UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: G-Unit on July 28, 2019, 10:21:36 AM

Title: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: G-Unit on July 28, 2019, 10:21:36 AM
Some people are convinced that the T9 were not involved in Madeleine's disappearance. I've seen many reasons quoted but none of them stands up to scrutiny in my opinion. What is the evidence which has convinced people to look elsewhere for an explanation?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Eleanor on July 28, 2019, 10:31:51 AM

Logistics.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: G-Unit on July 28, 2019, 10:39:39 AM
Logistics.

Thank you Eleanor. Which evidence has convinced you that it was logistically impossible?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 28, 2019, 10:43:57 AM
Some people are convinced that the T9 were not involved in Madeleine's disappearance. I've seen many reasons quoted but none of them stands up to scrutiny in my opinion. What is the evidence which has convinced people to look elsewhere for an explanation?


Consciously involved G?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: alphonse on July 28, 2019, 11:05:05 AM
I think logistics rule out Mr and Mrs Mc Cann
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Eleanor on July 28, 2019, 11:08:25 AM
Thank you Eleanor. Which evidence has convinced you that it was logistically impossible?

I am not feeling very bright this morning, and I sometimes lose words.  Moon Phases I suspect.

But it seems to me that it was logistically impossible for The McCanns to have been involved in the disappearance of their daughter and subsequent disposal of Madeleine's body in a place that  of which they had no knowledge.

I won't bore you all with the suggestions that have been made.  We all know what they are.  But to me, not one of them is even remotely related to common sense.

No body has ever been found, and since it cannot have been taken very far, why do you think this is?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 28, 2019, 11:15:03 AM
There is a school of thought that the files cannot be relied upon because of  translations, take this into consideration and is it impossible that there is a window of opportunity.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 28, 2019, 11:18:04 AM
I think logistics rule out Mr and Mrs Mc Cann

Based on what?

There is a school of thought that the files cannot be relied upon because of  translations, take this into consideration and is it impossible that there is a window of opportunity.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Eleanor on July 28, 2019, 11:18:51 AM
There is a school of thought that the files cannot be relied upon because of  translations, take this into consideration and is it impossible that there is a window of opportunity.

There were windows of opportunity, albeit restricted.  But how long do you think it would have taken to uplift a small child?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 28, 2019, 11:21:58 AM
There were windows of opportunity, albeit restricted.  But how long do you think it would have taken to uplift a small child?

The same for both scenarios.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 28, 2019, 11:22:13 AM
There were windows of opportunity, albeit restricted.  But how long do you think it would have taken to uplift a small child?

I don't know. What's your estimate ?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Eleanor on July 28, 2019, 11:40:30 AM
The same for both scenarios.

You don't get to dispose of a body during a small window of opportunity.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Eleanor on July 28, 2019, 11:41:24 AM
I don't know. What's your estimate ?

Maximum five minutes.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 28, 2019, 11:44:57 AM
You don't get to dispose of a body during a small window of opportunity.


Actual disposal - (the final solution) - might have been later during a larger window of oportunity.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 28, 2019, 11:50:12 AM
Logistics.
this. When someone comes up with a logical and plausible scenario of how this crime could have been achieved taking into account all the known facts I will be open to revising my opinion, however I’ve waited over 12 years to hear one and still not one has been put forward. 
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 28, 2019, 11:51:06 AM
You don't get to dispose of a body during a small window of opportunity.

It may have been placed for another move,but this failed.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 28, 2019, 11:52:09 AM
You don't get to dispose of a body during a small window of opportunity.

Well practised in this art?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: alphonse on July 28, 2019, 11:54:07 AM
To answer Barrier I don´t think Gerry was away from the table for long enough. Added to this is Jez´s impression that he would have to be the best actor in the world to be chatting to him while knowing his daughter lay dead and he had to shift the body. Also, it seems to me Gerry could not be Smithman. The Smith´s grandson said this man was wearing a long coat or a dark jacket. Silvia said Gerry was wearing a dark shirt. Are we sure Smithman is the suspect? 0f course not but it is one of the few things to go on in this case. No strange sightings of cars, Jane´s sighting discounted by SY--- Mrs Totman telling press they think this was Dr Totman etc.

 To me the perp is likely an Anglo or at least someone who understands English and quite likely between 30 and 40 years old.  He is also someone who either had access to the checking info or stumbled across it either visually as the Mc Canns said good night to their friends on the way up the hill every night or through loose talk about the partying doctors and their unusual checking regime
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: pathfinder73 on July 28, 2019, 12:02:02 PM
I am not feeling very bright this morning, and I sometimes lose words.  Moon Phases I suspect.

But it seems to me that it was logistically impossible for The McCanns to have been involved in the disappearance of their daughter and subsequent disposal of Madeleine's body in a place that  of which they had no knowledge.

I won't bore you all with the suggestions that have been made.  We all know what they are.  But to me, not one of them is even remotely related to common sense.

No body has ever been found, and since it cannot have been taken very far, why do you think this is?

So does a detective on Adrian Prout's account but he did it! You will be surprised by what perps can do.
 
A senior detective who played a key role in jailing wife killer Adrian Prout said he still has doubts over his explanation of how he concealed her body, a decade her murder.

But Detective Superintendent David Sellwood said this week that the ‘window of opportunity’ to dispose of the body was ‘very small’.


https://www.gloucestershirelive.co.uk/news/gloucester-news/prout-killer-detectives-doubts-remain-712576
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: alphonse on July 28, 2019, 12:02:26 PM
...................but I have to make it clear, if the Smith sighting is just an innocent father then I think the perp could be anyone, not just someone who understood English.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Eleanor on July 28, 2019, 12:10:04 PM

Actual disposal - (the final solution) - might have been later during a larger window of oportunity.

I do so admire your imagination.  What do you think The McCanns did with the body in the meantime?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Eleanor on July 28, 2019, 12:12:03 PM
Well practised in this art?

Oh, I see.  The McCanns had done this before than.  Now there's a thought.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: pathfinder73 on July 28, 2019, 12:13:55 PM
...................but I have to make it clear, if the Smith sighting is just an innocent father then I think the perp could be anyone, not just someone who understood English.

If he was innocent he would not be hiding. No record of Smithman's child at the creche that night. He is the missing link.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Eleanor on July 28, 2019, 12:15:06 PM
So does a detective on Adrian Prout's account but he did it! You will be surprised by what perps can do.
 
A senior detective who played a key role in jailing wife killer Adrian Prout said he still has doubts over his explanation of how he concealed her body, a decade her murder.

But Detective Superintendent David Sellwood said this week that the ‘window of opportunity’ to dispose of the body was ‘very small’.


https://www.gloucestershirelive.co.uk/news/gloucester-news/prout-killer-detectives-doubts-remain-712576

Didn't Adrian Prout dig a hole down in the woods?  How long did that take?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 28, 2019, 12:15:26 PM
I do so admire your imagination.  What do you think The McCanns did with the body in the meantime?

Well, Spammy had the idea of popping it in a bin, so maybe that's what happened with later retrieval.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Eleanor on July 28, 2019, 12:17:34 PM
Well, Spammy had the idea of popping it in a bin, so maybe that's what happened with later retrieval.

So The Bins weren't emptied then.  They must have been stinking.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 28, 2019, 12:29:33 PM
this. When someone comes up with a logical and plausible scenario of how this crime could have been achieved taking into account all the known facts I will be open to revising my opinion, however I’ve waited over 12 years to hear one and still not one has been put forward.

That would be because of the strict moderating.  No one to say anything against the McCanns - accused of libel accused or trolling and h8ting.

Well done G for getting it accepted as a real opportunity to discuss this.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Eleanor on July 28, 2019, 12:31:56 PM
That would be because of the strict moderating.  No one to say anything against the McCanns - accused of libel accused or trolling and h8ting.

Well done G for getting it accepted as a real opportunity to discuss this.

What absolute nonsense.  The McCanns are frequently Libelled on this Forum. even by innuendo alone.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: pathfinder73 on July 28, 2019, 12:42:01 PM
Didn't Adrian Prout dig a hole down in the woods?  How long did that take?

I wouldn't believe a word he said.

“He admitted the murder and told us of the circumstances of how he did it,” said Det Supt Sellwood. “But I was not convinced of the chronology of events from the killing of Kate to concealing the body.

“He had from the time he killed her in the evening to the morning of the next day when he hosted a shoot.

“It was a big job, the hole he dug was 5ft deep and 5ft long. He worked in the pipe laying business and was a farmer but it was still a big job.

“She was buried in the woods. We will never know how much planning went in to his actions.

“He buried her inside a pheasant pen, under a feeder, with pheasants all over it.

“We had highly trained dogs involved but he did it in a very convincing way.

“When he took police to identify the site, even he struggled to do it.

“He took us to the pen but he could not say where she lay. Almost the whole pen was dug up. She had been buried right on the edge of the area he identified.”


Farm left, body location right
(https://i2-prod.gloucestershirelive.co.uk/news/gloucester-news/article713743.ece/ALTERNATES/s615b/16765862.jpg)
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 28, 2019, 12:55:19 PM
To answer Barrier I don´t think Gerry was away from the table for long enough. Added to this is Jez´s impression that he would have to be the best actor in the world to be chatting to him while knowing his daughter lay dead and he had to shift the body. Also, it seems to me Gerry could not be Smithman. The Smith´s grandson said this man was wearing a long coat or a dark jacket. Silvia said Gerry was wearing a dark shirt. Are we sure Smithman is the suspect? 0f course not but it is one of the few things to go on in this case. No strange sightings of cars, Jane´s sighting discounted by SY--- Mrs Totman telling press they think this was Dr Totman etc.

 To me the perp is likely an Anglo or at least someone who understands English and quite likely between 30 and 40 years old.  He is also someone who either had access to the checking info or stumbled across it either visually as the Mc Canns said good night to their friends on the way up the hill every night or through loose talk about the partying doctors and their unusual checking regime

Thats if you accept the files as an absolute,there seems enough doubt in some quarters on their accuracy because of translations,so there must be some doubt on the timings.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: faithlilly on July 28, 2019, 01:01:57 PM
So The Bins weren't emptied then.  They must have been stinking.

The bins were emptied in the early hours of the 4th...I would assume this prohibited a proper search of them. Once the body is in the refuse system unless it is being specifically looked for there is a good chance it will never be found.

IF the parents were involved and IF Madeleine was sedated then a bin would be the perfect solution. Once the search began there was a good chance that the bin would be searched and the body found...the sedation would be blamed on the abductor, the body would receive a decent burial and so on. Unfortunately what the parents couldn’t have known is the time the bins were emptied, leaving very little time for the body to be found.

As to opportunity, we have no way of knowing how honest or accurate the tapas timeline is.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 28, 2019, 01:05:32 PM
To answer Barrier I don´t think Gerry was away from the table for long enough. Added to this is Jez´s impression that he would have to be the best actor in the world to be chatting to him while knowing his daughter lay dead and he had to shift the body. Also, it seems to me Gerry could not be Smithman. The Smith´s grandson said this man was wearing a long coat or a dark jacket. Silvia said Gerry was wearing a dark shirt. Are we sure Smithman is the suspect? 0f course not but it is one of the few things to go on in this case. No strange sightings of cars, Jane´s sighting discounted by SY--- Mrs Totman telling press they think this was Dr Totman etc.

 To me the perp is likely an Anglo or at least someone who understands English and quite likely between 30 and 40 years old.  He is also someone who either had access to the checking info or stumbled across it either visually as the Mc Canns said good night to their friends on the way up the hill every night or through loose talk about the partying doctors and their unusual checking regime


What we know from whom ever Tanner saw is that he himself saw nothing suspicious,how is this known,Redwood the DSI at the time.
https://youtu.be/1-4fp4kPi60
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 28, 2019, 01:06:50 PM
The bins were emptied in the early hours of the 4th...I would assume this prohibited a proper search of them. Once the body is in the refuse system unless it is being specifically looked for there is a good chance it will never be found.

IF the parents were involved and IF Madeleine was sedated then a bin would be the perfect solution. Once the search began there was a good chance that the bin would be searched and the body found...the sedation would be blamed on the abductor, the body would receive a decent burial and so on. Unfortunately what the parents couldn’t have known is the time the bins were emptied, leaving very little time for the body to be found.

As to opportunity, we have no way of knowing how honest or accurate the tapas timeline is.


Corrie McKeague was looked for but not found.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: alphonse on July 28, 2019, 01:06:59 PM
Yes, Smithman is about the only potential lead there is.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: faithlilly on July 28, 2019, 01:08:30 PM

Corrie McKeague was looked for but not found.

Madeleine wasn’t even looked for.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: pathfinder73 on July 28, 2019, 01:09:35 PM
The bins were emptied in the early hours of the 4th...I would assume this prohibited a proper search of them. Once the body is in the refuse system unless it is being specifically looked for there is a good chance it will never be found.

IF the parents were involved and IF Madeleine was sedated then a bin would be the perfect solution. Once the search began there was a good chance that the bin would be searched and the body found...the sedation would be blamed on the abductor, the body would receive a decent burial and so on. Unfortunately what the parents couldn’t have known is the time the bins were emptied, leaving very little time for the body to be found.

As to opportunity, we have no way of knowing how honest or accurate the tapas timeline is.

Did any searchers that night report seeing bins being emptied?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 28, 2019, 01:23:46 PM
To answer Barrier I don´t think Gerry was away from the table for long enough. Added to this is Jez´s impression that he would have to be the best actor in the world to be chatting to him while knowing his daughter lay dead and he had to shift the body. Also, it seems to me Gerry could not be Smithman. The Smith´s grandson said this man was wearing a long coat or a dark jacket. Silvia said Gerry was wearing a dark shirt. Are we sure Smithman is the suspect? 0f course not but it is one of the few things to go on in this case. No strange sightings of cars, Jane´s sighting discounted by SY--- Mrs Totman telling press they think this was Dr Totman etc.

 To me the perp is likely an Anglo or at least someone who understands English and quite likely between 30 and 40 years old.  He is also someone who either had access to the checking info or stumbled across it either visually as the Mc Canns said good night to their friends on the way up the hill every night or through loose talk about the partying doctors and their unusual checking regime


"To answer Barrier I don´t think Gerry was away from the table for long enough."

You are makig that statement based on what you are being told, there is no independant witnesess, however, it was noted by JT -in the panorama video that he did take longer than was expected for his check- Gerry in turn gave a reason about seeing his daughter and gazing at her lovingly,before/ after using the toilet.

"Added to this is Jez´s impression that he would have to be the best actor in the world to be chatting to him while knowing his daughter lay dead and he had to shift the body."


There are many videos of interviews  of the parents talking-while being adamant (convincing the public) a paedo gang stole their daughter.
Their behaviour is bizarre to say the least.

First interview: they refuse to answer stage managed questions- they do not accept blame they talk around it- they constantly refer to any negative take on  the events  as giving excuses the other parents do it and  we have had great support.

They also  erm um had to grieve but are much stronger now- my words in RED italics"probably IMO because they sold the abductor story successfully had legal,government, and financial support"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zzKS6HnTKOM

For a couple who claimed their daughter was snatched by a paedophile gang- they find time to have a wee laugh now and then... Nlot to mention their dinner dates for light relief from messrs Freud.

https://crimerocket.com/2019/03/18/have-the-mccanns-been-playing-us-for-fools-for-the-past-12-years/


Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: faithlilly on July 28, 2019, 01:30:35 PM
Did any searchers that night report seeing bins being emptied?

Not sure I’ve seen any reports from searchers.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Billy Whizz Fan Club on July 28, 2019, 01:31:10 PM
I am not feeling very bright this morning, and I sometimes lose words.  Moon Phases I suspect.

But it seems to me that it was logistically impossible for The McCanns to have been involved in the disappearance of their daughter and subsequent disposal of Madeleine's body in a place that  of which they had no knowledge.

I won't bore you all with the suggestions that have been made.  We all know what they are.  But to me, not one of them is even remotely related to common sense.

No body has ever been found, and since it cannot have been taken very far, why do you think this is?

If a body was moved in the car then logistically Smithman could have carried MM to a car belonging to a third party and the third party must have used a freezer to store a body until a later removal - I would suggest the date of this move would be the date of the beef/shrimp spillage if anyone can pin that down - logistically though it seems possible, IMO. Another option also possible is Smuthman carrying MM to another property Again it is logistically possible.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Billy Whizz Fan Club on July 28, 2019, 01:32:43 PM
There were windows of opportunity, albeit restricted.  But how long do you think it would have taken to uplift a small child?

Out of a freezer? Not long.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 28, 2019, 01:57:17 PM
What absolute nonsense.  The McCanns are frequently Libelled on this Forum. even by innuendo alone.

I disagree. It got to the stage on this forum most of my posts were deleted for challenging the parents version of accounts. and in particular mentioning kates own words describing her daughters genitalia as being wholly inappropriate.

However,moving forward. Motive opportunity.

I personally do not subscribe to the theory that the parents murdered their daughter.

However, on another chat where this is discussed in a mature manner by both abduction and accidental death scenarios.

The following theories involving the parents have been discussed else where:
1. MBM wakes and finds prescribed/unprescribed drugs and swallows them thinking they are sweets
(an xcellent timeline is provided by the person discussing this)
2. The parents do give the childen sedatives and  A  MBM has a allergic reaction and or wakes up and falls banging her head
3.Kate is stressed with being left with the three children- (She mentioned that Gerry isn't a hands on dad like the others there) MBM is playing up and Kate'snaps' lashes out at her daughter (Kate demonstrates her annoyance towards her daugher on one video where she wants to shake her daughter to get her to say somethingelse about Sean crying)
4 woke and wandered- found by kate and or Gerry outside the apartment dead or dying from an accident are likey
5 I will not discuss this on an open forum

The time lines vary to establish if any of these theories highly likely/believable. we can work through them if you want.

Why hide the childs body?  many reasons.
 A post  mortem could flag up:
 time and cause of death- if it wasn't natural causes then they would surely have been arrested- other children removed etc.

Signs of any kind of abuse- under fed- physical/sexual abuse

They panicked for fear of what would happen to them... just to name three


How could they hide the body?

initially in that cupboard to be taken later

hid somewhere she could be recovered to re dispose of her (claiming they had searched a particular are to keep from others finding MBM)

Reminder- these are not my thoughts or claims or theories- I am happy to discuss them.

Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: alphonse on July 28, 2019, 02:06:01 PM
I have no problem discussing it. I can see loads of contradictions in the statements of both Kate and Gerry but I in the end came to the conclusion that they were innocent. The guilty feeling about leaving the kids led to the spin doctors etc. Again, it´s just my opinion. So, on that other forum did they think the Mc Canns were happy to let Matt go and find the child missing? 
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: G-Unit on July 28, 2019, 02:17:29 PM
I am not feeling very bright this morning, and I sometimes lose words.  Moon Phases I suspect.

But it seems to me that it was logistically impossible for The McCanns to have been involved in the disappearance of their daughter and subsequent disposal of Madeleine's body in a place that  of which they had no knowledge.

I won't bore you all with the suggestions that have been made.  We all know what they are.  But to me, not one of them is even remotely related to common sense.

No body has ever been found, and since it cannot have been taken very far, why do you think this is?

I have days like that too.

The only evidence that they didn't know the area or anyone in it was provided by them; they said so.
It doesn't say who wrote this or why, but it would be very interesting to know where the information originated;

RUSSELL O'BRIEN

To the coordinator of the criminal investigation.

In the context of the investigation, we have collected information concerning a vehicle used by RUSSELL O'BRIEN, friend and member of the group who spent their holiday with the McCann family in the Algarve
 https://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/EDDIE-KEELA.htm
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Miss Taken Identity on July 28, 2019, 02:25:58 PM
I have no problem discussing it. I can see loads of contradictions in the statements of both Kate and Gerry but I in the end came to the conclusion that they were innocent. The guilty feeling about leaving the kids led to the spin doctors etc. Again, it´s just my opinion. So, on that other forum did they think the Mc Canns were happy to let Matt go and find the child missing?

I do not have an opinion of the parents guilt or innocence I am open minded, which is why I feel happy to discuss and challenge all theories.

I do not understand what you are trying to say about Matt?   It was claimed they did NOT check on each others children- this one day was different...

DP claims to have seen all childen at bed time
GM claims to have seen his daughter
MO few minutes after GM returns Matt goes to check (?)
KM finds daughter missing.

The reason this is different is because the checking was claimed as a 'listening at door'- how could Matt or any other T7 see MBM if there was never an agreed physical check.


To answer your question Matt would not have 'found' MBM  missing.

Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: alphonse on July 28, 2019, 03:00:07 PM
I understand all that you are saying but why would he say he did a visual check if it was only a listen?. He would be aware that failing to either see Madeleine or see she was gone could put him high on the Police radar. If it were me and I had lazily listened I would be quick to tell that to the Mc Canns when the alarm was raised.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: G-Unit on July 28, 2019, 03:08:12 PM
It's nice to see the interest in the thread, but where is the evidence which convinced people of the T9's non-involvement?

Eleanor and Alphonse have mentioned logistics, but the only information we have about what was possible between 5:30 and 10pm was provided by those who may have been involved. 

Alphonse mentions normal behaviour, but many people have proved capable of great acting when they found it necessary.

Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Billy Whizz Fan Club on July 28, 2019, 03:12:39 PM
Did any searchers that night report seeing bins being emptied?

I'm pretty sure it's documented in the PJ Files. Apologies if I'm mistaken.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Billy Whizz Fan Club on July 28, 2019, 03:34:58 PM

"To answer Barrier I don´t think Gerry was away from the table for long enough."

You are makig that statement based on what you are being told, there is no independant witnesess, however, it was noted by JT -in the panorama video that he did take longer than was expected for his check- Gerry in turn gave a reason about seeing his daughter and gazing at her lovingly,before/ after using the toilet.

"Added to this is Jez´s impression that he would have to be the best actor in the world to be chatting to him while knowing his daughter lay dead and he had to shift the body."


There are many videos of interviews  of the parents talking-while being adamant (convincing the public) a paedo gang stole their daughter.
Their behaviour is bizarre to say the least.

First interview: they refuse to answer stage managed questions- they do not accept blame they talk around it- they constantly refer to any negative take on  the events  as giving excuses the other parents do it and  we have had great support.

They also  erm um had to grieve but are much stronger now- my words in RED italics"probably IMO because they sold the abductor story successfully had legal,government, and financial support"

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zzKS6HnTKOM

For a couple who claimed their daughter was snatched by a paedophile gang- they find time to have a wee laugh now and then... Nlot to mention their dinner dates for light relief from messrs Freud.

https://crimerocket.com/2019/03/18/have-the-mccanns-been-playing-us-for-fools-for-the-past-12-years/

Is that interview really just three weeks after MM's disappearance? I know different people react differently... but it is quite staggering to watch! To talk about drifting towards negative thoughts "in the early days" but "we don't now - we're actually a lot more stronger now." It just doesn't sound credible. They claim to believe their daughter is still alive - the chances of abuse are therefore quite high, you can't be stronger after three weeks, surely?....... oh is this what they put down to be coached not to show emotion in case it affects how a would be abductor might treat their daughter? But... having a daughter kidnapped is nothing like "being a student and coming to the end of your overdraft limit"... and to say "a lot of good has come of this - well isn't it bizarre behaviour in the extreme?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 28, 2019, 04:28:35 PM
Didn't Adrian Prout dig a hole down in the woods?  How long did that take?
I'd say it would take a couple of hours in total.  You got to get a sharp spade first of all.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 28, 2019, 04:29:48 PM
So The Bins weren't emptied then.  They must have been stinking.
The implication is just an hour later.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Billy Whizz Fan Club on July 28, 2019, 04:40:18 PM
It's nice to see the interest in the thread, but where is the evidence which convinced people of the T9's non-involvement?

Eleanor and Alphonse have mentioned logistics, but the only information we have about what was possible between 5:30 and 10pm was provided by those who may have been involved. 

Alphonse mentions normal behaviour, but many people have proved capable of great acting when they found it necessary.

So, hypothetically speaking, we have nothing to rule out parental involvement... "logistics"? - we can discount this because their own supporters have poured scorn on the timelines. Presuming the rather unreliable accounts of the nannies can be believed we have a timeline between 5:30pm and the next day (narrow that down depending on your opinion of Smithman carrying MM or not) where it logistically possible to conceal a body, IMO.

Then we have behaviour.... Again this is not conclusive proof that the parents were not involved. Their behaviour, IMO, is much more suggestive of finality and coming to terms with that.... but acting normally that evening is certainly a big driver in terms of leading us to believe they are not involved.... What it doesn't do, however, is conclusively rule out their involvement beyond all reasonable doubt.

So what else do we have?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Anthro on July 28, 2019, 05:18:57 PM
To me, the most detrimental factor in getting to the bottom of what happened on the night of 3/5/7, is that at least two people in the T7-group have not given a truthful account as to their checking and estimated timing thereof. My thinking is that the so-called ‘missing piece of the puzzle’ lies in the timeline. One small detail might be uncovered to solve the crime if everyone in the group truthfully reveal their account of events.

To me, Madeleine’s disappearance has been a ‘simple’ operation by a skilled person acting alone and who knew exactly how to execute taking her swiftly, leaving no trace behind. That person had the advantage and skill to observe for a couple of days and eventually establishing a predictable pattern. S/he entered 5A, lift the child, exit and move on.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: alphonse on July 28, 2019, 05:20:57 PM
Anthro, when do you reckon she was taken- before Matt´s check around 9.30 or after his check?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Anthro on July 28, 2019, 05:24:16 PM
Hi Alphonse, I think after Matt’s check.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 28, 2019, 05:28:19 PM
Hi Alphonse, I think after Matt’s check.

So no Tannerman bearing Madeleine away? 

You'll disappoint some supporters, I suspect.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 28, 2019, 05:46:08 PM
Somebody's gonna mention the open window surely,oh bother I just did.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: faithlilly on July 28, 2019, 05:46:43 PM
To me, the most detrimental factor in getting to the bottom of what happened on the night of 3/5/7, is that at least two people in the T7-group have not given a truthful account as to their checking and estimated timing thereof. My thinking is that the so-called ‘missing piece of the puzzle’ lies in the timeline. One small detail might be uncovered to solve the crime if everyone in the group truthfully reveal their account of events.

To me, Madeleine’s disappearance has been a ‘simple’ operation by a skilled person acting alone and who knew exactly how to execute taking her swiftly, leaving no trace behind. That person had the advantage and skill to observe for a couple of days and eventually establishing a predictable pattern. S/he entered 5A, lift the child, exit and move on.

Where is your evidence?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 28, 2019, 05:58:18 PM
Where is your evidence?
All theories have to be kept as an open option.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 28, 2019, 06:00:19 PM
Theories without some supportive evidence go to the bottom of the pile of probability - IMO
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 28, 2019, 06:01:59 PM
Theories without some supportive evidence go to the bottom of the pile of probability - IMO
Non existent theories are below the surface so even lower that that.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involve
Post by: Anthro on July 28, 2019, 06:05:44 PM
Faithlilly, with due respect, nobody on the forum (presumably), has any evidence whatsoever. So, why challenge me to state anything as fact and providing evidence? I am referring to the partnership of Tanner/O’Brien. Their timeline of events does not seem to be accurate/truthful, i.e. the Irish teenager who also had no recollection of seeing Tanner at the time of passing Gerry/Jez. To me, when a crime is committed, the execution thereof is often covert and not that complex.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 28, 2019, 06:27:25 PM
Non existent theories are below the surface so even lower that that.

Which is how it should be - everything in its correct order.

Mind you, how would you know of a non-existent theory ?  ?{)(**
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 28, 2019, 06:29:54 PM
Which is how it should be - everything in its correct order.

Mind you, how would you know of a non-existent theory ?  ?{)(**
I was thinking of your theory?  Since you pick on everyone else's theory.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 28, 2019, 06:31:56 PM
I was thinking of your theory?  Since you pick on everyone else's theory.

I do't need a theory. I'm having more than enough fun with some of the ridiculous spread about on here   8(0(*
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 28, 2019, 06:35:39 PM
I do't need a theory. I'm having more than enough fun with some of the ridiculous spread about on here   8(0(*
Exactly the non-existent theory that is below the surface.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Mr Gray on July 28, 2019, 06:36:44 PM
I do't need a theory. I'm having more than enough fun with some of the ridiculous spread about on here   8(0(*

me too
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 28, 2019, 06:38:12 PM
Exactly the non-existent theory that is below the surface.


Technically, if its non-existent, it cannot be above or below a surface
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: pathfinder73 on July 28, 2019, 06:40:41 PM
Not sure I’ve seen any reports from searchers.

Nor me which is strange. If it was early hours then I think somebody would have seen it.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 28, 2019, 06:42:48 PM

Technically, if its non-existent, it cannot be above or below a surface
You seem to have gone all technical on me!
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 28, 2019, 06:49:15 PM
Nor me which is strange. If it was early hours then I think somebody would have seen it.
Most of the searchers finished before 4 AM.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 28, 2019, 06:56:59 PM
That would leave a window of opportunity for a corpse to be retrieved from a bin after the searchers had gone and before the waste disposal workers arrived - IMO
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 28, 2019, 07:03:46 PM
That would leave a window of opportunity for a corpse to be retrieved from a bin after the searchers had gone and before the waste disposal workers arrived - IMO

Or the opportunity was missed to return.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Anthro on July 28, 2019, 07:18:38 PM
I am trying to put across the fact that Madeleine has disappeared (which is the only known given in the case), all the clutter/publicity/fake news and the momentum it has gained over a period 12 years, might have overlooked the possibility that Madeleine’s removal from 5A was a fairly easy and uncomplicated exercise. Therefore, I propose that a timeline without any discrepancies might reveal some nugget/unknown detail that might be helpful in discovering as to what happened to Madeleine.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 28, 2019, 07:23:09 PM
I am trying to put across the fact that Madeleine has disappeared (which is the only known given in the case), all the clutter/publicity/fake news and the momentum it has gained over a period 12 years, might have overlooked the possibility that Madeleine’s removal from 5A was a fairly easy and uncomplicated exercise. Therefore, I propose that a timeline without any discrepancies might reveal some nugget/unknown detail that might be helpful in discovering as to what happened to Madeleine.

Trouble,is there aren't times with out discrepancies,maybe thats why it can't be resolved.Wheat from the chaff, is there a will,but after 12 yrs you'd hope so.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involve
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 28, 2019, 08:39:01 PM
Faithlilly, with due respect, nobody on the forum (presumably), has any evidence whatsoever. So, why challenge me to state anything as fact and providing evidence? I am referring to the partnership of Tanner/O’Brien. Their timeline of events does not seem to be accurate/truthful, i.e. the Irish teenager who also had no recollection of seeing Tanner at the time of passing Gerry/Jez. To me, when a crime is committed, the execution thereof is often covert and not that complex.

For the sake of readers, the Irish 'teenager' is almost certainly Aoife Smith.  She is Irish, was 12 at the time (not a teenager), was dining with 4 adults and 4 young relatives in the Dolphin restaurant at the time of Gerry and Jez, and the Dolphin is perhaps 800m away from 5A.

I don't know how this myth got started, but boy its got more lives than a cat.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Billy Whizz Fan Club on July 28, 2019, 08:51:56 PM
me too

They said you"d be back!!  ?>)()<

"Fun"/entertainment is probably not what should motivate us to be interested in a missing child case.

Not that I'm suggesting you're in any way making light of the case DaveL... (You're just making light of theories you don't agree with)
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 28, 2019, 09:19:43 PM
That would be because of the strict moderating.  No one to say anything against the McCanns - accused of libel accused or trolling and h8ting.

Well done G for getting it accepted as a real opportunity to discuss this.
I’m not talking about this forum only, I”m talking about anywhere, ever, on any forum, in any poxy pamphlet or pompous blog.  Not one single logical, plausible theory.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 28, 2019, 09:21:40 PM
The bins were emptied in the early hours of the 4th...I would assume this prohibited a proper search of them. Once the body is in the refuse system unless it is being specifically looked for there is a good chance it will never be found.

IF the parents were involved and IF Madeleine was sedated then a bin would be the perfect solution. Once the search began there was a good chance that the bin would be searched and the body found...the sedation would be blamed on the abductor, the body would receive a decent burial and so on. Unfortunately what the parents couldn’t have known is the time the bins were emptied, leaving very little time for the body to be found.

As to opportunity, we have no way of knowing how honest or accurate the tapas timeline is.
Why would sedation be blamed on an abductor if the body was found 5 minutes walk away from the apartment but not one minute walk away from the apartment?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: G-Unit on July 28, 2019, 09:59:42 PM
I’m not talking about this forum only, I”m talking about anywhere, ever, on any forum, in any poxy pamphlet or pompous blog.  Not one single logical, plausible theory.

Would you care to mention any evidence which, in yout opinion, eliminates the parents and their friends? I'm beginning to wonder if anyone has any.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 28, 2019, 10:04:30 PM
They said you"d be back!!  ?>)()<

"Fun"/entertainment is probably not what should motivate us to be interested in a missing child case.

Not that I'm suggesting you're in any way making light of the case DaveL... (You're just making light of theories you don't agree with)
Jassi is the one who first claimed to be having fun, why not turn your disapproval on her?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Mr Gray on July 28, 2019, 10:06:22 PM
Would you care to mention any evidence which, in yout opinion, eliminates the parents and their friends? I'm beginning to wonder if anyone has any.

Are you referring to evidence or proof..evidence cannot eliminate them... It can make their involvement unlikely... But not eliminate them
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 28, 2019, 10:11:51 PM
Would you care to mention any evidence which, in yout opinion, eliminates the parents and their friends? I'm beginning to wonder if anyone has any.
What sort of evidence would you accept, out of interest?  You won’t accept their words, or any of the Tapas 7, you won’t accept witness accounts of their normal behavior prior to the alarm being raised, or subsequent devastation, you won’t accept that there was logistically no opportunity, no motive, nor any means to completely remove all evidence of a death and a body, you won’t accept that a conspiracy of nine people to immediately agree to cover up an accidental death is far-fetched to the point of absurdity,  so what sort of evidence are you asking for?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involve
Post by: faithlilly on July 28, 2019, 10:51:44 PM
Faithlilly, with due respect, nobody on the forum (presumably), has any evidence whatsoever. So, why challenge me to state anything as fact and providing evidence? I am referring to the partnership of Tanner/O’Brien. Their timeline of events does not seem to be accurate/truthful, i.e. the Irish teenager who also had no recollection of seeing Tanner at the time of passing Gerry/Jez. To me, when a crime is committed, the execution thereof is often covert and not that complex.

What Irish teenager ?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: faithlilly on July 28, 2019, 10:53:28 PM
Nor me which is strange. If it was early hours then I think somebody would have seen it.

No I meant that I haven’t seen any reports from searchers about anything at all.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: pathfinder73 on July 28, 2019, 11:18:58 PM
That would leave a window of opportunity for a corpse to be retrieved from a bin after the searchers had gone and before the waste disposal workers arrived - IMO

Agreed. You could move from a temporary hiding place at that time but safer to do after the searchers retired at 4am.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Billy Whizz Fan Club on July 29, 2019, 12:32:16 AM
What sort of evidence would you accept, out of interest?  You won’t accept their words, or any of the Tapas 7, you won’t accept witness accounts of their normal behavior prior to the alarm being raised, or subsequent devastation, you won’t accept that there was logistically no opportunity, no motive, nor any means to completely remove all evidence of a death and a body, you won’t accept that a conspiracy of nine people to immediately agree to cover up an accidental death is far-fetched to the point of absurdity,  so what sort of evidence are you asking for?

In a hypothetical scenario in line with the facts as far as we can ascertain them:

It is logistically possible for a concealment and subsequent removal to take place.

There is a possible motive - trying to avoid charges of criminal neglect and the very real prospect of losing your jobs, houses and remaining children when nothing hypothetically speaking will bring MM back following a hypothetical tragic fatal accident.... This motive becomes even stronger if there has been misuse of anti-histamines to help the children sleep when the parents are out every night.

The remaining T7 might all believe the abduction story, but, hypothetically speaking, they are reluctant to do a reconstruction and their timelines don't work because they are trying to cover for the fact that their checks only involved listening and not proper visual checking. So there is no conspiracy of 9 people covering for an accidental death and concealment.

There are other questions that no-one ever addresses. Why was it so important for the public to be sold the abduction story? Why are Mitchell and senior members of the British Government involved? Why are there faux police press conferences arranged which urge the public to look for various odd looking lurkers... but they don't mention Smithman for months / years???

The real conspiracy is the story that an abduction took place. It has very little evidence to support it.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 29, 2019, 06:05:22 AM
In a hypothetical scenario in line with the facts as far as we can ascertain them:

It is logistically possible for a concealment and subsequent removal to take place.

There is a possible motive - trying to avoid charges of criminal neglect and the very real prospect of losing your jobs, houses and remaining children when nothing hypothetically speaking will bring MM back following a hypothetical tragic fatal accident.... This motive becomes even stronger if there has been misuse of anti-histamines to help the children sleep when the parents are out every night.

The remaining T7 might all believe the abduction story, but, hypothetically speaking, they are reluctant to do a reconstruction and their timelines don't work because they are trying to cover for the fact that their checks only involved listening and not proper visual checking. So there is no conspiracy of 9 people covering for an accidental death and concealment.

There are other questions that no-one ever addresses. Why was it so important for the public to be sold the abduction story? Why are Mitchell and senior members of the British Government involved? Why are there faux police press conferences arranged which urge the public to look for various odd looking lurkers... but they don't mention Smithman for months / years???

The real conspiracy is the story that an abduction took place. It has very little evidence to support it.
I’m afraid I am not a conspiracy theorist and therefore I don’t believe in a cover up thst involves friends, extended family media, etc.  In my opinion you can put forward a scenario but it would necessarily rely on an outlandish conspiracy theory and I reject that completely.


Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: G-Unit on July 29, 2019, 06:53:54 AM
What sort of evidence would you accept, out of interest?  You won’t accept their words, or any of the Tapas 7, you won’t accept witness accounts of their normal behavior prior to the alarm being raised, or subsequent devastation, you won’t accept that there was logistically no opportunity, no motive, nor any means to completely remove all evidence of a death and a body, you won’t accept that a conspiracy of nine people to immediately agree to cover up an accidental death is far-fetched to the point of absurdity,  so what sort of evidence are you asking for?

Leaving aside my views, that sounds like a list of the evidence that you think eliminates the group. To clarify;

1. You think they all told the truth.
2. You think witness statements about their behaviour are significant.
3. You mention the logistics which leave no opportunity in your opinion.
4. You can find no motive.
5. You think there was no opportunity to remove evidence or a body.
6. You think it's absurd that nine people would conspire to cover up an accidental death.

Is there anything else you think is significant?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 29, 2019, 07:16:17 AM
Leaving aside my views, that sounds like a list of the evidence that you think eliminates the group. To clarify;

1. You think they all told the truth.
2. You think witness statements about their behaviour are sognificant.
3. You mention the logistics which leave no opportunity in yoor opinion.
4. You can find no motive.
5. You think there was no oppertunity to remove evidence or a body.
6. You think it's absurd that nine people would conspire to cover up an accidental death.

Is there anything else you think is significant?
probably, but that will do for starters.  Obviously you reject all that evidence out of hand so now please tell me what sort of evidence of innocence you would accept .
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: G-Unit on July 29, 2019, 07:42:50 AM
probably, but that will do for starters.  Obviously you reject all that evidence out of hand so now please tell me what sort of evidence of innocence you would accept .

I'm not going to comment because my aim is to find out what evidence people are relying on to eliminate parental/T7 involvement.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 29, 2019, 07:50:04 AM
I'm not going to comment because my aim is to find out what evidence people are relying on to eliminate parental/T7 involvement.
Well now you know. Next?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: G-Unit on July 29, 2019, 08:09:13 AM
Well now you know. Next?

Thank you for contributing. Next? Hopefully others will contribute too.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 29, 2019, 08:29:36 AM
Thank you for contributing. Next? Hopefully others will contribute too.
And what then?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 08:38:38 AM
Some people are convinced that the T9 were not involved in Madeleine's disappearance. I've seen many reasons quoted but none of them stands up to scrutiny in my opinion. What is the evidence which has convinced people to look elsewhere for an explanation?

The 'some people are convinced that the T9 were not involved' includes forensic scientists, investigating authorities and judiciary over two countries.

And yes I appreciate Amaral believed/s the McCanns were involved but his hunch(es) were proved wrong.

You ask what is the evidence which has convinced people to look elsewhere and that's just it there's no evidence against the McCanns other than a witch-hunt and trial by social media based on a lot of subjectivity. 

Even if MM is found alive tomorrow I guarantee there will still be some who think the McCanns were involved.  These people will insist it isn't really MM, despite DNA tests confirming otherwise, and that its an inter-governmental cover-up involving senior politicians, intelligence services, Freemasons and the royal family etc.  Some are just conspiracy theorists.  Others will be unable to accept they called it wrong.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: G-Unit on July 29, 2019, 08:45:21 AM
And what then?

Then we'll all know why some people believe there was no parental/T7 involvement. Some might be convinced by the evidence which has convinced others.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 08:46:24 AM
So does a detective on Adrian Prout's account but he did it! You will be surprised by what perps can do.
 
A senior detective who played a key role in jailing wife killer Adrian Prout said he still has doubts over his explanation of how he concealed her body, a decade her murder.

But Detective Superintendent David Sellwood said this week that the ‘window of opportunity’ to dispose of the body was ‘very small’.


https://www.gloucestershirelive.co.uk/news/gloucester-news/prout-killer-detectives-doubts-remain-712576

But Prout had access to a vehicle.  There's no evidence the McCanns had access to a vehicle.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 08:53:29 AM
If he was innocent he would not be hiding. No record of Smithman's child at the creche that night. He is the missing link.

He might not be hiding.  He might just be oblivious to how his coming forward could assist the investigation if only to eliminate.  Until I joined in here I was oblivious to 'Smithman'. 

The GNR search and rescue dogs did not scent to the sighting of 'Smithman'.  It could well be he is simply another red herring at it seems the 'Tannerman' sighting is.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 08:54:51 AM
Well, Spammy had the idea of popping it in a bin, so maybe that's what happened with later retrieval.

But how do you explain the GNR search and rescue dogs did not track to any bins?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 29, 2019, 08:56:59 AM
But how do you explain the GNR search and rescue dogs did not track to any bins?

As you know, I don't put much reliance on these dogs, so not a problem for me that they don't go near a bin.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: G-Unit on July 29, 2019, 08:59:36 AM
The 'some people are convinced that the T9 were not involved' includes forensic scientists, investigating authorities and judiciary over two countries.

And yes I appreciate Amaral believed/s the McCanns were involved but his hunch(es) were proved wrong.

You ask what is the evidence which has convinced people to look elsewhere and that's just it there's no evidence against the McCanns other than a witch-hunt and trial by social media based on a lot of subjectivity. 

Even if MM is found alive tomorrow I guarantee there will still be some who think the McCanns were involved.  These people will insist it isn't really MM, despite DNA tests confirming otherwise, and that its an inter-governmental cover-up involving senior politicians, intelligence services, Freemasons and the royal family etc.  Some are just conspiracy theorists.  Others will be unable to accept they called it wrong.

Thanks for the contribution Holly. So you think they can be eliminated because there's a lack of incriminating evidence?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: G-Unit on July 29, 2019, 09:08:40 AM
But how do you explain the GNR search and rescue dogs did not track to any bins?

The GNR dog's route is interesting but not enlightening because no-one knows who or what they were tracking. You seem to be assuming it was Madeleine's novements on tthe evening of 3rd?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Mr Gray on July 29, 2019, 09:18:59 AM
Thanks for the contribution Holly. So you think they can be eliminated because there's a lack of incriminating evidence?

I think you need to define eliminated before we go any futher....I dont know what everyone else believes but i dont think we can totally eliminate the mccanns...nothing is certain...the evidence verystrongly suggests they are innocent and I think its highly unlikely they are involved...thats all we can say imo...and this is what i have said before
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Anthro on July 29, 2019, 09:39:48 AM
Shining in Luz, this is part of Aoife’s statement. Given her location at the time, surely she would not have been able to see Gerry and Jez talking (between 20:45 and 21:15)?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 29, 2019, 09:45:34 AM
Then we'll all know why some people believe there was no parental/T7 involvement. Some might be convinced by the evidence which has cinvinced others.
And what will this demonstrate exactly?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 09:51:47 AM
Thanks for the contribution Holly. So you think they can be eliminated because there's a lack of incriminating evidence?

Yes much the same way others have been ruled out eg Murat and the 3 local guys all of whom were thought to be involved in petty crime. 

Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 29, 2019, 09:57:15 AM
Yes much the same way others have been ruled out eg Murat and the 3 local guys all of whom were thought to be involved in petty crime.

Police seem to have had two bites of the interrogation cherry with Murat,who cooperated fully (i believe), which is more than can be said for certain of the main players.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 09:59:36 AM
The GNR dog's route is interesting but not enlightening because no-one knows who or what they were tracking. You seem to be assuming it was Madeleine's novements on tthe evening of 3rd?

Yes I am assuming the dogs tracked MM's last movements based on the fact the GNR dog handler received from KM an item MM had contact with.  Some will say how do I know it was an item MM had contact with and the answer is obviously I can't be sure but what I do know is that two dogs tracked exactly the same short path around the car park, block 5, and over the road into a neighboring car park so if they were not scenting MM then who were they scenting?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: The General on July 29, 2019, 10:03:03 AM
Police seem to have had two bites of the interrogation cherry with Mutat,who cooperated fully (i believe), which is more than can be said for certain of the main players.
While they ransacked his ma's house whilst he was Arguidoing in the clink.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Anthro on July 29, 2019, 10:26:06 AM
On the GE photo:

Blue = Dolphin restaurant
Green = Kelly’s bar
Red = Estrela apartments where the Smiths were staying
Yellow = Gerry and Jez

The ‘smoking teenager’ who saw Gerry and Jez, but not Tanner, is certainly not Aoife.

[attachment deleted by admin]
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 29, 2019, 10:31:30 AM
While they ransacked his ma's house whilst he was Arguidoing in the clink.
I wasn’t aware Murat was ever locked up?  Didn’t he receive the same sort of treatment and scrutiny as the McCanns?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 29, 2019, 10:37:40 AM
On the GE photo:

Blue = Dolphin restaurant
Green = Kelly’s bar
Red = Estrela apartments where the Smiths were staying
Yellow = Gerry and Jez

The ‘smoking teenager’ who saw Gerry and Jez, but not Tanner, is certainly not Aoife.

Unless there is another young girl, possibly Irish or not, possibly a teenager or not, possibly a smoker or not, ...

As no match has been found in the PJ Files, I have yet to be convinced this girl ever existed.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 29, 2019, 10:39:53 AM
Unless there is another young girl, possibly Irish or not, possibly a teenager or not, possibly a smoker or not, ...

As no match has been found in the PJ Files, I have yet to be convinced this girl ever existed.
I seem to remember Goncalo mentioning her in an interview.  Otherwise where did the story originate?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Anthro on July 29, 2019, 10:59:33 AM
PAULO Reis writes on Madeleine McCann:

    “A teenager, who was with her family at Ocean Club, saw Gerry McCann and Jeremy Wilkins talking, the night Madeleine disappeared – but she didn’t saw Jane Tanner or a man carrying a child. The girl wasn’t in the list of guests, as their presence at Ocean Club wasn’t registered with the management. Father and daughter have been in Portugal, recently, to help Policia Judiciaria in the reconstruction of what happened the night of May 3 and to give a formal statement to Police, according to a source close to the case.

    Speaking to SOS Madeleine, the Irish teenager confirmed she saw Gerry McCann and Jeremy Wilkins talking, for a few minutes, near the McCann apartment: “There was only the father of the little girl talking to another man.”

    The teenager went out for a cigarette, around the same time Jane Tanner said she saw a man carrying a child. She only mentioned what she saw to her family latter, because she had also to confess the reason why she was there. Since the beginning, Police had some doubts about Jane Tanner [sic] statement, as Jeremy Wilkins, a tennis partner of Madeleine’s father, told them he only saw Gerry McCann near the apartment”.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 29, 2019, 11:17:41 AM
PAULO Reis writes on Madeleine McCann:

    “A teenager, who was with her family at Ocean Club, saw Gerry McCann and Jeremy Wilkins talking, the night Madeleine disappeared – but she didn’t saw Jane Tanner or a man carrying a child. The girl wasn’t in the list of guests, as their presence at Ocean Club wasn’t registered with the management. Father and daughter have been in Portugal, recently, to help Policia Judiciaria in the reconstruction of what happened the night of May 3 and to give a formal statement to Police, according to a source close to the case.

    Speaking to SOS Madeleine, the Irish teenager confirmed she saw Gerry McCann and Jeremy Wilkins talking, for a few minutes, near the McCann apartment: “There was only the father of the little girl talking to another man.”

    The teenager went out for a cigarette, around the same time Jane Tanner said she saw a man carrying a child. She only mentioned what she saw to her family latter, because she had also to confess the reason why she was there. Since the beginning, Police had some doubts about Jane Tanner [sic] statement, as Jeremy Wilkins, a tennis partner of Madeleine’s father, told them he only saw Gerry McCann near the apartment”.

Jane Tanner walking up the street is an event that would be over in less than 40 seconds, but Gerry and Jez spoke to each other for  5 minutes or so, therefore she could have easily missed seeing Jane.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: faithlilly on July 29, 2019, 11:36:23 AM
The 'some people are convinced that the T9 were not involved' includes forensic scientists, investigating authorities and judiciary over two countries.

And yes I appreciate Amaral believed/s the McCanns were involved but his hunch(es) were proved wrong.

You ask what is the evidence which has convinced people to look elsewhere and that's just it there's no evidence against the McCanns other than a witch-hunt and trial by social media based on a lot of subjectivity. 

Even if MM is found alive tomorrow I guarantee there will still be some who think the McCanns were involved.  These people will insist it isn't really MM, despite DNA tests confirming otherwise, and that its an inter-governmental cover-up involving senior politicians, intelligence services, Freemasons and the royal family etc.  Some are just conspiracy theorists.  Others will be unable to accept they called it wrong.

If that day ever comes then I will be the first to hold my hands up...but 12 years and three investigations later it would appear that not one perpetrator outside of friends group has been identified.

Let’s look at your list of people who you claim have said the parents are not involved.

Forensic scientists....the DNA found could be Madeleine’s...there was nothing found to exclude that possibility. Of course Madeleine had stayed in that apartment and used items in that apartment that were then transferred by car to the new villa so even if her DNA had been found it would take the case forward not one jot.

Investigating authorities....the original investigation did not exonerate the parents, as we were told in the SC ruling....it simply said that there was no definitive evidence to charge anyone, in fact they could not even define what crime had been committed.

The ongoing investigations.....SY will not commit to naming suspects until they are charged. Some seem to believe  that because whatever SY representative the media talks to refuse to name the parents as suspects then they can’t be but I’m afraid investigations don’t work like that. Remember what happened when Cliff Richards was named

https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/news/cliff-richard-settles-legal-battle-over-bbc-sex-offender-reports-south-yorkshire-police-a7757431.html.

The Portuguese investigation is under judicial secrecy so they wouldn’t be able to reveal any details of their investigation either.

So remind me again who has said the parents are not involved ?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 29, 2019, 11:57:24 AM
PAULO Reis writes on Madeleine McCann:

    “A teenager, who was with her family at Ocean Club, saw Gerry McCann and Jeremy Wilkins talking, the night Madeleine disappeared – but she didn’t saw Jane Tanner or a man carrying a child. The girl wasn’t in the list of guests, as their presence at Ocean Club wasn’t registered with the management. Father and daughter have been in Portugal, recently, to help Policia Judiciaria in the reconstruction of what happened the night of May 3 and to give a formal statement to Police, according to a source close to the case.

    Speaking to SOS Madeleine, the Irish teenager confirmed she saw Gerry McCann and Jeremy Wilkins talking, for a few minutes, near the McCann apartment: “There was only the father of the little girl talking to another man.”

    The teenager went out for a cigarette, around the same time Jane Tanner said she saw a man carrying a child. She only mentioned what she saw to her family latter, because she had also to confess the reason why she was there. Since the beginning, Police had some doubts about Jane Tanner [sic] statement, as Jeremy Wilkins, a tennis partner of Madeleine’s father, told them he only saw Gerry McCann near the apartment”.

According to the PJ Files, the only Irish family which returned to Portugal were the Smiths, namely Martin, Peter and Aoife.

They were residing in Estrela da Luz, outside the OC.

The story is an example of reporting, a smattering of facts filled up with a large dose of invention.  Obviously IMO.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 29, 2019, 12:07:41 PM
According to the PJ Files, the only Irish family which returned to Portugal were the Smiths, namely Martin, Peter and Aoife.

They were residing in Estrela da Luz, outside the OC.

The story is an example of reporting, a smattering of facts filled up with a large dose of invention.  Obviously IMO.
I heard GA mention it  IIRC  of course.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 29, 2019, 12:21:29 PM
I heard GA mention it  IIRC  of course.

I'm not contesting whether he did.  But I prefer something a bit more substantial.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 29, 2019, 12:24:51 PM
I'm not contesting whether he did.  But I prefer something a bit more substantial.
The very person who the Smiths spoke to is not substantial enough!  The lead investigator not good enough!
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 29, 2019, 12:33:26 PM
The very person who the Smiths spoke to is not substantial enough!  The lead investigator not good enough!

I suppose you'll have a cite to support that statement ?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 29, 2019, 12:39:39 PM
I suppose you'll have a cite to support that statement ?
You mean "I heard GA mention it  IIRC  of course."  It is a distant memory but that quote from Paulo Reis (above) seems to be referring to a similar incident.

PAULO Reis writes on Madeleine McCann:

    “A teenager, who was with her family at Ocean Club, saw Gerry McCann and Jeremy Wilkins talking, the night Madeleine disappeared – but she didn’t saw Jane Tanner or a man carrying a child. The girl wasn’t in the list of guests, as their presence at Ocean Club wasn’t registered with the management. Father and daughter have been in Portugal, recently, to help Policia Judiciaria in the reconstruction of what happened the night of May 3 and to give a formal statement to Police, according to a source close to the case.

    Speaking to SOS Madeleine, the Irish teenager confirmed she saw Gerry McCann and Jeremy Wilkins talking, for a few minutes, near the McCann apartment: “There was only the father of the little girl talking to another man.”

    The teenager went out for a cigarette, around the same time Jane Tanner said she saw a man carrying a child. She only mentioned what she saw to her family latter, because she had also to confess the reason why she was there. Since the beginning, Police had some doubts about Jane Tanner [sic] statement, as Jeremy Wilkins, a tennis partner of Madeleine’s father, told them he only saw Gerry McCann near the apartment”.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 29, 2019, 01:08:52 PM
You mean "I heard GA mention it  IIRC  of course."  It is a distant memory but that quote from Paulo Reis (above) seems to be referring to a similar incident.

From what I know, Paulo Reis was simply a journalist at the time.  Journalists are under pressure to file copy.  Journalists are under pressure to make their report sound dramatic.

As to GA, I can only imagine him saying that after he had resigned from the police.  His career became media, under pressure to write a story, and to make said story sound dramatic.

The simple fact is, the Irish father and daughter who returned to Portugal are not in the PJ Files.  Unless they are the Smiths, in which case this story is nonsense.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 29, 2019, 01:11:06 PM
From what I know, Paulo Reis was simply a journalist at the time.  Journalists are under pressure to file copy.  Journalists are under pressure to make their report sound dramatic.

As to GA, I can only imagine him saying that after he had resigned from the police.  His career became media, under pressure to write a story, and to make said story sound dramatic.

The simple fact is, the Irish father and daughter who returned to Portugal are not in the PJ Files.  Unless they are the Smiths, in which case this story is nonsense.
Why is it nonsense?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 29, 2019, 01:20:16 PM
Why is it nonsense?

They were 800m away, in the Dolphin, at the time of the Jes/Gerry incident.

Surely you are familiar with the Smith family sighting?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 01:22:05 PM
If that day ever comes then I will be the first to hold my hands up...but 12 years and three investigations later it would appear that not one perpetrator outside of friends group has been identified.

Let’s look at your list of people who you claim have said the parents are not involved.

Forensic scientists....the DNA found could be Madeleine’s...there was nothing found to exclude that possibility. Of course Madeleine had stayed in that apartment and used items in that apartment that were then transferred by car to the new villa so even if her DNA had been found it would take the case forward not one jot.

Investigating authorities....the original investigation did not exonerate the parents, as we were told in the SC ruling....it simply said that there was no definitive evidence to charge anyone, in fact they could not even define what crime had been committed.

The ongoing investigations.....SY will not commit to naming suspects until they are charged. Some seem to believe  that because whatever SY representative the media talks to refuse to name the parents as suspects then they can’t be but I’m afraid investigations don’t work like that. Remember what happened when Cliff Richards was named

https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/music/news/cliff-richard-settles-legal-battle-over-bbc-sex-offender-reports-south-yorkshire-police-a7757431.html.

The Portuguese investigation is under judicial secrecy so they wouldn’t be able to reveal any details of their investigation either.

So remind me again who has said the parents are not involved ?

I'm not sure what you mean by ...'not one perpetrator outside of friends group has been identified." ?

The LCN DNA results were deemed "inconclusive" by FSS.

Inconclusive results -- Results may be inconclusive for several reasons. For example, contaminated samples often yield inconclusive results. So do very small or degraded samples, which may not have enough DNA to produce a full profile.

If the PJ/SY had anything on the McCanns/T7 they would charge them not continue with an investigation which has involved interviewing other suspects.

Some crimes take years to resolve/bring the perps to justice eg the murder of Lesley Molseed and Stephen Lawrence.  Some remain unsolved eg Jill Dando.  Some remain disappeared whereabouts unknown eg Suzy Lamplugh and Claudia Lawrence.

The fact MM's disappearance remains unresolved does not mean the McCanns/T7 were responsible.  It might mean the perp(s) got lucky and/or outwitted the authorities and/or the investigators were lacking. 
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 29, 2019, 01:36:40 PM
They were 800m away, in the Dolphin, at the time of the Jes/Gerry incident.

Surely you are familiar with the Smith family sighting?
Gerry and Jez talked just after 9:00  9:10 to 9:20 possibly and the Smithman sighting was around 10:00 PM .  Plenty of time to get from 5A to Dolphin.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 29, 2019, 01:40:34 PM
I'm not sure what you mean by ...'not one perpetrator outside of friends group has been identified." ?

The LCN DNA results were deemed "inconclusive" by FSS.

Inconclusive results -- Results may be inconclusive for several reasons. For example, contaminated samples often yield inconclusive results. So do very small or degraded samples, which may not have enough DNA to produce a full profile.

If the PJ/SY had anything on the McCanns/T7 they would charge them not continue with an investigation which has involved interviewing other suspects.

Some crimes take years to resolve/bring the perps to justice eg the murder of Lesley Molseed and Stephen Lawrence.  Some remain unsolved eg Jill Dando.  Some remain disappeared whereabouts unknown eg Suzy Lamplugh and Claudia Lawrence.

The fact MM's disappearance remains unresolved does not mean the McCanns/T7 were responsible.  It might mean the perp(s) got lucky and/or outwitted the authorities and/or the investigators were lacking.


No might about it,   IMO,  the perpetrator(s) definitely got lucky

Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: pathfinder73 on July 29, 2019, 01:58:50 PM
But Prout had access to a vehicle.  There's no evidence the McCanns had access to a vehicle.

Nobody requires a vehicle to hide a small body. If not every drain, bush, rock, boat etc. was checked that night then it can be done. Searchers did not have many torches so they weren't going to find anything in the dark.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 29, 2019, 02:01:08 PM
Gerry and Jez talked just after 9:00  9:10 to 9:20 possibly and the Smithman sighting was around 10:00 PM .  Plenty of time to get from 5A to Dolphin.

They were booked in at 7.30.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: pathfinder73 on July 29, 2019, 02:02:21 PM
The 'some people are convinced that the T9 were not involved' includes forensic scientists, investigating authorities and judiciary over two countries.

And yes I appreciate Amaral believed/s the McCanns were involved but his hunch(es) were proved wrong.

You ask what is the evidence which has convinced people to look elsewhere and that's just it there's no evidence against the McCanns other than a witch-hunt and trial by social media based on a lot of subjectivity. 

Even if MM is found alive tomorrow I guarantee there will still be some who think the McCanns were involved.  These people will insist it isn't really MM, despite DNA tests confirming otherwise, and that its an inter-governmental cover-up involving senior politicians, intelligence services, Freemasons and the royal family etc.  Some are just conspiracy theorists.  Others will be unable to accept they called it wrong.

Nothing has been proven wrong. Met officers donated to Amaral's fund so get real.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: G-Unit on July 29, 2019, 02:53:55 PM
I'm not sure what you mean by ...'not one perpetrator outside of friends group has been identified." ?

The LCN DNA results were deemed "inconclusive" by FSS.

Inconclusive results -- Results may be inconclusive for several reasons. For example, contaminated samples often yield inconclusive results. So do very small or degraded samples, which may not have enough DNA to produce a full profile.

If the PJ/SY had anything on the McCanns/T7 they would charge them not continue with an investigation which has involved interviewing other suspects.

Some crimes take years to resolve/bring the perps to justice eg the murder of Lesley Molseed and Stephen Lawrence.  Some remain unsolved eg Jill Dando.  Some remain disappeared whereabouts unknown eg Suzy Lamplugh and Claudia Lawrence.

The fact MM's disappearance remains unresolved does not mean the McCanns/T7 were responsible.  It might mean the perp(s) got lucky and/or outwitted the authorities and/or the investigators were lacking.

The fact that there' was insufficient evidence to identify the crime or those responsible means that all possible crimes and all possible perpetrators remain possible, surely?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 29, 2019, 03:22:41 PM
The fact that there' was insufficient evidence to identify the crime or those responsible means that all possible crimes and all possible perpetrators remain possible, surely?
No it does not, unless you consider it possible that Murat abducted, raped and murdered Madeleine with Sergey. Malinka’s help?  Do you?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 29, 2019, 03:38:05 PM
No it does not, unless you consider it possible that Murat abducted, raped and murdered Madeleine with Sergey. Malinka’s help?  Do you?

Using that argument, the same charge could be made against any of the Tapas men - with the possible exception of Payne.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 29, 2019, 03:40:40 PM
Using that argument, the same charge could be made against any of the Tapas men - with the possible exception of Payne.
According to G-Unit nothing and no one can be ruled out so that includes ALL the arguidos, as well as all the Tapas staff, the nannies, Jes Wilkins, the whole lot.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 29, 2019, 03:45:17 PM
According to G-Unit nothing and no one can be ruled out so that includes ALL the arguidos, as well as all the Tapas staff, the nannies, Jes Wilkins, the whole lot.

Yup, you can see why its been and continues to be such an uphill struggle for police forces to make sense of that evening's events.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 04:29:05 PM

No might about it,   IMO,  the perpetrator(s) definitely got lucky

Or investigators, Portuguese and/or British, were lacking ie incompetent.  The Yorkshire ripper was interviewed numerous times, slipping through the net, until he was eventually caught. 
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 29, 2019, 04:32:56 PM
Or investigators, Portuguese and/or British, were lacking ie incompetent.  The Yorkshire ripper was interviewed numerous times, slipping through the net, until he was eventually caught.

Sutcliffe committed numerous crimes and was not identified via questioning, but by the discovery of a hammer.  Without that he likely would have not been identified on that occasion either
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 04:37:09 PM
Nobody requires a vehicle to hide a small body. If not every drain, bush, rock, boat etc. was checked that night then it can be done. Searchers did not have many torches so they weren't going to find anything in the dark.

I didn't say the McCanns needed a vehicle to hide a small body but I can't see the opportunity to conceal a body, small or otherwise, and transferring it elsewhere outside PDL without access to a vehicle.  Bodies quickly decompose and smell attracting flies and such like.

The GNR tracker dogs did not scent MM outside the immediate vicinity.   

PJ combed the area with tracker dogs and a helicopter.  I believe a geologist was brought in to look for any signs of recently disturbed earth. 
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 04:48:03 PM
Nothing has been proven wrong. Met officers donated to Amaral's fund so get real.

There's no need to make it personal bordering on rudeness.

If Amaral's theory stood up to scrutiny how come the Home Office is still funding an investigation which revolves around an abduction and how come the McCanns were not charged with a number of offences eg perverting the course of justice and manslaughter or murder?

According to the media a donation of around 1K was made by MET officers.  If this is accurate you will always get mavericks in any organisation in the same way as you get a small number who engage in wrongdoing and corruption.

Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 29, 2019, 04:53:09 PM
There's no need to make it personal bordering on rudeness.

If Amaral's theory stood up to scrutiny how come the Home Office is still funding an investigation which revolves around an abduction and how come the McCanns were not charged with a number of offences eg perverting the course of justice and manslaughter or murder?

According to the media a donation of around 1K was made by MET officers.  If this is accurate you will always get mavericks in any organisation in the same way as you get a small number who engage in wrongdoing and corruption.

Because that's what they've chosen to concentrate on - without any apparent success.

Who should be pursuing these charges you mention ?
The Portuguese admit to not knowing what crime was committed.
OG have no jurisdiction outside of UK.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Angelo222 on July 29, 2019, 04:53:34 PM
The 'some people are convinced that the T9 were not involved' includes forensic scientists, investigating authorities and judiciary over two countries.

And yes I appreciate Amaral believed/s the McCanns were involved but his hunch(es) were proved wrong.

You ask what is the evidence which has convinced people to look elsewhere and that's just it there's no evidence against the McCanns other than a witch-hunt and trial by social media based on a lot of subjectivity. 

Even if MM is found alive tomorrow I guarantee there will still be some who think the McCanns were involved.  These people will insist it isn't really MM, despite DNA tests confirming otherwise, and that its an inter-governmental cover-up involving senior politicians, intelligence services, Freemasons and the royal family etc.  Some are just conspiracy theorists.  Others will be unable to accept they called it wrong.

Their whole attitude to the original investigators would suggest a somewhat different perspective Holly. Then again they might simply be xenophobic.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 05:00:33 PM
Sutcliffe committed numerous crimes and was not identified via questioning, but by the discovery of a hammer.  Without that he likely would have not been identified on that occasion either

There are many cases where perps of crime are able to continue offending, running into the hundreds sometimes, until they're apprehended.  Take Delroy Grant dubbed the 'Night Stalker' he was able to commit hundreds of heinous crimes against the elderly.  Was Grant clever in covering his tracks or was the MET just incompetent?
 
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 29, 2019, 05:13:37 PM
There are many cases where perps of crime are able to continue offending, running into the hundreds sometimes, until they're apprehended.  Take Delroy Grant dubbed the 'Night Stalker' he was able to commit hundreds of heinous crimes against the elderly.  Was Grant clever in covering his tracks or was the MET just incompetent?

He was certainly clever enough not to have his details on police databases.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 29, 2019, 06:23:33 PM
They were booked in at 7.30.
Booked in not locked in.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: faithlilly on July 29, 2019, 06:43:05 PM
I'm not sure what you mean by ...'not one perpetrator outside of friends group has been identified." ?

The LCN DNA results were deemed "inconclusive" by FSS.

Inconclusive results -- Results may be inconclusive for several reasons. For example, contaminated samples often yield inconclusive results. So do very small or degraded samples, which may not have enough DNA to produce a full profile.

If the PJ/SY had anything on the McCanns/T7 they would charge them not continue with an investigation which has involved interviewing other suspects.

Some crimes take years to resolve/bring the perps to justice eg the murder of Lesley Molseed and Stephen Lawrence.  Some remain unsolved eg Jill Dando.  Some remain disappeared whereabouts unknown eg Suzy Lamplugh and Claudia Lawrence.

The fact MM's disappearance remains unresolved does not mean the McCanns/T7 were responsible.  It might mean the perp(s) got lucky and/or outwitted the authorities and/or the investigators were lacking.

Yes the forensics were inconclusive but could have been Madeleine but as I said without context finding her DNA in the apartment or car would prove nothing.

SY/PJ are keeping their cards close to their chests. We have no idea who or what is being investigated, and that includes the parents.

Not sure the point you are making re unsolved crimes. How does that prove that the parents are innocent ?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: ShiningInLuz on July 29, 2019, 07:13:07 PM
Booked in not locked in.

Are you seriously suggesting a 12 year old girl left the dining table, wandered off 800 m, to a place nowhere near her route home, just to have a fag, then returned to witness when the bill was paid?  And the others in the dining group failed to notice her absence?

 &%%6
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 29, 2019, 07:16:45 PM
Are you seriously suggesting a 12 year old girl left the dining table, wandered off 800 m, to a place nowhere near her route home, just to have a fag, then returned to witness when the bill was paid?  And the others in the dining group failed to notice her absence?

 &%%6
Something like that.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 07:47:16 PM
Yes the forensics were inconclusive but could have been Madeleine but as I said without context finding her DNA in the apartment or car would prove nothing.

SY/PJ are keeping their cards close to their chests. We have no idea who or what is being investigated, and that includes the parents.

Not sure the point you are making re unsolved crimes. How does that prove that the parents are innocent ?

Well as I see it, it seems to me many think the McCanns were responsible because investigators have been unable to charge anyone.   

I don't think I've ever claimed the McCanns are innocent although in the eyes of the law they are just that.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: pathfinder73 on July 29, 2019, 08:08:09 PM
I didn't say the McCanns needed a vehicle to hide a small body but I can't see the opportunity to conceal a body, small or otherwise, and transferring it elsewhere outside PDL without access to a vehicle.  Bodies quickly decompose and smell attracting flies and such like.

The GNR tracker dogs did not scent MM outside the immediate vicinity.   

PJ combed the area with tracker dogs and a helicopter.  I believe a geologist was brought in to look for any signs of recently disturbed earth.

I agree to move away from PDL would require a vehicle but a temporary hiding place in PDL was possible. KM said so - she and Gerry were searching all alone - not another soul in sight. SY were checking pipes in 2014 but they did not check on top of the cliffs away from town. Hiding something where people don't frequent is the safer option if hidden outdoors.

Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 08:17:06 PM
I agree to move away from PDL would require a vehicle but a temporary hiding place in PDL was possible. KM said so - she and Gerry were searching all alone - not another soul in sight. SY were checking pipes in 2014 but they did not check on top of the cliffs away from town. Hiding something where people don't frequent is the safer option if hidden outdoors.

As I said the whole of PDL was searched extensively involving helicopters and officers on horseback to comb remote areas.  A geologist was also used to identify recent earth/soil disturbance.  Nothing was found. 
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 29, 2019, 08:25:54 PM
As I said the whole of PDL was searched extensively involving helicopters and officers on horseback to comb remote areas.  A geologist was also used to identify recent earth/soil disturbance.  Nothing was found.


I wonder what that really means ?

I find it difficult to believe that every square metre of PDL and environs was searched to the degree you suggest.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: G-Unit on July 29, 2019, 08:26:18 PM
I think you need to define eliminated before we go any futher....I dont know what everyone else believes but i dont think we can totally eliminate the mccanns...nothing is certain...the evidence verystrongly suggests they are innocent and I think its highly unlikely they are involved...thats all we can say imo...and this is what i have said before

Perhaps others agree with you and accept the possibility of parental/T7 involvement. I tend to think we have people here who are convinced that they're not. I was just trying to discover if their apparent conviction was based on evidence, and if so, what it was. Which evidence very srongly suggests to you that they're innocent?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: pathfinder73 on July 29, 2019, 08:29:05 PM
There's no need to make it personal bordering on rudeness.

If Amaral's theory stood up to scrutiny how come the Home Office is still funding an investigation which revolves around an abduction and how come the McCanns were not charged with a number of offences eg perverting the course of justice and manslaughter or murder?

According to the media a donation of around 1K was made by MET officers.  If this is accurate you will always get mavericks in any organisation in the same way as you get a small number who engage in wrongdoing and corruption.

Nobody has been charged and it's called the Disappearance of MM NOT the Abduction of. "However she left the apartment" meaning nobody or nothing is ruled out!

All the hypothesises that you or I could come up with, they all have to remain open and the key lines of enquiry open today focus on one or two of those areas but we have to keep them all open until we get to that critical piece of evidence that narrows it down and helps us to be more confident as to exactly what has happened on the day Maddie went missing. Mark Rowley
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 29, 2019, 08:31:53 PM
Yes the forensics were inconclusive but could have been Madeleine but as I said without context finding her DNA in the apartment or car would prove nothing.

SY/PJ are keeping their cards close to their chests. We have no idea who or what is being investigated, and that includes the parents.

Not sure the point you are making re unsolved crimes. How does that prove that the parents are innocent ?
We do have some idea as they have told us.  You, however, choose not to believe them.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: faithlilly on July 29, 2019, 08:43:42 PM
Well as I see it, it seems to me many think the McCanns were responsible because investigators have been unable to charge anyone.   

I don't think I've ever claimed the McCanns are innocent although in the eyes of the law they are just that.

I have never heard anyone say that they think the parents are innocent because no one has been charged, however it certainly doesn’t prove that anyone else is being investigated. We simply don’t know how the investigation is proceeding. You must agree however that if they parents were being investigated under British law we wouldn’t know about it until they were charged ?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 08:50:28 PM
Nobody has been charged and it's called the Disappearance of MM NOT the Abduction of. "However she left the apartment" meaning nobody or nothing is ruled out!

All the hypothesises that you or I could come up with, they all have to remain open and the key lines of enquiry open today focus on one or two of those areas but we have to keep them all open until we get to that critical piece of evidence that narrows it down and helps us to be more confident as to exactly what has happened on the day Maddie went missing. Mark Rowley

Mark Rowley confirms @ approx 14 mins in that however MM left the apartment she was abducted:

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/video/interview-with-assistant-commissioner-mark-rowley-who-news-footage/673183860
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 29, 2019, 08:52:25 PM
Mark Rowley confirms @ approx 14 mins in that however MM left the apartment she was abducted:

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/video/interview-with-assistant-commissioner-mark-rowley-who-news-footage/673183860
Alive then at the point  of being abducted.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 08:55:00 PM
I have never heard anyone say that they think the parents are innocent because no one has been charged, however it certainly doesn’t prove that anyone else is being investigated. We simply don’t know how the investigation is proceeding. You must agree however that if they parents were being investigated under British law we wouldn’t know about it until they were charged ?

Imo some think the McCanns are involved because no one else has been charged and/or the case remains unsolved. 

Mark Rowley is on record saying the original investigation dealt with the McCanns and there's no need for SY to review.

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/video/interview-with-assistant-commissioner-mark-rowley-who-news-footage/673183860
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 29, 2019, 08:55:52 PM
Alive then at the point  of being abducted.


He's only guessing, though. He doesn't actually know  - IMO
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 29, 2019, 09:06:54 PM
Alive then at the point  of being abducted.

He says they have no definitive evidence to say if she is alive or dead,not once has he or any one else said they have evidence Madeleine left 5a alive,Redwood some years previous say's the same,they just don't know.


However, Redwood did say during the same press conference that police were considering the possibility that Madeleine was not alive when taken from the apartment as well as the possibility that she was.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: faithlilly on July 29, 2019, 09:12:57 PM
Mark Rowley confirms @ approx 14 mins in that however MM left the apartment she was abducted:

https://www.gettyimages.co.uk/detail/video/interview-with-assistant-commissioner-mark-rowley-who-news-footage/673183860

Isn’t that a strange turn of phrase. Why not just say that Madeleine was abducted ?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 09:15:51 PM
Isn’t that a strange turn of phrase. Why not just say that Madeleine was abducted ?

I assume he meant whether MM woke and wondered or whether someone entered 5A either way she was abducted. 
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 29, 2019, 09:17:56 PM
Alive then at the point  of being abducted.

If the McCanns were not involved can you see a plausible explanation as to why someone would murder MM either intentionally or otherwise inside 5A and then remove her body?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 29, 2019, 09:19:53 PM
He says they have no definitive evidence to say if she is alive or dead,not once has he or any one else said they have evidence Madeleine left 5a alive,Redwood some years previous say's the same,they just don't know.


However, Redwood did say during the same press conference that police were considering the possibility that Madeleine was not alive when taken from the apartment as well as the possibility that she was.

That was before they received the information that resulted from the Crimewatch program. 

If the McCanns were not involved can you see a plausible explanation as to why someone would murder MM either intentionally or otherwise inside 5A and then remove her body?

Not easily.  You can always make up some unlikely story.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 29, 2019, 09:23:35 PM
That was before they received the information that resulted from the Crimewatch program. 



And since then the line is the same,no definitive evidence either way.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 29, 2019, 09:25:17 PM
And since then the line is the same,no definitive evidence either way.
Have you got the cite for that?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 29, 2019, 09:39:09 PM
Have you got the cite for that?


You provided it the other day.

Q: There is a chance she may still be alive.
MR: We have to keep an open mind, it is a missing person enquiry, we don’t have that definitive
evidence either way.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: faithlilly on July 29, 2019, 09:50:01 PM
I assume he meant whether MM woke and wondered or whether someone entered 5A either way she was abducted.

But that’s not what he said.  Did he mention woke and wandered ? This has been wiped from the SY website, along with all other mention of OG. I wonder why ?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: The General on July 29, 2019, 09:55:15 PM
But that’s not what he said.  Did he mention woke and wandered ? This has been wiped from the SY website, along with all other mention of OG. I wonder why ?
Gerry and Kate themselves dismissed this notion.
Let's get it right, it's an odd turn of phrase, with the first part of the sentence leaving us with possibilities, then a definitive stance that contradicts the former. It's a ham-fisted attempt to change the direction of an answer mid-sentence. In my most subservient, deferential of opinions proffered on a slate instead of a plate.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 29, 2019, 10:12:37 PM
Policemen are notoriously verbose, and imo some come across somewhat inarticulately when interviewed, Redwood and Rowley are two good examples of this.  Is it an attempt to try and appear cleverer than they actually are, by using 10 words where one would do?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: The General on July 29, 2019, 10:24:40 PM
Policemen are notoriously verbose, and imo some come across somewhat inarticulately when interviewed, Redwood and Rowley are two good examples of this.  Is it an attempt to try and appear cleverer than they actually are, by using 10 words where one would do?
It's an odd paradox and one you observe well.
I see it all the time, the Peter Principal, senior management promoted 'beyond their abilities', usually due to simple longevity, who subconsciously feign eloquence thinking that's what's expected in their new-found, lofty position. Sometimes coupled with Imposter Syndrome. The police force incubates this, with career policemen / women who are essentially bureaucrats, occasionally wheeled out as a talking head to trot out the usual soundbites, but are seemingly incapable of coherent improvisation.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 30, 2019, 12:07:28 AM

You provided it the other day.

Q: There is a chance she may still be alive.
MR: We have to keep an open mind, it is a missing person enquiry, we don’t have that definitive
evidence either way.

IMO you got that wrong.
The question was " There is a chance she may still be alive."

To be "still alive" she has to leave alive.  But you know it is 12 years plus so anything could have happened since then. 
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 30, 2019, 12:10:16 AM
Policemen are notoriously verbose, and imo some come across somewhat inarticulately when interviewed, Redwood and Rowley are two good examples of this.  Is it an attempt to try and appear cleverer than they actually are, by using 10 words where one would do?
You have gone beyond the limit with that comment.  Should I delete it? 
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 30, 2019, 12:12:03 AM
It's an odd paradox and one you observe well.
I see it all the time, the Peter Principal, senior management promoted 'beyond their abilities', usually due to simple longevity, who subconsciously feign eloquence thinking that's what's expected in their new-found, lofty position. Sometimes coupled with Impostor Syndrome. The police force incubates this, with career policemen / women who are essentially bureaucrats, occasionally wheeled out as a talking head to trot out the usual soundbites, but are seemingly incapable of coherent improvisation.
That is even worse.  Or is that said from a position of knowledge?
"Impostor Syndrome"  who talks about that? 
" the Peter Principal"  who knows about that too?

"The police force incubates this, with career policemen / women who are essentially bureaucrats, occasionally wheeled out as a talking head to trot out the usual soundbites, but are seemingly incapable of coherent improvisation"  That is what we want isn't it?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: G-Unit on July 30, 2019, 05:51:37 AM
That is even worse.  Or is that said from a position of knowledge?
"Impostor Syndrome"  who talks about that? 
" the Peter Principal"  who knows about that too?

"The police force incubates this, with career policemen / women who are essentially bureaucrats, occasionally wheeled out as a talking head to trot out the usual soundbites, but are seemingly incapable of coherent improvisation"  That is what we want isn't it?

I've both heard of the Peter Principle and seen it in action.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 30, 2019, 06:12:35 AM
IMO you got that wrong.
The question was " There is a chance she may still be alive."

To be "still alive" she has to leave alive.  But you know it is 12 years plus so anything could have happened since then.
Indeed but the digs in 2014 show imo their line of thinking,coupled with scaling back of OG to four showed the bulk of their investigation drew a blank.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Vertigo Swirl on July 30, 2019, 06:24:46 AM
You have gone beyond the limit with that comment.  Should I delete it?
What limit is that? If in doubt ask your boss.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: The General on July 30, 2019, 10:12:13 AM
That is even worse.  Or is that said from a position of knowledge?
"Impostor Syndrome"  who talks about that? 
" the Peter Principal"  who knows about that too?

"The police force incubates this, with career policemen / women who are essentially bureaucrats, occasionally wheeled out as a talking head to trot out the usual soundbites, but are seemingly incapable of coherent improvisation"  That is what we want isn't it?
The subject may not necessarily be aware of either psychological states / theories, but are merely exhibiting the specific personality traits.
Do we want this? Depends who 'we' are. Is it desirable for a reporter to receive the robotic, dogmatic sound bite to fill their column inches? Probably not. Is it desirable for a grieving mother to receive empty platitudes, notwithstanding the fact that there may not be another response available? The example isn't the best and most likely isn't typical, and is perhaps inadequate to discuss this in more detail.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Angelo222 on July 30, 2019, 10:35:50 AM
Well as I see it, it seems to me many think the McCanns were responsible because investigators have been unable to charge anyone.   

I don't think I've ever claimed the McCanns are innocent although in the eyes of the law they are just that.

Portugal's Supreme Court wouldn't agree.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 30, 2019, 10:43:31 AM
Portugal's Supreme Court wouldn't agree.

I guess I was thinking SY but of course the disappearance occurred in Portugal.  How does Portugal's Supreme Court view the McCanns given the aguido/aguida status has been lifted?
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: G-Unit on July 30, 2019, 11:00:03 AM
I guess I was thinking SY but of course the disappearance occurred in Portugal.  How does Portugal's Supreme Court view the McCanns given the aguido/aguida status has been lifted?

The McCann's lawyers claimed the couple were 'cleared' by the archiving report. The SC judges rejected that claim, which makes sense to me, but not to others. In my opinion people can only be cleared by the courts.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Mr Gray on July 30, 2019, 11:14:38 AM
The McCann's lawyers claimed the couple were 'cleared' by the archiving report. The SC judges rejected that claim, which makes sense to me, but not to others. In my opinion people can only be cleared by the courts.

Depends what is meant by cleared. Didn't the Portuguese claim the mccanns lost their chance to prove their innocence.... So could they have been cleared by simple reconstruction.
Courts don't completely clear people... They find them not guilty..

The mccanns were cleared of their suspect status by the archiving report...
The SC judgement said the mccanns were not entitled to the presumption of innocence... Ive already provided a cite from the ECHR which suggests the SC were wrong
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 30, 2019, 09:03:02 PM
Depends what is meant by cleared. Didn't the Portuguese claim the mccanns lost their chance to prove their innocence.... So could they have been cleared by simple reconstruction.
Courts don't completely clear people... They find them not guilty..

The mccanns were cleared of their suspect status by the archiving report...
The SC judgement said the mccanns were not entitled to the presumption of innocence... Ive already provided a cite from the ECHR which suggests the SC were wrong
This case isn't going away soon by the sound of it.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 30, 2019, 09:06:51 PM
This case isn't going away soon by the sound of it.

The ECHR remains in the same limbo as two yrs ago,application requiring a  decision.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Mr Gray on July 30, 2019, 09:07:25 PM
This case isn't going away soon by the sound of it.
I would say the case against the mccanns has gone away...the ECHR hasnt and I think it will be very very interesting based on what I ahve raed on the ECHR site
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Mr Gray on July 30, 2019, 09:08:32 PM
The ECHR remains in the same limbo as two yrs ago,application requiring a  decision.

of course it does...but there were those saying the mccanns would not apply and those saying it would be quickly thrown out
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 30, 2019, 09:09:16 PM
The ECHR remains in the same limbo as two yrs ago,application requiring a  decision.
I suppose Brexit has some bearing on the case too now.  Maybe Trump needs to throw his weight around.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Mr Gray on July 30, 2019, 09:10:13 PM
I suppose Brexit has some bearing on the case too now.  Maybe Trump needs to throw his weight around.

no bearing
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 30, 2019, 09:11:02 PM
no bearing
Stop pretending to know everything. 
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Mr Gray on July 30, 2019, 09:11:59 PM
Stop pretending to know everything.

ad hom...tell me how brexit affects the case ..it doesnt...
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 30, 2019, 09:12:24 PM
Stop pretending to know everything.

I sense he's likely to be right for once.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Mr Gray on July 30, 2019, 09:13:02 PM
I sense he's likely to be right for once.

thank you
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: jassi on July 30, 2019, 09:13:55 PM
I suppose Brexit has some bearing on the case too now.  Maybe Trump needs to throw his weight around.

As the EU is quite separate from the ECHR and America is not part of Europe, I find that unlikely
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Mr Gray on July 30, 2019, 09:14:35 PM
As the EU is quite separate from the ECHR and America is not part of Europe, I find that unlikely

yet rob tries to make out Im wrong
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 30, 2019, 09:16:21 PM
ad hom...tell me how brexit affects the case ..it doesnt...
I could see the Europeans don't want Portugal being told off for something those poms did in the first instance, especially since they are leaving the EU.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Mr Gray on July 30, 2019, 09:17:58 PM
I could see the Europeans don't want Portugal being told off for something those poms did in the first instance, especially since they are leaving the EU.

so you are libelling the ECHR judges and suggesting they wont apply the law fairly..I think thats a bit silly
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 30, 2019, 09:19:39 PM
so you are libelling the ECHR judges and suggesting they wont apply the law fairly..I think thats a bit silly
WUP ???    I know you love talking about the ECHR and not on the topic. 
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Mr Gray on July 30, 2019, 09:20:08 PM
WUP ???    I know you love talking about the ECHR and not on the topic.

you have discussed it too
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: barrier on July 30, 2019, 09:20:15 PM
Tis a strange set of circumstances,a innocent son gets shot to death on the London underground and the family find no recourse through the ECHR,a family claiming to be wronged through words, in the eyes of some have a case.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Mr Gray on July 30, 2019, 09:21:50 PM
Tis a strange set of circumstances,a innocent son gets shot to death on the London underground and the family find no recourse through the ECHR,a family claiming to be wronged through words, in the eyes of some have a case.

I think they both have  a case....
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 30, 2019, 09:25:03 PM
I think they both have  a case....
You would have more of a case if you got back to the OP.

"Some people are convinced that the T9 were not involved in Madeleine's disappearance. I've seen many reasons quoted but none of them stands up to scrutiny in my opinion. What is the evidence which has convinced people to look elsewhere for an explanation?"
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Mr Gray on July 30, 2019, 09:30:36 PM
You would have more of a case if you got back to the OP.

"Some people are convinced that the T9 were not involved in Madeleine's disappearance. I've seen many reasons quoted but none of them stands up to scrutiny in my opinion. What is the evidence which has convinced people to look elsewhere for an explanation?"

Ive already answerred to OP...I dont think the mccans are involved....I canr be 100% certain however....Ive suppplied the evidence to support my beleif many times and dont see the point in doing so again. If posters are going to use the SC ruling as some raeson to doubt the mccanns i feel its fair to say the judges in the SC may have erred and we will ahve a decision on taht from the ECHR
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 30, 2019, 09:35:51 PM
Ive already answerred to OP...I dont think the mccans are involved....I canr be 100% certain however....Ive suppplied the evidence to support my beleif many times and dont see the point in doing so again. If posters are going to use the SC ruling as some raeson to doubt the mccanns i feel its fair to say the judges in the SC may have erred and we will ahve a decision on taht from the ECHR
Well I hope the ECHR use spell checker before they publish the report.
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Mr Gray on July 30, 2019, 09:36:55 PM
Well I hope the ECHR use spell checker before they publish the report.

more ad homs...sign to everyone you are losing the argument...LOL
Title: Re: Parental/T7 Involvement
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 30, 2019, 10:22:30 PM
more ad homs...sign to everyone you are losing the argument...LOL
Who's arguing?  I'm not.