UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Robittybob1 on July 31, 2019, 09:10:42 AM

Title: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 31, 2019, 09:10:42 AM
Using the search engine on the forum there are 30  results for "Haute de la Garenne"  or is it "Haut de la Garenne".
All of the results were on the Madeleine McCann section (called a board).

What can we learn from an analysis of the posts already on the forum?

There were 20 more results for "Haut de la Garenne" rather than "Haute de la Garenne"  but even on Google there are examples of both spellings.

Each of the results seems to be on a different thread.  i.e. 50 odd threads, so it seems rather a task.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 31, 2019, 09:29:13 AM
http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10931.msg549224#msg549224

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=10341.msg548941#msg548941

http://miscarriageofjustice.co/index.php?topic=6106.msg542698#msg542698

ETC 50 times in total.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: The General on July 31, 2019, 09:41:48 AM
Nothing good will come from this thread.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 31, 2019, 09:50:28 AM
Nothing good will come from this thread.

I agree.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 31, 2019, 10:06:56 AM
I don't think anything particularly useful comes from any thread. There are those who believe the dog alerts are highly significant...
The answer to the question re cadaver odour is nobody knows. Did the dogs find any useful evidence... No
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 31, 2019, 10:38:56 AM
I don't think anything particularly useful comes from any thread. There are those who believe the dog alerts are highly significant...
The answer to the question re cadaver odour is nobody knows. Did the dogs find any useful evidence... No

I don't believe its true that nothing particularly useful comes from any thread.  Since arriving here I've learned a lot about the case and I wouldn't mind betting most here have a far better understanding of the case than most crime journalists etc. 

I think there is definitive knowledge about the odour.  We know from the Shannon Matthews case that the police identified problems with contamination:

The properties the dogs searched contained a high level of second hand furniture bought from dwellings where someone had died.  This resulted in numerous indications that required further investigation to confirm whether they were connected to the investigation, or to previous owners of the furniture.

Page 25:

http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Operation-Paris.pdf

There's further info here from the Forensic Science International which again illustrates the problem with contamination. 

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/51385143_Cadaver_dogs_-_A_study_on_detection_of_contaminated_carpet_squares

We know a previous owner of 5A, Michael William McCann (no relation to the McCanns) died in the UK in 2006.  If his wife transferred some item that was on or around Mr McCann when he passed then clearly this would continue emitting the odour. 

I'm just giving Mr McCann as one example.  Mrs Fenn was also widowed and may well have given something to the owners of 5A that was on or around Mr Fenn when he passed. 

I think PJ looked into whether anyone had died in 5A?  But as we can see it isn't just a case of whether anyone died in 5A but whether 5A was at any stage contaminated with the odour from a benign source.

I have again emailed the McCanns and Op Grange about this.   ?>)()<
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 31, 2019, 10:43:21 AM
I'm beginning to think the odour is tranferred from location to location by way of bacteria and funghi on skin cells and its this that the dogs are alerting to. 
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 31, 2019, 10:48:01 AM
I don't believe its true that nothing particularly useful comes from any thread.  Since arriving here I've learned a lot about the case and I wouldn't mind betting most here have a far better understanding of the case than most crime journalists etc. 

I think there is definitive knowledge about the odour.  We know from the Shannon Matthews case that the police identified problems with contamination:

The properties the dogs searched contained a high level of second hand furniture bought from dwellings where someone had died.  This resulted in numerous indications that required further investigation to confirm whether they were connected to the investigation, or to previous owners of the furniture.

Page 25:

http://library.college.police.uk/docs/npia/Operation-Paris.pdf

There's further info here from the Forensic Science International which again illustrates the problem with contamination. 

https://www.researchgate.net/publication/51385143_Cadaver_dogs_-_A_study_on_detection_of_contaminated_carpet_squares

We know a previous owner of 5A, Michael William McCann (no relation to the McCanns) died in the UK in 2006.  If his wife transferred some item that was on or around Mr McCann when he passed then clearly this would continue emitting the odour. 

I'm just giving Mr McCann as one example.  Mrs Fenn was also widowed and may well have given something to the owners of 5A that was on or around Mr Fenn when he passed. 

I think PJ looked into whether anyone had died in 5A?  But as we can see it isn't just a case of whether anyone died in 5A but whether 5A was at any stage contaminated with the odour from a benign source.

I have again emailed the McCanns and Op Grange about this.   ?>)()<

If you read Grimes statement he says he trains dogs to find forensically recoverable evidence.... Or something like that.

So the dogs role is to help find evidence... Whats happerd now is that the alerts themselves are being used as evidence.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: The General on July 31, 2019, 10:50:58 AM
Here we go...
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 31, 2019, 11:15:14 AM
Here we go...

You've already said as I recall the one thing that really makes you doubt the McCanns is the alerts. If I thought the alerts were indicative I to would doubt them... But I don't see them as having any value
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: alphonse on July 31, 2019, 11:18:23 AM
Eddie plays his cards very close to his chest.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Mr Gray on July 31, 2019, 11:20:43 AM
Eddie plays his cards very close to his chest.

The question is did Eddie alert to cadaver odour... The answer is we don't know
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: alphonse on July 31, 2019, 11:21:20 AM
Now on a serious note. I have no idea. Did they use a second blood dog as Grime explained in the Madeleine case?
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: The General on July 31, 2019, 11:33:06 AM
You've already said as I recall the one thing that really makes you doubt the McCanns is the alerts. If I thought the alerts were indicative I to would doubt them... But I don't see them as having any value
We know, hence the futility of the thread.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 31, 2019, 11:36:06 AM
The question is did Eddie alert to cadaver odour... The answer is we don't know

I think the question needs to be if Eddie was alerting to cadaver odour what was the source?  We can see from the UK police and forensic scientists that the dogs alert to the odour which does not need to have come directly from a corpse.  The odour is capable of being transferred from place to place on inanimate objects eg in the examples above furniture and carpets. 

We all shed some 40,000 skin rafts per minute.  These are made up of skin cells, bacteria, fungus and parasites  8)><(  My hunch is that during the post mortem interval the skin rafts continue shedding and the living organisms eg bacteria etc take on a different complexion and it is this that is capable of being transferred from one location to another and this that gives off the cadaver odour. 
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: alphonse on July 31, 2019, 11:39:33 AM
I certainly had more faith in the dog alerts before starting to look at this case. Now it appears more hit and miss but can be useful when they want someone to confess. When I say faith I mean I hadn´t really thought about it at all. I had maybe seen two or three crime programmes where they had brought in these cadaver dogs and the perp had ended up confessing. That´s all I had to go on. When you start scratching the surface it´s not always such a slam dunk.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: The General on July 31, 2019, 12:01:07 PM
I certainly had more faith in the dog alerts before starting to look at this case. Now it appears more hit and miss but can be useful when they want someone to confess. When I say faith I mean I hadn´t really thought about it at all. I had maybe seen two or three crime programmes where they had brought in these cadaver dogs and the perp had ended up confessing. That´s all I had to go on. When you start scratching the surface it´s not always such a slam dunk.
I see them as a useful detection tool. There's rarely a slam dunk i.e. cadaver dog finds actual cadaver, or blood dog finds blood, which is corroborative.
Otherwise they lend weight to the body of circumstantial evidence.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 31, 2019, 12:08:25 PM
I'm beginning to think the odour is transferred from location to location by way of bacteria and fungi on skin cells and its this that the dogs are alerting to.
That is a new one on me.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 31, 2019, 12:19:08 PM
I see them as a useful detection tool. There's rarely a slam dunk i.e. cadaver dog finds actual cadaver, or blood dog finds blood, which is corroborative.
Otherwise they lend weight to the body of circumstantial evidence.
There have been some remarkable finds where a body has been tossed into a lake, or the one that really struck home for me was a body buried about 12 foot down covered with sheets of plastic.

But you are right in most cases where a body is in the room or the crime scene is awash with blood you don't need a cadaver dog to find evidence.
If the perpetrator feels outdone by a dog, they might confess.  Best thing out for everyone.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Holly Goodhead on July 31, 2019, 12:30:00 PM
That is a new one on me.

How would you suggest cadaver odour is transferred from one location to another on inanimate objects? 
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: The General on July 31, 2019, 12:34:35 PM
How would you suggest cadaver odour is transferred from one location to another on inanimate objects?
This has been visited. Can't provide the cite, but there's a body of scientific analysis re: migration, particularly in burial. It happens, given the right parameters; water table, density of material, root systems, et al.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 31, 2019, 02:08:29 PM
How would you suggest cadaver odour is transferred from one location to another on inanimate objects?
I have been trying to figure that out.  That is why I thought your idea novel, even though I don't think it is right, but  possibly going down the right track.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 31, 2019, 02:10:32 PM
This has been visited. Can't provide the cite, but there's a body of scientific analysis re: migration, particularly in burial. It happens, given the right parameters; water table, density of material, root systems, et al.
That was showing how it can be transported via water movement.  But the real question is: What is in the water?
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on July 31, 2019, 09:55:44 PM
I wonder if scientists have worked out how the olfactory system actually works?  How does olfaction actually work?
https://www.ted.com/talks/jennifer_pluznick_you_smell_with_your_body_not_just_your_nose/transcript?language=en

Can sense up to a trillion odours!
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 01, 2019, 12:50:30 AM
Here is a scientist who actually discovered something about smell  https://www.ted.com/talks/luca_turin_on_the_science_of_scent#t-936940
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 01, 2019, 02:57:51 AM
Nothing good will come from this thread.
Well let's see if someone can prove you wrong!
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 01, 2019, 03:00:56 AM
I don't think anything particularly useful comes from any thread. There are those who believe the dog alerts are highly significant...
The answer to the question re cadaver odour is nobody knows. Did the dogs find any useful evidence... No
Are you saying there was no one ever charged for the incidents claimed at Haut de la Garenne? 
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 01, 2019, 03:08:54 AM
I don't believe its true that nothing particularly useful comes from any thread.  Since arriving here I've learned a lot about the case and I wouldn't mind betting most here have a far better understanding of the case than most crime journalists etc. 

...snip ....
We know a previous owner of 5A, Michael William McCann (no relation to the McCanns) died in the UK in 2006.  If his wife transferred some item that was on or around Mr McCann when he passed then clearly this would continue emitting the odour.

... snip ...

This idea that something contaminated with cadaver odour will continue emitting the odour, IMO is clearly wrong but has not been disproven by scientific experiment.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 01, 2019, 03:12:43 AM
If you read Grimes statement he says he trains dogs to find forensically recoverable evidence.... Or something like that.

So the dogs role is to help find evidence... Whats happerd now is that the alerts themselves are being used as evidence.
Well we have  debated that before too.  Even Grime may have said "he trains dogs to find forensically recoverable evidence"  but IMO they assist the forensic team "to find forensically recoverable evidence".  Splitting hairs???
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 01, 2019, 03:13:33 AM
Here we go...
Same old, same old. 
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 01, 2019, 03:15:29 AM
Eddie plays his cards very close to his chest.
Eddie the poker player.  I like the image.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 01, 2019, 03:17:29 AM
Now on a serious note. I have no idea. Did they use a second blood dog as Grime explained in the Madeleine case?
Someone did mention Keela in one of the documentaries.   I'll keep that question in the back of my mind.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 01, 2019, 03:22:07 AM
You've already said as I recall the one thing that really makes you doubt the McCanns is the alerts. If I thought the alerts were indicative I to would doubt them... But I don't see them as having any value
Did you mean it as it has ended up.   It reads illogically to me, so I'm wondering if you've dropped a word.

You wrote: "If I thought the alerts were indicative I to would doubt them".  But should it be
"If I thought the alerts were indicative I to would NOT doubt them"?

What would make you "NOT doubt them"?
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 01, 2019, 04:42:57 AM
On the basis of what is written in Wikipedia as being basically correct.  There have been some convictions made but not based on evidence found subsequent to dog searches.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jersey_child_abuse_investigation_2008
"Charges
Jersey Police have so far recorded claims of abuse from 100 people.[18] The police investigated 18 key suspects in the wider investigation,[19] but the Attorney General stated in 2009 that a significant number of these complaints were unsuitable for the criminal courts, including "being made to take cold showers, being clipped around the ear, slapped about the head and flicked with a wet towel".[20] Arrests and charges have been made[21] and as of August 2009 the investigation continues. However the police have stated that there will not be the number of prosecutions which were originally reported, and Detective Superintendent Gradwell stated in August 2009 that the problems with the handling of the inquiry before he took over had "generated a very high level of expectation among complainants and the public" that "a large number of people would be prosecuted".[22] Out of six files received by the prosecution lawyers in August 2008, charges were laid in respect of three of them and it was concluded by June 2009 that no charges would be brought in respect of the remaining three for "legal and evidential reasons" as explained by the Attorney General.[23] Detective Superintendent Gradwell stated in August 2009 that all the police officers from the UK working with the States police had agreed with decisions made by the Attorney General, lawyers and the independent legal team about cases submitted for prosecution, but that "a few more people are likely to be charged".[22] On 27 February 2010 a married couple from Scotland were charged with a number of common assaults on children while they were working at Haut de la Garenne in the 1970s and 1980s.[24]

Trials
In May 2009, Michael Aubin, then 46, admitted[25] in the Royal Court of Jersey two counts of gross indecency and two counts of indecent assault on children under 10 years old while he himself was a child resident of Haut de la Garenne. He was sentenced on 22 June 2009 to two years' probation, having spent 19 months on remand.[26] The trial was presided over by Royal Court Commissioner Julian Clyde-Smith.[27]

In August 2009, Gordon Claude Wateridge, then 78, was found guilty of eight counts of indecent assault and one count of assault but acquitted on 11 counts of indecent assault and one count of incitement to indecent assault, all relating to his time as a house parent at Haut de la Garenne in the 1970s.[28] Royal Court Commissioner Sir Christopher Pitchers, presiding, warned Wateridge to expect a custodial sentence for such a "breach of trust".[29] On 21 September Wateridge was sentenced to 2 years imprisonment by the Inferior Number of the Royal Court.[30]

In August 2009, Claude Donnelly, then 69, was sentenced by the Superior Number of Royal Court to a total of 15 years in prison after two trials in May 2009 and June 2009 for offences against young girls between 1968 and 1982. These offences were unconnected to Haut de la Garenne. He was convicted in May 2009 on one count of rape and three counts of indecent assault and in June 2009 on ten counts of indecent assault, four counts of rape and one count of procuring an act of gross indecency.[31] Royal Court Commissioner Sir Christopher Pitchers, presiding, said that the abuse had had a terrible effect on Donnelly's victims, and that the substantial period of imprisonment recommended by the Attorney General was correct.[32]

In November 2010, Morag and Anthony Jordan, a married couple who worked as house parents at Haut de la Garenne during the 1970s, were convicted of eight separate counts relating to physical abuse and subsequently received jail terms of nine and six months. Morag Jordan was acquitted of a further 28 counts and her husband of four. [33]"
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 01, 2019, 08:21:18 AM
Did you mean it as it has ended up.   It reads illogically to me, so I'm wondering if you've dropped a word.

You wrote: "If I thought the alerts were indicative I to would doubt them".  But should it be
"If I thought the alerts were indicative I to would NOT doubt them"?

What would make you "NOT doubt them"?

Rob... It's in plain English. I have not dropped any words. If you think it's illogical and don't understand it then the problem is with you unfortunately.
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 01, 2019, 08:47:37 AM
Rob... It's in plain English. I have not dropped any words. If you think it's illogical and don't understand it then the problem is with you unfortunately.
Well just to clear it up: What would make you "NOT doubt them"?
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 01, 2019, 08:49:45 AM
Well just to clear it up: What would make you "NOT doubt them"?

I never said that so why are you asking me
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 01, 2019, 08:54:58 AM
I never said that so why are you asking me
You said you would doubt them, so what would make you change your mind?

Here is the quote ""If I thought the alerts were indicative I too would doubt them"

What would make you not doubt them? 
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: John on August 01, 2019, 01:38:21 PM
Posters are reminded of the forum rules and the penalties for breaching same. Please keep posts amicable and constructive and above all, on topic. TY
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Mr Gray on August 01, 2019, 02:05:17 PM
You said you would doubt them, so what would make you change your mind?

Here is the quote ""If I thought the alerts were indicative I too would doubt them"

What would make you not doubt them?

Based on everything I've seen I think the McCanns are telling truth... But of course I can't be totally 100 % certain
Title: Re: Haute de la Garenne - Did Eddie find cadaver odour there?
Post by: Robittybob1 on August 01, 2019, 06:48:55 PM
Based on everything I've seen I think the McCanns are telling truth... But of course I can't be totally 100 % certain
So "them" are the McCanns and not the alerts.  No wonder we were at loggerheads.