UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: John on May 03, 2013, 09:28:21 PM
-
Matthew Oldfield said the shutters weren't down!! ...ie they were up!
I haven't heard any one mention this before and remember this was the second check he did at 9.25pm which is some 10 to 15 minutes after Gerry did his routine check.
4078 'I am sorry, you already said how long you think you were in the apartment for, I have forgotten''
Reply 'It can't have been more than a couple of minutes, because, erm, I mean, there was no, you know, it was just sort of a check and then it was back really. I remember sort of being able to pivot here and be able to see this room door was open as well and those shutters weren't down, they were just curtains and that was fairly, fairly light as well. And I just sort of came back out really through the same way and shutting the patio doors'.
00.41.58 4078 'So, like everybody that has had anything to do with this inquiry, you must have played back in your own mind the different possibilities of what could have happened''
Reply 'Yeah'.
Matthew Oldfeld Rogatory Interview 9th April 2008 (http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MATTHEW-OLDFIELD-ROGATORY.htm)
Stamp 00.40.06 > 00.41.58
-
So if they were down when Gerry did his check at 9.10pm and up when Matthew did his at 9.25pm, what does this tell you about the time of the abduction?
Add this to Jane Tanners sighting at 9.15pm and...
Answers on a postcard!
-
So if they were down when Gerry did his check at 9.10pm and up when Matthew did his at 9.25pm, what does that tell you about the time of the abduction?
Answers on a postcard!
It tells me he said different things in all three interviews
?>)()<
and NOT only on this issue, ie unreliable witness imho
-
So if they were down when Gerry did his check at 9.10pm and up when Matthew did his at 9.25pm, what does that tell you about the time of the abduction?
Answers on a postcard!
It tells me he said different things in all three interviews
?>)()<
and NOT only on this issue, ie unreliable witness imho
You do three interviews and see if you get each one the same.. Also how many times have you done something, or said something then latwer on remembered something else you should have said
-
So if they were down when Gerry did his check at 9.10pm and up when Matthew did his at 9.25pm, what does that tell you about the time of the abduction?
Answers on a postcard!
It tells me he said different things in all three interviews
?>)()<
and NOT only on this issue, ie unreliable witness imho
He saw two windows, so which one had the shutters not down ?
He noticed the curtains, but said they were green, like Jane/Russells' ones.
He saw two twins when only one was in a transparent cot.
He saw a bed, undone, but had no curiosity to find out whose bed it was.
Etc.
-
This is why most discussion of what actually happened is a total waste of time.
There is inadequate information to make any rational conclusion so people will just follow their prejudices.
-
Statements are facts, in this case with a risk of lost in translation. Statements don't describe in themselves a certain reality, but the perception their authors have, or pretend to give, of this reality.
For example it is a fact Mr McCann stated he entered through the main door with his key.
It's another fact Mr McCann stated one week later he entered through the french window.
What is the reality ?
In this case I think the second fact is the reality, because I can think of a motive for the first false reality.
-
Statements are facts, in this case with a risk of lost in translation. Statements don't describe in themselves a certain reality, but the perception their authors have, or pretend to give, of this reality.
For example it is a fact Mr McCann stated he entered through the main door with his key.
It's another fact Mr McCann stated one week later he entered through the french window.
What is the reality ?
In this case I think the second fact is the reality, because I can think of a motive for the first false reality.
Because of your mindset only!
-
I can see exactly what happened here. In his Portuguese statements Matthew doesn't admit that the shutters were up but infers it when he states that there was more light coming into the room. It has to be remembered that the childrens bedroom window was not well lit and was in a gloomy location being on the ground behind a wall. Matthew didn't want to admit that he missed the shutters being up when he did his second check at 9.25 so fluffed his responses. As usual with the passage of time the truth tends to emerge.
-
I can see exactly what happened here. In his Portuguese statements Matthew doesn't admit that the shutters were up but infers it when he states that there was more light coming into the room. It has to be remembered that the childrens bedroom window was not well lit and was in a gloomy location being on the ground behind a wall. Matthew didn't want to admit that he missed the shutters being up when he did his second check at 9.25 so fluffed his responses. As usual with the passage of time the truth tends to emerge.
That is not what the research says; some memories improve, others deteriorate depending on the context of their recall and replaying.
-
Statements are facts, in this case with a risk of lost in translation. Statements don't describe in themselves a certain reality, but the perception their authors have, or pretend to give, of this reality.
For example it is a fact Mr McCann stated he entered through the main door with his key.
It's another fact Mr McCann stated one week later he entered through the french window.
What is the reality ?
In this case I think the second fact is the reality, because I can think of a motive for the first false reality.
As previously mentioned elsewhere, I think the scope for misunderstandngs, mistranslations, mistakes etc during that very first interview was massive. The police officer was new to the case and probably unfamiliar with the layout of the apartment at that point. Gerry would have been exhausted and his whole world was falling apart around him as he sat there - still descending into every parents worst nightmare.
It's obvious that there was much confusion about the doors/keys etc on the part of many during that initial time. This 'previous confusion' was mentioned by the police officer who took Jane Tanner's rogatory statement.
-
I can see exactly what happened here. In his Portuguese statements Matthew doesn't admit that the shutters were up but infers it when he states that there was more light coming into the room. It has to be remembered that the childrens bedroom window was not well lit and was in a gloomy location being on the ground behind a wall. Matthew didn't want to admit that he missed the shutters being up when he did his second check at 9.25 so fluffed his responses. As usual with the passage of time the truth tends to emerge.
That is not what the research says; some memories improve, others deteriorate depending on the context of their recall and replaying.
The context counts certainly, but please do provide a link to memories having improved a year after.
The following day :
there was enough light in the bedroom for him to see the twins in their cots.
Compare to "Madeleine was here"
I was looking at Madeleine’s bed which was here and it was dark and I was looking and I was thinking, is that Madeleine or is that the bedding.
ten days later
Concerning the external blinds he clarifies that he did not see if it was closed or open. He recalls having thought that in that bedroom there was more brightness than there was in his daughter's room
and 11 months later
I can't see the shutters because the curtains were shut they weren't blowing about but there was a light behind us in the room and for some reason I thought, I got the impression of light coming through the doorway from behind me
-
I can see exactly what happened here. In his Portuguese statements Matthew doesn't admit that the shutters were up but infers it when he states that there was more light coming into the room. It has to be remembered that the childrens bedroom window was not well lit and was in a gloomy location being on the ground behind a wall. Matthew didn't want to admit that he missed the shutters being up when he did his second check at 9.25 so fluffed his responses. As usual with the passage of time the truth tends to emerge.
That is not what the research says; some memories improve, others deteriorate depending on the context of their recall and replaying.
The context counts certainly, but please do provide a link to memories having improved a year after.
The following day :
there was enough light in the bedroom for him to see the twins in their cots.
Compare to "Madeleine was here"
I was looking at Madeleine’s bed which was here and it was dark and I was looking and I was thinking, is that Madeleine or is that the bedding.
ten days later
Concerning the external blinds he clarifies that he did not see if it was closed or open. He recalls having thought that in that bedroom there was more brightness than there was in his daughter's room
and 11 months later
I can't see the shutters because the curtains were shut they weren't blowing about but there was a light behind us in the room and for some reason I thought, I got the impression of light coming through the doorway from behind me
Situations vary.
-
Statements are facts, in this case with a risk of lost in translation. Statements don't describe in themselves a certain reality, but the perception their authors have, or pretend to give, of this reality.
For example it is a fact Mr McCann stated he entered through the main door with his key.
It's another fact Mr McCann stated one week later he entered through the french window.
What is the reality ?
In this case I think the second fact is the reality, because I can think of a motive for the first false reality.
As previously mentioned elsewhere, I think the scope for misunderstandngs, mistranslations, mistakes etc during that very first interview was massive. The police officer was new to the case and probably unfamiliar with the layout of the apartment at that point. Gerry would have been exhausted and his whole world was falling apart around him as he sat there - still descending into every parents worst nightmare.
It's obvious that there was much confusion about the doors/keys etc on the part of many during that initial time. This 'previous confusion' was mentioned by the police officer who took Jane Tanner's rogatory statement.
Mr McCann was the only one to make a confusion about the door he had used and the door his wife had used. Mrs McCann made no confusion.
In another context (not a horror context I would say), I probably wouldn't pay attention to a man having a challenge reaction (how shutters could be lifted from the outside when he thought it wasn't possible).
Time was above panic (doctors normally are trained not to) in this disappearance context : the life of a little girl which could depend on seconds.
-
So if they were down when Gerry did his check at 9.10pm and up when Matthew did his at 9.25pm, what does this tell you about the time of the abduction?
Add this to Jane Tanners sighting at 9.15pm and...
Answers on a postcard!
If we are trying to pin-point the time at which an abductor struck, then the witness statements you have highlighted suggests that if an abduction took place, it happened between 9.10pm ( shutters down ) and 9.25pm ( shutters raised )
If we look at other witness statements though, a different picture can be drawn
In her first police statement Kate McCann says she found the curtains in the children's bedroom open when she made her 10pm check
Half an hour earlier Mathew Olfield had declared them closed
That suggests if an abduction took place it happened between 9.25pm ( curtains closed ) and 10pm ( curtains open )
The time-line of any possible abduction changes according to which witness statements are cited
-
Statements are facts, in this case with a risk of lost in translation. Statements don't describe in themselves a certain reality, but the perception their authors have, or pretend to give, of this reality.
For example it is a fact Mr McCann stated he entered through the main door with his key.
It's another fact Mr McCann stated one week later he entered through the french window.
What is the reality ?
In this case I think the second fact is the reality, because I can think of a motive for the first false reality.
As previously mentioned elsewhere, I think the scope for misunderstandngs, mistranslations, mistakes etc during that very first interview was massive. The police officer was new to the case and probably unfamiliar with the layout of the apartment at that point. Gerry would have been exhausted and his whole world was falling apart around him as he sat there - still descending into every parents worst nightmare.
It's obvious that there was much confusion about the doors/keys etc on the part of many during that initial time. This 'previous confusion' was mentioned by the police officer who took Jane Tanner's rogatory statement.
Mr McCann was the only one to make a confusion about the door he had used and the door his wife had used. Mrs McCann made no confusion.
In another context (not a horror context I would say), I probably wouldn't pay attention to a man having a challenge reaction (how shutters could be lifted from the outside when he thought it wasn't possible).
Time was above panic (doctors normally are trained not to) in this disappearance context : the life of a little girl which could depend on seconds.
But Anne, how do you know it was Gerry who became confused about the door- it might have been the translater or the police officer interviewing him - and as there is no verbatim record of the interview available we cannot be sure of how it happened.
I'm always puzzled why people think that because the McCanns were doctors they should somehow have behaved differently to parents of other professions on discovering that their daughter had been abducted.
To me - this is like saying if a Firefighter was called out - and found that the blaze was at his own home and one of his children had died in it - he should not be as affected as other people, because he was used to attending such tragedies.
Sorry but that makes no sense whatsoever to me.
-
So if they were down when Gerry did his check at 9.10pm and up when Matthew did his at 9.25pm, what does that tell you about the time of the abduction?
Answers on a postcard!
It tells me he said different things in all three interviews
?>)()<
and NOT only on this issue, ie unreliable witness imho
He saw two windows, so which one had the shutters not down ?
He noticed the curtains, but said they were green, like Jane/Russells' ones.
He saw two twins when only one was in a transparent cot.
He saw a bed, undone, but had no curiosity to find out whose bed it was.
Etc.
Both cots are transparent Anne, you can see through the side of the brown one, see photo 5
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/5A_PHOTO_REPORT.htm
-
The events which occurred and are related by Gerry, Matthew and Jane go a very long way to explaining the series of events that happened on the night Madeleine was abducted. It is not unreasonable therefore to conclude that the abductor was actually in the apartment when Gerry did his unscheduled cursory check making his escape some minutes later while Gerry and Jez chatted down the road. When Gerry did the check at 9.10pm the shutter was down, when Matthew did it at 9.25pm the shutter was up according to his rogatory statement. Remembering too that Jane's sighting of a man carrying a female child was at 9.15pm.
-
So if they were down when Gerry did his check at 9.10pm and up when Matthew did his at 9.25pm, what does that tell you about the time of the abduction?
Answers on a postcard!
It tells me he said different things in all three interviews
?>)()<
and NOT only on this issue, ie unreliable witness imho
He saw two windows, so which one had the shutters not down ?
He noticed the curtains, but said they were green, like Jane/Russells' ones.
He saw two twins when only one was in a transparent cot.
He saw a bed, undone, but had no curiosity to find out whose bed it was.
Etc.
Both cots are transparent Anne, you can see through the side of the brown one, see photo 5
http://www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/5A_PHOTO_REPORT.htm
Not through the bottom of the brown one. Link does'nt work for the moment.
-
The events which occurred and are related by Gerry, Matthew and Jane go a very long way to explaining the series of events that happened on the night Madeleine was abducted. It is not unreasonable therefore to conclude that the abductor was actually in the apartment when Gerry did his unscheduled cursory check making his escape some minutes later while Gerry and Jez chatted down the road. When Gerry did the check at 9.10pm the shutter was down, when Matthew did it at 9.25pm the shutter was up according to his rogatory statement. Remembering too that Jane's sighting of a man carrying a female child was at 9.15pm.
If the man Jane Tanner saw was the abductor, then he would almost certainly have to be placed in the highly unlikely position of hiding in the apartment when Gerry made his check
We know he didn't climb in through the window because of forensic evidence
We know, too, that he didn't get in through the open patio doors within the few minutes between Gerry's check and Tanner's sighting, because Gerry and Jez were standing outside the gate that lead to them
So unless we venture into the duplicate key realm of fanasty, we have to believe Gerry's theory that the abductor was hiding behind the door ... however ridiculous the suggestion is
-
icabodcrane
We know he didn't climb in through the window because of forensic evidence
We know, too, that he didn't get in through the open patio doors within the few minutes between Gerry's check and Tanner's sighting, because Gerry and Jez were standing outside the gate that lead to them
you know a lot
-
Statements are facts, in this case with a risk of lost in translation. Statements don't describe in themselves a certain reality, but the perception their authors have, or pretend to give, of this reality.
For example it is a fact Mr McCann stated he entered through the main door with his key.
It's another fact Mr McCann stated one week later he entered through the french window.
What is the reality ?
In this case I think the second fact is the reality, because I can think of a motive for the first false reality.
As previously mentioned elsewhere, I think the scope for misunderstandngs, mistranslations, mistakes etc during that very first interview was massive. The police officer was new to the case and probably unfamiliar with the layout of the apartment at that point. Gerry would have been exhausted and his whole world was falling apart around him as he sat there - still descending into every parents worst nightmare.
It's obvious that there was much confusion about the doors/keys etc on the part of many during that initial time. This 'previous confusion' was mentioned by the police officer who took Jane Tanner's rogatory statement.
Mr McCann was the only one to make a confusion about the door he had used and the door his wife had used. Mrs McCann made no confusion.
In another context (not a horror context I would say), I probably wouldn't pay attention to a man having a challenge reaction (how shutters could be lifted from the outside when he thought it wasn't possible).
Time was above panic (doctors normally are trained not to) in this disappearance context : the life of a little girl which could depend on seconds.
But Anne, how do you know it was Gerry who became confused about the door- it might have been the translater or the police officer interviewing him - and as there is no verbatim record of the interview available we cannot be sure of how it happened.
I'm always puzzled why people think that because the McCanns were doctors they should somehow have behaved differently to parents of other professions on discovering that their daughter had been abducted.
To me - this is like saying if a Firefighter was called out - and found that the blaze was at his own home and one of his children had died in it - he should not be as affected as other people, because he was used to attending such tragedies.
Sorry but that makes no sense whatsoever to me.
Benice, Mr and Mrs McCann had the same translator, a sworn in translator, who at the end translates everything in English again in order to get the approbation or not of the interviewed. Besides only the main door could be locked with a key and Mr McCann mentions the key.
Doctors are trained to react in front of emergencies. It's part of their cursus. Mr or Mrs McCann, I don't remember, referred to this many years ago.
The instance of the firefighter doesn't make sense to me as well.
-
Remember it wasn't the first time an intruder got into an apartment at Ocean Club using a key. Wouldn't it be interesting to know what else went missing from 5a over the years?
-
Remember it wasn't the first time an intruder got into an apartment at Ocean Club using a key. Wouldn't it be interesting to know what else went missing from 5a over the years?
John, which intruder and with OC apartment do you mean, please ?
-
Quote:
So unless we venture into the duplicate key realm of fanasty, Unquote
Hardly fantasy. A very logical and highly likely theory/speculation.
-
Quote:
So unless we venture into the duplicate key realm of fanasty, Unquote
Hardly fantasy. A very logical and highly likely theory/speculation.
That's what I meant ... it is 'speculation' ( there is no evidence at all to support it )
-
Quote:
So unless we venture into the duplicate key realm of fanasty, Unquote
Hardly fantasy. A very logical and highly likely theory/speculation.
That's what I meant ... it is 'speculation' ( there is no evidence at all to support it )
If the key duplicate is speculation, how shall we call the opening of the window ? One annihilates the other, one turns the other ludicrous.
Suddenly I realise, off topic sorry, that Chinagirl said the translations of the files were biased and gave an example. I asked the reference...
-
AnneGuedes - Rather than take this thread further off-topic, I shall reply to you in the thread entitled "A question for AnneGuedes the translator."
-
Remember it wasn't the first time an intruder got into an apartment at Ocean Club using a key. Wouldn't it be interesting to know what else went missing from 5a over the years?
John, which intruder and with OC apartment do you mean, please ?
The lady above the McCann's apartment for one. Didn't she report an intruder getting in to her locked apartment? There are also numerous other reports of strangers lurking around the premises.
Spare keys for all the apartments except the privately owned ones were kept in a safe in the resort garage. All maintenance workers knew the combination of the safe and had access to these keys so it was by no means a difficult task to get hold of a key.
Remember this is not the sort of thing that Mark Warner would want to promote but it is fact...not speculation. There would appear to have been a security problem at the resort which I have yet to see addressed in any threads.
-
Remember it wasn't the first time an intruder got into an apartment at Ocean Club using a key. Wouldn't it be interesting to know what else went missing from 5a over the years?
John, which intruder and with OC apartment do you mean, please ?
The lady above the McCann's apartment for one. Didn't she report an intruder getting in to her locked apartment? There are also numerous other reports of strangers lurking around the premises.
Spare keys for all the apartments except the privately owned ones were kept in a safe in the resort garage. All maintenance workers knew the combination of the safe and had access to these keys so it was by no means a difficult task to get hold of a key.
Remember this is not the sort of thing that Mark Warner would want to promote but it is fact...not speculation. There would appear to have been a security problem at the resort which I have yet to see addressed in any threads.
Not a difficult task supposing you were member of the staff. All were checked.
Mrs Fenn's intruder disappeared through the window... Could have got in the same way.
If it were plausible 3/5 minutes were enough for an abductor to get in (how would he know the way was free, since Mr McCann didn't shut any door), stun a little girl, seize her and be on time on FGM, then a reconstruction was required.
-
.
Benice, Mr and Mrs McCann had the same translator, a sworn in translator, who at the end translates everything in English again in order to get the approbation or not of the interviewed. Besides only the main door could be locked with a key and Mr McCann mentions the key.
[/quote]
----------------------------------------------------------------------
Anne I'm not criticising the translator's skills, I am suggesting that she (or the the Pj officer) may have misunderstood what GM said or he may have misunderstood something they said. There was obviously discussion about both doors and about keys. We know that confusion was caused during those first interviews because the British policewoman interviewing Jane Tanner mentions it. Apparently some of the group called the Patio door the Front door and the other door the Back door. That fact in itself would be cause for misunderstandings - if the Pj considered the patio door to be the back door and the other door the Front door. (which is what I would do)
Gerry McCann is an intelligent person - so why would he decide to tell such a really stupid lie? Having said that the patio door was left unlocked, it would be obvious to anyone that he would use that door. It would be silly to claim that for no reason at all he decided to walk past an entrance 50 metres away - and take the much longer route round to the front door to achieve the same end i.e. to enter the apartment. In fact he would have to be really 'thick' not to realise how unbelievable that claim would be. - and I don't think he is thick - in fact far from it.
Therefore the only other reason is because misunderstandings must have taken place during the interview.
As far as I know the notes would be typed up in Portuguese and read back to Gerry by the interpretor. There is a vast difference between reading something yourself at your own pace, when any errors would jump out of the page at you and listening to someone else reading to you at their pace - especially considering GMs state of mind at that time.
I don't know what the procedure was after that - but if the statement was later typed in English and given to GM - then maybe that would be the time that he noticed the error
In Kates book she gives examples of how meanings could be lost in translation:
Quote
'I was really upset' had become 'I was fed up'.
'I never felt that relaxed' became 'I'd never felt so relaxed'
Unquote.
IMO many 'sceptics' do not place enough importance on the ''language barrier'' and the difficulties which could arise, as a result of it.
-
Would Matthew Oldfield not have felt the cold as the window would have been open as well as the shutters.? it was very cold that night by all accounts. By his account there was no wind though as the curtains were not moving although by other accounts it was a breezy night.
-
The problem in the beginning always was which was the front door and which was the back door. It took me a minute or ten to work it out. But it was a perfect opportunity to accuse The McCanns of lying, when in fact it was just confusion all round.
-
Would Matthew Oldfield not have felt the cold as the window would have been open as well as the shutters.? it was very cold that night by all accounts. By his account there was no wind though as the curtains were not moving although by other accounts it was a breezy night.
I suppose it would depend on what sort of clothing he was wearing, and breezes do 'gust' at varying levels of strength. He was only there for a matter of seconds - and if he didn't notice the curtains moving then I presume the breeze had died down momentarily at that time.
His only mission for being there was to ascertain that the children were asleep, and so as he heard no noise or sounds of movement he assumed all was well. There was no reason for him to take particular note of his surroundings at that point. It was only after Madeleine disappeared that it became important for him to try to remember everything he could about what he had seen. I believe he did his best, but who knows how accurate his recollections were.
IMO I think the main point established by his visit was that the door was much further open than Gerry had left it after his visit.
-
Would Matthew Oldfield not have felt the cold as the window would have been open as well as the shutters.? it was very cold that night by all accounts. By his account there was no wind though as the curtains were not moving although by other accounts it was a breezy night.
I suppose it would depend on what sort of clothing he was wearing, and breezes do 'gust' at varying levels of strength. He was only there for a matter of seconds - and if he didn't notice the curtains moving then I presume the breeze had died down momentarily at that time.
His only mission for being there was to ascertain that the children were asleep, and so as he heard no noise or sounds of movement he assumed all was well. There was no reason for him to take particular note of his surroundings at that point. It was only after Madeleine disappeared that it became important for him to try to remember everything he could about what he had seen. I believe he did his best, but who knows how accurate his recollections were.
IMO I think the main point established by his visit was that the door was much further open than Gerry had left it after his visit.
However well you are dressed you can sense a drop on temperature on your face at least.
Re the door, it was more open than they had left it when Gerry did his check at 9.10 or so, so what does that mean?
Madeleine was at an age that she could get up and go to the toilet. The door being more open doesnt actually prove anything.
And I have asked this before, why did Matthew go out of his way to go inside the apartment and just do a listening check when he could have done one outside the bedroom window after leaving his flat as he did half an hour earlier to listen out for crying?
-
Would Matthew Oldfield not have felt the cold as the window would have been open as well as the shutters.? it was very cold that night by all accounts. By his account there was no wind though as the curtains were not moving although by other accounts it was a breezy night.
I suppose it would depend on what sort of clothing he was wearing, and breezes do 'gust' at varying levels of strength. He was only there for a matter of seconds - and if he didn't notice the curtains moving then I presume the breeze had died down momentarily at that time.
His only mission for being there was to ascertain that the children were asleep, and so as he heard no noise or sounds of movement he assumed all was well. There was no reason for him to take particular note of his surroundings at that point. It was only after Madeleine disappeared that it became important for him to try to remember everything he could about what he had seen. I believe he did his best, but who knows how accurate his recollections were.
IMO I think the main point established by his visit was that the door was much further open than Gerry had left it after his visit.
However well you are dressed you can sense a drop on temperature on your face at least.
Re the door, it was more open than they had left it when Gerry did his check at 9.10 or so, so what does that mean?
Madeleine was at an age that she could get up and go to the toilet. The door being more open doesnt actually prove anything.
And I have asked this before, why did Matthew go out of his way to go inside the apartment and just do a listening check when he could have done one outside the bedroom window after leaving his flat as he did half an hour earlier to listen out for crying?
I don't know what the temperature inside 5A was - so cannot hazard a guess.
The fact that the door was open means that someone must have opened it. Only her parents could say whether she was in the habit of waking up, going to the toilet and then going back to bed by herself. If she'd never done that before then there is high possibility that someone else opened the door.
It seems pretty obvious to me that Kate had asked Matthew to actually go into the apartment to check. as that is what she was going to do - had she gone herself - and not agreed to let Matthew make the check for her.
-
Well let's see, was it because at 9.30 the window would have been open.. the problems that a fabricated timeline cause eh!
***
Well yes, *but* apparently he has said in his rogatory interview that the shutters were not down when he went in to check
The window would also have been open and I dont believe a shut window and shutters would have the same feel as a closed window and shutters, that is why I am not convinced he went inside, apart from him saying all sorts of things that were not true, that there was a bookcase with lots of books which he looked through,two windows, green or green and yellow curtains etc
-
The fact that the door was open means that someone must have opened it. Only her parents could say whether she was in the habit of waking up, going to the toilet and then going back to bed by herself. If she'd never done that before then there is high possibility that someone else opened the door.
****
How would they know if they were not there, they were in a different country, with different foods and drinks and routines, and if the kids woke up and cried out for the toilet or anything else,no one there
It's all speculation anyway on this front, I just dont think finding a door a bit more open proves a stranger was in there
-
Well let's see, was it because at 9.30 the window would have been open.. the problems that a fabricated timeline cause eh!
***
Well yes, *but* apparently he has said in his rogatory interview that the shutters were not down when he went in to check
The window would also have been open and I dont believe a shut window and shutters would have the same feel as a closed window and shutters, that is why I am not convinced he went inside, apart from him saying all sorts of things that were not true, that there was a bookcase with lots of books which he looked through,two windows, green or green and yellow curtains etc
But his rogatory statement doesn't say that, does it?
00.23.05 4078 'Okay'.
He actually says:
"I've spent a lot of time debating how far the door was open, from previous questioning, and, you know, it wasn't flat back against the wall, because that would have looked odd, it was just sort of halfway open, so it seemed slightly unusual that it should be so wide open, because you could see straight into the middle of the room from the angle that you approach it, because the, you've got sofas here and you've got a bookcase here and you have to come out, you've got sort of the wall of the bedroom and then it goes back where the bathroom is"
And this:
I can't see the shutters because thee curtains were shut and, they're similar curtains to the ones you've got in there, and you just get an impression of just like green and yellow but they were closed
www.mccannpjfiles.co.uk/PJ/MATTHEW-OLDFIELD-ROGATORY.htm