UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: Rachel Granada on May 05, 2013, 08:28:07 PM

Title: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 05, 2013, 08:28:07 PM
Has anyone heard anything about this?  I heard a rumour about mid-June but of course we can't set any store by rumours.  If anyone has any news, please keep us posted!
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: ferryman on May 05, 2013, 08:33:11 PM
The rumour you heard is one step ahead of my.

The last i heard definitely is that the attempts at an out of court settlement had broken down without resolution.

That's it ...
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 08:38:06 PM
Does the 'stay' in proceedings allow for negotiations to be re-opened during that period ?

What I mean is,  if the McCanns made an offer for settlement which was rejected by Amaral,  could they come back with an improved offer as long as it was made withing the  'stay'  period  ?
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: ferryman on May 05, 2013, 08:43:34 PM
What I mean is,  if the McCanns made an offer for settlement which was rejected by Amaral,

Much more likely to be the other way round ...
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: registrar on May 05, 2013, 08:46:37 PM
What I mean is,  if the McCanns made an offer for settlement which was rejected by Amaral,

Much more likely to be the other way round ...

Quite

Kate runs a marathon in an incredible time

Amaral looks sick and forlorn

If I was counsel to Amaral - I'd tell him to shut the bl..dy hell up
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 05, 2013, 08:48:04 PM
What I mean is,  if the McCanns made an offer for settlement which was rejected by Amaral,

Much more likely to be the other way round ...


I'd tend to agree with that, ferryman.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 05, 2013, 08:51:16 PM
Does the 'stay' in proceedings allow for negotiations to be re-opened during that period ?

What I mean is,  if the McCanns made an offer for settlement which was rejected by Amaral,  could they come back with an improved offer as long as it was made withing the  'stay'  period  ?

I wouldn't have thought that it was the McCanns offering a settlement to Amaral.  In my opinion it may have been Amaral trying to salvage something out of it all.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: icabodcrane on May 05, 2013, 08:52:56 PM
I was just going by reports in the portuguese press and TV,  which stated it was the McCanns who wanted to settle out of court 

In any event,   could negotiations be re-opened time and again, providing the stay period was still in place ?

Or would it be a one time offer, and if refused, the court process would be started again immediately ?
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: registrar on May 05, 2013, 09:00:35 PM
Amaral is toast

a criminal who mishandled at least two criminal investigations

a stain on Portugal's pride (how many peeps attended the hearing in Lisbon - 4-5? one with a silly hat)

If Amaral was to retire on his dad's couch and read a few good books - Dostoyevsky springs to mind

He would save himself from yet another level of hell
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Jean-Pierre on May 05, 2013, 09:31:30 PM
McCann V Amaral is a civil case.

If teh McCanns want to withdraw, they can.  At any stage.

So what "improved offer by the McCanns" is being fondly imagined?
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: cherrylight on May 06, 2013, 04:35:35 PM
What would be the damage to the McCanns by withdrawing?

How would that look to supporters and would that allow the book and the documentary to be distributed.

Then of course would they be liable for the existing court costs and Amaral's own legal fees?

Would that not look like a malicious complaint in the first place?

And would that open up a punishment?



Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Jean-Pierre on May 06, 2013, 05:03:13 PM
No

Check the Portuguese law regarding costs - each side is responsible for their own.

If they decide to drop it then a statement along the lines of "We have decided to concentrate on the search for our daughter, the libel case is proving to be a distraction and we have decided to drop proceedings" - no problem.

Why maliicious - they have good legal grounds for bringing the action in the first place.  And punishment for dropping a case?  You are joking.

But all this is speculation - Amaral is in much teh same position as Bennett - up creek, no paddle.  Even in a Portguese Court.  Sorry. 



 
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Benice on May 06, 2013, 05:29:21 PM
No

Check the Portuguese law regarding costs - each side is responsible for their own.

If they decide to drop it then a statement along the lines of "We have decided to concentrate on the search for our daughter, the libel case is proving to be a distraction and we have decided to drop proceedings" - no problem.

Why maliicious - they have good legal grounds for bringing the action in the first place.  And punishment for dropping a case?  You are joking.

But all this is speculation - Amaral is in much teh same position as Bennett - up creek, no paddle.  Even in a Portguese Court.  Sorry.


I do hope you're right Jean-Pierre, although I have to say I am not so confident.  Portuguese law seems to be very different to UK law.  It's a mystery to me that although it has been adjudicated by the Portuguese courts that Leanor Cipriano's 'confession' was extracted by torture, - she is still in prison.  Would that be the case here ?- I don't think so.




Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 06, 2013, 05:32:52 PM
What would be the damage to the McCanns by withdrawing?

How would that look to supporters and would that allow the book and the documentary to be distributed.

Then of course would they be liable for the existing court costs and Amaral's own legal fees?

Would that not look like a malicious complaint in the first place?

And would that open up a punishment?

Hello and welcome cherrylight.  I'm sure we may find out in the fullness of time who it was who requested negotiations to settle out of court.  Personally, I can't see it being the McCanns.  They just want Amaral's slurs stopped.  Of course I could be wrong, and they may well have just wanted the whole thing settled without the stress of a court case.  In my opinion it is not about the money for the McCanns - they just want the slurs to stop.

Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 06, 2013, 05:36:11 PM
What would be the damage to the McCanns by withdrawing?

How would that look to supporters and would that allow the book and the documentary to be distributed.

Then of course would they be liable for the existing court costs and Amaral's own legal fees?

Would that not look like a malicious complaint in the first place?

And would that open up a punishment?
These are good questions.
Of course they can withdraw since the initiative was theirs.
No punishment but :
Mr Amaral wouldn't have to pay the court costs (he would likely have to pay his lawyer)
As Mr Amaral's properties were frozen, he certainly were entitled to receive a compensation for that.
The pro would call the withdrawal magnanimity and the anti malice...
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 05:36:59 PM
No

Check the Portuguese law regarding costs - each side is responsible for their own.

If they decide to drop it then a statement along the lines of "We have decided to concentrate on the search for our daughter, the libel case is proving to be a distraction and we have decided to drop proceedings" - no problem.

Why maliicious - they have good legal grounds for bringing the action in the first place.  And punishment for dropping a case?  You are joking.

But all this is speculation - Amaral is in much teh same position as Bennett - up creek, no paddle.  Even in a Portguese Court.  Sorry.


I do hope you're right Jean-Pierre, although I have to say I am not so confident.  Portuguese law seems to be very different to UK law.  It's a mystery to me that although it has been adjudicated by the Portuguese courts that Leanor Cipriano's 'confession' was extracted by torture, - she is still in prison.  Would that be the case here ?- I don't think so.

Portuguese law in general does take a bit of explaining.

A Portuguese officer (Almeida) is actually convicted of inflicting a barbaric (medieval) torture of bastinado and receives a suspended sentence.

Meanwhile police officers (unidentified) are judicially proven to have tortured Leonor and not merely does her conviction stick.  It is actually increased because she is deemed not to have got her story completely straight while she was having the cr*p beaten out of her with a bag over her head ...

It's perverse.

It's not funny

There was no evidence against Leonor besides the (extorted) "confession".

A further point; she was beaten (nearly) blind, but her eyesight recovered (for now)

That needn't mean she'll get away with it ...
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Benice on May 06, 2013, 05:54:54 PM
No

Check the Portuguese law regarding costs - each side is responsible for their own.

If they decide to drop it then a statement along the lines of "We have decided to concentrate on the search for our daughter, the libel case is proving to be a distraction and we have decided to drop proceedings" - no problem.

Why maliicious - they have good legal grounds for bringing the action in the first place.  And punishment for dropping a case?  You are joking.

But all this is speculation - Amaral is in much teh same position as Bennett - up creek, no paddle.  Even in a Portguese Court.  Sorry.


I do hope you're right Jean-Pierre, although I have to say I am not so confident.  Portuguese law seems to be very different to UK law.  It's a mystery to me that although it has been adjudicated by the Portuguese courts that Leanor Cipriano's 'confession' was extracted by torture, - she is still in prison.  Would that be the case here ?- I don't think so.

Portuguese law in general does take a bit of explaining.

A Portuguese officer (Almeida) is actually convicted of inflicting a barbaric (medieval) torture of bastinado and receives a suspended sentence.

Meanwhile police officers (unidentified) are judicially proven to have tortured Leonor and not merely does her conviction stick.  It is actually increased because she is deemed not to have got her story completely straight while she was having the cr*p beaten out of her with a bag over her head ...

It's perverse.

It's not funny

There was no evidence against Leonor besides the (extorted) "confession".

A further point; she was beaten (nearly) blind, but her eyesight recovered (for now)

That needn't mean she'll get away with it ...

The whole case appears to be appalling from beginning to end - and although they took Leonor back to court  - the relevant authorities seem to be unconcerned as to who did torture her. She sustained those dreadful injuries in a police station - you would think the Pj would leave no stone unturned to find the perpetrators.  But apparently not.

This is one of the reasons why I am not convinced that the McCanns will get justice in Portugal.





Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: icabodcrane on May 06, 2013, 06:13:55 PM
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 06, 2013, 06:17:36 PM
Benice said: The whole case appears to be appalling from beginning to end - and although they took Leonor back to court  - the relevant authorities seem to be unconcerned as to who did torture her. She sustained those dreadful injuries in a police station - you would think the Pj would leave no stone unturned to find the perpetrators.  But apparently not.

This is one of the reasons why I am not convinced that the McCanns will get justice in Portugal.


Benice, I am flabbergasted that a police officer who was arguido in the torture of Leonor was put in charge of another missing child case!  In the UK, I would think an officer would have been suspended pending further investigation? It beggars belief! Plus the fact that statements given to the UK police by the Gaspar couple, who probably thought as they were giving statements to the UK police that they would remain confidential, were then released by the PT Authorities!!

I have all my fingers and toes crossed that Kate and Gerry McCann will get justice in PT, and Amaral and his slurs will be stopped once and for all.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 06:20:31 PM
What would be the damage to the McCanns by withdrawing?

How would that look to supporters and would that allow the book and the documentary to be distributed.

Then of course would they be liable for the existing court costs and Amaral's own legal fees?

Would that not look like a malicious complaint in the first place?

And would that open up a punishment?
These are good questions.
Of course they can withdraw since the initiative was theirs.
No punishment but :
Mr Amaral wouldn't have to pay the court costs (he would likely have to pay his lawyer)
As Mr Amaral's properties were frozen, he certainly were entitled to receive a compensation for that.
The pro would call the withdrawal magnanimity and the anti malice...

You have an amusing take on the law!

Why would he be entitled to compensation- it was the courts, not the McCanns who decided that freezing assets was legal.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 06, 2013, 06:21:26 PM
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?

The personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family? What about the trauma and distress that his book, written to cash in on the back of another family's suffering, has caused to Kate and Gerry McCann and their family?  How much pain do you think his execrable fridge theory caused to the McCanns?
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 06, 2013, 06:21:57 PM
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?

in the UK he would have to apply and prove "wasted costs/expenses" or that an action was vexacious, I have no idea what happens in Portugal
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: icabodcrane on May 06, 2013, 06:30:16 PM
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?

The personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family? What about the trauma and distress that his book, written to cash in on the back of another family's suffering, has caused to Kate and Gerry McCann and their family?  How much pain do you think his execrable fridge theory caused to the McCanns?

And they are perfectly entitled to go on with the libel action to seek redress for that damage

What I asked was,  if the McCanns choose  not  to seek redress in court, and simply  'withdraw'  would Amaral be in a position to seek redress  from  them  ?

( I'm not saying he should have that right,  just asking if he  would from a legal standpoint )
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 06:31:27 PM
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?

The personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family? What about the trauma and distress that his book, written to cash in on the back of another family's suffering, has caused to Kate and Gerry McCann and their family?  How much pain do you think his execrable fridge theory caused to the McCanns?

And they are perfectly entitled to go on with the libel action to seek redress for that damage

What I asked was,  if the McCanns choose  not  to seek redress in court, and simply  'withdraw'  would Amaral be in a position to seek redress  from  them  ?

( I'm not saying he should have that right,  just asking if he  would from a legal standpoint )

WHat for? What would be the claim?
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 06, 2013, 06:33:13 PM
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?

The personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family? What about the trauma and distress that his book, written to cash in on the back of another family's suffering, has caused to Kate and Gerry McCann and their family?  How much pain do you think his execrable fridge theory caused to the McCanns?

And they are perfectly entitled to go on with the libel action to seek redress for that damage

What I asked was,  if the McCanns choose  not  to seek redress in court, and simply  'withdraw'  would Amaral be in a position to seek redress  from  them  ?

( I'm not saying he should have that right,  just asking if he  would from a legal standpoint )

you missed my reply
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: icabodcrane on May 06, 2013, 06:35:29 PM
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?

The personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family? What about the trauma and distress that his book, written to cash in on the back of another family's suffering, has caused to Kate and Gerry McCann and their family?  How much pain do you think his execrable fridge theory caused to the McCanns?

And they are perfectly entitled to go on with the libel action to seek redress for that damage

What I asked was,  if the McCanns choose  not  to seek redress in court, and simply  'withdraw'  would Amaral be in a position to seek redress  from  them  ?

( I'm not saying he should have that right,  just asking if he  would from a legal standpoint )

you missed my reply

I just saw it, thanks for that

I guess we need someone with knowledge of Portuguese law to give us the answer
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 06, 2013, 06:36:10 PM
Amaral has been embroiled in one court action or another with the McCanns for the past four years over his book

He must have amassed huge legal fees by now.  His assets were sequestrated and his earning capacity severely curtailed by the seizure  of his books ... not to mention, of course, the personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family 

Can it really be that the McCanns,  when it comes to the wire,  can just  'drop it'  ? and that the damage their legal actions have wrought on Amaral would be dismissed as inconsequential ?

Would he not be in a postion to demand recompence from them if they were to simply  'withdraw'  after all that ?

The personal trauma and distress caused to him and his family? What about the trauma and distress that his book, written to cash in on the back of another family's suffering, has caused to Kate and Gerry McCann and their family?  How much pain do you think his execrable fridge theory caused to the McCanns?

And they are perfectly entitled to go on with the libel action to seek redress for that damage

What I asked was,  if the McCanns choose  not  to seek redress in court, and simply  'withdraw'  would Amaral be in a position to seek redress  from  them  ?

( I'm not saying he should have that right,  just asking if he  would from a legal standpoint )

Yes, sorry icabod - I just got a little emotional there! Interesting question, but what would he sue for? It was the courts that froze his assets, not the McCanns.  Plus would he have the funds for a counter-sue? What with having fees to pay for his doomed attempt to sue for "defacing his honour", paying back the brother he tried to swindle etc.  Especially when the PJ are seeking to strip him of his pension...
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 06:44:30 PM
Does the 'stay' in proceedings allow for negotiations to be re-opened during that period ?

What I mean is,  if the McCanns made an offer for settlement which was rejected by Amaral,  could they come back with an improved offer as long as it was made withing the  'stay'  period  ?

While they all wait for a new Trial Date, any of them can try to negotiate a Settlement.  The "Stay Period" is now over.  They are simply waiting for a new date of Trial  This will not prevent a settlement being reached.
Amaral can still offer a better settlement during this time.

PS.  Plaintiffs simply do not offer Settlements.  They Withdraw.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 06, 2013, 06:53:24 PM
Quote
PS.  Plaintiffs simply do not offer Settlements.  They Withdraw.

wrong - either side can propose a settlement
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 06, 2013, 06:57:51 PM
the most common proposal being: I think I can win xxx if this case goes to court - but to avoid that I will settle for xxx minus something now.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 06, 2013, 07:02:45 PM
What would be the damage to the McCanns by withdrawing?

How would that look to supporters and would that allow the book and the documentary to be distributed.

Then of course would they be liable for the existing court costs and Amaral's own legal fees?

Would that not look like a malicious complaint in the first place?

And would that open up a punishment?
These are good questions.
Of course they can withdraw since the initiative was theirs.
No punishment but :
Mr Amaral wouldn't have to pay the court costs (he would likely have to pay his lawyer)
As Mr Amaral's properties were frozen, he certainly were entitled to receive a compensation for that.
The pro would call the withdrawal magnanimity and the anti malice...

You have an amusing take on the law!

Why would he be entitled to compensation- it was the courts, not the McCanns who decided that freezing assets was legal.
Did I say it wasn't the court's decision ? But the decision followed a requirement made by Isabel Duarte.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 07:03:53 PM
Quote
PS.  Plaintiffs simply do not offer Settlements.  They Withdraw.

wrong - either side can propose a settlement

By "Simply do not", may I ask you to regard the word, "Simply" in all it's glorious connotations?
I can do Semantics as well, ya know.  I could off said, "In Difficulty, might."  But I don't think that The McCanns are actually in any Difficulty here.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 06, 2013, 07:07:09 PM
Quote
PS.  Plaintiffs simply do not offer Settlements.  They Withdraw.

wrong - either side can propose a settlement

By "Simply do not", may I ask you to regard the word, "Simply" in all it's glorious connotations?
I can do Semantics as well, ya know.  I could off said, "In Difficulty, might."  But I don't think that The McCanns are actually in any Difficulty here.

the most common proposal being: I think I can win xxx if this case goes to court - but to avoid that I will settle for xxx minus something now.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 06, 2013, 07:07:45 PM
settlements are done every day.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 07:08:05 PM
What would be the damage to the McCanns by withdrawing?

How would that look to supporters and would that allow the book and the documentary to be distributed.

Then of course would they be liable for the existing court costs and Amaral's own legal fees?

Would that not look like a malicious complaint in the first place?

And would that open up a punishment?
These are good questions.
Of course they can withdraw since the initiative was theirs.
No punishment but :
Mr Amaral wouldn't have to pay the court costs (he would likely have to pay his lawyer)
As Mr Amaral's properties were frozen, he certainly were entitled to receive a compensation for that.
The pro would call the withdrawal magnanimity and the anti malice...

You have an amusing take on the law!

Why would he be entitled to compensation- it was the courts, not the McCanns who decided that freezing assets was legal.
Did I say it wasn't the court's decision ? But the decision followed a requirement made by Isabel Duarte.

And quite possibly a few other people, not least The State of Portugal, to whom Goncalo Amaral owes a great deal of money.  Most of it long before The McCanns ever set foot in Portugal.  And some of it before Madeleine was even born.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 06, 2013, 07:09:16 PM
Rachel : What with having fees to pay for his doomed attempt to sue for "defacing his honour", paying back the brother he tried to swindle etc.  Especially when the PJ are seeking to strip him of his pension...
Is this common knowledge, Rachel ? Or do you have special informations ?
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 06, 2013, 07:10:32 PM
the point is that the Mccanns do not have to offer amaral anything - but they may accept a settlement offerered by him - even if they suggested the matter first.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 07:11:29 PM
Quote
PS.  Plaintiffs simply do not offer Settlements.  They Withdraw.

wrong - either side can propose a settlement

By "Simply do not", may I ask you to regard the word, "Simply" in all it's glorious connotations?
I can do Semantics as well, ya know.  I could off said, "In Difficulty, might."  But I don't think that The McCanns are actually in any Difficulty here.

the most common proposal being: I think I can win xxx if this case goes to court - but to avoid that I will settle for xxx minus something now.

Why should The McCanns do that?
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 06, 2013, 07:13:25 PM
The State of Portugal, to whom Goncalo Amaral owes a great deal of money.  Most of it long before The McCanns ever set foot in Portugal.  And some of it before Madeleine was even born.
Funcionaria do ministério das finanças or creditor ?
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 06, 2013, 07:16:17 PM
Rachel : What with having fees to pay for his doomed attempt to sue for "defacing his honour", paying back the brother he tried to swindle etc.  Especially when the PJ are seeking to strip him of his pension...
Is this common knowledge, Rachel ? Or do you have special informations ?

LOL! Disingenuous Anne.  PS) hope I have spelt that right!

I think you may know full well that Amaral tried to swindle his own brother, owes plenty to the PT State, failed miserably in an attempt to sue about "loss of honour" over his perjury conviction, and that the PJ Bosses are looking into stripping certain PJ who have been convicted of perjury/torture of their pensions.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 07:16:49 PM
Rachel : What with having fees to pay for his doomed attempt to sue for "defacing his honour", paying back the brother he tried to swindle etc.  Especially when the PJ are seeking to strip him of his pension...
Is this common knowledge, Rachel ? Or do you have special informations ?

It is Common Knowledge.  And all over The Net.  Try Google.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 07:19:07 PM
the point is that the Mccanns do not have to offer amaral anything - but they may accept a settlement offerered by him - even if they suggested the matter first.

Also, only The Plaintiff can ask The Court for a Stay.  Even when a settlement is offered by The Defendant.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: debunker on May 06, 2013, 07:24:12 PM
What would be the damage to the McCanns by withdrawing?
I386
How would that look to supporters and would that allow the book and the documentary to be distributed.

Then of course would they be liable for the existing court costs and Amaral's own legal fees?

Would that not look like a malicious complaint in the first place?

And would that open up a punishment?
These are good questions.
Of course they can withdraw since the initiative was theirs.
No punishment but :
Mr Amaral wouldn't have to pay the court costs (he would likely have to pay his lawyer)
As Mr Amaral's properties were frozen, he certainly were entitled to receive a compensation for that.
The pro would call the withdrawal magnanimity and the anti malice...

You have an amusing take on the law!

Why would he be entitled to compensation- it was the courts, not the McCanns who decided that freezing assets was legal.
Did I say it wasn't the court's decision ? But the decision followed a requirement made by Isabel Duarte.

And accepted as necessary by the court.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Redblossom on May 06, 2013, 07:25:14 PM
There was an interview on PT TV where it was said it is normal for the defendant, ie Mr Amaral,  to ask for settlement discussions but never the plaintiffs but in this case it was the plaintiffs that asked, ie the Mccanns, and that this was highly unusual.Was that programme wrong? I will see if I can dig it out, I *think* it was on Joana Morais's website, do be patient before you get an an uncontrollable urge to jump,scream and shout, thanking you

ETA

It didnt take me long to find it, but I thought there was one with english subtitles to the video, anyway,here it is, so unless anyone wants to assert the guests are lying, then explain this please


http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2013/01/mccanns-ask-for-extrajudicial-settlement.html
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: DCI on May 06, 2013, 07:43:24 PM
Rachel : What with having fees to pay for his doomed attempt to sue for "defacing his honour", paying back the brother he tried to swindle etc.  Especially when the PJ are seeking to strip him of his pension...
Is this common knowledge, Rachel ? Or do you have special informations ?

LOL! Disingenuous Anne.  PS) hope I have spelt that right!

I think you may know full well that Amaral tried to swindle his own brother, owes plenty to the PT State, failed
miserably in an attempt to sue about "loss of honour" over his perjury conviction, and that the PJ Bosses are looking into stripping certain PJ who have been convicted of perjury/torture of their pensions.

Yes he did, and lost that case.

http://justice4mccannfam.5forum.biz/t3832-gonc-s-debts-and-brothers-court-case
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 07:53:41 PM
There was an interview on PT TV where it was said it is normal for the defendant, ie Mr Amaral,  to ask for settlement discussions but never the plaintiffs but in this case it was the plaintiffs that asked, ie the Mccanns, and that this was highly unusual.Was that programme wrong? I will see if I can dig it out, I *think* it was on Joana Morais's website, do be patient before you get an an uncontrollable urge to jump,scream and shout, thanking you

ETA

It didnt take me long to find it, but I thoufht there was one with english subtitles to the video, anyway,here it is, so unless anyone wants to assert the guests are lying, then explain this please


http://joana-morais.blogspot.com/2013/01/mccanns-ask-for-extrajudicial-settlement.html


Quote from the interview.

HC - Let's see if this meeting will end in something, if it doesn't, at least it bought someone time, whomever that someone is.

I rest my case.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 08:05:06 PM


http://www.jn.pt/Dossies/dossie.aspx?content_id=3204064&dossier=O%20caso%20Maddie%20McCann&page=1

Portuguese newspaper ordered to pay 15,000 euros to Robert Murat
Posted at 19:30to 19.30

The Lisbon Court of Appeal ordered the newspaper "Correio da Manha" to pay compensation of 15,000 euros to Robert Murat, the first suspect in the case of the disappearance of the Algarve British child Madeleine McCann.

Into question the "moral damage" suffered by Murat following several reports published that paper, which according to the court, give it a "unhealthy personality, not only in the area of ​​pedophilia as even the zooerastia, consistent with the practice of criminal offense related to the disappearance of unfortunate child. "

The compensation for the violation of the right to peace and quiet will be paid jointly by the three journalists who signed the news and the company that owns the newspaper.

"The goal of extended runs can not obnubilar journalistic duties, alias statutory body, respect for the presumption of innocence, not taking statements or images that reach the dignity of persons, as well as news publishing raising discrimination" , cites the judgment of Appeal, that the Lusa had access.

Madeleine McCann disappeared from the apartment where he was vacationing with his parents and younger twin brothers, in the tourist village "Ocean Club", in Praia da Luz, Lagos, on the evening of May 3, 2007.

A few days later, Robert Murat, a British man who lived a few meters from that village and who meanwhile had made available to help the child's parents, especially as a translator, was made defendant.

The newspaper wrote in an article entitled "Pedophilia is the track" that Murat would be "a predator" and obtain access to sites of sexual violence.

"And is this english 33 years that the Judicial Police believed to have drawn little Maddie from the bed where she slept in the Ocean Club, to the house where he lives with his mother," added the CM.

Murat was the condition of the accused, until July 21, 2008, when the prosecutor decided to drop the investigation into the disappearance of Madeleine McCann.

-------------------------

Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 08:07:19 PM
You cannot rest any case  until you have  made one, is your case here on this board? pls give me a link  to read it, thanks in advance

if it is in dribs and drabs here and there, pls detail it out in one post for clarity on here so posters know what you are talking about

It is part of the interview about who asked for a settlement.  And if Whatshisname doesn't know, then I'm sure you don't either.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 06, 2013, 08:14:42 PM
Murat was the condition of the accused !
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 08:22:39 PM
Murat was the condition of the accused !

Until July the 21st 2008.

Robert Murat has just won 15,000 Euros from CdM, for a Presumption of Innocence.

Best that Amaral Settle before it gets any worse.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 06, 2013, 08:25:34 PM
Rachel : What with having fees to pay for his doomed attempt to sue for "defacing his honour", paying back the brother he tried to swindle etc.  Especially when the PJ are seeking to strip him of his pension...
Is this common knowledge, Rachel ? Or do you have special informations ?

It is Common Knowledge.  And all over The Net.  Try Google.
In which language ?
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 06, 2013, 08:27:51 PM
the point is that the Mccanns do not have to offer amaral anything - but they may accept a settlement offerered by him - even if they suggested the matter first.
Why should they accept, logically ?
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: DCI on May 06, 2013, 08:29:24 PM
Murat was the condition of the accused !

Until July the 21st 2008.

Robert Murat has just won 15,000 Euros from CdM, for a Presumption of Innocence.

Best that Amaral Settle before it gets any worse.

Oh my, Amaral repeated all that in his book. Now I wonder who gave/sold the info to CdM?
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 06, 2013, 08:31:29 PM
Rachel : What with having fees to pay for his doomed attempt to sue for "defacing his honour", paying back the brother he tried to swindle etc.  Especially when the PJ are seeking to strip him of his pension...
Is this common knowledge, Rachel ? Or do you have special informations ?


LOL! Disingenuous Anne.  PS) hope I have spelt that right!

I think you may know full well that Amaral tried to swindle his own brother, owes plenty to the PT State, failed miserably in an attempt to sue about "loss of honour" over his perjury conviction, and that the PJ Bosses are looking into stripping certain PJ who have been convicted of perjury/torture of their pensions.
I know nothing of that, Rachel. If you don't believe it, I can't help it.
Was it reported by Lusa ? What connection has that with the McCann's libel case ?
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 08:36:53 PM

Tis truly amazing what we all know about Goncalo Amaral, while some Portuguese Citizens, and others who live in Portugal, appear to remain in blissful ignorance.

This should surely tell them something.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 06, 2013, 08:42:50 PM

Tis truly amazing what we all know about Goncalo Amaral, while some Portuguese Citizens, and others who live in Portugal, appear to remain in blissful ignorance.

This should surely tell them something.

We know that he is a convicted perjuror who tried to cheat his own brother.  And is there not another torture complaint pending against him in the Cipriano case (please correct me if I've got that wrong, someone).

Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: DCI on May 06, 2013, 08:44:55 PM
Rachel : What with having fees to pay for his doomed attempt to sue for "defacing his honour", paying back the brother he tried to swindle etc.  Especially when the PJ are seeking to strip him of his pension...
Is this common knowledge, Rachel ? Or do you have special informations ?

It is Common Knowledge.  And all over The Net.  Try Google.
In which language ?

Here it is Anne.

http://justice4mccannfam.5forum.biz/t3734-goncalo-amaral-and-paulo-pereira-cristovao-accused-of-attacks-on-leonor-cipriano

http://www.cmjornal.xl.pt/detalhe/noticias/nacional/portugal/pj-pede-suspensao-para-investigadores
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 08:57:54 PM

Tis truly amazing what we all know about Goncalo Amaral, while some Portuguese Citizens, and others who live in Portugal, appear to remain in blissful ignorance.

This should surely tell them something.

We know that he is a convicted perjuror who tried to cheat his own brother.  And is there not another torture complaint pending against him in the Cipriano case (please correct me if I've got that wrong, someone).

No, you are not wrong.  Amaral is an Arguido in the case of personally beating up Leandro Silva while someone held the poor man's arms behind his back.

Amaral by proven Court Records is a thoroughly dishonest and utterly disgusting character.  Tis surprising how many people don't know this.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Rachel Granada on May 06, 2013, 09:09:09 PM
Eleanor said: No, you are not wrong.  Amaral is an Arguido in the case of personally beating up Leandro Silva while someone held the poor man's arms behind his back.

Amaral by proven Court Records is a thoroughly dishonest and utterly disgusting character.  Tis surprising how many people don't know this.


Thanks Eleanor, I seemed to think that was the case but wasn't sure.  Amaral is not exactly the "man of dignity and courage" that many think he is, eh!
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 06, 2013, 09:20:15 PM

Tis truly amazing what we all know about Goncalo Amaral, while some Portuguese Citizens, and others who live in Portugal, appear to remain in blissful ignorance.

This should surely tell them something.
This time I agree with Eleanor : I'm amazed some spend so much energy in muck raking.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: DCI on May 06, 2013, 09:25:01 PM
Why did Amaral, claim the PJ were Persecuting him, only last year? >@@(*&)
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 09:38:27 PM

Tis truly amazing what we all know about Goncalo Amaral, while some Portuguese Citizens, and others who live in Portugal, appear to remain in blissful ignorance.

This should surely tell them something.
This time I agree with Eleanor : I'm amazed some spend so much energy in muck raking.

Hardly Muck Raking.  Amaral has ridden rough shod over every decent Portuguese Citizen who do pay their Taxes and Mortgages.  As far back as 2002 he was in debt to The State and to The Banks.

I could say so much more about this awful man, but that would be spurious.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: faithlilly on May 06, 2013, 10:01:50 PM
Something or nothing, you decide.

A contributor to the OFM Facebook page emailed the webmaster asking whether the rumours of the McCanns seeking a settlement with Amaral were true. Webmaster told contributor that she would have to ask Kate and would get back to them. Webmaster replied to contributor, after we can presume, discussion with Kate that the rumours were false. These facts were made public on Blacksmith's blog after which webmaster denied Kate had told her about the rumours being false and if the allegations were repeated legal action would be taken.

Now if Amaral had been the one to ask for a settlement why wouldn't Kate put her name to the false rumours claim, even when it was absolutely clear that  the webmaster would not have made such a claim without Kate's say so ? If it  was  true why was she afraid to put her name to  the fact that Amaral was seeking a settlement ?
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 06, 2013, 10:11:23 PM
I always thought Mr Amaral was a very normal human being. His book was a short seller here in Portugal, I didn't buy it, I had a look.
The McCanns didn't like his conclusion, I understand them. They could have just ignored it, but unreasonably (imo) they decided not to (may be they understood it was ridiculous to attack this book and this is why they proposed a settlement).
Nevertheless some people started to turn Gonçalo Amaral into a post-modern anti-hero !
An amazing phenomenon was born.
What has this man to arouse so much passion ?
I look and look at him, I don't understand. Now as he's so thin, he looks like a persecuted and sanctified man. Saint Sebastian !
Really amazing.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Jean-Pierre on May 06, 2013, 10:20:08 PM
Something or nothing, you decide.

A contributor to the OFM Facebook page emailed the webmaster asking whether the rumours of the McCanns seeking a settlement with Amaral were true. Webmaster told contributor that she would have to ask Kate and would get back to them. Webmaster replied to contributor, after we can presume, discussion with Kate that the rumours were false. These facts were made public on Blacksmith's blog after which webmaster denied Kate had told her about the rumours being false and if the allegations were repeated legal action would be taken.

Now if Amaral had been the one to ask for a settlement why wouldn't Kate put her name to the false rumours claim, even when it was absolutely clear that  the webmaster would not have made such a claim without Kate's say so ? If it  was  true why was she afraid to put her name to  the fact that Amaral was seeking a settlement ?

And this Blacksmith - a reliable source?
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 10:25:48 PM

Tis truly amazing what we all know about Goncalo Amaral, while some Portuguese Citizens, and others who live in Portugal, appear to remain in blissful ignorance.

This should surely tell them something.
This time I agree with Eleanor : I'm amazed some spend so much energy in muck raking.

Hardly Muck Raking.  Amaral has ridden rough shod over every decent Portuguese Citizen who do pay their Taxes and Mortgages.  As far back as 2002 he was in debt to The State and to The Banks.

I could say so much more about this awful man, but that would be spurious.

Your and others weakness is that however black you try to paint this man it can never mean white by deduction for the mccanns, YOUR BIG mistake in your pathetic arguments, end of you are tooooo transparent as to your silly agenda, i suggest you give it up and concentrate on the facts od the MADELEINE CASE, that is IF you have the time after denigrating and lambasting everyone avilable,  sad sad and sadder

I suggest that you pay more attention to your spelling and grammar.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 10:30:33 PM
I always thought Mr Amaral was a very normal human being. His book was a short seller here in Portugal, I didn't buy it, I had a look.
The McCanns didn't like his conclusion, I understand them. They could have just ignored it, but unreasonably (imo) they decided not to (may be they understood it was ridiculous to attack this book and this is why they proposed a settlement).
Nevertheless some people started to turn Gonçalo Amaral into a post-modern anti-hero !
An amazing phenomenon was born.
What has this man to arouse so much passion ?
I look and look at him, I don't understand. Now as he's so thin, he looks like a persecuted and sanctified man. Saint Sebastian !
Really amazing.

It wasn't his book that was the real problem.  Like Bennett, he was never going to stop.

Sanctified?  Sheesh.  Go and have a lie down.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: ferryman on May 06, 2013, 10:38:50 PM
Something or nothing, you decide.

A contributor to the OFM Facebook page emailed the webmaster asking whether the rumours of the McCanns seeking a settlement with Amaral were true. Webmaster told contributor that she would have to ask Kate and would get back to them. Webmaster replied to contributor, after we can presume, discussion with Kate that the rumours were false. These facts were made public on Blacksmith's blog after which webmaster denied Kate had told her about the rumours being false and if the allegations were repeated legal action would be taken.

Now if Amaral had been the one to ask for a settlement why wouldn't Kate put her name to the false rumours claim, even when it was absolutely clear that  the webmaster would not have made such a claim without Kate's say so ? If it  was  true why was she afraid to put her name to  the fact that Amaral was seeking a settlement ?

And this Blacksmith - a reliable source?

One of Blacksmith's last blogs was about the 'lies' the McCanns are supposed to have told just before the inspection at the villa.

I responded, asking what earthly point that inspection had given that Madeleine never lived there.

Whether that had anything to do with what happened next, I don't know, but he pulled (almost) everything off his blog and hasn't blogged again since.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 06, 2013, 10:44:43 PM
I always thought Mr Amaral was a very normal human being. His book was a short seller here in Portugal, I didn't buy it, I had a look.
The McCanns didn't like his conclusion, I understand them. They could have just ignored it, but unreasonably (imo) they decided not to (may be they understood it was ridiculous to attack this book and this is why they proposed a settlement).
Nevertheless some people started to turn Gonçalo Amaral into a post-modern anti-hero !
An amazing phenomenon was born.
What has this man to arouse so much passion ?
I look and look at him, I don't understand. Now as he's so thin, he looks like a persecuted and sanctified man. Saint Sebastian !
Really amazing.

It wasn't his book that was the real problem.  Like Bennett, he was never going to stop.

Sanctified?  Sheesh.  Go and have a lie down.
Then why ban his book ? In the beginning of the third millennium, Fahrenheit a book is doomed to be counterproductive.
Whether you like it or not, you and some others have transformed this man into Saint Sebastian.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 10:49:04 PM
I always thought Mr Amaral was a very normal human being. His book was a short seller here in Portugal, I didn't buy it, I had a look.
The McCanns didn't like his conclusion, I understand them. They could have just ignored it, but unreasonably (imo) they decided not to (may be they understood it was ridiculous to attack this book and this is why they proposed a settlement).
Nevertheless some people started to turn Gonçalo Amaral into a post-modern anti-hero !
An amazing phenomenon was born.
What has this man to arouse so much passion ?
I look and look at him, I don't understand. Now as he's so thin, he looks like a persecuted and sanctified man. Saint Sebastian !
Really amazing.

It wasn't his book that was the real problem.  Like Bennett, he was never going to stop.

Sanctified?  Sheesh.  Go and have a lie down.
Then why ban his book ? In the beginning of the third millennium, Fahrenheit a book is doomed to be counterproductive.
Whether you like it or not, you and some others have transformed this man into Saint Sebastian.

I don't think so.  Except among a few deluded middle aged women, perhaps.  It all sounds like desperation to me.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: DCI on May 06, 2013, 10:55:20 PM
I always thought Mr Amaral was a very normal human being. His book was a short seller here in Portugal, I didn't buy it, I had a look.
The McCanns didn't like his conclusion, I understand them. They could have just ignored it, but unreasonably (imo) they decided not to (may be they understood it was ridiculous to attack this book and this is why they proposed a settlement).
Nevertheless some people started to turn Gonçalo Amaral into a post-modern anti-hero !
An amazing phenomenon was born.
What has this man to arouse so much passion ?
I look and look at him, I don't understand. Now as he's so thin, he looks like a persecuted and sanctified man. Saint Sebastian !
Really amazing.

It wasn't his book that was the real problem.  Like Bennett, he was never going to stop.

Sanctified?  Sheesh.  Go and have a lie down.
Then why ban his book ? In the beginning of the third millennium, Fahrenheit a book is doomed to be counterproductive.
Whether you like it or not, you and some others have transformed this man into Saint Sebastian.

Could have been something to do with it all being lies, Anne. And not just about the McCann's, look what he wrote about Murat. It wouldn't surprise me to see Murat take legal action, against Amaral  >@@(*&)
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 10:59:15 PM
I always thought Mr Amaral was a very normal human being. His book was a short seller here in Portugal, I didn't buy it, I had a look.
The McCanns didn't like his conclusion, I understand them. They could have just ignored it, but unreasonably (imo) they decided not to (may be they understood it was ridiculous to attack this book and this is why they proposed a settlement).
Nevertheless some people started to turn Gonçalo Amaral into a post-modern anti-hero !
An amazing phenomenon was born.
What has this man to arouse so much passion ?
I look and look at him, I don't understand. Now as he's so thin, he looks like a persecuted and sanctified man. Saint Sebastian !
Really amazing.

It wasn't his book that was the real problem.  Like Bennett, he was never going to stop.

Sanctified?  Sheesh.  Go and have a lie down.
Then why ban his book ? In the beginning of the third millennium, Fahrenheit a book is doomed to be counterproductive.
Whether you like it or not, you and some others have transformed this man into Saint Sebastian.

Could have been something to do with it all being lies, Anne. And not just about the McCann's, look what he wrote about Murat. It wouldn't surprise me to see Murat take legal action, against Amaral  >@@(*&)

I shall be surprised if Murat doesn't take legal action against Amaral.  Perhaps he already is.  Won't that be fun.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: faithlilly on May 06, 2013, 11:09:54 PM
Something or nothing, you decide.

A contributor to the OFM Facebook page emailed the webmaster asking whether the rumours of the McCanns seeking a settlement with Amaral were true. Webmaster told contributor that she would have to ask Kate and would get back to them. Webmaster replied to contributor, after we can presume, discussion with Kate that the rumours were false. These facts were made public on Blacksmith's blog after which webmaster denied Kate had told her about the rumours being false and if the allegations were repeated legal action would be taken.

Now if Amaral had been the one to ask for a settlement why wouldn't Kate put her name to the false rumours claim, even when it was absolutely clear that  the webmaster would not have made such a claim without Kate's say so ? If it  was  true why was she afraid to put her name to  the fact that Amaral was seeking a settlement ?

And this Blacksmith - a reliable source?

One of Blacksmith's last blogs was about the 'lies' the McCanns are supposed to have told just before the inspection at the villa.

I responded, asking what earthly point that inspection had given that Madeleine never lived there.

Whether that had anything to do with what happened next, I don't know, but he pulled (almost) everything off his blog and hasn't blogged again since.

Responded ? How ?

And please let me put your mind at rest HB, your question had nothing to do with Blacksmith pulling his blog posts I can assure you.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: Eleanor on May 06, 2013, 11:13:50 PM

Oh Dear.  Some people are getting frightfully tetchy tonight.  I wonder why that could be.
Title: Re: McCanns vs Amaral Court Case
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 06, 2013, 11:20:08 PM

Whether you like it or not, you and some others have transformed this man into Saint Sebastian.

I don't think so.  Except among a few deluded middle aged women, perhaps.  It all sounds like desperation to me.
Saint Sebastian is supposed to be the earliest gay icon ;)