UK Justice Forum 🇬🇧

Disappeared and Abducted Children and Young Adults => Madeleine McCann (3) disappeared from her parent's holiday apartment at Ocean Club, Praia da Luz, Portugal on 3 May 2007. No trace of her has ever been found. => Topic started by: debunker on May 07, 2013, 05:04:47 PM

Title: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: debunker on May 07, 2013, 05:04:47 PM
One of the three Ohio girls freed yesterday was pronounced dead by the Cadaver Dog sent to investigate the house where she was thought to have been murdered and buried.

Guess it was one of those 2 cases out of ten when cadaver dogs get it wrong.
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: ferryman on May 07, 2013, 05:14:17 PM
Who was asking a little while back about instances where a cadaver dog alerted and a person presumed dead turned out alive?
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: ferryman on May 07, 2013, 05:20:32 PM
Who was asking a little while back about instances where a cadaver dog alerted and a person presumed dead turned out alive?

From the last place a person was seen alive, not any old place after some dubious tip off.
Dogs don't lie though do they Redblossom?

The premise is ridiculous, anyway, because we know cadaver dogs react to blood.  It's what happened with Eddie's reaction to the Renault, and its probably what happened when the dogs in the Zapata case reacted ...
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: debunker on May 07, 2013, 05:30:46 PM
I think you're slightly over-stating it - the cadaver dog DID alert 3 times but nothing was found, ergo I don't believe Dejesus was written off as dead (except by the lynch mob of course!)

I was using a little poetic licence!

[ censored word ]s will assure you that if a dog alerts, that declares the person dead.
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: debunker on May 07, 2013, 05:31:50 PM
Who was asking a little while back about instances where a cadaver dog alerted and a person presumed dead turned out alive?

From the last place a person was seen alive, not any old place after some dubious tip off.

How do you explain these false alerts?

How accurate do you think the dogs are?
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: Eleanor on May 07, 2013, 05:49:57 PM
Who was asking a little while back about instances where a cadaver dog alerted and a person presumed dead turned out alive?

From the last place a person was seen alive, not any old place after some dubious tip off.
Dogs don't lie though do they Redblossom?

The alerts could have been an error or not, the question I was responding to was Ferryman's, correcting him on what he remembered.

What do you mean, "Could have been an error or not?"  The young woman is clearly alive.
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: Eleanor on May 07, 2013, 07:44:00 PM
Who was asking a little while back about instances where a cadaver dog alerted and a person presumed dead turned out alive?

From the last place a person was seen alive, not any old place after some dubious tip off.
Dogs don't lie though do they Redblossom?

The alerts could have been an error or not, the question I was responding to was Ferryman's, correcting him on what he remembered.

What do you mean, "Could have been an error or not?"  The young woman is clearly alive.
You  need to understand that cadaver dogs do not alert to individuals, so yes, the cadaver dog did NOT alert to this missing person

Oh.  I see.  There was another Cadaver, was there?  I wonder what happened to that one?
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: faithlilly on May 07, 2013, 07:46:28 PM
Who was asking a little while back about instances where a cadaver dog alerted and a person presumed dead turned out alive?

From the last place a person was seen alive, not any old place after some dubious tip off.
Dogs don't lie though do they Redblossom?

The premise is ridiculous, anyway, because we know cadaver dogs react to blood.  It's what happened with Eddie's reaction to the Renault, and its probably what happened when the dogs in the Zapata case reacted ...

Except Keela didn't react in the bedroom and Eddie did. Back to the drawing board eh !
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: ferryman on May 07, 2013, 07:56:23 PM
Who was asking a little while back about instances where a cadaver dog alerted and a person presumed dead turned out alive?

From the last place a person was seen alive, not any old place after some dubious tip off.
Dogs don't lie though do they Redblossom?

The premise is ridiculous, anyway, because we know cadaver dogs react to blood.  It's what happened with Eddie's reaction to the Renault, and its probably what happened when the dogs in the Zapata case reacted ...

Except Keela didn't react in the bedroom and Eddie did. Back to the drawing board eh !

For you, Faith, yes.

What type of error was Eddie's shenanigans with cuddle-cat?  A failure to alert when he should have?

Or an alert when he shouldn't?
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 07, 2013, 10:27:27 PM
CC was found on top of Madeleine's bed. Eddie didn't alert in Madeleine's bedroom. If he smelt something on CC, it was through contamination (may be the pants contaminated by British corpses that he alerted to). This scent is probably stronger when the object is in a closed place than outside.
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: AnneGuedes on May 07, 2013, 10:32:11 PM
the POINT is, that cadaver dogs do NOT react to individuals dead body scent, efgo your original comment was misguided
It's crucial to understand this. My cadaver and Eleanor's cadaver will smell the same.
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: amaraltheofficeboy on May 07, 2013, 10:34:28 PM
CC was found on top of Madeleine's bed. Eddie didn't alert in Madeleine's bedroom. If he smelt something on CC, it was through contamination (may be the pants contaminated by British corpses that he alerted to). This scent is probably stronger when the object is in a closed place than outside.

yep 3 months later, in a cupboard, in a different place
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: faithlilly on May 08, 2013, 11:24:10 AM
Who was asking a little while back about instances where a cadaver dog alerted and a person presumed dead turned out alive?

From the last place a person was seen alive, not any old place after some dubious tip off.
Dogs don't lie though do they Redblossom?

The premise is ridiculous, anyway, because we know cadaver dogs react to blood.  It's what happened with Eddie's reaction to the Renault, and its probably what happened when the dogs in the Zapata case reacted ...

Except Keela didn't react in the bedroom and Eddie did. Back to the drawing board eh !

For you, Faith, yes.

What type of error was Eddie's shenanigans with cuddle-cat?  A failure to alert when he should have?

Or an alert when he shouldn't?

Why don't you send Martin Grime a letter to Martin Grime and ask ?
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: Carana on May 08, 2013, 11:56:14 AM
the POINT is, that cadaver dogs do NOT react to individuals dead body scent, efgo your original comment was misguided
It's crucial to understand this. My cadaver and Eleanor's cadaver will smell the same.

As would a lingering scent of your dried blood somewhere or mine. Or any scent within his trained parameters which may not have anything whatsoever to do with either of us.

Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: peter claridge on May 08, 2013, 12:08:34 PM
Perhaps the dog was alerting to Seabass or a sex cleanup tissue or nappies or rotting meat or someone that had died there before or someone suffered from nosebleeds or cut themselves whilst shaving or someone had been in the house who'd been in contact with six dead bodies..
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 12:12:44 PM
Perhaps the dog was alerting to Seabass or a sex cleanup tissue or nappies or rotting meat or someone that had died there before or someone suffered from nosebleeds or cut themselves whilst shaving or someone had been in the house who'd been in contact with six dead bodies..

Very possible that he alerted to dried blood as that was what he was trained for and alerts to as well as cadaver odor (source: Martin Grime).

Supercilious answers like that one often come a cropper when the sardonic humour of their intent comes face to face with the facts in the real world!

You do know that Eddie did alert to blood, didn't you?
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: ferryman on May 08, 2013, 12:14:33 PM
Who was asking a little while back about instances where a cadaver dog alerted and a person presumed dead turned out alive?

From the last place a person was seen alive, not any old place after some dubious tip off.
Dogs don't lie though do they Redblossom?

The premise is ridiculous, anyway, because we know cadaver dogs react to blood.  It's what happened with Eddie's reaction to the Renault, and its probably what happened when the dogs in the Zapata case reacted ...

Except Keela didn't react in the bedroom and Eddie did. Back to the drawing board eh !

For you, Faith, yes.

What type of error was Eddie's shenanigans with cuddle-cat?  A failure to alert when he should have?

Or an alert when he shouldn't?

Why don't you send Martin Grime a letter to Martin Grime and ask ?

I would need to send it to the (I gather now late!) Eddie. Even at his prime, Eddie couldn't read.

In fact, at his prime, I suspect Eddie was probably a perfectly sound cadaver dog ...
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: debunker on May 08, 2013, 12:21:56 PM
Perhaps the dog was alerting to Seabass or a sex cleanup tissue or nappies or rotting meat or someone that had died there before or someone suffered from nosebleeds or cut themselves whilst shaving or someone had been in the house who'd been in contact with six dead bodies..

Very possible that he alerted to dried blood as that was what he was trained for and alerts to as well as cadaver odor (source: Martin Grime).

Supercilious answers like that one often come a cropper when the sardonic humour of their intent comes face to face with the facts in the real world!

You do know that Eddie did alert to blood, didn't you?
You do know that Kate lied about being in contact with six dead bodies, didn't you?

Did Kate ever say that?

What exactly did she say?

Do you have a cite?
Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: Benice on May 08, 2013, 12:35:03 PM
Perhaps the dog was alerting to Seabass or a sex cleanup tissue or nappies or rotting meat or someone that had died there before or someone suffered from nosebleeds or cut themselves whilst shaving or someone had been in the house who'd been in contact with six dead bodies..

Very possible that he alerted to dried blood as that was what he was trained for and alerts to as well as cadaver odor (source: Martin Grime).

Supercilious answers like that one often come a cropper when the sardonic humour of their intent comes face to face with the facts in the real world!

You do know that Eddie did alert to blood, didn't you?
You do know that Kate lied about being in contact with six dead bodies, didn't you?

Why would she tell such a whopper knowing that it could so easily be proved to be a lie?   All the police would have to do is check her 'work record' if they wanted to find out whether she'd had contact with cadavers.     Not that I believe she ever made that claim.  It's a myth IMO.


 

Title: Re: Cadaver Dog in the DeJesus Case alerted falsely
Post by: Eleanor on May 08, 2013, 12:39:04 PM

Cristovao made up the tale of six dead bodies in his book.  Kate never said it.