the type of crime is relevant, the term of
prescription only runs from the day that result is verified.

Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 19, 2019, 12:46:04 PM
4. When the verification of the result not comprehended in the type of crime is relevant, the term of
prescription only runs from the day that result is verified.

So if they found out tomorrow that MM was murdered the Statute of limitations for murder would start from tomorrow.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: barrier on July 19, 2019, 12:47:43 PM
Does that mean there is a statute of limitation for murder too?

I don't think its clear, as demonstrated in the thread I linked to.
But the crime is still undetermined,with out a body will it ever be a murder,if that is what happened.
Rowley described it as a missing persons case,so is it possible the time as run out on that one.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 19, 2019, 12:52:12 PM
I don't think its clear, as demonstrated in the thread I linked to.
But the crime is still undetermined,with out a body will it ever be a murder,if that is what happened.
Rowley described it as a missing persons case,so is it possible the time as run out on that one.
"Missing person" isn't really a crime as such.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 19, 2019, 12:53:41 PM
So if they found out tomorrow that MM was murdered the Statute of limitations for murder would start from tomorrow.

I would think it would be something like this.  I can't imagine a developed country having laws that allow perps to escape justice if they are able to fall under the radar for X amount of time, can you?

Consider international laws where perps of war crimes have been found guilty in the international courts decades after the event.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: barrier on July 19, 2019, 12:54:21 PM
Bit of a side note but just as important imo,Tractor driver man was never considered in the reopening according to this.

Criminal responsibility is also extinguished by death, by amnesty, by general pardon and by indult.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: barrier on July 19, 2019, 12:55:06 PM
"Missing person" isn't really a crime as such.

Rowley was a bit fuzzy with his interview.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 19, 2019, 12:56:56 PM
Rowley was a bit fuzzy with his interview.
I took it he was saying Madeleine was abducted.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 19, 2019, 01:01:13 PM
I don't think its clear, as demonstrated in the thread I linked to.
But the crime is still undetermined,with out a body will it ever be a murder,if that is what happened.
Rowley described it as a missing persons case,so is it possible the time as run out on that one.

I've recently read 'Under The Wig' by William Clegg QC.  He devotes some chapters to some of the more high profile cases he has been involved in one being the case of Don Banfield: A Murder Without a Body.  His wife and daughter were found guilty of his murder despite the fact his body was not found.  Ok this is UK law but I wouldn't mind betting it's not dissimilar in Portugal. 

The only way in which MM's case would not involve criminality is if she woke, wandered and came to some harm by her own actions.  Imo this is not what happened.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 19, 2019, 01:03:12 PM
Bit of a side note but just as important imo,Tractor driver man was never considered in the reopening according to this.

Criminal responsibility is also extinguished by death, by amnesty, by general pardon and by indult.

I think he would be considered as such but not held criminally responsible. 
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: barrier on July 19, 2019, 01:08:18 PM
Rowley was a bit fuzzy with his interview.


I took it he was saying Madeleine was abducted.

He said "however" she left the apartment she was abducted.
That could mean by what means,what he never said was by a stranger.

The most important people of all,the PJ say they have to be prepared for different scenario's.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: G-Unit on July 19, 2019, 01:37:48 PM
I've recently read 'Under The Wig' by William Clegg QC.  He devotes some chapters to some of the more high profile cases he has been involved in one being the case of Don Banfield: A Murder Without a Body.  His wife and daughter were found guilty of his murder despite the fact his body was not found.  Ok this is UK law but I wouldn't mind betting it's not dissimilar in Portugal. 

The only way in which MM's case would not involve criminality is if she woke, wandered and came to some harm by her own actions.  Imo this is not what happened.

Don Banfield's wife and daughter had their convictions overturned on Appeal. The Met's evidence wasn't conclusive enough.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-23522195
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 19, 2019, 01:54:14 PM
Don Banfield's wife and daughter had their convictions overturned on Appeal. The Met's evidence wasn't conclusive enough.
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-23522195

The convictions were quashed because the appeal court judges decided that it wasn't possible to exclude the possibility that either the mother or daughter had been responsible without the participation of the other.  The jury had convicted on the basis of joint enterprise. 

The point is it is possible to convict without a body eg the case of Suzanne Pilley where David Gilroy was found guilty.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 19, 2019, 02:21:40 PM

He said "however" she left the apartment she was abducted.
That could mean by what means,what he never said was by a stranger.

The most important people of all,the PJ say they have to be prepared for different scenario's.

He was meaning

a) an abductor entered 5A and exited with MM

or

b) MM woke and wandered and was abducted from outside

He made the point she was not old enough to make the decision to start a new life elsewhere.  It seems from the above he has ruled out woke and wandered and came to some harm by her own actions. 
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: jassi on July 19, 2019, 02:26:11 PM
He was meaning

a) an abductor entered 5A and exited with MM

or

b) MM woke and wandered and was abducted from outside

He made the point she was not old enough to make the decision to start a new life elsewhere.  It seems from the above he has ruled out woke and wandered and came to some harm by her own actions.

A shame he never explained the reason(s) for thinking this.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 19, 2019, 02:39:55 PM
A shame he never explained the reason(s) for thinking this.

Yes that's what I thought.  Although I have to say before I started looking at the case I was inclined to think (on what basis I don't know) that MM may have woke and wandered and ended up down the road works that were going on? or ended up in the ocean etc.  But based on what I've learned since imo its stranger abduction from 5A. 
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: barrier on July 19, 2019, 02:48:22 PM
Yes that's what I thought.  Although I have to say before I started looking at the case I was inclined to think (on what basis I don't know) that MM may have woke and wandered and ended up down the road works that were going on? or ended up in the ocean etc.  But based on what I've learned since imo its stranger abduction from 5A.

The most important of them all,the PJ don't allow this to be their only school of thought.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 19, 2019, 02:57:07 PM
The most important of them all,the PJ don't allow this to be their only school of thought.

And that's the way it should be but I'm just someone with too much time on their hands on an internet forum  8(8-)) 

But you got me thinking if the McCanns were involved (I don't believe for 1 min they were) why not dispose of a pair of MM's footwear and leave the patio doors slightly ajar along with child gate and road to gate open lending to the idea she woke and wandered and came to some harm outside the apartment? 
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 19, 2019, 09:17:14 PM
And that's the way it should be but I'm just someone with too much time on their hands on an internet forum  8(8-)) 

But you got me thinking if the McCanns were involved (I don't believe for 1 min they were) why not dispose of a pair of MM's footwear and leave the patio doors slightly ajar along with child gate and road to gate open lending to the idea she woke and wandered and came to some harm outside the apartment?

You have asked this on three threads Holly. For my reply see the appropraite thread.

"He made the point she was not old enough to make the decision to start a new life elsewhere.  It seems from the above he has ruled out woke and wandered and came to some harm by her own actions. "


I did not read his words like that, I read him saying she didn't voluntarily leave the house to run away. If she did leave the house by her own accord, it was for a reason.

OR

he is saying she was removed without her consent.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 19, 2019, 09:22:36 PM
Well I sent a comprehensive email some days ago.  I hope it can assist.  We shall see.   ?>)()< 8(>((

Great you solved the case. really exciting. I am sure they will grab another 1 million to investigate that.


Poor Sadie has had her folders changed colour to try and out fox them blood hunters who, what stole Maddie.

OR perhaps it wasn't her folders at all..  Just a stab in the dark with that.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 20, 2019, 11:57:18 AM
Great you solved the case. really exciting. I am sure they will grab another 1 million to investigate that.

Poor Sadie has had her folders changed colour to try and out fox them blood hunters who, what stole Maddie.

OR perhaps it wasn't her folders at all..  Just a stab in the dark with that.

I have never said I've solved the case.  No one can say that until such time some significant developments take place. 

However I do believe I have made a significant breakthrough.  Op Grange have all the info.  As I said IF I'm right I would suggest we will all know sooner rather than later. 


Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 20, 2019, 12:03:57 PM
I have never said I've solved the case.  No one can say that until such time some significant developments take place. 

However I do believe I have made a significant breakthrough.  Op Grange have all the info.  As I said IF I'm right I would suggest we will all know sooner rather than later.
Why don't you give us an outline to your thoughts in a separate thread?  Please.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 20, 2019, 01:24:15 PM
Why don't you give us an outline to your thoughts in a separate thread?  Please.

You know why because I have already stated my reasons here:

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10897.msg546420#msg546420
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: jassi on July 20, 2019, 01:29:12 PM
Not sure why you felt the need to share the information about emailing OG with us in the first place as you are not prepared to 'spill the beans'

Was it to demonstrate how clever you think you are?
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Billy Whizz Fan Club on July 20, 2019, 01:44:11 PM

The only way in which MM's case would not involve criminality is if she woke, wandered and came to some harm by her own actions.  Imo this is not what happened.

And it's worth stating that even in that scenario there would be some serious questions to answer with regards to criminal negligence, IMO.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Anthro on July 20, 2019, 05:31:16 PM
Ear print vs fingerprint.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Anthro on July 20, 2019, 05:37:23 PM
I apologise. I am trying to upload photos but without success.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 20, 2019, 07:00:09 PM
You know why because I have already stated my reasons here:

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10897.msg546420#msg546420
"I told Op Grange I have not shared other than I copied the email to 'The Find Madeleine' site and told my partner and I need to keep it this way." 
That was in the past tense.  You didn't say you would keep it a secret forever.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 21, 2019, 09:52:56 AM
Not sure why you felt the need to share the information about emailing OG with us in the first place as you are not prepared to 'spill the beans'

Was it to demonstrate how clever you think you are?

We'll see how clever I am or not as the case may be.  Even if I'm right does 'clever' come into it? 

Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 21, 2019, 09:59:49 AM
We'll see how clever I am or not as the case may be.  Even if I'm right does 'clever' come into it?
I would say so, definitely.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 21, 2019, 10:04:42 AM
Quote from: Holly Goodhead link=topic=10897.msg546915#msg546915 dated=1563699176
We'll see how clever I am or not as the case may be.  Even if I'm right does 'clever' come into it?

Do you really believe after looking at the case for s couple of weeks you can solve it when SY and the PJ have been looking at it for years

Obviously if you were connected to the case and had some new evidence that might happen...but you are not
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: G-Unit on July 21, 2019, 10:20:16 AM
Do you really believe after looking at the case for s couple of weeks you can solve it when SY and the PJ have been looking at it for years

Obviously if you were connected to the case and had some new evidence that might happen...but you are not

I agree, Davel, it seems highly unlikely. I'm amazed that some people seem to think the police need to be informed of their theories, to be honest. I would only ever contact the police if I had useful infornation that I thought they didn't have. I wouldn't expect them to need or want my thoughts on a case.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 21, 2019, 12:08:54 PM
He was meaning

a) an abductor entered 5A and exited with MM

or

b) MM woke and wandered and was abducted from outside

He made the point she was not old enough to make the decision to start a new life elsewhere.  It seems from the above he has ruled out woke and wandered and came to some harm by her own actions.


Yes Indeed and this (sentence in red font) was predicted. The remit is to find an abductor as are the parents wishes and story. He was offfering up his conclusion to prepare us- however, he may not have got the nod from the PJ who could have peed all over it. As THEY do not believe in stranger abduction and the story created by the T9 which md ethem say it was.


Woke and wandered would show the parents as the callous arrogant pair they are IMO.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 21, 2019, 12:17:38 PM
I have never said I've solved the case.  No one can say that until such time some significant developments take place. 

However I do believe I have made a significant breakthrough.  Op Grange have all the info.  As I said IF I'm right I would suggest we will all know sooner rather than later.

I am sorry I don't believe you have important information, you just want to play detective. Like Sadie.

We have had 3 private imvestigators, two police forces, numerous journalists all studying this case and YOU think you may have helped solved it in a few weeks. okayyyyy. Thing is  you will need to provide evidence of sorts- got any? or is it just. I have been looking at this case I HAVE FOUND SOMETHING YOU LOT ALL MISSED  xyz did it!
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 21, 2019, 10:01:32 PM
Do you really believe after looking at the case for s couple of weeks you can solve it when SY and the PJ have been looking at it for years

Yes.

And John has pointed out to you all numerous times how ineffective SY have been in solving the murder of Jill Dando; through sheer desperation they nailed Barry George, a man with mental and physical disabilities, when anyone with any basic knowledge of the soc would know it was carried out by a professional.

SY and PJ  @)(++(*  As KM said Tweedledum and Tweedledee  @)(++(*


Obviously if you were connected to the case and had some new evidence that might happen...but you are not

Why do I need to be connected to the case?  There's a mountain of evidence in the public domain.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: G-Unit on July 22, 2019, 06:54:46 AM
Yes.

And John has pointed out to you all numerous times how ineffective SY have been in solving the murder of Jill Dando; through sheer desperation they nailed Barry George, a man with mental and physical disabilities, when anyone with any basic knowledge of the soc would know it was carried out by a professional.

SY and PJ  @)(++(*  As KM said Tweedledum and Tweedledee  @)(++(*


Why do I need to be connected to the case?  There's a mountain of evidence in the public domain.

Interestingly the person who led the Dando investigation was given the McCann case. 
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 22, 2019, 08:43:43 AM
Interestingly the person who led the Dando investigation was given the McCann case.

Well the lead detective on the JD murder investigation was Hamish Campbell who I know has played a role in the MM investigation, but lead?

Imo based on the cases I've looked at the police are simply not fit for purpose. People here talk about them as though they are some elite force to be reckoned with when imo they're anything but.  I have no personal gripe with the police since I've never been involved in any criminality in my life nor associated with any such person(s) but I simply do not rate them based on the cases I've looked at.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: jassi on July 22, 2019, 09:30:42 AM
I think much of the UK police's success in solving crime depends heavily on technology - camera surveillance, forensic science and access to various data bases.

Faced with an event where none of these are available, they will flounder as much as any other force.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 22, 2019, 09:50:15 AM
I think much of the UK police's success in solving crime depends heavily on technology - camera surveillance, forensic science and access to various data bases.

Faced with an event where none of these are available, they will flounder as much as any other force.

I disagree.  It impossible to carry out a crime and not leave some clue behind.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: jassi on July 22, 2019, 09:53:20 AM
I disagree.  It impossible to carry out a crime and not leave some clue behind.

I didn't say there wouldn't be clues, just not the sort that a high tech police force is used to dealing with.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 22, 2019, 10:02:40 AM
I didn't say there wouldn't be clues, just not the sort that a high tech police force is used to dealing with.

Clues are clues are they not?  Who are you referring to as high tech: PJ, SY or neither?
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: G-Unit on July 22, 2019, 10:47:32 AM
Well the lead detective on the JD murder investigation was Hamish Campbell who I know has played a role in the MM investigation, but lead?

Imo based on the cases I've looked at the police are simply not fit for purpose. People here talk about them as though they are some elite force to be reckoned with when imo they're anything but.  I have no personal gripe with the police since I've never been involved in any criminality in my life nor associated with any such person(s) but I simply do not rate them based on the cases I've looked at.

HC was the SIO in the McCann investigative review, reporting to Commannder Simon Foy.  Redwood was the IO working under Campbell.

The Metropolitan Police are no better than any other force. In fact their track record is pretty bad in more ways than one.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 22, 2019, 10:57:21 AM
Clues are clues are they not?  Who are you referring to as high tech: PJ, SY or neither?

Yes clues are clues, however,there are physical and circumstancial evidence which can make or break a case.

It is easy to get someones DNA and or fingerprint and plant it at a scene.

It also depends on the crime.

murder  you require motive and opportunity
manslaughter  you just need opportunity and circumstances which led up to the fatal blow.

That is why some genuine rape cases are so difficult  to get to court.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 22, 2019, 11:03:47 AM
Yes clues are clues, however,there are physical and circumstancial evidence which can make or break a case.

It is easy to get someones DNA and or fingerprint and plant it at a scene.

It also depends on the crime.

murder  you require motive and opportunity
manslaughter  you just need opportunity and circumstances which led up to the fatal blow.

That is why some genuine rape cases are so difficult  to get to court.

Yes I agree broadly although I'm not sure its easy to plant DNA and fingerprints?

What physical and circumstantial evidence do you believe exists in this case?
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 22, 2019, 11:06:45 AM
HC was the SIO in the McCann investigative review, reporting to Commannder Simon Foy.  Redwood was the IO working under Campbell.

The Metropolitan Police are no better than any other force. In fact their track record is pretty bad in more ways than one.

Yep I agree.  In far too many cases they're either grossly incompetent or corrupt. 

Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 22, 2019, 11:08:16 AM
Yes clues are clues, however,there are physical and circumstancial evidence which can make or break a case.

It is easy to get someones DNA and or fingerprint and plant it at a scene.

It also depends on the crime.

murder  you require motive and opportunity
manslaughter  you just need opportunity and circumstances which led up to the fatal blow.

That is why some genuine rape cases are so difficult  to get to court.
It wasn't easy to get Madeleine's DNA or finger prints and plant them at the scene.  What are you talking about?   Planting fingerprints ??  I've never heard about that!
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 22, 2019, 11:59:33 AM
Yes I agree broadly although I'm not sure its easy to plant DNA and fingerprints?

What physical and circumstantial evidence do you believe exists in this case?

Easy if you know how!  I can't reall the exact case, but there have been two instances in Scotland where a police officer was jailed for doing just that.  I will google later to see if I can find any more about it.

I don't have a theory so I can't offer physical or circumstancial evidence to procure it. Which is what I expect of those who do claim to know.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"It wasn't easy to get Madeleine's DNA or finger prints and plant them at the scene.  What are you talking about?   Planting fingerprints ??  I've never heard about that!"

Oh Seriously Rob? where do I claim this happened in the MBM case?  I was replying to a generic question.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 22, 2019, 12:03:37 PM
Easy if you know how!  I can't reall the exact case, but there have been two instances in Scotland where a police officer was jailed for doing just that.  I will google later to see if I can find any more about it.

I don't have a theory so I can't offer physical or circumstancial evidence to procure it. Which is what I expect of those who do claim to know.


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
"It wasn't easy to get Madeleine's DNA or finger prints and plant them at the scene.  What are you talking about?   Planting fingerprints ??  I've never heard about that!"

Oh Seriously Rob? where do I claim this happened in the MBM case?  I was replying to a generic question.
You didn't but I just reminded you it would be difficult in the McCann case.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 22, 2019, 12:06:54 PM
You didn't but I just reminded you it would be difficult in the McCann case.

Hmm ok. There was no such claim in  the McCann case .?
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 22, 2019, 12:22:05 PM
It wasn't easy to get Madeleine's DNA or finger prints and plant them at the scene.  What are you talking about?   Planting fingerprints ??  I've never heard about that!

MM's fingerprints would legitimately be all over 5A along with potentially dna evidence so how would this assist in this case?
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 22, 2019, 12:28:31 PM
MM's fingerprints would legitimately be all over 5A along with potentially dna evidence so how would this assist in this case?
But of all the fingerprints examined were any of Madeleine?   I have not seen a report suggesting Madeline's prints were identified.  Were small prints just ignored?  It would be helpful if we are trying to determine woke and wandered.  Her prints could have been be on the front door.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: barrier on July 22, 2019, 12:32:12 PM
But of all the fingerprints examined were any of Madeleine?   I have not seen a report suggesting Madeline's prints were identified.  Were small prints just ignored?  It would be helpful if we are trying to determine woke and wandered.  Her prints could have been be on the front door.

How could they tell if it was Madeleine finger print's,she's gone.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 22, 2019, 12:33:52 PM
But of all the fingerprints examined were any of Madeleine?   I have not seen a report suggesting Madeline's prints were identified.  Were small prints just ignored?  It would be helpful if we are trying to determine woke and wandered.  Her prints could have been be on the front door.

Yes, Indeed! or the patio door, however, they may have been seen and eliminated.

It gives food for thought that  the 'woke and wandered and having an accident' was the police thinking at that time,
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: jassi on July 22, 2019, 12:35:15 PM
But of all the fingerprints examined were any of Madeleine?   I have not seen a report suggesting Madeline's prints were identified.  Were small prints just ignored?  It would be helpful if we are trying to determine woke and wandered.  Her prints could have been be on the front door.

How would that help ? Having been in the apartment for nearly a week, finding her prints anywhere would not be unreasonable.
IMO
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 22, 2019, 12:38:14 PM
How could they tell if it was Madeleine finger print's,she's gone.
They were able to establish Madeleine's DNA so IMO it would not be impossible to go to their home in England and get samples of Madeleine's prints by a process of elimination.
Title: Re: 12 Years On...Is The Case Any Closer To Being Solved?
Post by: John on July 28, 2019, 06:32:07 PM
I apologise. I am trying to upload photos but without success.

Photos must be uploaded to the forum in image file format such as GIF, JPEG or PNG.