UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: ferryman on May 02, 2013, 06:14:05 PM
-
I will add in edits.
The Daily Mirror says this:
A suspicious stalker was seen lurking outside Madeleine McCann's holiday flat just five days before she vanished, it was confirmed yesterday.
British holidaymaker Paul Gordon has told detectives he spotted a "dodgy looking" male at the patio doors.
When confronted, the "non British"- looking man claimed he was collecting money for charity before vanishing.
The new information renews fears that paedophiles may have stalked the McCanns for days at the Ocean Club complex, in Praia da Luz on the Portuguese Algarve.
Yesterday, speaking publicly for the first time, brewery executive Paul said: "I've given a statement and hope the information may help find Madeleine.
"I told police all I know. I was in the apartment before the McCanns but I've never met them."
Paul, 34, arrived at his home in Fareham, Hants, concealing his face with a hoodie and walked with his back facing the street at all times.
He and his family rented the Praia flat for a fortnight at the end of April before Kate and Gerry McCann, both 39, took it over.
After Madeleine disappeared on May 3, Paul contacted Scotland Yard.
He told detectives how he spotted the mystery man outside the flat's patio doors as his own children, aged one and two, slept inside.
The stranger claimed he was collecting donations for an orphanage.
But he roused suspicions as the patio doors are at the rear of the house and concealed by a high hedge.
Paul went inside to get some money and the man abruptly left.
At first, Paul feared he was casing the flat to plan a burglary. Then Madeleine disappeared and he realised the incidents may be linked.
Paul said the man did not look British and was outside the apartment long enough to work out its layout .
The patio doors were unlocked the night Madeleine, four, vanished.
Paul was interviewed several times and has given a sworn statement.
He has also volunteered to give DNA and fingerprint samples.
One of his friends said earlier: "He's very safety-conscious when it comes to his children." McCann spokesman Clarence Mitchell confirmed Paul had come forward.
He said: "Mr Gordon has spoken to police and to our investigators. Gerry and Kate have never met him."
A friend of suspect Robert Murat, 34, falsely told police the Brit expat was drunk in a cafe the night Madeleine vanished.
Murat insists he was at home with his mother Jenny, 71. A source told newspaper 24 Horas: "The friend guaranteed Murat was in a coffee shop about five kilometres from the Ocean Club. He said he left drunk."
Murat's lawyer Francisco Pagarete, said: "He tried to defend Robert and ended up prejudicing him. We can prove Murat was with his mother."
Portuguese police claim they have enough evidence to prosecute the McCanns who are also official suspects.
Detectives still plan to travel to the UK to interview the couple and the seven holiday friends they were dining with when Madeleine went missing.
GP Kate and cardiologist Gerry have always denied any involvement.
Check out all the latest News, Sport & Celeb gossip at Mirror.co.uk http://www.mirror.co.uk/news/uk-news/i-saw-stalker-by-maddy-apartment-284548#ixzz2S9jc4Atl
Follow us: @DailyMirror on Twitter | DailyMirror on Facebook
Note the verbatim quote from Pagarete. Is he* talking about Martin Smith?
Martin Smith's statement as we read it doesn't correspond with what Pagarete says.
I will add in an edit ...
From Martin Smith's first statement we have this:
— States that it is not possible for him to recognise the individual in person or by photograph.
— Adds that in May and August of 2006, he saw ROBERT MURAT in Praia da Luz bars. On one of these occasions, the first, he was inebriated and spoke to everyone. He did not wear glasses at that time. He also states that the individual who carried the child was not ROBERT. He would have recognised him immediately.
Hmmmm!
I was under the impression Murat's friend Tuck Price had said Murat had been teetotal for many years.
I confess, I can't find that quote now. I'll add if I come across it.
Or unless anyone else can? ...
Edited to clarify question ...
-
Note the verbatim quote from Pagarete. He is talking about Martin Smith?
Are you asking a question or stating your belief here Ferryman ? The inclusion of a question mark at the end of the sentence is confusing.
Martin Smith's statement as we read it doesn't correspond with what Pagarete says.
I will add in an edit ...
From Martin Smith's first statement we have this:
— States that it is not possible for him to recognise the individual in person or by photograph.
— Adds that in May and August of 2006,
This is one whole year before Madeleine went missing !
he saw ROBERT MURAT in Praia da Luz bars. On one of these occasions, the first, he was inebriated and spoke to everyone. He did not wear glasses at that time. He also states that the individual who carried the child was not ROBERT. He would have recognised him immediately.
-
Note the verbatim quote from Pagarete. He is talking about Martin Smith?
Are you asking a question or stating your belief here Ferryman ? The inclusion of a question mark at the end of the sentence is confusing.
Martin Smith's statement as we read it doesn't correspond with what Pagarete says.
I will add in an edit ...
From Martin Smith's first statement we have this:
— States that it is not possible for him to recognise the individual in person or by photograph.
— Adds that in May and August of 2006,
This is one whole year before Madeleine went missing !
he saw ROBERT MURAT in Praia da Luz bars. On one of these occasions, the first, he was inebriated and spoke to everyone. He did not wear glasses at that time. He also states that the individual who carried the child was not ROBERT. He would have recognised him immediately.
Yes, that was intended to be a question.
And that was my query about the anomaly.
If Pagarete isn't talking about Martin Smith, then who is he talking about?
I can't think of another witness statement in the files that remotely matches what (or particularly whose statement) Pagarete describes.
Can anyone else?
-
Apart from the danger of quoting red rags, as if they were any kind of font of truth, Martin. Smith in his statement does not say he saw Murat in a bar drunk that night.
-
Hi Ferryman, is it just me who is struggling to find a link between the question posed in the thread subject line and the cited references in the body of the post ?
Also the 'damascus moment' reference is rather ill used, a more apt phrase may be 'eureka moment' !
-
And there is also this from the Irish Gardia police officer who took Mr Smith's statement:
He [Mr Smith] has been contacted by numerous tabloid press looking for stories. He has been contacted by Mr Brian Kennedy who is supporting the McCann family to take part in a photo fit exercise. He has given no stories or helped in any photo fits. He sent a solicitor's letter to six papers in relation material that was printed that was misquoted. The Evening Herald paid his solicitor's fees and all papers printed an apology. His photograph appeared in another tabloid paper and this matter is being pursued at the moment.
-
Hi Ferryman, is it just me who is struggling to find a link between the question posed in the thread subject line and the cited references in the body of the post ?
Also the 'damascus moment' reference is rather ill used, a more apt phrase may be 'eureka moment' !
The anomaly is in working out who, if not Martin Smith, Pagarete is talking about
-
Apart from the danger of quoting red rags, as if they were any kind of font of truth, Martin. Smith in his statement does not say he saw Murat in a bar drunk that night.
No matter the source, a verbatim quote from a named person is a verbatim quote from a named person ...
-
Hi Ferryman, is it just me who is struggling to find a link between the question posed in the thread subject line and the cited references in the body of the post ?
Also the 'damascus moment' reference is rather ill used, a more apt phrase may be 'eureka moment' !
The anomaly is in working out who, if not Martin Smith, Pagarete is talking about
Hi Ferryman, what is the Martin Smith 'damascus moment' you quote in the title thread ? That may help me understand where you are coming from, thank you.
-
Hi Ferryman, is it just me who is struggling to find a link between the question posed in the thread subject line and the cited references in the body of the post ?
Also the 'damascus moment' reference is rather ill used, a more apt phrase may be 'eureka moment' !
The anomaly is in working out who, if not Martin Smith, Pagarete is talking about
Hi Ferryman, what is the Martin Smith 'damascus moment' you quote in the title thread ? That may help me understand where you are coming from, thank you.
The Damacas moment of apparent conviction he'd seen Gerry ...
-
Hi Ferryman, is it just me who is struggling to find a link between the question posed in the thread subject line and the cited references in the body of the post ?
Also the 'damascus moment' reference is rather ill used, a more apt phrase may be 'eureka moment' !
The anomaly is in working out who, if not Martin Smith, Pagarete is talking about
And that is why you cannot trust newspaper articles who can copy and paste and jiggle around all sorts of info whilst not actually saying anything
@)(++(*
-
Hi Ferryman, is it just me who is struggling to find a link between the question posed in the thread subject line and the cited references in the body of the post ?
Also the 'damascus moment' reference is rather ill used, a more apt phrase may be 'eureka moment' !
The anomaly is in working out who, if not Martin Smith, Pagarete is talking about
And that is why you cannot trust newspaper articles who can copy and paste and jiggle around all sorts of info whilst not actually saying anything
@)(++(*
Any thoughts on who Pagarete is talking about?
-
But what bearing does the main body of your OP have in relation to Martin Smith's claimed sighting ?
I apologise in advance if it is staring me in the face but I just can't see the correlation !
-
Hi Ferryman, is it just me who is struggling to find a link between the question posed in the thread subject line and the cited references in the body of the post ?
Also the 'damascus moment' reference is rather ill used, a more apt phrase may be 'eureka moment' !
The anomaly is in working out who, if not Martin Smith, Pagarete is talking about
And that is why you cannot trust newspaper articles who can copy and paste and jiggle around all sorts of info whilst not actually saying anything
@)(++(*
Any thoughts on who Pagarete is talking about?
No, but I won't waste my time on something futile, as in trying to find any truth from snippets from a red rag, something solid to go on might be better
-
But what bearing does the main body of your OP have in relation to Martin Smith's claimed sighting ?
I apologise in advance if it is staring me in the face but I just can't see the correlation !
Martin Smith claims to have seen Gerry.
He claims the man was definitely not Robert Murat because (according to his statement) he had met Murat in a bar a year ago before.
That doesn't exactly correspond with what the paper reports that someone (if not Smith, then who) had seen Murat in the bar that night.
But the paper's version would certainly tally with Smith (inadvertently) landing Murat in trouble because it would contradict Murat's claim and the alibi of his mother that he spent the whole evening May 3rd in doors with his mother ...
-
But what bearing does the main body of your OP have in relation to Martin Smith's claimed sighting ?
I apologise in advance if it is staring me in the face but I just can't see the correlation !
Martin Smith claims to have seen Gerry.
He claims the man was definitely not Robert Murat because (according to his statement) he had met Murat in a bar a year ago before.
That doesn't exactly correspond with what the paper reports that someone (if not Smith, then who) had seen Murat in the bar that night.
But the paper's version would certainly tally with Smith (inadvertently) landing Murat in trouble because it would contradict Murat's claim and the alibi of his mother that he spent the whole evening May 3rd in doors with his mother ...
Hi Ferryman, sorry, I was getting tangled up in Paul Gordon's recollection of events..
In my opinion I don't think that the 'friend of Murat' reference was Martin Smith.
I will have a look through articles and see if I can clarify further !
-
But what bearing does the main body of your OP have in relation to Martin Smith's claimed sighting ?
I apologise in advance if it is staring me in the face but I just can't see the correlation !
Martin Smith claims to have seen Gerry.
He claims the man was definitely not Robert Murat because (according to his statement) he had met Murat in a bar a year ago before.
That doesn't exactly correspond with what the paper reports that someone (if not Smith, then who) had seen Murat in the bar that night.
But the paper's version would certainly tally with Smith (inadvertently) landing Murat in trouble because it would contradict Murat's claim and the alibi of his mother that he spent the whole evening May 3rd in doors with his mother ...
Hi Ferryman, sorry, I was getting tangled up in Paul Gordon's recollection of events..
In my opinion I don't think that the 'friend of Murat' reference was Martin Smith.
I will have a look through articles and see if I can clarify further !
Thank you.
There could well be someone else in the file I've missed, and if so, I would be most interested to find out who.
-
So, it wasn't actually Robert Murat who Mr, Smith did know. But it could have been Gerry McCann who Mr. Smith didn't know.
Okay, See you in Court.
-
So, it wasn't actually Robert Murat who Mr, Smith did know. But it could have been Gerry McCann who Mr. Smith didn't know.
Okay, See you in Court.
Who shall you be seeing in court and under what summons ?
-
Okay, See you in Court.
Why make such an incendiary comment and not elaborate further when asked to do so ?
-
Hi Ferryman, is it just me who is struggling to find a link between the question posed in the thread subject line and the cited references in the body of the post ?
Also the 'damascus moment' reference is rather ill used, a more apt phrase may be 'eureka moment' !
The anomaly is in working out who, if not Martin Smith, Pagarete is talking about
And that is why you cannot trust newspaper articles who can copy and paste and jiggle around all sorts of info whilst not actually saying anything
@)(++(*
Isn't it pathetic the way that Hideho uses so many newspaper headlines (never mind stories) to prop up her propaganda then? What a fool she is according to you? I have to agree on this point.
-
This is nothing to do with hideho videos or what I think of them, it is about Mr Smith obviously having words put in his mouth or being misquoted by the papers, which he complained about btw red rags reporting on it and someone trying to make it out as some kind of truth. The lawyer maybe read the quotes and assumes they were true, they were not.
-
This is nothing to do with hideho videos or what I think of them, it is about Mr Smith obviously having words put in his mouth or being misquoted by the papers, which he complained about btw red rags reporting on it and someone trying to make it out as some kind of truth. The lawyer maybe read the quotes and assumes they were true, they were not.
Aside from an easily rectifiable administrative error, why was Mr Smith never interviewed a second time?
-
This is nothing to do with hideho videos or what I think of them, it is about Mr Smith obviously having words put in his mouth or being misquoted by the papers, which he complained about btw red rags reporting on it and someone trying to make it out as some kind of truth. The lawyer maybe read the quotes and assumes they were true, they were not.
Aside from an easily rectifiable administrative error, why was Mr Smith never interviewed a second time?
He was, see last entry on this link
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MARTIN_SMITH.htm
Why derail the thread from your OP?
-
I suspect that the "source" got it wrong and forgot to mention that MS was talking about the previous year. Pagarete could easily have assumed that "the friend" was placing RM 5 km away on the night (and therefore it couldn't have been him).
A friend of suspect Robert Murat, 34, falsely told police the Brit expat was drunk in a cafe the night Madeleine vanished.
Murat insists he was at home with his mother Jenny, 71. A source told newspaper 24 Horas: "The friend guaranteed Murat was in a coffee shop about five kilometres from the Ocean Club. He said he left drunk."
Murat's lawyer Francisco Pagarete, said: "He tried to defend Robert and ended up prejudicing him. We can prove Murat was with his mother."
-
I suspect that the "source" got it wrong and forgot to mention that MS was talking about the previous year. Pagarete could easily have assumed that "the friend" was placing RM 5 km away on the night (and therefore it couldn't have been him).
A friend of suspect Robert Murat, 34, falsely told police the Brit expat was drunk in a cafe the night Madeleine vanished.
Murat insists he was at home with his mother Jenny, 71. A source told newspaper 24 Horas: "The friend guaranteed Murat was in a coffee shop about five kilometres from the Ocean Club. He said he left drunk."
Murat's lawyer Francisco Pagarete, said: "He tried to defend Robert and ended up prejudicing him. We can prove Murat was with his mother."
Ah. I'd lost track of this thread.
That can't be right, because Pagarete definitely says someone (if not Smith, then who?) whose intentions in respect of Murat were good, ended up landing him in the brown stuff.
There is literally no one (whose statements we read in the files) who meets that description, and there is only one who makes reference to Murat and bars ...
-
I suspect that the "source" got it wrong and forgot to mention that MS was talking about the previous year. Pagarete could easily have assumed that "the friend" was placing RM 5 km away on the night (and therefore it couldn't have been him).
A friend of suspect Robert Murat, 34, falsely told police the Brit expat was drunk in a cafe the night Madeleine vanished.
Murat insists he was at home with his mother Jenny, 71. A source told newspaper 24 Horas: "The friend guaranteed Murat was in a coffee shop about five kilometres from the Ocean Club. He said he left drunk."
Murat's lawyer Francisco Pagarete, said: "He tried to defend Robert and ended up prejudicing him. We can prove Murat was with his mother."
Ah. I'd lost track of this thread.
That can't be right, because Pagarete definitely says someone (if not Smith, then who?) whose intentions in respect of Murat were good, ended up landing him in the brown stuff.
There is literally no one (whose statements we read in the files) who meets that description, and there is only one who makes reference to Murat and bars ...
Ferryman, which description are you thinking of, please ?
-
This one, Anne:
Murat's lawyer Francisco Pagarete, said: "He tried to defend Robert and ended up prejudicing him. We can prove Murat was with his mother."
If not Smith, then who?
-
So, it wasn't actually Robert Murat who Mr, Smith did know. But it could have been Gerry McCann who Mr. Smith didn't know.
Okay, See you in Court.
Who shall you be seeing in court and under what summons ?
I was being ironic.
Far too much importance was placed on Mr. Smith's 60/80% remark by Amaral and others, especially in the light of what the rest of The Smith Family had to say. Consequently, no one was ever going to finish up in Court on Mr. Smith's evidence.
As for Robert Murat being drunk in a Bar, that was just some newspaper mixing up what someone said, probably Mr. Smith. There was a lot of that going on at the time.
-
As for Robert Murat being drunk in a Bar, that was just some newspaper mixing up what someone said, probably Mr. Smith. There was a lot of that going on at the time.
Who do you think Pagarete was referring to whose intentions in respect of Murat were good but who dunhimbad?
-
As for Robert Murat being drunk in a Bar, that was just some newspaper mixing up what someone said, probably Mr. Smith. There was a lot of that going on at the time.
Who do you think Pagarete was referring to whose intentions in respect of Murat were good but who dunhimbad?
I can only presume that Pagarete was referring to Mr. Smith. But I don't think it really matters.
There are two points to consider. Either Mr. Smith was talking about an incident in 2006. Or someone was attempting to give Robert Murat an alibi when he didn't need one. Neither of which were going to be crucial in pointing obvious suspicion at Robert Murat.
-
As for Robert Murat being drunk in a Bar, that was just some newspaper mixing up what someone said, probably Mr. Smith. There was a lot of that going on at the time.
Who do you think Pagarete was referring to whose intentions in respect of Murat were good but who dunhimbad?
I can only presume that Pagarete was referring to Mr. Smith. But I don't think it really matters.
There are two points to consider. Either Mr. Smith was talking about an incident in 2006. Or someone was attempting to give Robert Murat an alibi when he didn't need one. Neither of which were going to be crucial in pointing obvious suspicion at Robert Murat.
Put simply, if Pagarete was referring to Smith, then Smith's statement has been tampered with in some way so that what we read would not reflect what Pagarete says.
That is what matters (to me, at least), not any suggestion of doubt over Murat.
Frankly I don't care whether Murat was out and about on the night or whether he spent the evening with his mother.
I do care that the statements we read should reflect what the people who made them said.
-
As for Robert Murat being drunk in a Bar, that was just some newspaper mixing up what someone said, probably Mr. Smith. There was a lot of that going on at the time.
Who do you think Pagarete was referring to whose intentions in respect of Murat were good but who dunhimbad?
I can only presume that Pagarete was referring to Mr. Smith. But I don't think it really matters.
There are two points to consider. Either Mr. Smith was talking about an incident in 2006. Or someone was attempting to give Robert Murat an alibi when he didn't need one. Neither of which were going to be crucial in pointing obvious suspicion at Robert Murat.
Put simply, if Pagarete was referring to Smith, then Smith's statement has been tampered with in some way so that what we read would not reflect what Pagarete says.
That is what matters (to me, at least), not any suggestion of doubt over Murat.
Frankly I don't care whether Murat was out and about on the night or whether he spent the evening with his mother.
I do care that the statements we read should reflect what the people who made them said.
Pagarete is a Lawyer, so he at least should know that he shouldn't jump to conclusions. If in fact he did.
Did or did not Pagarete attempt to bring a Prosecution against Jane Tanner, on behalf of Robert Murat, simply for giving a statement to The Police? Or so it seemed.
Or was it because Amaral said that Jane Tanner identified Robert Murat when in fact she never did?
I don't know enough about Pagarete to decide, and nothing ever came of it anyway.
But I find it difficult to believe that Pagarete is that stupid.