UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧
Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: John on May 07, 2013, 03:52:26 AM
-
There is hope for Madeleine McCann as three young women abducted as teenagers nearly a decade ago have been found alive and well along with at least one female child in a house in Cleveland, Ohio.
It is believed the women were kept in an underground dungeon by a 52-year-old Hispanic bus driver who was arrested at the scene hqving attempted to flee from police.
(http://www.theblaze.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/Berry_and_DeJesus_20130506191340_320_240.jpg)
A neighbor in the community said he heard screams and rushed to the house where he found one of the women, Amanda Berry, who was reported missing a decade ago as a teenager. He lent her his cell phone to call police.
"Help me! I'm Amanda Berry. ... I've been kidnapped and I've been missing for 10 years and I'm here. I'm free now," Berry is heard frantically telling a 911 emergency operator in a recording of the call, released by police and posted on the website of the Cleveland Plain Dealer.
During the call, she gave the name of her alleged abductor and said he was "out of the house." She urged police to come quickly and indicated that she knew her disappearance had been widely reported in the media.
The neighbor, Charles Ramsey, said in an interview broadcast by CNN that when he arrived Berry appeared desperate to get through the door, which did not open properly.
"I see this girl going nuts trying to get outside," he said, adding that he was astonished when she identified herself.
"Then I realized I'm calling 911 for Amanda Berry. I thought that girl was dead," he said. He said Berry had emerged from the house "with a little girl."
All three women were taken to a local hospital, MetroHealth Medical Center, where Dr Gerald Maloney told a news conference they were all "safe" and "appear to be in fair condition."
"This isn't the ending we usually have to these stories, so we're very happy. We're very happy for them," Maloney said.
He declined to comment on unconfirmed media reports that two children were found with the three women at the house.
CROWDS CHEER
Crowds on the street where the women were found cheered as police cars drove into the cordoned-off area around the house.
The two women found with Berry, now 26, were identified by authorities as Gina DeJesus, 23, who vanished in 2004 at age 14, and Michelle Knight, who was reported to be 20 when she disappeared more than a decade ago.
Berry was last seen leaving her job at a fast-food restaurant to go home on the day before her 17th birthday.
On the 10th anniversary of her disappearance, family members and activists held a vigil for Berry, and authorities recently reminded the public of a $25,000 reward for information about what had become of her, according to the Cleveland Plain Dealer.
City Councilwoman Dona Brady, a friend of the family, told Reuters that Berry's grief-stricken mother had died at age 47, essentially from a broken heart.
Police identified the suspect as Ariel Castro, 52, a bus driver for Cleveland public schools.
His uncle, Caesar Castro, who owns a grocery store on the same street, said his nephew owned the house where the women were found. He added that members of his family and the family of DeJesus "grew up together."
"Everyone is shocked," said the elder Castro. He said he had known his nephew to be "a good guy" and a musician who played the bass.
Cleveland Mayor Frank Jackson said, "I am thankful that Amanda Berry, Gina DeJesus and Michelle Knight have been found alive."
"We have many unanswered questions regarding this case, and the investigation will be ongoing. Again, I am thankful that these three young ladies are found and alive," he added.
-
WONDERFUL NEWS
Absolutely incredible news. It will not be easy for the people involved and it is tragic that the mother of one of the women is now dead but it is in itself a wonderful story where hope is shown to be justified.
Till there is evidence beyond doubt that a missing individual is dead, only the most heard-hearted person would ever give up hope.
Unfortunately there are such people out there who positively revel in the possibility of a missing child's death. There are others who treat the whole disappearance as nothing more than a game of detectives.
Thankfully the majority of people want to keep the names of Madeleine and other missing people in the public arena with the hope that they may one day be reunited with their families. It is the human thing to do.
-
You cannot possibly compare the case of Madeleine Mccann to this case, they are chalk and cheese. These 3 ladies knew who they were when they went missing, they were grown ups. Madeleine was 3, she's probably forgotten and might even be speaking another language but I don't believe it is possible but I'm not allowed to suggest why 8(0(*
Does anyone have statistic as to how many people missing for more than say 5 or 10 years are found either dead, alive or never found? And the statistics of children under the age of 5 with the afore mentioned answers?
Have people forgotten about Katrice Lee, Ben Needham, Johnny Gosch? The only baby I can name as being found is Natalie Horrell.
-
A wonderful story. It is always uplifting to hear that any missing or abducted person has been found. It gives others hope to go on.
Thank you, John. Most of us needed to read that.
-
Why do [ censored word ]s have the need to believe so certainly that Madeleine will not come back.
Every time a story like this is published they go into a frenzy to try to prove why it is dissimilar to Madeleine.
I happen to think that in all probability she IS dead, but I don't feel the meed to bleat on about other cases in an attempt to prove it.
It is part of the [ censored word ]s agenda to prove their own myths.
-
Nice to hear these missing girls have been found. I hope Maddie is alive and well too somewhere safe. It's certainly a possibility.
8@??)(
-
Best news for a long while 8@??)( 8@??)( 8@??)(
Let's hope these women are allowed the space and time - to come home - not just in a physical way
Kate & Gerry must feel elated - hope never dies
Who said - 'If I knew the world would come to an end tomorrow - I'd plant an apple tree today'?
-
Nice to hear these missing girls have been found. I hope Maddie is alive and well too somewhere safe. It's certainly a possibility.
8@??)(
It makes you wonder how it was possible that these girls were kept in such an urban environment for all these years without a trace of them being found. How do you think Cleveland Police are going to come out of this one? Red faces all round or the usual "It wisnae oor fault"?
-
WONDERFUL NEWS
Absolutely incredible news. It will not be easy for the people involved and it is tragic that the mother of one of the women is now dead but it is in itself a wonderful story where hope is shown to be justified.
Till there is evidence beyond doubt that a missing individual is dead, only the most heard-hearted person would ever give up hope.
Unfortunately there are such people out there who positively revel in the possibility of a missing child's death. There are others who treat the whole disappearance as nothing more than a game of detectives.
Thankfully the majority of people want to keep the names of Madeleine and other missing people in the public arena with the hope that they may one day be reunited with their families. It is the human thing to do.
Nothing to add
-
Fabulous news. Sometimes miracles do happen.
-
Nice to hear these missing girls have been found. I hope Maddie is alive and well too somewhere safe. It's certainly a possibility.
8@??)(
It makes you wonder how it was possible that these girls were kept in such an urban environment for all these years without a trace of them being found. How do you think Cleveland Police are going to come out of this one? Red faces all round or the usual "It wisnae oor fault"?
Not just the police. The neighbours must be scratching their heads at how they never noticed anything strange.
-
'I'm like, "I'm calling 911 for Amanda Berry? I thought this girl was dead."'
- Charles Ramsey
-
'I'm like, "I'm calling 911 for Amanda Berry? I thought this girl was dead."'
- Charles Ramsey
So he wouldn't have been looking for her in his neighbour's basement. Or for the very young girl who was also there.
-
'I'm like, "I'm calling 911 for Amanda Berry? I thought this girl was dead."'
- Charles Ramsey
So he wouldn't have been looking for her in his neighbour's basement. Or for the very young girl who was also there.
Puzzled - please explain your train of thought
-
'I'm like, "I'm calling 911 for Amanda Berry? I thought this girl was dead."'
- Charles Ramsey
So he wouldn't have been looking for her in his neighbour's basement. Or for the very young girl who was also there.
Puzzled - please explain your train of thought
He thought she was dead, so he wasn't even thinking of looking.
It is obviously perfectly possible to hid a very young child, even a baby, in a basement without the neighbours being aware, or even hearing said baby crying.
-
I know that we should not bring things here from other fora, but a quick look at the usual suspects will show the depth of their hatred!
-
I know that we should not bring things here from other fora, but a quick look at the usual suspects will show the depth of their hatred!
I know where your coming from
Easier said than done though - but scroll past the vitriol and hatred
Akin to avoiding dog muck on the pavement
-
I know that we should not bring things here from other fora, but a quick look at the usual suspects will show the depth of their hatred!
I know where your coming from
Easier said than done though - but scroll past the vitriol and hatred
Akin to avoiding dog muck on the pavement
I used to find it offensive four or five years ago. Now, I am sad/happy to say that I just find the sites hilarious; they are so removed from any possible reality and inhabited by the winnowed out most serious [ censored word ]s- all dissent banished.
There conclusions and discussions now make me laugh. Much like I used to get furious at Creationist sites and Tin Hat Conspiracy sites, but now just find them sad and amusing.
I must be mellowing!
-
I know that we should not bring things here from other fora, but a quick look at the usual suspects will show the depth of their hatred!
I know where your coming from
Easier said than done though - but scroll past the vitriol and hatred
Akin to avoiding dog muck on the pavement
I used to find it offensive four or five years ago. Now, I am sad/happy to say that I just find the sites hilarious; they are so removed from any possible reality and inhabited by the winnowed out most serious h.....s- all dissent banished.
There conclusions and discussions now make me laugh. Much like I used to get furious at Creationist sites and Tin Hat Conspiracy sites, but now just find them sad and amusing.
I must be mellowing!
and good on you
McCann bashing has become a hobby for some of these deviants
The shame is - the few lucid McCann sceptics - who may have valid points - get drowned out
Sticking my head out here - quite deliberately - I have yet to see an intelligent reason for Kate's book
It was crass and insensitive (given that it was written for the twins and mentioning Madeleine's genitalia)
That's why applaud this forum - a comment like the above would have got me banned for life from other places
AND it's only a comment - not presumption or assumption of fact
-
I know that we should not bring things here from other fora, but a quick look at the usual suspects will show the depth of their hatred!
I know where your coming from
Easier said than done though - but scroll past the vitriol and hatred
Akin to avoiding dog muck on the pavement
I used to find it offensive four or five years ago. Now, I am sad/happy to say that I just find the sites hilarious; they are so removed from any possible reality and inhabited by the winnowed out most serious h.....s- all dissent banished.
There conclusions and discussions now make me laugh. Much like I used to get furious at Creationist sites and Tin Hat Conspiracy sites, but now just find them sad and amusing.
I must be mellowing!
and good on you
McCann bashing has become a hobby for some of these deviants
The shame is - the few lucid McCann sceptics - who may have valid points - get drowned out
Sticking my head out here - quite deliberately - I have yet to see an intelligent reason for Kate's book
It was crass and insensitive (given that it was written for the twins and mentioning Madeleine's genitalia)
That's why applaud this forum - a comment like the above would have got me banned for life from other places
AND it's only a comment - not presumption or assumption of fact
People do have different opinions- that's life.
I do not warm to the McCanns at all, but I DO understand why she wroite the book, and her comments about genitalia- I found that poignant and moved me to the point of tears. For me it operationalized the reality and horror of child sexual abuse.
Different strokes.
-
fair dues
-
The common problem of the [ censored word ]s (as I have pointed out many times) is their lack of empathy and lack of flexibility- they can only see the world in their own mindset- all else is too threatening to comprehend. It is all part of a personality type into which most of them fall- authoritarian, inflexible, unable to see others points of view, unable to imagine themselves in such circumstances, fear of what they might really do or have done in the past.
-
The common problem of the h.....s (as I have pointed out many times) is their lack of empathy and lack of flexibility- they can only see the world in their own mindset- all else is too threatening to comprehend. It is all part of a personality type into which most of them fall- authoritarian, inflexible, unable to see others points of view, unable to imagine themselves in such circumstances, fear of what they might really do or have done in the past.
Moved to tears by a mother's mention of daughter's genitalia, schadenfroh nurse Debunker, but not imagining a little girl ignoring where her Mum is at the moment she needed her at most (as her mother said).
-
The common problem of the h.....s (as I have pointed out many times) is their lack of empathy and lack of flexibility- they can only see the world in their own mindset- all else is too threatening to comprehend. It is all part of a personality type into which most of them fall- authoritarian, inflexible, unable to see others points of view, unable to imagine themselves in such circumstances, fear of what they might really do or have done in the past.
Moved to tears by a mother's mention of daughter's genitalia, schadenfroh nurse Debunker, but not imagining a little girl ignoring where her Mum is at the moment she needed her at most (as her mother said).
Moved to tears at the reality of child sexual abuse and the effect on the mother.
I have said repeatedly that I condemn the McCanns for their childcare- not there right to do it that way but the fact they did it. I never would have done what they did.
You seem to have trouble grasping the point.
-
The common problem of the h.....s (as I have pointed out many times) is their lack of empathy and lack of flexibility- they can only see the world in their own mindset- all else is too threatening to comprehend. It is all part of a personality type into which most of them fall- authoritarian, inflexible, unable to see others points of view, unable to imagine themselves in such circumstances, fear of what they might really do or have done in the past.
empathy - no sociopath has any of it
circumnavigating Godwin's law - Mao/Lenin/Pol Pot/Salazar - not an ounce of empathy
And there is a big difference between empathy and sympathy
The empathetic person sees another person in a hole - and drops in a rope in for the person to clamber out
The sympathetic person - jumps right into the hole - doing no one any favours
Empathy is a good thing
- walking in someone else's shoes is a good thing
it's what humans should do - look out for one another
-
I know that we should not bring things here from other fora, but a quick look at the usual suspects will show the depth of their hatred!
I know where your coming from
Easier said than done though - but scroll past the vitriol and hatred
Akin to avoiding dog muck on the pavement
I used to find it offensive four or five years ago. Now, I am sad/happy to say that I just find the sites hilarious; they are so removed from any possible reality and inhabited by the winnowed out most serious h.....s- all dissent banished.
There conclusions and discussions now make me laugh. Much like I used to get furious at Creationist sites and Tin Hat Conspiracy sites, but now just find them sad and amusing.
I must be mellowing!
and good on you
McCann bashing has become a hobby for some of these deviants
The shame is - the few lucid McCann sceptics - who may have valid points - get drowned out
Sticking my head out here - quite deliberately - I have yet to see an intelligent reason for Kate's book
It was crass and insensitive (given that it was written for the twins and mentioning Madeleine's genitalia)
That's why applaud this forum - a comment like the above would have got me banned for life from other places
AND it's only a comment - not presumption or assumption of fact
People do have different opinions- that's life.
I do not warm to the McCanns at all, but I DO understand why she wroite the book, and her comments about genitalia- I found that poignant and moved me to the point of tears. For me it operationalized the reality and horror of child sexual abuse.
Different strokes.
I agree. The most horrific thoughts would push themselves into her mind. Thoughts which any mother who thought her child could be in the hands of a paedaphile would have to endure at some point.
I have no idea why some people think the mention of 'genitalia' is so shocking - or why they even mention the twins in this respect. In fact I wish someone with that opinion would explain it to me.
-
I have no issue with the mentioning of genitalia
I have an issue with a book supposedly written for the twins, by their mother - mentioning bodily aspects of their elder sister
Uncalled for, crass and unnecessary
And if that makes me Pollyanna - so be it
-
The common problem of the h.....s (as I have pointed out many times) is their lack of empathy and lack of flexibility- they can only see the world in their own mindset- all else is too threatening to comprehend. It is all part of a personality type into which most of them fall- authoritarian, inflexible, unable to see others points of view, unable to imagine themselves in such circumstances, fear of what they might really do or have done in the past.
Moved to tears by a mother's mention of daughter's genitalia, schadenfroh nurse Debunker, but not imagining a little girl ignoring where her Mum is at the moment she needed her at most (as her mother said).
Moved to tears at the reality of child sexual abuse and the effect on the mother.
I have said repeatedly that I condemn the McCanns for their childcare- not there right to do it that way but the fact they did it. I never would have done what they did.
You seem to have trouble grasping the point.
I grasp your point Debuncare ;)
It wouldn't pass my mind to condemn these parents for their childcare. I'm not sure I would never have done what they did. I'm not on earth to judge people.
-
I have no idea why some people think the mention of 'genitalia' is so shocking - or why they even mention the twins in this respect. In fact I wish someone with that opinion would explain it to me.
Benice, I'm not shocked but I'm wondering about the motive for it.
If genitalia are concerned, I don't think a little girl would survive not having her Mum close by.
I hope the twins will not read their mother's book without preparation, I hope their parents will talk to them and discuss the case with them and let them express themselves.
-
Why do h.....s have the need to believe so certainly that Madeleine will not come back.
Every time a story like this is published they go into a frenzy to try to prove why it is dissimilar to Madeleine.
I happen to think that in all probability she IS dead, but I don't feel the meed to bleat on about other cases in an attempt to prove it.
It is part of the h.....s agenda to prove their own myths.
Yes, it's so obvious that good news stories like this worry and even sicken them. Strange people aren't they? I recall one of these so-called sceptics confirming they'd be absolutely gutted if Madeleine were ever found alive and I believe they were being quite sincere when they said it.
that's troubling
the discovery of Madeleine's remains (albeit she is very much an alive and findable child)
would bring those barstewards 'joy'?
-
Stories like this remind us that there is always hope
How very sad, though, that the mother of the missing girl died of a broken heart
-
I have no idea why some people think the mention of 'genitalia' is so shocking - or why they even mention the twins in this respect. In fact I wish someone with that opinion would explain it to me.
Benice, I'm not shocked but I'm wondering about the motive for it.
If genitalia are concerned, I don't think a little girl would survive not having her Mum close by.
I hope the twins will not read their mother's book without preparation, I hope their parents will talk to them and discuss the case with them and let them express themselves.
Anne, I understand that the McCanns have received ongoing counselling regarding the twins and the best way to handle the different aspects of what happened to their family. Even without such counselling I think both Kate and Gerry will know their children better than anyone else - and being intelligent people will prepare them - regarding the book when they are satisfied they are old enough. To think otherwise is ridiculous IMO.
-
Why do h.....s have the need to believe so certainly that Madeleine will not come back.
Every time a story like this is published they go into a frenzy to try to prove why it is dissimilar to Madeleine.
I happen to think that in all probability she IS dead, but I don't feel the meed to bleat on about other cases in an attempt to prove it.
It is part of the h.....s agenda to prove their own myths.
Yes, it's so obvious that good news stories like this worry and even sicken them. Strange people aren't they? I recall one of these so-called sceptics confirming they'd be absolutely gutted if Madeleine were ever found alive and I believe they were being quite sincere when they said it.
I remember that, Martha, and it was repeated quite a few times in various places. I find it so difficult to understand why people should actually wish a small child to be dead - perhaps it is because it would be the ultimate and painful revenge? >@@(*&)
-
Why do h.....s have the need to believe so certainly that Madeleine will not come back.
Every time a story like this is published they go into a frenzy to try to prove why it is dissimilar to Madeleine.
I happen to think that in all probability she IS dead, but I don't feel the meed to bleat on about other cases in an attempt to prove it.
It is part of the h.....s agenda to prove their own myths.
Yes, it's so obvious that good news stories like this worry and even sicken them. Strange people aren't they? I recall one of these so-called sceptics confirming they'd be absolutely gutted if Madeleine were ever found alive and I believe they were being quite sincere when they said it.
I remember that, Martha, and it was repeated quite a few times in various places. I find it so difficult to understand why people should actually wish a small child to be dead - perhaps it is because it would be the ultimate and painful revenge? >@@(*&)
If the "sceptics" have spent the last 6 years trying their damnedest to convince anyone who will listen that the McCanns hid their child's body, then the discomfort of being proven wrong by Madeleine turning up alive would be quite excruciating and painful for some. I think that's the main reason.
It's funny isn't it how the Pro-McCanns rejoice in good news stories like this one, whilst the stories that really excite the "sceptics" are those of parental neglect and murder, of cadaver dogs scenting corpses etc. Talk about chalk and cheese!
A friend told me that someone said that the McCanns would one day produce a clone of Madeleine so as to cover up their crime! Do they ever take a step back and see how ludicrous this kind of comment is?
-
fantastic result - concentrate on the very positive things and not the negative.
Well done Charles - I hope he gets the reward.
-
Excellent news for the families involved.
Have I missed the part where cadaver dogs, having been brought in to search for the girls, alerted to multiple locations and have now been proven to be mistaken ?
-
Luckily these girls were three. Had someone here heard about one or more of them before ?
-
The common problem of the h.....s (as I have pointed out many times) is their lack of empathy and lack of flexibility- they can only see the world in their own mindset- all else is too threatening to comprehend. It is all part of a personality type into which most of them fall- authoritarian, inflexible, unable to see others points of view, unable to imagine themselves in such circumstances, fear of what they might really do or have done in the past.
empathy - no sociopath has any of it
circumnavigating Godwin's law - Mao/Lenin/Pol Pot/Salazar - not an ounce of empathy
And there is a big difference between empathy and sympathy
The empathetic person sees another person in a hole - and drops in a rope in for the person to clamber out
The sympathetic person - jumps right into the hole - doing no one any favours
Empathy is a good thing
- walking in someone else's shoes is a good thing
it's what humans should do - look out for one another
Before criticizing and enemy you should walk a mile in his shoes; not only will you understand him better, you will have another pair of shoes.
....running (walking?) away laughing and ducking....
-
Excellent news for the families involved.
Have a missed part where cadaver dogs, having been brought in to search for the girls, alerted to multiple locations and have now been proven to be mistaken ?
@)(++(* 8@??)( It was only a matter of time before this happened and this case with the three girls is the perfect example of how dog alerts can be complete bull. Another myth for the appropriate thread??
-
Excellent news for the families involved.
Have a missed part where cadaver dogs, having been brought in to search for the girls, alerted to multiple locations and have now been proven to be mistaken ?
@)(++(* 8@??)( It was only a matter of time before this happened and this case with the three girls is the perfect example of how dog alerts can be complete bull. Another myth for the appropriate thread??
I think Faithlily may have been being facetious!
-
In the deJesus case they tore up a garage floor and used cadaver dogs, but I have found no record of any alerts.
-
Excellent news for the families involved.
Have a missed part where cadaver dogs, having been brought in to search for the girls, alerted to multiple locations and have now been proven to be mistaken ?
@)(++(* 8@??)( It was only a matter of time before this happened and this case with the three girls is the perfect example of how dog alerts can be complete bull. Another myth for the appropriate thread??
I think Faithlily may have been being facetious!
Priceless @)(++(*
-
In the deJesus case they tore up a garage floor and used cadaver dogs, but I have found no record of any alerts.
That may be because she wasn't dead !
-
In the deJesus case they tore up a garage floor and used cadaver dogs, but I have found no record of any alerts.
That may be because she wasn't dead !
No. There would be a 20% chance that any cadaver ID would be incorrect!
-
I have no idea why some people think the mention of 'genitalia' is so shocking - or why they even mention the twins in this respect. In fact I wish someone with that opinion would explain it to me.
Benice, I'm not shocked but I'm wondering about the motive for it.
If genitalia are concerned, I don't think a little girl would survive not having her Mum close by.
I hope the twins will not read their mother's book without preparation, I hope their parents will talk to them and discuss the case with them and let them express themselves.
Anne, I understand that the McCanns have received ongoing counselling regarding the twins and the best way to handle the different aspects of what happened to their family. Even without such counselling I think both Kate and Gerry will know their children better than anyone else - and being intelligent people will prepare them - regarding the book when they are satisfied they are old enough. To think otherwise is ridiculous IMO.
I agree plainly : ridiculous.
-
Excellent news for the families involved.
Have a missed part where cadaver dogs, having been brought in to search for the girls, alerted to multiple locations and have now been proven to be mistaken ?
@)(++(* 8@??)( It was only a matter of time before this happened and this case with the three girls is the perfect example of how dog alerts can be complete bull. Another myth for the appropriate thread??
I think Faithlily may have been being facetious!
So might Angelo.
-
In the deJesus case they tore up a garage floor and used cadaver dogs, but I have found no record of any alerts.
Ah, but they didn't have Eddie.
-
So the dogs DID alert in the Gina Dejesus investigation...
http://www.cleveland.com/metro/index.ssf/2013/05/judge_orders_release_of_man_su.html
Assistant County Prosecutor Jennifer Driscoll said a police dog trained to alert officers to the scent of cadavers "indicated" in three locations at Hurayt's West 50th Street home on Friday that a dead body may have been present at one time.
Two of the locations where the dog sat, the indicator used to alert police, were in Hurayt's garage, where an informant told investigators Hurayt had buried the girl's body beneath a freshly poured concrete floor. Investigators tore up the floor in the garage and under a doghouse.
The dog also alerted to a location in the house, Driscoll said.
Police arrested Hurayt, 35, a registered sexual predator, on Thursday based on the informant's tip. But investigators who dug up the garage floor and searched the house didn't find a body or any physical evidence of the 14-year-old girl, who has been missing since April 2004. Nineteen items removed from the house will be investigated further, Driscoll said.
Well done, Martha. So Eddie wasn't the only one who got it wrong.
-
Excellent news for the families involved.
Have a missed part where cadaver dogs, having been brought in to search for the girls, alerted to multiple locations and have now been proven to be mistaken ?
Why are you talking about cadaver dogs with reference to this case? Is it because you are a "sceptic" and just can't help yourself?
Out of curiosity, Martha, how would you qualify the "non sceptics" ? Using an antonym ? Or discriminating ?
-
So the dogs DID alert in the Gina Dejesus investigation...
http://www.cleveland.com/metro/index.ssf/2013/05/judge_orders_release_of_man_su.html
Assistant County Prosecutor Jennifer Driscoll said a police dog trained to alert officers to the scent of cadavers "indicated" in three locations at Hurayt's West 50th Street home on Friday that a dead body may have been present at one time.
Two of the locations where the dog sat, the indicator used to alert police, were in Hurayt's garage, where an informant told investigators Hurayt had buried the girl's body beneath a freshly poured concrete floor. Investigators tore up the floor in the garage and under a doghouse.
The dog also alerted to a location in the house, Driscoll said.
Police arrested Hurayt, 35, a registered sexual predator, on Thursday based on the informant's tip. But investigators who dug up the garage floor and searched the house didn't find a body or any physical evidence of the 14-year-old girl, who has been missing since April 2004. Nineteen items removed from the house will be investigated further, Driscoll said.
Well done, Martha. So Eddie wasn't the only one who got it wrong.
I can't take the credit for finding this report as I got it from another site - but it does rather put a spanner in the works of "sceptics" like Faithlilly and their complete faith in the ability of the cadaver dogs.
Thank God Law Enforcement didn't take it further on Dog's Evidence. That bloke could have been executed by now.
-
Out of curiosity, Martha, how would you qualify the "non sceptics" ? Using an antonym ? Or discriminating ?
Pardon? I use the term "sceptic" ironically. I'm sure you realise that. I could equally use the term "justice-seekers". These are the terms preferred by people who I would describe in different words, except those words are proscribed on this forum. 8)--)) There is no such thing as a "non-sceptic" or a "non-justice-seeker" on this board. Hope that's clear!
Whether you use "sceptic" ironically or not, this qualifies appropriately those who don't believe, the Thomasalike if you prefer : those who need to see.
Now what's not clear is how you would qualify yourself : a believer ? a gullible ? a fan ? All antonyms of "sceptic".
-
Interesting that in the light of this interesting information regarding the false alerts by a cadaver dog in the Gina Dejesus investigation the conversation has now diverted onto what label I choose to give myself. Since when did I become the topic under discussion?
I noticed that.
-
Deserves a separate thread!
It will have one.
-
Interesting that in the light of this interesting information regarding the false alerts by a cadaver dog in the Gina Dejesus investigation the conversation has now diverted onto what label I choose to give myself. Since when did I become the topic under discussion?
Very interesting. No one seems all that keen on discussing the fact that this man could have been wrongly convicted, and even executed. Although I'm not sure about Ohio and The Death Penalty.
I don't care if he was a sexual predator. He was clearly innocent of this crime. But being a sexual predator would not have helped him at all during a Trial.
-
Interesting that in the light of this interesting information regarding the false alerts by a cadaver dog in the Gina Dejesus investigation the conversation has now diverted onto what label I choose to give myself. Since when did I become the topic under discussion?
Very interesting. No one seems all that keen on discussing the fact that this man could have been wrongly convicted, and even executed. Although I'm not sure about Ohio and The Death Penalty.
I don't care if he was a sexual predator. He was clearly innocent of this crime. But being a sexual predator would not have helped him at all during a Trial.
Don't worry - I expect the Dog apologists are busy concocting an excuse for these false alerts and will be back to explain all before the day is out.
You are almost certainly right. And I can hardly wait to hear it.
This is such a slam dunk that only delusion will deal with it.
-
Interesting that in the light of this interesting information regarding the false alerts by a cadaver dog in the Gina Dejesus investigation the conversation has now diverted onto what label I choose to give myself. Since when did I become the topic under discussion?
Very interesting. No one seems all that keen on discussing the fact that this man could have been wrongly convicted, and even executed. Although I'm not sure about Ohio and The Death Penalty.
I don't care if he was a sexual predator. He was clearly innocent of this crime. But being a sexual predator would not have helped him at all during a Trial.
Don't worry - I expect the Dog apologists are busy concocting an excuse for these false alerts and will be back to explain all before the day is out.
You are almost certainly right. And I can hardly wait to hear it.
This is such a slam dunk that only delusion will deal with it.
And luckily for them they have been practising such delusional reaction for years.
-
Interesting that in the light of this interesting information regarding the false alerts by a cadaver dog in the Gina Dejesus investigation the conversation has now diverted onto what label I choose to give myself. Since when did I become the topic under discussion?
Very interesting. No one seems all that keen on discussing the fact that this man could have been wrongly convicted, and even executed. Although I'm not sure about Ohio and The Death Penalty.
I don't care if he was a sexual predator. He was clearly innocent of this crime. But being a sexual predator would not have helped him at all during a Trial.
Don't worry - I expect the Dog apologists are busy concocting an excuse for these false alerts and will be back to explain all before the day is out.
You are almost certainly right. And I can hardly wait to hear it.
This is such a slam dunk that only delusion will deal with it.
And luckily for them they have been practising such delusional reaction for years.
But this one is a teensy bit different since the young woman is obviously alive.
This not going to do much for Prosecutors and Cadaver Dogs in future.
Can't you just imagine it? "Excuse me, Yer Honour."
Oh sorry, I forgot. This wasn't Eddie.
-
Interesting that in the light of this interesting information regarding the false alerts by a cadaver dog in the Gina Dejesus investigation the conversation has now diverted onto what label I choose to give myself. Since when did I become the topic under discussion?
Do we know whether both a blood and cadaver dog were both deployed in the Dejesus investigation ?
-
It seems that already there are certain posters elsewhere who are 'rubbishing' what happened.
Re: Three women found in Ohio house after being missing for a decade
Hobs wrote:
Something in this story is off, i can't quite put my finger on it. i need more stattements to come to a conclusion.
The obvious one is why did they not try to escape at any point?
Philthecynic Today
This is my thought too. Also why, in her 911 call does she feel the need to identify herself as one of the kidnap victims in her first few sentences. Surely "I'm being held prisoner get me out of here." would do it. The kidnapping was old news so it seems she was trying to remind people for some reason. After 10 years I'd just want to end the misery and tell your story once rescued. Something is not right but it's in no way connected to Maddy's case.
Conspiracy Rules, Okay!!
-
Interesting that in the light of this interesting information regarding the false alerts by a cadaver dog in the Gina Dejesus investigation the conversation has now diverted onto what label I choose to give myself. Since when did I become the topic under discussion?
Do we know whether both a blood and cadaver dog were both deployed in the Dejesus investigation ?
Blood dog not needed as cadaver dog can sniff blood and if he she alerts it MUST just be blood and innocent according to the latest ideology touted on here
No-one (especially me) has said that. You just make up sentences to make it look like others are lying.
You do not understand the dogs.
-
Interesting that in the light of this interesting information regarding the false alerts by a cadaver dog in the Gina Dejesus investigation the conversation has now diverted onto what label I choose to give myself. Since when did I become the topic under discussion?
Do we know whether both a blood and cadaver dog were both deployed in the Dejesus investigation ?
Would it have made any difference? The young woman is ALIVE.
-
This is super news, I'm over the moon for the girls and their families. Never give up hope!
-
It seems that already there are certain posters elsewhere who are 'rubbishing' what happened.
Re: Three women found in Ohio house after being missing for a decade
Hobs wrote:
Something in this story is off, i can't quite put my finger on it. i need more stattements to come to a conclusion.
The obvious one is why did they not try to escape at any point?
Philthecynic Today
This is my thought too. Also why, in her 911 call does she feel the need to identify herself as one of the kidnap victims in her first few sentences. Surely "I'm being held prisoner get me out of here." would do it. The kidnapping was old news so it seems she was trying to remind people for some reason. After 10 years I'd just want to end the misery and tell your story once rescued. Something is not right but it's in no way connected to Maddy's case.
Conspiracy Rules, Okay!!
Sheesh. Is that the best they can do? Any minute now these girls will have locked themselves up to get THE MONEY.
-
It seems that already there are certain posters elsewhere who are 'rubbishing' what happened.
Re: Three women found in Ohio house after being missing for a decade
Hobs wrote:
Something in this story is off, i can't quite put my finger on it. i need more stattements to come to a conclusion.
The obvious one is why did they not try to escape at any point?
Philthecynic Today
This is my thought too. Also why, in her 911 call does she feel the need to identify herself as one of the kidnap victims in her first few sentences. Surely "I'm being held prisoner get me out of here." would do it. The kidnapping was old news so it seems she was trying to remind people for some reason. After 10 years I'd just want to end the misery and tell your story once rescued. Something is not right but it's in no way connected to Maddy's case.
Conspiracy Rules, Okay!!
Sheesh. Is that the best they can do? Any minute now these girls will have locked themselves up to get THE MONEY.
Their families did it!
-
oh this is so tedious
Bilderbergers, masons, jews all trotted out again
3 women are safe tonight - who weren't safe last night
that's all there is to know - and reason to rejoice
-
Interesting that in the light of this interesting information regarding the false alerts by a cadaver dog in the Gina Dejesus investigation the conversation has now diverted onto what label I choose to give myself. Since when did I become the topic under discussion?
Do we know whether both a blood and cadaver dog were both deployed in the Dejesus investigation ?
Would it have made any difference? The young woman is ALIVE.
Of course it would have made a difference. As we know a cadaver dog will alert to blood from a living person and only when a blood dog fails to alert at the same spot can we gauge whether the alert was to a cadaver or not. If a blood dog was not brought in in the Dejesus case then it remains a possibility the cadaver dog alerted to blood.
Of course in the McCann case as Eddie alerted in the bedroom and Keela didn't there is every reason to suspect Eddie's alert was indeed to cadaver.
-
oh this is so tedious
Bilderbergers, masons, jews all trotted out again
3 women are safe tonight - who weren't safe last night
that's all there is to know - and reason to rejoice
Quite and it IS great news, one in a million
Point here is, that a few idiots who are questioning the truth of the matter are being used, as per normal when it suits, some quarters, to blacken all people who have questions about the Mccanns, disgraceful as the skeptics in these girls case, YOU and ALL those who do it and all NORMAL people can see its a hypocrisy and a cheap shot, one wonders why one needa to fall to these levels actually, bizarre
there may be a point to this post
I'm still searching
-
Interesting that in the light of this interesting information regarding the false alerts by a cadaver dog in the Gina Dejesus investigation the conversation has now diverted onto what label I choose to give myself. Since when did I become the topic under discussion?
Do we know whether both a blood and cadaver dog were both deployed in the Dejesus investigation ?
Would it have made any difference? The young woman is ALIVE.
Of course it would have made a difference. As we know a cadaver dog will alert to blood from a living person and only when a blood dog fails to alert at the same spot can we gauge whether the alert was to a cadaver or not. If a blood dog was not brought in in the Dejesus case then it remains a possibility the cadaver dog alerted to blood.
Of course in the McCann case as Eddie alerted in the bedroom and Keela didn't there is every reason to suspect Eddie's alert was indeed to cadaver.
With Keela at 90% reliability and Eddie the same, the chances of their alerts indicating cadaver are 80% only. So it might indicate the possibility of cadaver, but only at a certain level of probability.
-
oh this is so tedious
Bilderbergers, masons, jews all trotted out again
3 women are safe tonight - who weren't safe last night
that's all there is to know - and reason to rejoice
Quite and it IS great news, one in a million
Point here is, that a few idiots who are questioning the truth of the matter are being used, as per normal when it suits, some quarters, to blacken all people who have questions about the Mccanns, disgraceful as the skeptics in these girls case, YOU and ALL those who do it and all NORMAL people can see its a hypocrisy and a cheap shot, one wonders why one needa to fall to these levels actually, bizarre
Normal people are by definition neither paranoid nor deluded.
-
oh this is so tedious
Bilderbergers, masons, jews all trotted out again
3 women are safe tonight - who weren't safe last night
that's all there is to know - and reason to rejoice
Quite and it IS great news, one in a million
Point here is, that a few idiots who are questioning the truth of the matter are being used, as per normal when it suits, some quarters, to blacken all people who have questions about the Mccanns, disgraceful as the skeptics in these girls case, YOU and ALL those who do it and all NORMAL people can see its a hypocrisy and a cheap shot, one wonders why one needa to fall to these levels actually, bizarre
there may be a point to this post
I'm still searching
There is a point to the post (bear with me)
It is after supper time.
Time for pudding.
The proof of the pudding is in the eating.
The proof is probably about 40- probably Vodka and fruit juice.
Batten down the hatches for another night of incoherency.
-
This is super news, I'm over the moon for the girls and their families. Never give up hope!
That's just how I feel about it Rachel
Why this thread has descended into something mean and nasty is beyond me
-
This is super news, I'm over the moon for the girls and their families. Never give up hope!
That's just how I feel about it Rachel
Why this thread has descended into something mean and nasty is beyond me
Yup, you are right there icabod. It's a day when three families were granted the miracle they had hoped for for many years. A miracle that will bouy up the families of other missing people.
-
oh this is so tedious
Bilderbergers, masons, jews all trotted out again
3 women are safe tonight - who weren't safe last night
that's all there is to know - and reason to rejoice
Quite and it IS great news, one in a million
Point here is, that a few idiots who are questioning the truth of the matter are being used, as per normal when it suits, some quarters, to blacken all people who have questions about the Mccanns, disgraceful as the skeptics in these girls case, YOU and ALL those who do it and all NORMAL people can see its a hypocrisy and a cheap shot, one wonders why one needa to fall to these levels actually, bizarre
there may be a point to this post
I'm still searching
There is a point to the post (bear with me)
It is after supper time.
Time for pudding.
The proof of the pudding is in the eating.
The proof is probably about 40- probably Vodka and fruit juice.
Batten down the hatches for another night of incoherency.
it's a shame
she has moments of clarity
then the super strenght white lightning kicks in
and it all goes to pot
-
This is super news, I'm over the moon for the girls and their families. Never give up hope!
That's just how I feel about it Rachel
Why this thread has descended into something mean and nasty is beyond me
icabodcrane
Stories like this remind us that there is always hope
How very sad, though, that the mother of the missing girl died of a broken heart
your positivity, although correct, was underwhelming
-
Why is the press so quiet about Michelle Knight? Was no family there for her?
-
Joanne
Does anyone have statistic as to how many people missing for more than say 5 or 10 years are found either dead, alive or never found? And the statistics of children under the age of 5 with the afore mentioned answers?
Have people forgotten about Katrice Lee, Ben Needham, Johnny Gosch? The only baby I can name as being found is Natalie Horrell.
-
It would appear one of the suspects, Ariel Castro, who actually lived in the house, has been investigated for possible child abduction and lost his job after the incident noted below.
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2013/may/08/cleveland-ariel-castro-child-abduction
-
Why is the press so quiet about Michelle Knight? Was no family there for her?
It seems she is in hospital, possibly a special one, her mother was on CNN this morning saying she hoped her daughter would let her visit her. As the details emerge of what this man did to them, I would think Michelle will have a much longer period of readjustment.
-
Michelle Knight doesn't appear to be in a very good state. Five miscarriages and facial injuries due to beatings. And there is some speculation about her family being involved in a child of hers being taken away from her prior to her abduction.
I'm not sure I would be too keen on seeing my mother under those circumstances.
I hope and pray that she recovers. But I doubt that she wishes that she was dead.
-
Michelle Knight doesn't appear to be in a very good state. Five miscarriages and facial injuries due to beatings. And there is some speculation about her family being involved in a child of hers being taken away from her prior to her abduction.
I'm not sure I would be too keen on seeing my mother under those circumstances.
I hope and pray that she recovers. But I doubt that she wishes that she was dead.
I believe her mother was convinced she had run away when she disappeared, and she moved away to another State. I presume that she didn't try to keep her daughter's profile high in the way the families of the other 2 girls did.
If that's true then that will be very hard for Michelle to come to terms with. Also the mother must feel dreadfully guilty. All very sad.
-
Michelle Knight doesn't appear to be in a very good state. Five miscarriages and facial injuries due to beatings. And there is some speculation about her family being involved in a child of hers being taken away from her prior to her abduction.
I'm not sure I would be too keen on seeing my mother under those circumstances.
I hope and pray that she recovers. But I doubt that she wishes that she was dead.
I believe her mother was convinced she had run away when she disappeared, and she moved away to another State. I presume that she didn't try to keep her daughter's profile high in the way the families of the other 2 girls did.
If that's true then that will be very hard for Michelle to come to terms with. Also the mother must feel dreadfully guilty. All very sad.
I believe that what you say is correct. Her mother has also had another child herself. So poor Michelle has been kicked in the teeth all round.
-
My thoughts are with Michelle today.
-
This story is just appalling ... then we have the unspeakably horrific details emerging in the Tia Sharp trial 8(8-))
I think I'll have to stop reading the news for a while
-
This story is just appalling ... then we have the unspeakably horrific details emerging in the Tia Sharp trial 8(8-))
I think I'll have to stop reading the news for a while
Yes, there is a lot of evil in this world, icabod, and it's so awful.