UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Robittybob1 on July 22, 2019, 11:49:02 PM
-
Is it scientific to say dogs have a greater sense of olfaction than Humans?
There have been many different estimates used but what is the scientific answer.
Some interesting points raised here. https://youtu.be/Gf4k0VgCQjg
It says dogs have 15 times as many sensory cells as humans. But other adaptations as well, separate air pockets, high sniffing rate (5 times per second), breathing in and out through separate channels.
That a dog's nose is close to the ground is also important (not mentioned).
51
-
This is interesting SIL does Goncalo do this? https://youtu.be/-9TThJgBBew
-
This is truly remarkable https://youtu.be/XPluctLY8Y4
-
This is interesting SIL does Goncalo do this? https://youtu.be/-9TThJgBBew
If you mean, does he run around like a lunatic in a dog pack, the answer is no.
On the rare occasion that he does get a chance to play with one of the other resident dogs, yes, they both run around like lunatics. My dog stops smelling anything, and runs the other dog into the ground.
When he is out without another dog, he mainly likes to spend his time with his nose down to the ground, for a superior sniff.
-
If you mean, does he run around like a lunatic in a dog pack, the answer is no.
On the rare occasion that he does get a chance to play with one of the other resident dogs, yes, they both run around like lunatics. My dog stops smelling anything, and runs the other dog into the ground.
When he is out without another dog, he mainly likes to spend his time with his nose down to the ground, for a superior sniff.
I meant have you seen him flare his nostrils? I was not really aware prior to this that a dog breaths in and out in different ways.
-
I meant have you seen him flare his nostrils?
Of course I have seen him flare his nostrils. He's a dog!
-
Of course I have seen him flare his nostrils. He's a dog!
So do I .
-
I'm left a bit speechless after reading this article. "Dogs' Dazzling Sense of Smell" https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/article/dogs-sense-of-smell/
-
Not particularly scientific:
https://www.dogster.com/lifestyle/dogs-sense-of-smell-facts
"7 Amazing Facts About Your Dog’s Sense of Smell."
"1. A dog’s sense of smell is way stronger than ours
Yeah, you can read that two ways, but think back to what your dog smells like when wet, and you’ll figure out the right meaning. When it comes to nose sensitivity, dogs are the paws-down winners over humans. Numbers abound about how much better a dog’s sense of smell is than ours. There are so many variables that it’s almost impossible to quantify. I’ve seen figures indicating that a dog’s sense of smell is from 10 to 100 to 1,000 to 1,000,000 times better. Scientists I’ve spoken with say that dogs can detect some, if not most, odors at concentrations of parts per trillion.
Psychologist and prolific dog book author Stanley Coren gave me an example of what that huge sniffer sensitivity looks like. Let’s say you have a gram of a component of human sweat known as butyric acid. Surprisingly, humans are quite good at smelling this. If you let it evaporate in the space of a 10-story building, many of us would still be able to detect a faint scent upon entering the building. Not bad, for a human nose. But consider this: If you put the 135-square-mile city of Philadelphia under a 300-foot-high enclosure, evaporated the gram of butyric acid and let a dog in, the average dog would still be able to detect the odor.
-
Consider some of these details:
"Why Do Dogs Have Such a Great Sense of Smell?"
https://www.scienceabc.com/nature/animals/why-dogs-sense-of-smell-is-so-good.html
"Dog Brain vs. Human Brain
By now, we clearly know that dogs have a nose that can smell about 1,000-10,000 times better than a human, but how are dogs able to remember all the different smells that they have sensed throughout their life?
The answer lies in the difference between the brains of dogs and humans. A human brain has a larger visual cortex than dogs, whereas a dog’s brain has a much larger olfactory cortex than humans. The visual cortex is responsible for processing visual information, whereas the olfactory cortex is responsible for processing the sense of smell. A dog’s olfactory cortex is about 40 times larger than that of a human."
Why would a dog want to remember a smell for life? "How are dogs able to remember all the different smells that they have sensed throughout their life?" Who said they remember it for life?
Grime trained his dogs daily which tends to point to not a lot of long term memory of smells IMO.
-
Last one I promise:
"Dogs can smell better than people, but exactly how much better?"
https://www.sandiegoreader.com/news/2001/nov/15/dogs-can-smell-better-people-exactly-how-much-bett/#
" a scientist in Michigan has discovered that the best smellers in the world are fish. A thousand times better than dogs, he says.... "
Maybe one day we will be discussing "cadaver fish" rather than "cadaver dogs"!
-
Interesting links Robitty however one thing you will find on this forum is that some people prefer to ignore the science, whether its dogs, smoking, the age of the earth, etc and no amount of links will change their entrenched views. That’s online forums for you!
-
Interesting links Robitty however one thing you will find on this forum is that some people prefer to ignore the science, whether its dogs, smoking, the age of the earth, etc and no amount of links will change their entrenched views. That’s online forums for you!
Life in general,I'd say,brexiteer,remainer,Tory,labour,Liberal,better red than dead ,et al ,there are some with entranced views and won't be swayed,its not just forums.
-
Life in general,I'd say,brexiteer,remainer,Tory,labour,Liberal,better red than dead ,et al ,there are some with entranced views and won't be swayed,its not just forums.
Indeed but in real life face to face discussion can be more nuanced, on forums there is no room for nuance otherwise it is leapt upon by the opposition as a sign of weakness in one’s position and can be twisted to try and win the debate, therefore only extremes may exist. IMO. That said, I don’t think anyone who believes the earth is 6000 years old, or that dogs and humans have the same olfactory abilities are open to reason no matter how nuanced the discussion.
-
This is truly remarkable https://youtu.be/XPluctLY8Y4
It's also something that no human being could do.
-
Scientists say dogs have more receptors, improved nostrils, and more of their brain devoted to olfaction compared to humans.
-
"In Some Ways, Your Sense of Smell Is Actually Better Than a Dog’s
Human noses are especially attuned to picking up odors in bananas, urine and human blood
Read more: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/science-nature/you-actually-smell-better-dog-180963391/#HDWlbzQsErvqAZSk.99"
Some studies have shown that humans can learn to track scents like canines. (Erik Reis / Alamy)
"The verdict: While not quite as effective as hounds, humans can follow a scent trail. And they get a lot better at it if they keep trying.
“They showed that humans could do it,” says Joel Mainland, a neuroscientist at Philadelphia's Monell Center who helped lay the groundwork for the scent-tracking study. “They were much worse at it than dogs, but if you let them practice for a few weeks, they also got much better very rapidly.”
Yet in the decade since, the idea that humans are prodigious sniffers hasn’t really caught on. We tend to get overshadowed by other animals like dogs, which are so reputed for their olfactory abilities that we employ them to tease apart the chemical vapors from bombs, drugs and even cancer on our behalf."
-
If Humans have as good a sense of smell as dogs then doctors would be trained to sniff out cancers in their patients, rather than dogs which have recently been used to do so. Also, policemen and women would be trained to sniff out where on a person drugs had been concealed like dogs do, and bouncers at clubs could do the same to prevent illegal substances being consumed on the premises. I’m sure SIL has a perfectly logical reason why humans in these jobs are not trained to do these jobs, probably something to do with humans not having tails or something.
-
To quote ny husband; why keep a dog and bark yourself lol. Dogs are good at following scent trails, they're noses are close to the ground and they can run and sniff at the same time. Why replace them with humans who would be much slower?
-
To quote ny husband; why keep a dog and bark yourself lol. Dogs are good at following scent trails, they're noses are close to the ground and they can run and sniff at the same time. Why replace them with humans who would be nuch slower?
the reason dogs are used to follow scent trails has a little more to do with them being able to run with their noses close to the ground....they are not repalced by humans because humans do not have any where near the sensitivity to detect scent
-
the reason dogs are used to follow scent trails has a little more to do with them being able to run with their noses close to the ground....they are not replaced by humans because humans do not have any where near the sensitivity to detect scent
But can you prove that?
-
But can you prove that?
what do you mean by prove ..the fact that dogs are used worldwide in prefernce to humans...the fact tht dogs ahve many more scent detectors...the fact that its an esatblished fact..isnt taht proof enough
-
what do you mean by prove ..the fact that dogs are used worldwide in prefernce to humans...the fact tht dogs ahve many more scent detectors...the fact that its an esatblished fact..isnt taht proof enough
They might be circumstantial proof. I want something that I can really prove it to SIL. Some simple test.
-
But can you prove that?
Nothing to prove its a scientific fact accepted by all.
-
A simple test would be very easy...can a human detect the scent of a small amount of drugs wrapped in a packet.
It's a silly argument...sil is wrong...it's a simple as that
-
A simple test would be very easy...can a human detect the scent of a small amount of drugs wrapped in a packet.
It's a silly argument...sil is wrong...it's a simple as that
Well we can hardly run a test with illegal drugs. It is the training bit that would be the difficult bit.
OK let's just use a paracetamol tablet, can humans smell paracetamol tablets?
How do we train Goncalo to sniff out a paracetamol tablet?
-
Well we can hardly run a test with illegal drugs. It is the training bit that would be the difficult bit.
OK let's just use a paracetamol tablet, can humans smell paracetamol tablets?
How do we train Goncalo to sniff out a paracetamol tablet?
I don't need to do a test. It's patently obvious
-
I don't need to do a test. It's patently obvious
Can you smell paracetamol? I know they taste absolutely horrible. So do they smell horrible?
-
Have you tried your paracetamol test yet? I am afflicted by a continually congested nose so I doubt if I can smell it. Off to try.
-
Have you tried your paracetamol test yet? I am afflicted by a continually congested nose so I doubt if I can smell it. Off to try.
i havent suggested a paracetamol test....if people want to beleive the earth is flat....i dont feela need to prove them wrong...but im at liberty tosay their idea is absurd. Afaiac...sils belief that humans and dogs have similar abilities to detect scent is in the same league as the flat earthers. Have there been any peer reviewed scientific studies to show the earth is round and not flat
-
Have you tried your paracetamol test yet? I am afflicted by a continually congested nose so I doubt if I can smell it. Off to try.
I can smell a paracetamol tablet held to my nose. If a dog could find a paracetamol tablet in a room they have better sense of smell than me.
-
If you believe it to be true...why are you attempting to train your dog as s cadaver dog....why don't you train yourself...
I would say that's because you know it isn't true
Whereas I would say it's clear you haven't thought things through.
-
Whereas I would say it's clear you haven't thought things through.
Then correct me if I'm wrong...dogs have a far superior ability for scent detection than humans...
-
Posting on topic....its absolutely ridiculous to claim that humans scent detection is anywhere near that of a dog...thats why dogs and not humans are used for scent detection..to claim otherwise is akin to claiming the earth is flat
-
Dogs can be trained to detect certain cancers, if doctors have the same olfactory ability as dogs why have they not been trained to do this? My question goes to SIL.
-
Dogs can be trained to detect certain cancers, if doctors have the same olfactory ability as dogs why have they not been trained to do this? My question goes to SIL.
If you can be bothered to post some evidence of this, I will be happy to look at it.
Otherwise ...
-
Evidence, it's common knowledge.
I wouldn't say it is common knowledge. Will a dog trained to sniff cancer pick up all types of cancer? Is there one particular odour on a person's breath if cancer is present? How do you train a dog to pick up cancer?
-
Maybe the science of this can't actually be resolved as no article or paper gives an actual figure on the number of times that canine olfaction is better than human.
Canines have evolved along a path whereby their hunting and hence survival depended on the ability to find their prey using their noses.
They also developed the pack, strength in numbers to tackle the larger prey animals. Did dogs resort to using tools?
Funny enough dogs have piggybacked off their relationship with humans and hence enjoy the benefit of tools without having to lose the dogginess e.g going for a ride in a car to the beach.
I'm curious to know if dogs actually think smells, we read words and picture the scene, do dogs do that with smells.
-
From personal experience, Cadaver odour is very distinctive but only really becomes apparent to the human nose when the body is fairly “ripe”.
-
I'm not sure where I heard it, I think it was in the Send in the Dogs video, but sniffer dogs need something else as well as a good nose. The breeds used are all gun dogs and they are bred to have a desire to work and to keep on working. So in the UK it's mostly labradors and springer or cocker spaniels.
-
If you can provide actual scientific evidence that dogs can smell better than humans, I'm happy to consider it. Until then ...
-
If you can provide actual scientific evidence that dogs can smell better than humans, I'm happy to consider it. Until then ...
Is it something like a brain scan that will convince you?
If it was possible to do a brain scan on a dog and a man both allowed to smell the same source. We'd look for increase in brain activity as the odour is brought within 1 meter of the subject.
If dogs showed a larger increase in brain activity would you accept that?
-
If you can provide actual scientific evidence that dogs can smell better than humans, I'm happy to consider it. Until then ...
It’s an accepted fact and I have provided numerous cites to that effect. You. on the other hand have made claims and provided not one single cite to back them up.
-
Here’s everything you need to know about the science of dogs olfactory system, peer reviewed and all I believe. Obviously it won’t impress those who believe they know everything about the subject already and who have a different view on the matter, but to the rest of us it really should be the last word on the subject.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5884888/#!po=0.746269
-
Here’s everything you need to know about the science of dogs olfactory system, peer reviewed and all I believe. Obviously it won’t impress those who believe they know everything about the subject already and who have a different view on the matter, but to the rest of us it really should be the last word on the subject.
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5884888/#!po=0.746269
Do I need to go beyond the abstract and introduction? Because it's boring and irrelevant.
Cite 2 is a study of n-amyl acetate, which has a scent akin to pears and apples.
Maybe they should get dog teams working on fruit farms?
Gonçalo likes many types of fruit, but he's not keen on strawberries. Perhaps I should fire him?
-
This 60 Minutes report is really interesting and on topic. They even give some dogs a MRI scan.
It points out that different breeds of dogs have been selected for certain traits, so not all will have the same ability for olfaction.
https://www.cbsnews.com/video/chaser-smartest-dog-in-world-60-minutes-2019-07-27/?fbclid=IwAR25IqQ6XhWDkRx6A0g_PVEmNOydyz4ukX607YY7Rb-S0KMCUuJT-HQC7iE
I recommend you watch it more than once. I personally think cats are smarter than dogs. Humans train dogs but cats train humans.
My cat knows how to give me signals and expects me to respond, but I struggle to get her to do anything I want her to do.
-
Do I need to go beyond the abstract and introduction? Because it's boring and irrelevant.
Cite 2 is a study of n-amyl acetate, which has a scent akin to pears and apples.
Maybe they should get dog teams working on fruit farms?
Gonçalo likes many types of fruit, but he's not keen on strawberries. Perhaps I should fire him?
You dismiss a 67 page science based report on the olfactory system of dogs which makes clear their superiority over humans in this respect as “boring and irrelevant” and then supply no counter cite of your own just (imo) facetious and idiotic questions. You are not imo a serious truth seeker, just someone with rather funny ideas. Not goading just saying how I see it.
-
This 60 Minutes report is really interesting and on topic. They even give some dogs a MRI scan.
It points out that different breeds of dogs have been selected for certain traits, so not all will have the same ability for olfaction.
https://www.cbsnews.com/video/chaser-smartest-dog-in-world-60-minutes-2019-07-27/?fbclid=IwAR25IqQ6XhWDkRx6A0g_PVEmNOydyz4ukX607YY7Rb-S0KMCUuJT-HQC7iE
I recommend you watch it more than once. I personally think cats are smarter than dogs. Humans train dogs but cats train humans.
My cat knows how to give me signals and expects me to respond, but I struggle to get her to do anything I want her to do.
So, when a dog finds that which it recognises, the reward centre in its brain lights up, but doesn't at other smells.
That's classic Vanessa Mae.
It might be Chaser was the dog that I saw and read about years ago, but I think that particular dog is probably dead by now.
A very interesting video. Many *&(+(+
-
I had a friend who owned a really splendid Bloodhound. She got very fed up with The Police asking if they could borrow this dog. In the end she refused because her dog became far more interested in tracking something or another than being a family pet.
Have you watched The Green Mile?
I am pretty positive that dogs are much better at this than people will ever be, although I have no idea for why. Excepting that it hadn't been dead for very long. If it had then humans can smell it, although I never have.
But it is a fact that dead bodies are often found by dog walkers.
O'Connor the Dachshund wouldn't have any trouble at all in finding a corpse long before I sniffed it. And oh my, he loves digging up anything, dead or alive.
I sat in bed for two nights last week, and couldn't understand a rather nasty smell. The bloomin cat, I thought. I wasn't wrong. One dead bird and an horrible mushy mouse under my bed. God knows what O'Connor would have done with those if he was allowed in my bedroom. It doesn't bear thinking of.
-
It is quite obvious to me that Dogs are better at this than Humans. But I don't feel inclined to stop SIL from expressing an opinion.
-
It is quite obvious to me that Dogs are better at this than Humans. But I don't feel inclined to stop SIL from expressing an opinion.
Of course he can express his opinion, stupid though it is imo. SIL believes that someone who performs autopsies would be able to tell if a dead body only an hour or so old had lain in a room two months earlier for a brief period. Personally I have trouble believing a dog could do it. I’m 100% certain a human couldn’t. And where Vanessa Mae fits into all of this God only knows. No cites at all from SIL while I have produced numerous cites to support the thread title and all of them have been sneered at by SIL. Is this acceptable or is it WUMing?
-
Any further flippant disruptive posting on this subject will attract sanctions. I have removed all the silliness.
-
Is it scientific to say dogs have a greater sense of olfaction than Humans?
There have been many different estimates used but what is the scientific answer.
Some interesting points raised here. https://youtu.be/Gf4k0VgCQjg
It says dogs have 15 times as many sensory cells as humans. But other adaptations as well, separate air pockets, high sniffing rate (5 times per second), breathing in and out through separate channels.
That a dog's nose is close to the ground is also important (not mentioned).
Don't know about being scientific but it is universally accepted that dogs and most other mammals for that matter have a much greater sense of smell than humans.
-
Don't know about being scientific but it is universally accepted that dogs and most other mammals for that matter have a much greater sense of smell than humans.
I notice my cat won't bother to taste her food if it doesn't smell right. (Well that is how I interpret what she does, for she doesn't say much.)
-
Don't know about being scientific but it is universally accepted that dogs and most other mammals for that matter have a much greater sense of smell than humans.
Of course it is... Some sense at last
-
Of course it is... Some sense at last
Where scientists have the difficulty is to put a figure on that. How many times better is it?
-
Where scientists have the difficulty is to put a figure on that. How many times better is it?
No one had tried to put a figure on it but there's plenty of scientific evidence to show dogs have a better sense of smell than humans.... That's why we have detection dogs
-
No one had tried to put a figure on it but there's plenty of scientific evidence to show dogs have a better sense of smell than humans.... That's why we have detection dogs
Scientists have.
-
Scientists have.
No one here... We just accept dogs are far better at scent detection
-
No one here... We just accept dogs are far better at scent detection
Accepting something is not actually scientific.
-
Accepting something is not actually scientific.
On Saturday I was watching qualification for the German GP.
My grandson popped his head into our living room, put down a bag of shopping, and went out again, closing the door behind him. The whole thing took no more than 2 seconds.
I smelled that he had been smoking, and it was simply tobacco, as opposed to containing marijuana.
As a life-long non-smoker, I hate tobacco smoke with a passion, so I'm quite sensitive to it.
While I watched the F1, my wife came in 5 minutes later and quietly scuttled through the living room, so as not to disturb me.
I got another distinct whiff of tobacco smoke. My wife stopped smoking around the year 2000, so that was secondary transfer.
People are not allowed to smoke in our car, so the actual smoking had taken place at least 20 mins earlier.
My dog did not alert to the smell of tobacco smoke. He was much more interested in doing a high-five with my wife.
Now I know for a fact that dogs are used at international airports to detect tobacco. So think the above true tale through carefully.
Is my cadaver dog a reject as a tobacco dog? Should my clearly superior sense of smell lead me to seek employment as a tobacco human?
This is still the Vanessa Mae effect. I do hope the spring clean has not thrown out Robitty's wonderful video of this, but I was prudent enough to capture the link.
&^^&*
-
I recall it was on 60 minutes but there is snippet on YT https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=omaHv5sxiFI.
-
On Saturday I was watching qualification for the German GP.
My grandson popped his head into our living room, put down a bag of shopping, and went out again, closing the door behind him. The whole thing took no more than 2 seconds.
I smelled that he had been smoking, and it was simply tobacco, as opposed to containing marijuana.
As a life-long non-smoker, I hate tobacco smoke with a passion, so I'm quite sensitive to it.
While I watched the F1, my wife came in 5 minutes later and quietly scuttled through the living room, so as not to disturb me.
I got another distinct whiff of tobacco smoke. My wife stopped smoking around the year 2000, so that was secondary transfer.
People are not allowed to smoke in our car, so the actual smoking had taken place at least 20 mins earlier.
My dog did not alert to the smell of tobacco smoke. He was much more interested in doing a high-five with my wife.
Now I know for a fact that dogs are used at international airports to detect tobacco. So think the above true tale through carefully.
Is my cadaver dog a reject as a tobacco dog? Should my clearly superior sense of smell lead me to seek employment as a tobacco human?
This is still the Vanessa Mae effect. I do hope the spring clean has not thrown out Robitty's wonderful video of this, but I was prudent enough to capture the link.
&^^&*
Why would you have expected your dog to alert to tobacco smoke? Do you think if you grandson had picked up a two hour old corpse two months previously and then briefly entered the room you would have been able to detect that? Even after receiving years of training? If so please explain why you believe so, many thanks.
-
*&^^&
On Saturday I was watching qualification for the German GP.
My grandson popped his head into our living room, put down a bag of shopping, and went out again, closing the door behind him. The whole thing took no more than 2 seconds.
I smelled that he had been smoking, and it was simply tobacco, as opposed to containing marijuana.
As a life-long non-smoker, I hate tobacco smoke with a passion, so I'm quite sensitive to it.
While I watched the F1, my wife came in 5 minutes later and quietly scuttled through the living room, so as not to disturb me.
I got another distinct whiff of tobacco smoke. My wife stopped smoking around the year 2000, so that was secondary transfer.
People are not allowed to smoke in our car, so the actual smoking had taken place at least 20 mins earlier.
My dog did not alert to the smell of tobacco smoke. He was much more interested in doing a high-five with my wife.
Now I know for a fact that dogs are used at international airports to detect tobacco. So think the above true tale through carefully.
Is my cadaver dog a reject as a tobacco dog? Should my clearly superior sense of smell lead me to seek employment as a tobacco human?
This is still the Vanessa Mae effect. I do hope the spring clean has not thrown out Robitty's wonderful video of this, but I was prudent enough to capture the link.
&^^&*
I find it odd you think Mae has no natural talent and her skill is simply a product of practice..do you think anyone could reach her level of skill given enough practice time
And of course how do you know your dog did not detect the tobacco smoke
-
its alittle known fact that there is no scientific evidence to show that jumping out of a plane is safer with or without a parachute...no scientific studies......
-
its alittle known fact that there is no scientific evidence to show that jumping out of a plane is safer with or without a parachute...no scientific studies......
Do you know why? There were no volunteers for the second part of the experiment.
-
Do you know why? There were no volunteers for the second part of the experiment.
there has been no experiment...no scientific studies. ....
-
there has been no experiment...no scientific studies. ....
As I said they couldn't get the experiment off the ground.
-
As I said they couldn't get the experiment off the ground.
yes I know...so theres no scientific evidence
-
yes I know...so theres no scientific evidence
I'll let you win, just this time mind you.
-
there has been no experiment...no scientific studies. ....
Care to participate in the first one? I'll pay for the plane. I'll even do the control myself.
-
Care to participate in the first one? I'll pay for the plane. I'll even do the control myself.
i have enough sense to know taht scientific validation isnt always needed...some things are just so obvious...thats the point I was making...wold have thought you would have realised
-
i have enough sense to know taht scientific validation isnt always needed...some things are just so obvious...thats the point I was making...wold have thought you would have realised
But we demand scientific proof.
-
Why was my post about training Eddie to play the violin removed?
-
Why was my post about training Eddie to play the violin removed?
Well it wasn't me.
-
Well it wasn't me.
If humans can be trained to be as good as dogs then surely it stands to reason that the reverse is true? If not why not?
-
If humans can be trained to be as good as dogs then surely it stands to reason that the reverse is true? If not why not?
Dogs don't live long enough. Humans might be 23 -24 by the time they have finished their degree. Most dogs don't see their 12th birthday.
-
Dogs don't live long enough. Humans might be 23 -24 by the time they have finished their degree. Most dogs don't see their 12th birthday.
Dogs can run about almost from birth. Perhaps we could train human babies to start running before they can walk. Alternatively, when they are crawling about perhaps we could give them cadaver detection training that they can take with them into adulthood.
-
Why would you have expected your dog to alert to tobacco smoke? Do you think if you grandson had picked up a two hour old corpse two months previously and then briefly entered the room you would have been able to detect that? Even after receiving years of training? If so please explain why you believe so, many thanks.
I'll be happy to answer your questions if you have the decency to answer mine. *&(+(+
-
Do you know why? There were no volunteers for the second part of the experiment.
Scientific studies have to pass an ethics committee.
This wouldn't.
It's a strawman.
-
Dogs can run about almost from birth. Perhaps we could train human babies to start running before they can walk. Alternatively, when they are crawling about perhaps we could give them cadaver detection training that they can take with them into adulthood.
It is easier to balance on 4 legs for sure.
-
I'll be happy to answer your questions if you have the decency to answer mine. *&(+(+
No and no. Now it’s your turn.
-
Why was my post about training Eddie to play the violin removed?
When was it made?
I booted a complaint up to Sir and an enormous chunk of the thread was expunged. That's why I was worried about the potential loss of Robitty's most excellent dog brain video. It would appear that Sir just looked at where the fractiousness set in, and wiped the whole block thereafter. I presume he is far too busy to sift through a vast amount of dross trying to work out if anything can be salvaged from such wreckage.
-
When was it made?
I booted a complaint up to Sir and an enormous chunk of the thread was expunged. That's why I was worried about the potential loss of Robitty's most excellent dog brain video. It would appear that Sir just looked at where the fractiousness set in, and wiped the whole block thereafter. I presume he is far too busy to sift through a vast amount of dross trying to work out if anything can be salvaged from such wreckage.
I think you may have hit the nail on the head there.
-
When was it made?
I booted a complaint up to Sir and an enormous chunk of the thread was expunged. That's why I was worried about the potential loss of Robitty's most excellent dog brain video. It would appear that Sir just looked at where the fractiousness set in, and wiped the whole block thereafter. I presume he is far too busy to sift through a vast amount of dross trying to work out if anything can be salvaged from such wreckage.
thi morning after the great expunging. I asked if Eddie could have been trained to play the violin as well as Vanessa Mae.
-
thi morning after the great expunging. I asked if Eddie could have been trained to play the violin as well as Vanessa Mae.
The screeching violin hurts a dog's sensitive ears.
-
No and no. Now it’s your turn.
I shall be as communicative with you as you were with me.
Don't.
No idea.
No idea.
As ye sow so shall ye reap.
-
thi morning after the great expunging. I asked if Eddie could have been trained to play the violin as well as Vanessa Mae.
From memory, I think it takes around 17,000 hours of training to get to world class.
I haven't worked out how many years that takes for a human, but as Robitty pointed out, Eddie would have died before completion.
-
Why was my post about training Eddie to play the violin removed?
Because you were insinuating that Grime was on the fiddle?
That's all I got.
-
Because you were insinuating that Grime was on the fiddle?
That's all I got.
If Grime was on the fiddle and Eddie was on the violin they would be a formidable duet.
-
From memory, I think it takes around 17,000 hours of training to get to world class.
I haven't worked out how many years that takes for a human, but as Robitty pointed out, Eddie would have died before completion.
Not everyone can attain world class... It needs natural ability too
-
Not everyone can attain world class... It needs natural ability too
For things like sprinting, quite possibly.
But the thread title is not about things like sprinting. *&^^&
-
I shall be as communicative with you as you were with me.
Don't.
No idea.
No idea.
As ye sow so shall ye reap.
Really? No idea?? Yes I think that’s the most sensible thing you’ve contributed to this thread.
-
From memory, I think it takes around 17,000 hours of training to get to world class.
I haven't worked out how many years that takes for a human, but as Robitty pointed out, Eddie would have died before completion.
I believe VM was something of a child prodigy starting violin at 4 following piano lessons, by 8 she was already approaching world class. Let’s say we give Eddie 4 hours violin training for the first 8 years of his life. That’s ruffly (sic) 12,000 hours. What grade violin would you expect him to have reached by then?
-
For things like sprinting, quite possibly.
But the thread title is not about things like sprinting. *&^^&
In your opinion... Mozart just practised a lot
-
In fact rather than teach Eddie the violin, why not teach him to speak? It only takes a human child a few years to make thmselves fully understood and his vocab need not have been great, just words like “I smell cadaver”, “toss me that cuddly toy” “McCanns dunnit” and “sausages” would have sufficed.
-
In fact rather than teach Eddie the violin, why not teach him to speak? It only takes a human child a few years to make thmselves fully understood and his vocab need not have been great, just words like “I smell cadaver”, “toss me that cuddly toy” “McCanns dunnit” and “sausages” would have sufficed.
Our dog speaks to us all the time. Every dog owner will tell you that. &^^&*
-
I believe VM was something of a child prodigy starting violin at 4 following piano lessons, by 8 she was already approaching world class. Let’s say we give Eddie 4 hours violin training for the first 8 years of his life. That’s ruffly (sic) 12,000 hours. What grade violin would you expect him to have reached by then?
I think you are misunderstanding or misrepresenting Vanessa Mae's life.
And you are misunderstanding or misrepresenting Eddie's capabilities.
What has this to do with the thread topic?
-
In your opinion... Motzart just practiced a lot
Is that my opinion, or your opinion?
Or your opinion of what you think is my opinion?
It would help if you typed properly.
-
Is that my opinion, or your opinion?
Or your opinion of what you think is my opinion?
It would help if you typed properly.
Natural ability plays a major part in almost every skill.
Sports... Football, tennis. Golf... Swimming.. Etc etc
Then we have art... Did Davinci have talent or did he just practice a lot... Music... Pavarotti... Has he just practiced or does he have natural talent. Einstein.. Meths ohysics
I would think you've had no experience of children learning music... Some struggle and some shine..
Practice makes you good but to be world class you need practice and talent... Very few can achieve the level of Vanessa Mae... There's probably a million chinese trying
-
Natural ability plays a major part in almost every skill.
Sports... Football, tennis. Golf... Swimming.. Etc etc
Then we have art... Did Davinci have talent or did he just practice a lot... Music... Pavarotti... Has he just practiced or does he have natural talent. Einstein.. Meths ohysics
I would think you've had no experience of children learning music... Some struggle and some shine..
Practice makes you good but to be world class you need practice and talent... Very few can achieve the level of Vanessa Mae... There's probably a million chinese trying
Whereas, with the right kit, I'm confident I could teach Gonçalo to be world class in playing music.
Vanessa Mae rocks!
How much is that doggie in the window?
-
I believe VM was something of a child prodigy starting violin at 4 following piano lessons, by 8 she was already approaching world class. Let’s say we give Eddie 4 hours violin training for the first 8 years of his life. That’s ruffly (sic) 12,000 hours. What grade violin would you expect him to have reached by then?
A chewed up one.
(https://encrypted-tbn0.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQ3MMZ2SRengbkTnPdBX8I5yIXBZvAq7J1VP9pnQcLBky33zgSr)
-
In fact rather than teach Eddie the violin, why not teach him to speak? It only takes a human child a few years to make thmselves fully understood and his vocab need not have been great, just words like “I smell cadaver”, “toss me that cuddly toy” “McCanns dunnit” and “sausages” would have sufficed.
To a good handler he probably already does say all those but in Dog language. It would be impossible AFAIK to get a dog to speak in English, but some might have mastered a single word.
Especially a "Yes" as in "Do you want a bone?" To which the dog replies "Yip Yip"
"Marc Métral and his talking dog Wendy wow the judges | Audition Week 1 | Britain's Got Talent 2015"
https://youtu.be/1inR2b7PS5M It will put a smile on your face at a minimum.
-
I think you are misunderstanding or misrepresenting Vanessa Mae's life.
And you are misunderstanding or misrepresenting Eddie's capabilities.
What has this to do with the thread topic?
In what way am I misunderstanding Vanessa Mae’s life? Do tell, and remember you kept banging on about Vanessa Mae which is entirely unrelated to this topic afaic.
-
Whereas, with the right kit, I'm confident I could teach Gonçalo to be world class in playing music.
Vanessa Mae rocks!
How much is that doggie in the window?
What sort of kit would you need?
-
What sort of kit would you need?
Something like a remotely controlled "foreleg"
-
In what way am I misunderstanding Vanessa Mae’s life? Do tell, and remember you kept banging on about Vanessa Mae which is entirely unrelated to this topic afaic.
Her life story is pretty awful, IMO.
I'm banging on about the Vanessa Mae effect. If you prefer, try Pavlov or operant conditioning.
We covered all this a long time back.
-
Her life story is pretty awful, IMO.
I'm banging on about the Vanessa Mae effect. If you prefer, try Pavlov or operant conditioning.
We covered all this a long time back.
I'd like you to explain the Vanessa Mae effect once again?
-
Her life story is pretty awful, IMO.
I'm banging on about the Vanessa Mae effect. If you prefer, try Pavlov or operant conditioning.
We covered all this a long time back.
you will find there are millions of children...tens perhaps hundreds going through the same hot housing...at least she had the talent to actually make it
-
I'd like you to explain the Vanessa Mae effect once again?
imo...sil wont explain it ...because there is no such thing..
-
imo...sil wont explain it ...because there is no such thing..
One can always make up new terms, it just needs some explanation. There is googled and I'm sure there is a Vanessa Mae effect.
-
One can always make up new terms, it just needs some explanation. There is googled and I'm sure there is a Vanessa Mae effect.
no there isnt....cite......Ive no problem with sil making terms up...but it should be understood thats whats it is...so cite for vanessa mae effect....put it in google ...se what comes up...nothing
-
Something like a remotely controlled "foreleg"
I've just read this post totally in isolation, not having read back. I actually want one.
-
What sort of kit would you need?
At this moment, I'm thinking of a 7 pad pawpad, A - G, a computer connection, sound capability, and some simple software to drive the pawpad.
'How much is that doggie in the window' uses C and G7. I don't reckon I can teach Gonk to do 7ths, so the software would set up to play G7 when Gonk pressed the G pad.
'One man went to mow, went to mow a meadow, one man and his dog, went to mow a meadow' requires C and G, so the software would set the pawpad to play a G when Gonk pressed the G pad.
-
there has been no experiment...no scientific studies. ....
There wouldn’t be, it is applied science.
-
I'd like you to explain the Vanessa Mae effect once again?
Training. If you wish to be picky, that includes learning.
Go back and view your dog video again. It's classic Vanessa Mae effect.
-
There wouldn’t be, it is applied science.
so you think the reason no tests have been done is because its applied science... I can think of a much simpler reason
-
Training. If you wish to be picky, that includes learning.
Go back and view your dog video again. It's classic Vanessa Mae effect.
so we can confirm...the vanessa mae effect is a term you have invented to explain the more you practice the better you get
-
Why was my post about training Eddie to play the violin removed?
Why was my post quoting your post removed? Kinell, my ratio of posts / deletion is running at about 1/3.
Good job all of human endeavour is futile, otherwise I'd be very cross.
-
At this moment, I'm thinking of a 7 pad pawpad, A - G, a computer connection, sound capability, and some simple software to drive the pawpad.
'How much is that doggie in the window' uses C and G7. I don't reckon I can teach Gonk to do 7ths, so the software would set up to play G7 when Gonk pressed the G pad.
'One man went to mow, went to mow a meadow, one man and his dog, went to mow a meadow' requires C and G, so the software would set the pawpad to play a G when Gonk pressed the G pad.
Whats’s wrong with a simple violin and bow like what Vanessa trained on?
-
Why was my post quoting your post removed? Kinell, my ratio of posts / deletion is running at about 1/3.
Good job all of human endeavour is futile, otherwise I'd be very cross.
I wished I’d read it, I bet it was worth the price of admission.
-
I wished I’d read it, I bet it was worth the price of admission.
It was too. Sadly it's been consigned to Room 101, where this exchange is inevitably destined, stricken from the record by an unseen hand.
I would have liked to have seen your original 'violin' post first hand.
-
It was too. Sadly it's been consigned to Room 101, where this exchange is inevitably destined, stricken from the record by an unseen hand.
I would have liked to have seen your original 'violin' post first hand.
It was a classic @)(++(*
-
At this moment, I'm thinking of a 7 pad pawpad, A - G, a computer connection, sound capability, and some simple software to drive the pawpad.
'How much is that doggie in the window' uses C and G7. I don't reckon I can teach Gonk to do 7ths, so the software would set up to play G7 when Gonk pressed the G pad.
'One man went to mow, went to mow a meadow, one man and his dog, went to mow a meadow' requires C and G, so the software would set the pawpad to play a G when Gonk pressed the G pad.
how long before zonc could play paganninis 5th caprice...thats one of my all time favourites played on the electric guitar by my dear son...hes good... hes excellent ...but million miles away from being world class
-
At this moment, I'm thinking of a 7 pad pawpad, A - G, a computer connection, sound capability, and some simple software to drive the pawpad.
'How much is that doggie in the window' uses C and G7. I don't reckon I can teach Gonk to do 7ths, so the software would set up to play G7 when Gonk pressed the G pad.
'One man went to mow, went to mow a meadow, one man and his dog, went to mow a meadow' requires C and G, so the software would set the pawpad to play a G when Gonk pressed the G pad.
intersting point...if you look at the beatles...early songs ...C F G7 Am....but then they learnt to play the guitar
-
Whats’s wrong with a simple violin and bow like what Vanessa trained on?
Doggie tucking a violin into his neck, fingering with his left paw whilst bowing with his right paw?
It's easier to hire Vanessa Mae.
-
Doggie tucking a violin into his neck, fingering with his left paw whilst bowing with his right paw?
It's easier to hire Vanessa Mae.
Why not? All it takes is a bit of training, same as humans being trained to alert to the presence of a corpse that had once lain in situ briefly in a room a couple of months previously. Whilst biologically and anatomically they may not have the same advantages as dogs a few years training would soon fix that.
-
Doggie tucking a violin into his neck, fingering with his left paw whilst bowing with his right paw?
It's easier to hire Vanessa Mae.
in your opinion... i actually think youve got more chance of your dog doing just that than you have of hiring Vanessa
-
how long before zonc could play paganninis 5th caprice...thats one of my all time favourites played on the electric guitar by my dear son...hes good... hes excellent ...but million miles away from being world class
I have no reason to disagree with your assessment of your son. How's his car doing, by the way?
I think Robitty's dog video features Chaser. That dog is world class.
-
I have no reason to disagree with your assessment of your son. How's his car doing, by the way?
I think Robitty's dog video features Chaser. That dog is world class.
thats a diferent son...the musician is the one who studied medicine at leicester....hes in adelaide at the moment...the NHS are flying him and his family back business...supplying 3 months accomodation ...so he can prop up the failing NHS
-
thats a diferent son...the musician is the one who studied medicine at leicester....hes in adelaide at the moment...the NHS are flying him and his family back business...supplying 3 months accomodation ...so he can prop up the failing NHS
Adelaide? Shame, if I'd known he was there, he could answer so many pertinent questions.
Kindly ask him to look out for drug doggies on departure and arrival. I'm not suggesting he is doing anything illegal. I'd just like to know if he gets screened by a doggie or not.
I wish your family bon voyage.
-
Adelaide? Shame, if I'd known he was there, he could answer so many pertinent questions.
Kindly ask him to look out for drug doggies on departure and arrival. I'm not suggesting he is doing anything illegal. I'd just like to know if he gets screened by a doggie or not.
I wish your family bon voyage.
I actually got screened and alerted to in Sydney.. Ive posted the details before... Just an extensive search of my suitcase... Probing questions to se if I started to sweat... And I was let on my way
-
I actually got screened and alerted to in Sydney.. Ive posted the details before... Just an extensive search of my suitcase... Probing questions to se if I started to sweat... And I was let on my way
Crikey!
And had you been handling anything to cause a dog to alert?
-
no there isnt....cite......Ive no problem with sil making terms up...but it should be understood thats whats it is...so cite for vanessa mae effect....put it in google ...se what comes up...nothing
It doesn't have to be on Google to google it. It just has to be defined in SIL's head.
-
I've just read this post totally in isolation, not having read back. I actually want one.
That is similar to how the French man made his dog "talk" on BGT. It had a remotely control mouth and he was a ventriloquist. His batteries must have been playing up for every time he had to make the dog "talk" the hand with the remote control had to be moved closer to the dog.
-
I actually got screened and alerted to in Sydney.. Ive posted the details before... Just an extensive search of my suitcase... Probing questions to se if I started to sweat... And I was let on my way
Did they give you a roll with poppy seeds on during the flight?
-
so you think the reason no tests have been done is because its applied science... I can think of a much simpler reason
Parachuting is an application of science.
-
Parachuting is an application of science.
if so then everything is an application of science.
-
if so then everything is an application of science.
Of the sciences that I know at advanced level, there is a theoretical branch and an applied branch.
I can't see why it would be different in any other science.
-
if so then everything is an application of science.
In the literal sense, I suppose that's true. We are the living embodiment of our scientific discoveries.
Are we still talking about parachutes?
-
Parachuting is an application of science.
Stating the obvious
-
Stating the obvious
It’s why you don’t test the science.
-
It’s why you don’t test the science.
Einstein said time is relative... I would say that's pure science... And it's been tested
-
Einstein said time is relative... I would say that's pure science... And it's been tested
There have been enough times people have got rid of their relatives by tampering with their parachutes to know "that time is relative" if you leap from a plane without a parachute. You don't need to be Einstein to know that.
-
There have been enough times people have got rid of their relatives by tampering with their parachutes to know "that time is relative" if you leap from a plane without a parachute. You don't need to be Einstein to know that.
never said you did...but theres no scientific evidence to support it
-
never said you did...but there's no scientific evidence to support it
There will be DNA and fingerprints all over the crime scene.
-
There have been enough times people have got rid of their relatives by tampering with their parachutes to know "that time is relative" if you leap from a plane without a parachute. You don't need to be Einstein to know that.
https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2018/jun/15/emile-cilliers-army-sergeant-jailed-for-tampering-with-wife-parachute
"British sergeant jailed for life for tampering with wife's parachute"